428 réponses à ce sujet

[richard_rider]

Wasn't enjoyable, hell nothing about the ending is enjoyable, but we did what was necessary...either way, I'm pretty sure BW ruined the ME universe for a lot of people...

[moater boat]

It wasn't genocide any more than leaving Ashley or Kaiden on Virmire was murder you twit. Learn what words mean so I don't have to take the time to explain to you why you are an idiot.

[Funkdrspot]

The Mad Hanar wrote...

Do you enjoy commiting genocide, Shepard?

Paragon Shep said this to TIM not 5 minutes before the StarChild convo:

"If we destroy the reapers, this ends today, but you can't control them..."
"BUT I CAN!!"
"Are you willing to bet humanity's existence on it?"

Point being, i didn't like killing the Geth and EDI but I wasn't willing to bet every race's existence on the chance that the reapers weren't lying. I picked the choice I would have picked if i was actually Shepard.

[The Night Mammoth]

The Geth didn't die. Unless the Crucible somehow takes out all forms of software too.

Which would be yet another addition to the list of nonsensical ass-pulls BioWare achieved in this game.

You could of course just do that yourself and headcanon around the idiocy of Control, so the Reapers become your lackeys that Shep can use to solve the galaxy's problems. After all, isn't that what BioWare wanted? For us to use our imagination to fill in the gaps? 

Modifié par The Night Mammoth, 09 mai 2012 - 10:07 .

[vixvicco]

The Mad Hanar wrote...

Do you enjoy commiting genocide, Shepard?

It's not genocide if its not organic. If you're killing a synthetic, is it really murder?

[Necrotron]

Tietj wrote...

Well, the geth were already dead in my playthrough. So... I didn't commit genocide.

Touché

[ploppy54]

Destroy is the only ending from the start it's been to save the galaxy and destroy the reapers the other choices just go against that, when I can bring myself to play again I will pick destroy again

[Obvakhi]

If what the Catalyst says is true, and that the Reapers fly off to god knows where, never to come back.... then Control is the better ending. Simply because it has the least amount of casualties. The geth are still alive & the Citadel is still intact.

[Shallyah]

Nobody enjoys commiting genocide.

However, I'd have enjoyed less being the cause of the Genocide of millions of species in the future by choosing Synthesis or Control.

So the question is: Did you enjoy having in your hand the possibility of saving the Galaxy, and being a fool dimwitted tool in the end to choose the opposite of what you had been fighting for all your life?

Modifié par Shallyah, 09 mai 2012 - 10:41 .

[Arcadian Legend]

TheBlackBaron wrote...

It's not genocide if you can just, y'know, build more robots. Are we expected to believe there is no record anywhere in the galaxy of how to construct more geth?

If it even wipes out all synthetic life in the first place - EDI survives, assuming that's not just an oversight. Frankly, depending on if you believe in certain theories that shall not be named, there's little point in believing anything holo-child (calling him the Star Child is an insult to Stanley Kubrick and Arthur C. Clarke) says to begin with.

EDIT: Also, Mr. Big Pimpin up there, nice sig. 

Exactly. Who's to say we can't build more geth? Not to mention there could have always been geth outside Mass Relay range.

[CroGamer002]

^But will those new robots be geth?

[Obvakhi]

Arcadian Legend wrote...

TheBlackBaron wrote...

It's not genocide if you can just, y'know, build more robots. Are we expected to believe there is no record anywhere in the galaxy of how to construct more geth?

If it even wipes out all synthetic life in the first place - EDI survives, assuming that's not just an oversight. Frankly, depending on if you believe in certain theories that shall not be named, there's little point in believing anything holo-child (calling him the Star Child is an insult to Stanley Kubrick and Arthur C. Clarke) says to begin with.

EDIT: Also, Mr. Big Pimpin up there, nice sig. 

Exactly. Who's to say we can't build more geth? Not to mention there could have always been geth outside Mass Relay range.

And who's to say those new robots won't want to eradicate all organic life later on? 

[Arcadian Legend]

Mesina2 wrote...

^But will those new robots be geth?

If the quarians remake them in the exact same way as before. There may be some slight differences, but it may not be all that different from reviving Shep. Remember how Miranda said she would try anything to make sure Shep was the exact same man/women she was before death? (disregarding player choice) Plus if there were some Geth outside relay range (possible, they'd have remote stations EVERYWHERE in and around the Veil and other places) there won't be any worries regarding that because they know how to build themselves probably better than even the quarians if you know what I'm trying to say.

Plus as a side note Destroy is the only ending that ensure total death for reapers. I keep getting the feeling regarding the other two that due to the fact they are still active there is little in the end stopping them from coming back again if they deemed it necessary.

[Pelle6666]

Stupid ending, stupid post.
Red was just the least ridiculous.

[Arcadian Legend]

Obvakhi wrote...

Arcadian Legend wrote...

TheBlackBaron wrote...

It's not genocide if you can just, y'know, build more robots. Are we expected to believe there is no record anywhere in the galaxy of how to construct more geth?

If it even wipes out all synthetic life in the first place - EDI survives, assuming that's not just an oversight. Frankly, depending on if you believe in certain theories that shall not be named, there's little point in believing anything holo-child (calling him the Star Child is an insult to Stanley Kubrick and Arthur C. Clarke) says to begin with.

EDIT: Also, Mr. Big Pimpin up there, nice sig. 

Exactly. Who's to say we can't build more geth? Not to mention there could have always been geth outside Mass Relay range.

And who's to say those new robots won't want to eradicate all organic life later on? 

Only because the quarians treated them like pieces of ****. If we were tp screw up and rebuild the geth as something that would kill us from the start of their recreation that's our own damn fault. And we'd probably deserve it for it. Also lulz at your sig. Seen that too many times.

Modifié par Arcadian Legend, 09 mai 2012 - 11:02 .

[vixvicco]

jreezy wrote...

vixvicco wrote...

The Mad Hanar wrote...

Do you enjoy commiting genocide, Shepard?

It's not genocide if its not organic.

So wrong it's funny.

I don't get how people get all emotional about the geth. Like really? Just because they can imitate being human, doesn't make them equal to a person. So people are actually conflicted about this choice because they are afraid to kill a machine? That like saying you don't want to shut down a computer because you're scared you'll hurt its feelings. 
Plus, the Reapers clearly weren't created by organics, whereas the geth where. If I had to consider it genocide, I would only consider it so in regards to the Reapers, who you want to kill anyway. They are partly organic as well, which is another point. I like Legion, but to save him over a living, breathing thing? Stupid.

Modifié par vixvicco, 09 mai 2012 - 11:01 .

[Aggie Punbot]

The Mad Hanar wrote...

Do you enjoy commiting genocide, Shepard?

In war, harsh decisions have to be made. Shepard had to make one with the Alpha Relay, and s/he had to make one regarding the geth. Wanting to guarantee that the Reapers are never able to reap again is not a bad thing. Neither Control nor Synthesis guarantee that the Reapers will not return, but Destroy does.

Modifié par TS2Aggie, 09 mai 2012 - 11:00 .

[crimzontearz]

if it means Shepard lives? oh yeah

[Obvakhi]

vixvicco wrote...
I don't get how people get all emotional about the geth. Like really? Just because they can imitate being human, doesn't make them equal to a person. So people are actually conflicted about this choice because they are afraid to kill a machine? That like saying you don't want to shut down a computer because you're scared you'll hurt its feelings. 
Plus, the Reapers clearly weren't created by organics, whereas the geth where. If I had to consider it genocide, I would only consider it so in regards to the Reapers, who you want to kill anyway. They are partly organic as well, which is another point. I like Legion, but to save him over a living, breathing thing? Stupid.

That's exactly what a Renegade Shepard would say. "Who gives a damn about a robot, humans come first!"
Paragon Shepard clearly believes synthetics have every right to live as organics do.

Modifié par Obvakhi, 09 mai 2012 - 11:08 .

[Dendio1]

Renegade shepard is a jerk and my paragon shepard would put him down.

[Xenite]

That whole logic depends on assuming the star-child was telling the truth in the first place.

Why would ANYONE trust what a reaper says? Not only that but Shepard lives after the explosion, proving the brat was FOS!

[WE_Belisarius]

My Shepard did not enjoyed commiting genocide, since he already killed the Geth on Rannoch.
Btw OP, did your Shepard enjoyed the massmurdering of 300.000 Batarians in Arrival?