And how in the worlds name those beaming everyone with some kind of laser from the mass relays, suddenly change your dna? What?! Wouldn't synthesis imply that every organic should undergo upgrades, like those TIM and Saren got? So everyone is suddenly cyborgs? What is this new dna? On with points those it affect the organic body (with a beam, seriously... space magic weee).
It simply is irrationallity in it's purest form. And the idea that synthesis should create a peaceful world between organics and synthetics implies that the god child should also rewrite the way each individual thinks (indoctrination gasp!!). Because every species (incl. synthetics) have their individual ideas. Will the krogan simply say: "What the hell, we are half-synthetics now, so lets hold hands and dance all night with the turians and salarians"? Or for example if we made the assumption that the war between the geth and quarians hadn't ended before the synthesis took place. Would they simply give up the war because their all 50/50?
For peace to exist, the god child would also have to rewrite every single individuals mind, to accept that now all races are equal and the same.
And then there's the point about shepard simply chooses for everyone, taking away their personal freedom, by choosing synthesis.
It simply is a mind-blowingly flawed theory presented by the god child, not to say that the rest it says is any better.
* Update*
The idea the god child has, is that synthetic life no matter what WILL DESTOY all organic life because they will come to the conclusion that organic life is flawed. If synthetics already came to this conclusion, would it change anything that they are suddenly 50/50? Probably impossible to answer this question because it requires too many assumptions. Which also shows the flaws behind synthesis.
Example with organic vs organic: If the US and Russia where at war and suddenly some "thing" made them all half-Russian and half-American, would that end the war? Probably not because each indiviual still identifies themselves as their former dna.
Would synthetics also think this way or are they as invidual thinkers flawed? Meaning that their oppion about a specie suddenly changes because of a change in that species dna?
Another thing I thought about: If the former humans suddenly decides that they want to create new synthetics (for labour as an example) doesn't that simply recreate the "problem" or are these synthetics also 50/50 (meaning: more space magic)?
Modifié par Steve The Seal, 07 mai 2012 - 07:49 .
Retour en haut
