276 réponses à ce sujet

[snfonseka]

done

[hellgate49698]

Done and Done.

[ardensia]

Post redacted: Looking at wrong stats.

Modifié par ardensia, 11 mai 2012 - 04:17 .

[Nauks]

The I.T section might need an addition.

Bioware simply confirming it wouldn't suffice, even if I.T. is true, the game (as it is currently) ends on a cliffhanger.

[Zolt51]

Nauks wrote...

The I.T section might need an addition.

Bioware simply confirming it wouldn't suffice, even if I.T. is true, the game (as it is currently) ends on a cliffhanger.

Right, I meant it that way: If IT is made canon, of course the real ending should be given. Made it clearer now.

[Nauks]

Zolt51 wrote...

Nauks wrote...

The I.T section might need an addition.

Bioware simply confirming it wouldn't suffice, even if I.T. is true, the game (as it is currently) ends on a cliffhanger.

Right, I meant it that way: If IT is made canon, of course the real ending should be given. Made it clearer now.

Ow ok, *tips hat*
Survey taken, loads of options, very thorough.

Modifié par Nauks, 11 mai 2012 - 04:35 .

[Zolt51]

From the comments:

My greatest annoyance by far was Joker's Wild Ride to gilligan's planet. It needs to be explained why he was beating feet through the Charon Relay.

Second was the inability to challenge the Catalysts assumptions.

Can't believe I forgot about these two. Added the first to Part 3 - that's if you want to actually change that scene. If you just want to explain it, I believe "What happens to the squad while we're on the Citadel" covers it.
Added the second to part 2 since it could still fit in without altering the existing dialogue lines or choices.

Modifié par Zolt51, 11 mai 2012 - 05:01 .

[dgcatanisiri]

If you're going to include more content for Miranda and Jack as separate questions, the other romance options should be included. For detail's sake, there probably should be a section on the squadmates and their usage in-game.

[Zolt51]

Bumps head against wall. Tali's FACE! Of course! Why did I not include this from the start?

I'm afraid I'm going to skew the survey a bit with these additions. I might publish a separate analysis excluding the first 600 results or so.

Other things:
- Fixing the Journal seems to be the most common bug complaint in single player.
- Harbinger as a boss battle has come up a few times. I had it as an option in the previous survey, but it didn't get enough support to warrant putting it back in.

[SpiritWolf448]

Done.

And I would really love for them to fix the annoying bugs, like heads turning 180° when speaking to people, characters floating in the air, Shepard twitching like he has a spasm during some conversation scenes, the horrible lighting, the face import ****.... even without the debacle that was the ending, the game has many smaller problems which, all taken together, really take the wind out of it's sails.

[devSin]

This doesn't guard against ballot-stuffing, does it?

That and changing the survey questions partway through would make it all pretty invalid, although still interesting.

[Zolt51]

devSin wrote...

This doesn't guard against ballot-stuffing, does it?

That and changing the survey questions partway through would make it all pretty invalid, although still interesting.

Nope it doesn't. The only way to do that would be to make a BSN survey, or somehow log IP's. But I love the analysis power of Google Docs.

I actually don't mind that people fill this in a second time: Since I've been tweaking the survey a bit in the last couple hours, it's their right to give different answers. If enough people answer this (and it looks good so far), a few hardliners voting 3-4 times won't matter. I can also scan for large groups of similar answers to root out mass abusers or bots.

Speaking of analysis:
- The bar is set high for Bioware: 67% of respondents want at least 10 of the 12 options (originally) proposed in part 2. 27% want ALL of them.
- The reward may be equally high. The satisfaction delta stands a 0.91 point (out of 5) This is the difference between how satisifed people are with the game as it is, versus how satisifed they would be with their choices in Pt 2 implemented.

I'm very happy to have the breakdown by platform. Since Xbox users actually constitute the vast majority of the player base, I might re-weight the survey results in their favour a bit. Of course I'll be very transparent about that. Fortunately the differences between Xbox and PC players aren't that huge.

Modifié par Zolt51, 11 mai 2012 - 05:57 .

[Shajar]

Done and you can laugh about my "extra" comments

Modifié par Shajar, 11 mai 2012 - 06:37 .

[Zolt51]

Stupid, stupid me! I had forgotten to enable "Share summary of results!" Now you will see the results after you have completed the survey.

Direct link to the summary here:
https://docs.google....2alNKWlAzSHc6MQ

Modifié par Zolt51, 11 mai 2012 - 06:47 .

[Belisarius09]

Done. I think you did an excellent job in keeping your personal bias as a pro-ender out of the survey. To be honest my first impression of you from the survey was that you hated the endings before I read your post where you stated you are unabashedly pro-ender. So, excellent job in short.

[Zolt51]

Shajar wrote...

Done and you can laugh about my "extra" comments

If I go by the timestamp that would be: "Tali is hot" and I agree.

[Zolt51]

Fixed the results on the second IT question. After I changed the wording of one of the answers, totals weren't tallying correctly.

Modifié par Zolt51, 11 mai 2012 - 07:54 .

[milena87]

Oh well, why not? Done.

[Talhydras]

Really cool survey! Thanks for setting this up - I think you did a great job. Thanks also for sharing the results and analysis.

[Capthon]

Done.

[Zolt51]

To celebrate 700 replies, I've started looking at part 3: Those options that require major rework and change to parts of the game, contrary to what Bioware has announced.

- 57% of respondents have chosen at least one option in Part 3, and will be dissatisfied / very dissatisfied if it is NOT implemented.
- 26% have chosen 3 or more options in Part 3, and will be dissatisfied / very dissatisfied if they are NOT implemented.

Clearly the most popular of these is to replace or alter the Catalyst somehow (79%) with the most popular choice being by Harbinger (44%)
Cutting or modifying the "Joker runs away" scene is also very popular: 83% of respondents since the option was introduced. That is: As opposed to just explaining it.
Adding an option for conventional battle (Reject the 3 choices) also gets 77% support. I'm curious, would you guys still want to have that option even if we loose?

Modifié par Zolt51, 11 mai 2012 - 09:06 .

[ThiZZo]

Done.

[Ghost Rider LSOV]

Done here too.

[BobbyDylan]

Ghostrider!!!!!!

[Renessa]

Done. Very good survey.
Funnily enough, filling out the questionare made it clearer for me just how unsatisfied I would be, if they will just explain these awful endings.