428 réponses à ce sujet

[JBPBRC]

*looks at OP*

Troll thread is troll.

[balance5050]

Terminator Krogans that lay eggs by the thousands... wait... robot eggs? I've already confused myself.

[RocketManSR2]

I can see it now, the new species that the TC created travel to another galaxy:

"We will add your biological and technological distinctiveness to our own."
"Resistance is futile. You will be assimilated."

[kookie28]

The Mad Hanar wrote...

Do you enjoy commiting genocide, Shepard?

I enjoyed shutting down the machines.

And living.

[Dude_in_the_Room]

Genocide is a hobby of mine. I kill many as a hero in just about any game.

[HellbirdIV]

The Mad Hanar wrote...

Do you enjoy commiting genocide, Shepard?

Yes. The Reapers deserved it, they were, as a species, entirely and irreversibly evil.

If you're talking about the geth, their deaths are on the Reapers. If they don't die from the Reaper-killing radiation, then the Reapers would kill or lobotomize them anyway.

[Dude_in_the_Room]

The Mad Hanar wrote...

Dude_in_the_Room wrote...

Genocide is a hobby of mine. I kill many as a hero in just about any game.

Did you destroy Megaton? You destroyed Megaton, didn't you?

They deserved it.....stupid zealots.

[rubynorman]

David7204 wrote...

No.

But I enjoy not being united with Liara even less.

SergeantSnookie wrote...

Do you enjoy dying, Shepard?

QuantumSheep13 wrote...

I picked "Destroy" because red's my second-favourite colour.

(My first favourite is pink).

+1

[Rockstarblunt]

The Mad Hanar wrote...

Do you enjoy commiting genocide, Shepard?

You actually believe and trust what the catalyst says? No shepard didn't commit genocide with destroy option.

it's been proven that the catalyst does indeed lie. Sigh.

Gullible OP.

[Eclipse merc]

Yup, it's a hobby of mine I like to do in my spare time.

[Awoken Eyes]

The Mad Hanar wrote...

But you did do it on purpose. He told you "If you shoot this tube, the Geth will die."


It seems you knew what you were doing going into it.

I can't seem to recall actually seeing the Geth dying, did you? I don't recall seeing anyone dying apart from the Illusive Man and Anderson.
So, as long as I don't have solid proof I commited, as you say, "genocide", it didn't happen.

[s17tabris]

The Mad Hanar wrote...

Do you enjoy commiting genocide, Shepard?

No. Shep didn't live long enough to enjoy it.

[Awoken Eyes]

The Mad Hanar wrote...
Sooo...pics or it didn't happen?

Exactly, and while your at it, you might want to search for the definition of "genocide".

[shurikenmanta]

Not particularly, but it's not like I had any other real option. I trusted Harbinger Junior about as far as I could throw him and it was either, from that POV, the Geth dying or *infinitely more* dying. At that point, it was Reapers go down or nothing.

[Zolt51]

I picked destroy on my renegade ending. Clear conscience too, the Geth were already history. Don't blame me, blame the Quarians.

Should have added 2+2 when they chose to take reaper upgrades. We are trying to destroy the reapers, and you guys want to become more like them? Well...

Modifié par Zolt51, 09 mai 2012 - 07:21 .

[Total Biscuit]

Picked red without a moments hesitation. Both Green and Blue leave the Reapers alive, (green even possibly upgrades them) and able to continue the cycle if they break free or change their minds at some point down the road.

That's not a risk any sane person should be willing to take, and if it had been a Geth or EDI in Shepards place at the end, and they'd wipe out all organic life instead, I'd have wanted them to do the same thing, the right thing, and finish the job, stop the Reapers, no matter the cost.

And, given that EDI was fine in my ending, and from what's been said about the Geth surviving with a high enough EMS, my Shepard didn't commit genocide anyway. Yay for him.

The ending was still total bollocks throughout mind.

[Zolt51]

Total Biscuit wrote...
That's not a risk any sane person should be willing to take, and if it had been a Geth or EDI in Shepards place at the end, and they'd wipe out all organic life instead, I'd have wanted them to do the same thing, the right thing, and finish the job, stop the Reapers, no matter the cost.

Thank you for callind my Paragon shep insane.

Please, I undestand that many of us have strong opinions on the endings, but that's no reason to go down to the level of personal insults.

Modifié par Zolt51, 09 mai 2012 - 07:23 .

[OneWithTheAssassins]

With the IT in place, destroy is the best ending.
Even without the IT, its still the best ending IMO.
But that doesn't mean that I liked my choise, or any of them as a matter of fact.

Modifié par OneWithTheAssassins, 09 mai 2012 - 07:25 .

[ZombieChad]

No, but their death was necessary to stop a far worse evil. You might have noticed the species of genocidal AI dreadnoughts in the game. I take consolation that their sacrifice (along with every other person who died) stopped the biggest warmongers and mass murderers ever.

I can even support Control to some extent, I won't choose it as it sounds that at best as if Shep is one Anti-virus sweep from being removed. Then from what we're told in each cycle the Indoctrinated always seem to try and control the Reapers. The Reapers' according to what we see are still out there and any other real effects we have to imagine Shepard getting into Harbinger's head "Assuming Control" and piloting him into a star. I can understand why some would choose it though I think this one is down to whether you believe one man can quieten the millions of Reapers and subvert them to be friendlier without becoming despotic like Leto II does in God-Emperor of Dune. 

I also take consolation from the fact I've not corrupted the essence of every single species in the galaxy on the advice of the entity that started all this Synthesis adjusts the biochemistry of eveything and merges it with Reaper tech on the advice of an entity that has a flawed logic and even more flawed plan. Yet many proponents claim it won't alter the essence of people I think that's highly unlikely as we're simply a collection of electrical signals running through sack of chemicals and water and any change in composition of that will change what you "are".

So instead of trusting those responsible for the genocide of possibly millions of species I put my trust in life (both any future Synthetic/surviving Geth and Organic species) to make it's own decisions without me and a wave of Green BS.

From a writing perspective I can accept the blast of blue energy controlling the Reapers the blast (a control signal) of red energy killing the Reapers/AI (a kill-switch). A green wave adjusting all organic matter? ****** off. I'll go so far as to say that whilst the concept of Synthesis is interesting (Ieldra2 did a good post on it, somewhere) it's implementation is dire and makes it the most evil and subversive of choices that strips all survivor's of their individual's rights to choose their own fate.

I can see the next question what about the rights of the Geth... "Ruthless Calculus" we're in a war for the very existence of all species and the sacrifice of one species so that every other species is freed from an imposed order based on flawed logic and cyclic slaughter whilst retaining it's own identity and freedom of choice for an individual? BARGAIN. I would make the same choice regardless of species on the line, from the beginning I thought we'd face a choice where the most guaranteed method to stop the Reapers was the sacrifice of  mankind with other lesser options available. Besides from what I saw AI other than the Reapers can work really well with organics provided their survival isn't threatened (understandably) and that the Geth and Quarian conflict wasn't far off the reactions of Human's and Turian's during the First Contact War.

PS: EDI survived.

Modifié par ZombieChad, 09 mai 2012 - 07:28 .

[dorktainian]

The Mad Hanar wrote...

Do you enjoy commiting genocide, Shepard?

only a truly disturbed jellyfish could come up with a comment like that for what is the only correct choice of ending.

/facepalm.