33 réponses à ce sujet

[Saodade]

frylock23 wrote...

Heh, if I'm going off my sp games, Kaidan and Garrus are very old comrades in arms. They've been my power squad since ME1. They team up quickly to take out the other two since they have the combination of tech and biotics to make a pretty lethal package.

Once Thane and Legion are down, and Thane would go first as the bigger threat (Both Kaidan and Garrus are too well equipped and experienced at handling Geth to worry about taking out Legion first.), Kaidan and Garrus would do something completely unconventional to settle who wins. Or, they'd just break Thunderdome.

Seriously, I think Kaidan could take out Garrus with his biotics before Garrus could drop Kaidan with a bullet.

Of course, I'm Kaidan biased. And Kaidan was training biotic SpecOps ...

aye but Kaidan  got his head  smacked  repeatedly by a  female robot.

(just teasing lol)

[mireisen]

Judging at how squishy drell adepts are in Gold MP, yeah...unless there's a harem of asari adepts/justicars I just can't see Thane's survivability; added onto his illness. So his solo ability just got nerfed in ME3.

Kaidan dies a lot. He's really balanced but can't solo worth anything. He's the psyduck of ME.

So it's really between Legion and Garrus. I would have stated Garrus #1 but he apparently isn't that sneaky (clumsy during Thessia mission) and Legion has that hydrolic "shh shh" sound every time he takes a step. Garrus would still probably win though. Surviving 3 merc groups by himself (for weeks I think?) is pretty pro.

[Pipe 42]

Depending on when this happens, it'd be Garrus in my opinion. The other three are dead in my main playthrough :-p

Presuming for the sake of clarity they are all there, I still think my vote would go to Garrus. The man's a badass!

Kaiden doesn't have that killer instinct imo.

Thane is good but dislikes direct confrontation, the only time he gets in a straight up fight, he gets stabbed. True, he's ill but he stomps Mesana Dantius in ME2.

Legion would be closest rival, but considering he can find only a .32% increase to the guns whilst Garrus picks up .44% without trying, shows computational power isn't all it's cracked up to be.

Instinct seems to carry the day, and Garrus is the second most badass fellow in the galaxy. Just behind Conrad imo :-p

[Gruntyfy]

Thane is the winner?

[Deltakarma]

Gruntyfy wrote...

Thane is the winner, hands down.

*coughs*

[Urrnot Repps]

What happened to "Two men enter, one man leaves!"?
Besides that, I'm sure Thane would win, hands down.

[Candidate 88766]

Thane and Garrus are quite possibly two of the best marksmen in the galaxy, but Legion will always be more accurate due to the fact that it is a machine. Thane is an assassin, and while excellent if he stays to the shadows wouldn't match up to either Garrus or Legion in open combat, which is what Thunderdome implies.

So its out of Legion and Garrus imo. Legion is faster, stronger, more accurate, can take more damage, and will never tire. Garrus, however, has massive experience with dealing with the geth and Legion's platform is based on the standard geth trooper.

So overall, I reckon Garrus would have the edge. If it got to close combat Thane might outmatch him, but overall I think Garrus would win.

I don't think Kaidan would stand much of a chance in this category - his role is more that of support, not combat.



However, if each contestant was able to fight in their ideal conditions Thane would win, due to his nigh-unparalled skills as an assassin. In the open combat of the Thunderdome those skills count for little, but in ideal conditions Thane could kill the others without them ever knowing he was there.

Modifié par Candidate 88766, 10 mai 2012 - 10:23 .

[Gen Petitt]

Garrus would win he has ridiculous headshot accuracy and calibrations

[kumquats]

Wow that's a hard one. I mean Thane is ill and all, but how he fights against Kei Leng is impressiv.
Maybe Legion could win if he uses the most amazing Grenadier Specc for Geth. ^.^

Kaidan would never win, he is more of a supporter.
Garrus would not win, because he would camp one spot and sniper everyone. And everyone who playes shooters know, that campers don't win.

My money is on Legion, Geth have a wallhack. ^.^
But Thane is very close.