Ce sujet est fermé
thisisme8 wrote...
GethPrimeMKII wrote...
thisisme8 wrote...
Domanese wrote...
thisisme8 wrote...
The inaudible sound is actually a really interesting point and an intelligent addition by BioWare. Theoretical? Yes. Proof of indoctrination? No. Then again, gravity is only a theory, so take what I just said how you will.
Rifneno: Even as you jest, just by using the word "us," you imply that you do.
Okay and now back to you and I apperciate the time given to answer me back. Basically gravity and for my own example music is invisible but you can still experience it/ hear it. Infrasonic noise you can of course not hear but you can still of course detect it with the right equipment. You have however acknowledged it of course and I applaude that.
To me it does stand out as incredibly needless work if Indoctrination was not what they were going for and probably one of the cruelest red herrings possible if that was what put into the game. Which to me is outside the realm of possibility.
I will however yield to something here and now, it's true that the IT is just a theory at the moment since until theres flat out confirmation or denial by the Word of God its up in the air but the amount of evidence to support it is more vast then what I have seen from the literalist point of view and makes more sense to me.
As for the whole "only clairfying and adding on to the current endings", the IT does not change the ending but works alongside it giving clairification and adding onto the current endings at its core. We also have seen some people actually write out scenarios in how the IT would work without extra gameplay.
I realize that I will not change your mind and such and thats not my intention since its not possible. What i can do is provide you with why we think the way we do.
My own problem with IT is really the reasoning behind it. Why would the Catalyst need to lie to Shepard? Would an AI, although capable, lie while conceding at the same time? The cycle is over, so there is no need to tell Shepard that he is not indoctrinated, but he still goes so far as to say he is not. Unless IT's true meaning is the indoctrination of the player, and not Shepard. But still, the cycle is over.
I'm sorry but where in the f**k are you pulling this crap from?
The Catalyst tells Shep that the Illusive man couldn't control the reapers since he was already under their control. The Catalyst then tells Shep that he/she can control the reapers. Maybe I'm making a huge jump here, but that tells me that Shep is not under their control - thus not indoctrinated.
You have been very respectful, so I'll politely respond here. You are talking to the Reaper Leader/creator/whatever. The leader of your enemy will want to deceive you. Of course it would say oh that indoctrinated guy can't control them! But yea, you can! You are tooootally not falling for my master plan of taking you over and bending you to my will. Trust me. I'm serious. Would I lie?
Retour en haut
