Aller au contenu

Photo

The canon (minimum) amount of time Shepard has been exposed to Reaper tech


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
461 réponses à ce sujet

#351
111987

111987
  • Members
  • 3 758 messages

balance5050 wrote...

111987 wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...

111987 wrote...

@dreman9999

Saren was not indoctrinated after he died. You cannot indoctrinate a dead brain.

You can implant a person, who then dies, and then take control of their body provided it is still intact.

Otherwise we would see the equivalent of zombies running around everywhere the Reapers are. Implants are a necessity in this situation.

Your not getting mypoitn..The damage is still there....Think ofindoctrination like brain damege..You can't undo it andit does not go away. Even if it doesnot advance when Shepard isdead...It' still there to start agein when Shepard is revived. Think of it like a snow ball effect. It's still count as 3 years because nothing can be undone...Think ofit like TIM's indoctrination that lasted, slowly for over 20 years.


No, you are not getting my point. You said Sovereign could indoctrinate Saren's dead brain, which is how he controlled him. This is FALSE; he controlled them through the implants.

Even if your claims that Shepard's mind somehow retained the indoctrination 'seed' in it, how do you explain the fact that Shepard has been exposed less than a full day throughout all three games (assuming you don't do Arrival)? Unless you are suggesting indoctrination, once it hits you, grows on its own without any more exposure. Which would be totally unfounded.

TIM was not slowly indoctrinated after 20 years. He only became indoctrinated after implanting himself.


Saren created Cerberus, a splinter group that thought to control the reapers ad were indoctrinated.

EVERY CYCLE HAS A SPLINTER GROUP THAT WAS INDOCTRINATED AND THOUGHT TO CONTROL THE REAPERS.

As Neo would say "It's just another form of control"

Of course TIM had at least a hint of indoc to be manipulated in to serving the reapers like so many before him have.


I'll assume you meant TIM, not Saren.

Cerberus was indoctrinated. TIM was not, until the end, after his implants. Otherwise he wouldn't have been opposing the Reapers his whole life, and otherwise the Reapers wouldn't have come for him on Sanctuary. Why bother if he was indoctrinated?

#352
Raiil

Raiil
  • Members
  • 4 011 messages

balance5050 wrote...

Elyiia wrote...

balance5050 wrote...


The thing is he keeps showing you the evidence and you can't even seem to accept the possibility when it says right in the Codex NO ONE fully understands indoctriation or how it works. 


Evidence? All the "evidence" he's shown is that one type of Reaper device indoctrinates by being there and is using that as "evidence" that all Reaper devices indoctrinate by being. He's also claiming the Collector base indoctrinates when organics are not even supposed to reach it. Again, tell me how there's even a resistance on Earth if husks and killing husks causing indoctrination.


This will sound ridiculous to you probably, but even Shepard would assume that all reaper tech indoctrinates.


Which is why he freely and continually storms bases filled with Reaper tech (even a frigging ship) on a regular basis.

Really.


Like, for real.

#353
dreman9999

dreman9999
  • Members
  • 19 067 messages

Valentia X wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...

Valentia X wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...

-snip-


Are you just... ignoring everything I actually say? Seriously? I said that there is no proof that all Reaper-based tech is capable of passive indoctrination.

I am not saying that Reapers can't use their foot solders are Indoc amplifiers.

I am not saying that it doesn't exist, I even noted some cases where we know it to be fact.


So are you just blowing off what I actually say, or what?

Let's take a quick note of the reaper based tech we seen in the game.
1.Dragons teeth.
2. Implants.
3.Indoctriantion devices.
4. The reapers them selves or reaperparts.
.....
2 and 3 we know can indoctrinate becauseof the codex andstory.
4 We know indoctriante based on the dead reaper and the hanar diplomate.
Only1,dragons teeth is question....But every dragon teeth we see has husk on it....Regardlessif the dragons teeth can indoctriante you or not...The husk still can.
....
Do you understand now?


1. Dragon's Teeth do not show any signs of passively indoctrinating
2. Implants do not show signs of indepentantly passively indoctrinating. They may help amplify the Reaper signal more but there is nothing to show that the implants, such as they are, passively indoctrinate (in the sense that, say, the derelict Reaper does- there is no evidence that their mere existence creates indoc rays).
3. ....what? That's what we're talking about, I think we both know that.
4. We know that there are devices capable of indoctrinating passively. No one in the thread is arguing that.
5. We already established that Reaper ground forces can become an antenna for indoctrination, at least in the case of organics.


...

Do you understand now? There is nothing in game that states that all Reaper-based tech is capable of passively indoctrinating other organics in their near vicinity. That there is Reaper-based tech that can passively indoctrinate in no way, shape, or form states or points to the idea that all Reaper-based tech does passively indoctrinate others in the area.

You cannot prove that it does, either, because we run into Reaper-based tech, or spin-offs (as the Collector ship may be considered) that do not show signs of passive enviornemental indoctrination. You can show what proof of devices that can; they are not undeniable proof that all can.

1.Didy ou even read what I said? My pointasto list reaper tech in the game.
1.Dragons teeth.
2. Implants.
3.Indoctriantion devices.
4. The reapers them selves or reaperparts. 
....
These areall reaper tech. Stop jumping to concusions.

2.Implants do show sign of passive indoctriantion.It's stated in the cerberus base and in ME:RETRIBUTION


His best guess was that a week had passed. Maybe two. Probably not three. The passage of time wasimpossible to track in the cell. There was nothing to do but eat and sleep. But when he slept he haddreams—nightmares he could never quite recall on waking, but that left him shivering nonetheless.He still had had no contact with anyone from Cerberus. But he couldn’t really say he was aloneanymore.They were inside his head, speaking to him in whispers too faint to understand. These weren’t like thecritical, sarcastic voice he used to hear in his thoughts. That voice was gone. The others had silenced itforever.He tried to ignore them, but it was impossible to block out their constant, insidious murmur. There wassomething simultaneously repulsive yet seductive about them. Their presence in his mind was both aviolation and an invitation: the Reapers calling to him across the great void of space.Somehow he knew that if he concentrated on them, he would be able to understand what they said.But he didn’t want to understand. He was trying very hard not to understand because he knewunderstanding the voices was the beginning of the end.With each passing hour Grayson could feel the whispers growing stronger. More insistent. Yet eventhough Cerberus had implanted him with this horrific alien technology, his will was still his own. For now,he was still able to resist them. And he intended to hold them at bay for as long as was humanly possible.“I thought you said the transformation would only take a week,” the Illusive Man said to Dr. Nuri.They were staring down at Grayson through the one-way window in the ceiling of his cell. Kai Lengwas lurking in the shadows over by the wall, standing so still he almost seemed to disappear in thedarkness.
(Page 55). The fact that implatation can be resisted for a week makes it clear it an influence.

Also, you missed the dead reaper and the indocrination deviceon Arrival.

#354
111987

111987
  • Members
  • 3 758 messages

FellishBeast wrote...

If this post is supposed to disprove IT, it misses the point. IT doesn't claim Shep is indoctrinated.

Edit: Also, Arrival definitely happens even if you don't play the DLC. It's the whole reason Shepard is on earth at the beginning of ME3.


No no no no no. Please read the dozen or so posts in this thread explaining that Arrival does not happen for all Shepards. If you do not import, than an Alliance team does Arrival.

#355
balance5050

balance5050
  • Members
  • 5 245 messages

Valentia X wrote...

balance5050 wrote...

Elyiia wrote...

balance5050 wrote...


The thing is he keeps showing you the evidence and you can't even seem to accept the possibility when it says right in the Codex NO ONE fully understands indoctriation or how it works. 


Evidence? All the "evidence" he's shown is that one type of Reaper device indoctrinates by being there and is using that as "evidence" that all Reaper devices indoctrinate by being. He's also claiming the Collector base indoctrinates when organics are not even supposed to reach it. Again, tell me how there's even a resistance on Earth if husks and killing husks causing indoctrination.


This will sound ridiculous to you probably, but even Shepard would assume that all reaper tech indoctrinates.


Which is why he freely and continually storms bases filled with Reaper tech (even a frigging ship) on a regular basis.

Really.


Like, for real.


Right so he's around it all the time so it makes sense that it's having an effect on him=]

Modifié par balance5050, 14 mai 2012 - 06:55 .


#356
dreman9999

dreman9999
  • Members
  • 19 067 messages

Valentia X wrote...

balance5050 wrote...

Elyiia wrote...

balance5050 wrote...


The thing is he keeps showing you the evidence and you can't even seem to accept the possibility when it says right in the Codex NO ONE fully understands indoctriation or how it works. 


Evidence? All the "evidence" he's shown is that one type of Reaper device indoctrinates by being there and is using that as "evidence" that all Reaper devices indoctrinate by being. He's also claiming the Collector base indoctrinates when organics are not even supposed to reach it. Again, tell me how there's even a resistance on Earth if husks and killing husks causing indoctrination.


This will sound ridiculous to you probably, but even Shepard would assume that all reaper tech indoctrinates.


Which is why he freely and continually storms bases filled with Reaper tech (even a frigging ship) on a regular basis.

Really.


Like, for real.

You make it like he has a choice. You hve to fight reaper forces and go to therebase ground to fight them. That's the entore problem with fighting reapers...You risk indoctriantion.

#357
Elyiia

Elyiia
  • Members
  • 1 568 messages

balance5050 wrote...

Elyiia wrote...

balance5050 wrote...


The thing is he keeps showing you the evidence and you can't even seem to accept the possibility when it says right in the Codex NO ONE fully understands indoctriation or how it works. 


Evidence? All the "evidence" he's shown is that one type of Reaper device indoctrinates by being there and is using that as "evidence" that all Reaper devices indoctrinate by being. He's also claiming the Collector base indoctrinates when organics are not even supposed to reach it. Again, tell me how there's even a resistance on Earth if husks and killing husks causing indoctrination.


This will sound ridiculous to you probably, but even Shepard would assume that all reaper tech indoctrinates.


And? There's no evidence they all indoctrinate the same way and to assume so is crazy. Dragon's teeth specifically work by impaling an organic. Why bother impaling if it can do it just by being there, which would be much more effective.

The Collector base, the Collector ship and the Reaper IFF all have one thing in common. Organics are not supposed to come close to them.

#358
dreman9999

dreman9999
  • Members
  • 19 067 messages

Elyiia wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...

Elyiia wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...

Seriously, I'm not sure if you're trolling or if you're actually not understanding this. The orb is what caused the indoctrinated agents who then used the dragon's teeth. This is not hard.

1.There is no orb...Just the object that is simular to what the geth were worshiping in Faros.
2. I already movedon from Dragon teeth indoctrianting.
3. Husk can indoctrinated as well....And they are found on dragons teeth.


1) That is the orb, it says so right in the passage you linked.
2) Good, because there's no evidence they do.
3) It specifically says that Husks can give off the signal, however this is not what actually indoctrinates. The nanites are what indoctrinate. The husks can allow the Reapers to amplify the commands to the nanites. Otherwise every single front line unit would be indoctrinated. Furthermore Shepard's contact with husks is literally a few seconds before he explodes them.


1. http://www.youtube.c...qViKzHzI#t=243s
3.The nanites are commanded by QEC.

From ME:retribution

The waves are something different....


So we're back on the Dragon's teeth. I love this circular arguing. You know there are husks and there are dragon's teeth. That is all you know. I could claim that cyborg Trexes came in and put them on the dragon's teeth. You can't prove they didn't.

So kindly show how I am wrong and show what the waves do.

No...We arenot back to dragons teeth...READ WHAT I WROTE...I'm talking about the nanites. What's in the husk. That what your not getting. Reaper nanitescan indoctrinate....There's a book about it.

#359
balance5050

balance5050
  • Members
  • 5 245 messages

Elyiia wrote...

balance5050 wrote...

Elyiia wrote...

balance5050 wrote...


The thing is he keeps showing you the evidence and you can't even seem to accept the possibility when it says right in the Codex NO ONE fully understands indoctriation or how it works. 


Evidence? All the "evidence" he's shown is that one type of Reaper device indoctrinates by being there and is using that as "evidence" that all Reaper devices indoctrinate by being. He's also claiming the Collector base indoctrinates when organics are not even supposed to reach it. Again, tell me how there's even a resistance on Earth if husks and killing husks causing indoctrination.


This will sound ridiculous to you probably, but even Shepard would assume that all reaper tech indoctrinates.


And? There's no evidence they all indoctrinate the same way and to assume so is crazy. Dragon's teeth specifically work by impaling an organic. Why bother impaling if it can do it just by being there, which would be much more effective.

The Collector base, the Collector ship and the Reaper IFF all have one thing in common. Organics are not supposed to come close to them.


Agree to disagree, I think reaper tech indoctrinates and you don't.

#360
dreman9999

dreman9999
  • Members
  • 19 067 messages

Elyiia wrote...

balance5050 wrote...

Elyiia wrote...

balance5050 wrote...


The thing is he keeps showing you the evidence and you can't even seem to accept the possibility when it says right in the Codex NO ONE fully understands indoctriation or how it works. 


Evidence? All the "evidence" he's shown is that one type of Reaper device indoctrinates by being there and is using that as "evidence" that all Reaper devices indoctrinate by being. He's also claiming the Collector base indoctrinates when organics are not even supposed to reach it. Again, tell me how there's even a resistance on Earth if husks and killing husks causing indoctrination.


This will sound ridiculous to you probably, but even Shepard would assume that all reaper tech indoctrinates.


And? There's no evidence they all indoctrinate the same way and to assume so is crazy. Dragon's teeth specifically work by impaling an organic. Why bother impaling if it can do it just by being there, which would be much more effective.

The Collector base, the Collector ship and the Reaper IFF all have one thing in common. Organics are not supposed to come close to them.

You not understand the ponit of dragons teeth...Their point is to enhance the inductee no purely indoctrinate them. Why do you think they put all that tech in there bodies?

#361
BigGuy28

BigGuy28
  • Members
  • 552 messages

Elyiia wrote...

balance5050 wrote...

Elyiia wrote...

balance5050 wrote...


The thing is he keeps showing you the evidence and you can't even seem to accept the possibility when it says right in the Codex NO ONE fully understands indoctriation or how it works. 


Evidence? All the "evidence" he's shown is that one type of Reaper device indoctrinates by being there and is using that as "evidence" that all Reaper devices indoctrinate by being. He's also claiming the Collector base indoctrinates when organics are not even supposed to reach it. Again, tell me how there's even a resistance on Earth if husks and killing husks causing indoctrination.


This will sound ridiculous to you probably, but even Shepard would assume that all reaper tech indoctrinates.


And? There's no evidence they all indoctrinate the same way and to assume so is crazy. Dragon's teeth specifically work by impaling an organic. Why bother impaling if it can do it just by being there, which would be much more effective.

The Collector base, the Collector ship and the Reaper IFF all have one thing in common. Organics are not supposed to come close to them.


You can't win with them, it's like a religion, believe what they believe or they will beat you over the head until you do. After all, they are "freedom fighters fighting for the truth".

#362
balance5050

balance5050
  • Members
  • 5 245 messages

Elyiia wrote...


And? There's no evidence they all indoctrinate the same way and to assume so is crazy. Dragon's teeth specifically work by impaling an organic. Why bother impaling if it can do it just by being there, which would be much more effective.

 
So husks give off the indoctriation signal but dragons teeth, the thing that MAKE the husks, don't? Strange logic.

Modifié par balance5050, 14 mai 2012 - 07:02 .


#363
Elyiia

Elyiia
  • Members
  • 1 568 messages

BigGuy28 wrote...

Elyiia wrote...

balance5050 wrote...

Elyiia wrote...

balance5050 wrote...


The thing is he keeps showing you the evidence and you can't even seem to accept the possibility when it says right in the Codex NO ONE fully understands indoctriation or how it works. 


Evidence? All the "evidence" he's shown is that one type of Reaper device indoctrinates by being there and is using that as "evidence" that all Reaper devices indoctrinate by being. He's also claiming the Collector base indoctrinates when organics are not even supposed to reach it. Again, tell me how there's even a resistance on Earth if husks and killing husks causing indoctrination.


This will sound ridiculous to you probably, but even Shepard would assume that all reaper tech indoctrinates.


And? There's no evidence they all indoctrinate the same way and to assume so is crazy. Dragon's teeth specifically work by impaling an organic. Why bother impaling if it can do it just by being there, which would be much more effective.

The Collector base, the Collector ship and the Reaper IFF all have one thing in common. Organics are not supposed to come close to them.


You can't win with them, it's like a religion, believe what they believe or they will beat you over the head until you do. After all, they are "freedom fighters fighting for the truth".


I just can't keep up with their huge logic jumps, I give up. Even if you do, they attack your intelligence. "You don't believe Reaper tech indoctrinates" because I clearly haven't been saying Reaper tech designed to do so does.

#364
BigGuy28

BigGuy28
  • Members
  • 552 messages

Elyiia wrote...

I just can't keep up with their huge logic jumps, I give up. Even if you do, they attack your intelligence. "You don't believe Reaper tech indoctrinates" because I clearly haven't been saying Reaper tech designed to do so does.


Sadly that is a common theme, if you don't like the IT you clearly are too stupid to understand it.

#365
dreman9999

dreman9999
  • Members
  • 19 067 messages

111987 wrote...

balance5050 wrote...

111987 wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...

111987 wrote...

@dreman9999

Saren was not indoctrinated after he died. You cannot indoctrinate a dead brain.

You can implant a person, who then dies, and then take control of their body provided it is still intact.

Otherwise we would see the equivalent of zombies running around everywhere the Reapers are. Implants are a necessity in this situation.

Your not getting mypoitn..The damage is still there....Think ofindoctrination like brain damege..You can't undo it andit does not go away. Even if it doesnot advance when Shepard isdead...It' still there to start agein when Shepard is revived. Think of it like a snow ball effect. It's still count as 3 years because nothing can be undone...Think ofit like TIM's indoctrination that lasted, slowly for over 20 years.


No, you are not getting my point. You said Sovereign could indoctrinate Saren's dead brain, which is how he controlled him. This is FALSE; he controlled them through the implants.

Even if your claims that Shepard's mind somehow retained the indoctrination 'seed' in it, how do you explain the fact that Shepard has been exposed less than a full day throughout all three games (assuming you don't do Arrival)? Unless you are suggesting indoctrination, once it hits you, grows on its own without any more exposure. Which would be totally unfounded.

TIM was not slowly indoctrinated after 20 years. He only became indoctrinated after implanting himself.


Saren created Cerberus, a splinter group that thought to control the reapers ad were indoctrinated.

EVERY CYCLE HAS A SPLINTER GROUP THAT WAS INDOCTRINATED AND THOUGHT TO CONTROL THE REAPERS.

As Neo would say "It's just another form of control"

Of course TIM had at least a hint of indoc to be manipulated in to serving the reapers like so many before him have.


I'll assume you meant TIM, not Saren.

Cerberus was indoctrinated. TIM was not, until the end, after his implants. Otherwise he wouldn't have been opposing the Reapers his whole life, and otherwise the Reapers wouldn't have come for him on Sanctuary. Why bother if he was indoctrinated?

You notunderstanding what I meanabout TIM...I'm not saying he is under reaper control..I'm say he is in the process of reaper indoctrination.Being in the process of does not mean the reapers can inflence or control him...Just the foundation of indoctrination is in him...That's why TIM was easilly indoctrianted in the end. sapposivly.

#366
Raiil

Raiil
  • Members
  • 4 011 messages

dreman9999 wrote...



I mentioned that Reaper ships can passively indoctrinate. I even used it to illustrate that there are some that can. And yes, Object Rho does indoctrinate. I'm well aware. Again, that it is not proof that all Reaper-based tech can passively indoctrinate organics in their near vicinity. You seem to missing the point that I'm making, because I'm not denying that it can it does happen. I'm simply saying there's no proof that everthing based off of Reaper tech will invariably passively indoctrinate. You also have no definitve proof that they do; in fact, the Dragon's Teeth may be the biggest argument on hand to say that they don't, since the organic body has to be put onto the teeth for the huskification to begin.


The reason why Object Rho is not added to the definitive list is because not every Shepard does that mission. My canon Shepard didn't. 

#367
balance5050

balance5050
  • Members
  • 5 245 messages

dreman9999 wrote...

111987 wrote...

balance5050 wrote...

111987 wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...

111987 wrote...

@dreman9999

Saren was not indoctrinated after he died. You cannot indoctrinate a dead brain.

You can implant a person, who then dies, and then take control of their body provided it is still intact.

Otherwise we would see the equivalent of zombies running around everywhere the Reapers are. Implants are a necessity in this situation.

Your not getting mypoitn..The damage is still there....Think ofindoctrination like brain damege..You can't undo it andit does not go away. Even if it doesnot advance when Shepard isdead...It' still there to start agein when Shepard is revived. Think of it like a snow ball effect. It's still count as 3 years because nothing can be undone...Think ofit like TIM's indoctrination that lasted, slowly for over 20 years.


No, you are not getting my point. You said Sovereign could indoctrinate Saren's dead brain, which is how he controlled him. This is FALSE; he controlled them through the implants.

Even if your claims that Shepard's mind somehow retained the indoctrination 'seed' in it, how do you explain the fact that Shepard has been exposed less than a full day throughout all three games (assuming you don't do Arrival)? Unless you are suggesting indoctrination, once it hits you, grows on its own without any more exposure. Which would be totally unfounded.

TIM was not slowly indoctrinated after 20 years. He only became indoctrinated after implanting himself.


Saren created Cerberus, a splinter group that thought to control the reapers ad were indoctrinated.

EVERY CYCLE HAS A SPLINTER GROUP THAT WAS INDOCTRINATED AND THOUGHT TO CONTROL THE REAPERS.

As Neo would say "It's just another form of control"

Of course TIM had at least a hint of indoc to be manipulated in to serving the reapers like so many before him have.


I'll assume you meant TIM, not Saren.

Cerberus was indoctrinated. TIM was not, until the end, after his implants. Otherwise he wouldn't have been opposing the Reapers his whole life, and otherwise the Reapers wouldn't have come for him on Sanctuary. Why bother if he was indoctrinated?

You notunderstanding what I meanabout TIM...I'm not saying he is under reaper control..I'm say he is in the process of reaper indoctrination.Being in the process of does not mean the reapers can inflence or control him...Just the foundation of indoctrination is in him...That's why TIM was easilly indoctrianted in the end. sapposivly.


They planted the seed of "control" into TIM's head during the Shanxi incident IMO, would you agree?

#368
dreman9999

dreman9999
  • Members
  • 19 067 messages

Elyiia wrote...

BigGuy28 wrote...

Elyiia wrote...

balance5050 wrote...

Elyiia wrote...

balance5050 wrote...


The thing is he keeps showing you the evidence and you can't even seem to accept the possibility when it says right in the Codex NO ONE fully understands indoctriation or how it works. 


Evidence? All the "evidence" he's shown is that one type of Reaper device indoctrinates by being there and is using that as "evidence" that all Reaper devices indoctrinate by being. He's also claiming the Collector base indoctrinates when organics are not even supposed to reach it. Again, tell me how there's even a resistance on Earth if husks and killing husks causing indoctrination.


This will sound ridiculous to you probably, but even Shepard would assume that all reaper tech indoctrinates.


And? There's no evidence they all indoctrinate the same way and to assume so is crazy. Dragon's teeth specifically work by impaling an organic. Why bother impaling if it can do it just by being there, which would be much more effective.

The Collector base, the Collector ship and the Reaper IFF all have one thing in common. Organics are not supposed to come close to them.


You can't win with them, it's like a religion, believe what they believe or they will beat you over the head until you do. After all, they are "freedom fighters fighting for the truth".


I just can't keep up with their huge logic jumps, I give up. Even if you do, they attack your intelligence. "You don't believe Reaper tech indoctrinates" because I clearly haven't been saying Reaper tech designed to do so does.

Ok  then...Let's try to make this clear...List all the types of reaper tech you see in ME...

#369
111987

111987
  • Members
  • 3 758 messages

dreman9999 wrote...

You notunderstanding what I meanabout TIM...I'm not saying he is under reaper control..I'm say he is in the process of reaper indoctrination.Being in the process of does not mean the reapers can inflence or control him...Just the foundation of indoctrination is in him...That's why TIM was easilly indoctrianted in the end. sapposivly.


I disagree. He wasn't in the process of Reaper indoctrination until he implanted himself (or potentially via exposure to the salvaged Human Reaper). The nanides allow for rapid indoctrination.

#370
balance5050

balance5050
  • Members
  • 5 245 messages

Valentia X wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...



I mentioned that Reaper ships can passively indoctrinate. I even used it to illustrate that there are some that can. And yes, Object Rho does indoctrinate. I'm well aware. Again, that it is not proof that all Reaper-based tech can passively indoctrinate organics in their near vicinity. You seem to missing the point that I'm making, because I'm not denying that it can it does happen. I'm simply saying there's no proof that everthing based off of Reaper tech will invariably passively indoctrinate. You also have no definitve proof that they do; in fact, the Dragon's Teeth may be the biggest argument on hand to say that they don't, since the organic body has to be put onto the teeth for the huskification to begin.


The reason why Object Rho is not added to the definitive list is because not every Shepard does that mission. My canon Shepard didn't. 


My Shepard did do the Arrival, so I see the indoctrination easy.

#371
balance5050

balance5050
  • Members
  • 5 245 messages

111987 wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...

You notunderstanding what I meanabout TIM...I'm not saying he is under reaper control..I'm say he is in the process of reaper indoctrination.Being in the process of does not mean the reapers can inflence or control him...Just the foundation of indoctrination is in him...That's why TIM was easilly indoctrianted in the end. sapposivly.


I disagree. He wasn't in the process of Reaper indoctrination until he implanted himself (or potentially via exposure to the salvaged Human Reaper). The nanides allow for rapid indoctrination.


He was hit with reaper tech during the first contact wars, this is where he got his distinctive eyes from, there was atleast some light reaper influence because he started Cerberus which is the Splinter group that EVERY cycle has.

The reaper indoc lead him to start Cerberus.

Modifié par balance5050, 14 mai 2012 - 07:11 .


#372
dreman9999

dreman9999
  • Members
  • 19 067 messages

Valentia X wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...



I mentioned that Reaper ships can passively indoctrinate. I even used it to illustrate that there are some that can. And yes, Object Rho does indoctrinate. I'm well aware. Again, that it is not proof that all Reaper-based tech can passively indoctrinate organics in their near vicinity. You seem to missing the point that I'm making, because I'm not denying that it can it does happen. I'm simply saying there's no proof that everthing based off of Reaper tech will invariably passively indoctrinate. You also have no definitve proof that they do; in fact, the Dragon's Teeth may be the biggest argument on hand to say that they don't, since the organic body has to be put onto the teeth for the huskification to begin.


The reason why Object Rho is not added to the definitive list is because not every Shepard does that mission. My canon Shepard didn't. 

But there's till is everything else...
Let's try tomake this clear...List all the types of reaper tech in ME.....

#373
Raiil

Raiil
  • Members
  • 4 011 messages

balance5050 wrote...

Elyiia wrote...


And? There's no evidence they all indoctrinate the same way and to assume so is crazy. Dragon's teeth specifically work by impaling an organic. Why bother impaling if it can do it just by being there, which would be much more effective.

 
So husks give off the indoctriation signal but dragons teeth, the thing that MAKE the husks, don't? Strange logic.




. Ultimately, the Reaper gains the ability to use the victim's body to amplify its signals, manifesting as "alien" voices in the mind. 


The ability doesn't mean that they automatically do it, It means that they merely gain the capbility to do so. If they didn't, every organic would start falling to indoctrination in days, since all you would need to do is gather husks at a choke point and have them sit there until everyone else becomes indoctrinated. This isn't the case. 

#374
dreman9999

dreman9999
  • Members
  • 19 067 messages

111987 wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...

You notunderstanding what I meanabout TIM...I'm not saying he is under reaper control..I'm say he is in the process of reaper indoctrination.Being in the process of does not mean the reapers can inflence or control him...Just the foundation of indoctrination is in him...That's why TIM was easilly indoctrianted in the end. sapposivly.


I disagree. He wasn't in the process of Reaper indoctrination until he implanted himself (or potentially via exposure to the salvaged Human Reaper). The nanides allow for rapid indoctrination.

Read ME:EVOLUTION. TIM was hit by a partial indoctination wave in the comic...Why was he not inoctinated but have the eyes of indoctination inplanted in him?

#375
balance5050

balance5050
  • Members
  • 5 245 messages

Valentia X wrote...

balance5050 wrote...

Elyiia wrote...


And? There's no evidence they all indoctrinate the same way and to assume so is crazy. Dragon's teeth specifically work by impaling an organic. Why bother impaling if it can do it just by being there, which would be much more effective.

 
So husks give off the indoctriation signal but dragons teeth, the thing that MAKE the husks, don't? Strange logic.




. Ultimately, the Reaper gains the ability to use the victim's body to amplify its signals, manifesting as "alien" voices in the mind. 


The ability doesn't mean that they automatically do it, It means that they merely gain the capbility to do so. If they didn't, every organic would start falling to indoctrination in days, since all you would need to do is gather husks at a choke point and have them sit there until everyone else becomes indoctrinated. This isn't the case. 


Indoctrination can be present with out a reaper actually taking control, Rana Thanoptis went years before killing a bunch of Asari officials.