Aller au contenu

Photo

Was the Ending a Hallucination? - Indoctrination Theory Mark II!


55528 réponses à ce sujet

#37801
HellishFiend

HellishFiend
  • Members
  • 5 546 messages

plfranke wrote...

I have to say though Hellish I still really don't understand why exactly Legion had to die. I'm all for "what the author intended" but they could have at least explained it better.


The explanation lies within the fact that the lore states a sentient computer program can not simply be copied (insert boromir meme). They are unique. And in order for the entirety of the Geth race to make full use of the reaper code upgrades and gain full sentience, he had to disseminate his programming across the entire consensus. Beyond that, we dont need to know the exact specifics, because it's a fictional universe. 

#37802
paxxton

paxxton
  • Members
  • 8 445 messages

HellishFiend wrote...

BansheeOwnage wrote...

HellishFiend wrote...

paxxton wrote...

I would understand it if he wasn't an AI but he is. It was sad but also artificial because there was a straightforward way to save him.


Fine, you're entitled to your opinion, but I wholeheartedly disagree. 

You forgot to tell him there is no way of saving him.


paxxton is arguing that Legion's death serves no purpose to the themes or plot because he feels the author could have devised an easy way to save him. 

Not quite. It serves a purpose because after 2 games player's acribe human values to him. So when he dies the emotions are there. But it's not necessary for Legion to die because he could upload himself to the consensus prior to frying the platform.

#37803
Arian Dynas

Arian Dynas
  • Members
  • 3 799 messages
[quote]RampantAndroid wrote...

But do we know it's the london rubble? I see no real evidence to substantiate that, because what you're saying is that the ending scenes - ostensibly after Shep is dead - mean nothing.

Further, you're equating the idea that the developers wanted to make you indoctrinated at some point to the idea that you're indoctrinated at the end, which is a bad assumption I think. We do not know how they wanted to use that, if at all. I highly doubt they planned to end the series with a "everything you did was pointless, because now you're indoctrinated and the galaxy will burrnnnnnn." Everyone we've seen who was indoctrinated lost control, and was unable to question their decisions.

Further, everything we know about indoctrination is that it must happen while in close proximity to a reaper/reaper tech - and it takes time. How long did it take for the Cerberus team in ME2 to go insane? Or the Batarians who found Leviathon? Or the team in Arrival? It wasn't instantaneous. Honestly, IT seems a stretch at best - no matter what variation of it you pick. The only curious point I see is where is Shep when the post-credits scene happens? And what did the dreams mean? At BEST I could see that the whole thing was a dream, but not Shep being indoctrinated.[/quote]

The name of the video is SHEP_ALIVE.

Pretty conclusive there. Bioware has CONFIRMED it is both Shepard and he is alive.

Also, the fact that he is surrounded by concrete we have matched to that found in London is pretty conclusive.

Indoctrination is explicitly stated to have two types, Slow, like that which afflicted Saren and TIM, and fast, like that which creates husks. To help you understand, I have dug up this helpful post from long ago;

[quote]Arian Dynas wrote...

As I see it, there are 7 stages of Indoctrination.

The Motor Control Stage, or "Fast" Indoctrination - Fast Indoctrination, in which the synaptic pathways of the entire brain are remapped, completely overwritting both the personality of the individual, as well as lower brain functions, leaving the subject entirely incapable of caring for or defending itself, reducing it to the level of a drooling animal. By this point, the only things it is capable of are receiving commands from the controlling Reaper, and minor bodily and regulatory functions, suck as breathing and other fuctions centered in the Reptillian Brain.

The Subliminal Stage, or Stage 2 Slow - 
First contact, the Reaper can begin the process, but there are no symptoms, the subject remains a "carrier" in that either sufficient time to break down their willpower or continued exposure to Indoctrination signals will advance the process to stage 2. Imagine stage one as being similar to a hole being ripped in a piece of Nylon. Give it enough time and it will run on it's own, but if someone pulls at it, it tears faster.

The Subconcious Stage, or Stage 3 Slow - 
The Reaper has begun to hijack some of the more minor perception based mental processes and can begin to make it's presence known, auditory hallucinations of whispers and feelings of paranoia begin here, as does the sensation of being watched, bad dreams can also take place.

The Hallucinatory-Preperatory Stage, or Stage 3 Slow - The information processing centers of the brain are entirely under the control of the Reaper by this point, whom can either make the subject perceive ghostly presences, nonexistent beings, and can speak directly to the subject by way of a sort of telepathic hallucination. If there are multiple subjects they may begin to share memories or hallucinations, sometimes even dreams as preperation for integration together as a Reaper Mind.

The Mental Control Stage, or Stage 4a Slow - By this point, the Reaper has now managed to take direct control of the Prefrontal Cortex, maniplulating the personality and personal values of the subject directly, attacking their own sense of ethics in a way they can't argue, as opposed to manipulating their perception of events. Some choose to resist at this stage, rather than simply give in and surrender control, instead retreating into their own minds, entering into a catatonic state, and leaving the Reaper uncontested in his control of the body. This of course is an undesired outcome, since the entire purpose of Slow Indoctrination is to gain the acceptance of the subject, allowing the Reapers to make use of their technical skills and social knowledge, rather than merely using their body.

Indoctrination or Stage 4b Slow - The Reaper, finding itself unable to directly control the personality of the subject finds itself needing to change the subject's acceptance of their veiwpoint, thus moving to true indoctrination, forcing the subject, either through trickery, intimidation or subtle manipulation to accept the Reaper's argument.

Implantation or Stage 5 - The subject has allowed physical implantation of Reaper technology into it's body, either by nanides, which potentially could have been used thus far to speed the process along, or through more traditional implantation. This is also the same stage Husks are at, seeing as they are the results of Fast Indoctrination with Implantation. 

Shepard has had far more than enough contact to indoctrinate him 30 times over. The Arch Monolith, the object responsible for the indoctrination of Saren and The Illusive Man, could turn a human being from zero to husk in less than a second. It indoctrinated TIM and Saren via contact from beings who touched the Monolith.

#37804
BansheeOwnage

BansheeOwnage
  • Members
  • 11 290 messages

RampantAndroid wrote...

Yeah - Shiala only broke free due to the Thorian. Again, you're confirming indoc needed to happen prior to ME3. If it's so simple to become indoc by just fighting the reaper forces, then all of earth, palavan, thessia and such would be done already.

As for the prothean VIs, you're using one theory to back another theory up. This doesn't seem wise.


You have 2 options:
1. The indoc VI can only detect late-stage indoc
2. The indoc VI is a plothole
Posted Image
Oops.

Modifié par BansheeOwnage, 03 juillet 2012 - 12:44 .


#37805
plfranke

plfranke
  • Members
  • 1 404 messages

HellishFiend wrote...

plfranke wrote...

I have to say though Hellish I still really don't understand why exactly Legion had to die. I'm all for "what the author intended" but they could have at least explained it better.


The explanation lies within the fact that the lore states a sentient computer program can not simply be copied (insert boromir meme). They are unique. And in order for the entirety of the Geth race to make full use of the reaper code upgrades and gain full sentience, he had to disseminate his programming across the entire consensus. Beyond that, we dont need to know the exact specifics, because it's a fictional universe. 

So it's okay when that isn't explained but not synthesis?

#37806
Arian Dynas

Arian Dynas
  • Members
  • 3 799 messages

paxxton wrote...

HellishFiend wrote...

paxxton wrote...

HellishFiend wrote...

paxxton wrote...

HellishFiend wrote...

paxxton wrote...

Is there a way to save Legion? If not, Tali should die too.


Legion/Geth VI always die one way or another regardless of what happens. It's a vital part of the theme regarding how synthetics show some of the same characteristics of organics when it comes to things like sacrifice, freedom, and fighting for what you believe in.

You mean unnecessary death?


Not one for themes, are you?

Legion can't die because he can upload himself to another platform. His death is stretching the theme and is unnecessary.


And I suppose you also think Romeo And Juliet is just a story about idiots killing themselves because there are a number of ways the tragedy could have been avoided?

No, they are mentally impaired. Posted Image
Drama -> tragedy -> the end Posted Image


Well, to be honest, I read Romeo and Juliet, and I can't disagree with him on that count.

#37807
HellishFiend

HellishFiend
  • Members
  • 5 546 messages

plfranke wrote...

HellishFiend wrote...

plfranke wrote...

I have to say though Hellish I still really don't understand why exactly Legion had to die. I'm all for "what the author intended" but they could have at least explained it better.


The explanation lies within the fact that the lore states a sentient computer program can not simply be copied (insert boromir meme). They are unique. And in order for the entirety of the Geth race to make full use of the reaper code upgrades and gain full sentience, he had to disseminate his programming across the entire consensus. Beyond that, we dont need to know the exact specifics, because it's a fictional universe. 

So it's okay when that isn't explained but not synthesis?


Are you really drawing a comparison between a complex series of ones and zeroes interacting with each other and the universal rewriting of the genetic structure of every living thing to somehow magically incorporate synthetics, plus somehow giving artificial things an organic genetic structure?

Modifié par HellishFiend, 03 juillet 2012 - 12:44 .


#37808
Turbo_J

Turbo_J
  • Members
  • 1 217 messages

jgibson14352 wrote...

i think were misunderstanding each other, lets agree on this-there is no set point where an individual is indoctrinated. indoctrinated means that they hear voices that tell them to further reaper goals, whether knowingly or not. by free, i meant they still had the capacity to resist, like what the rachni queen said "we hear the voices,l but they cannot control us". shialas email said she still heard the voices, but the collective consciousness of Zhus hope helped her to ignore them
indoctrination is something that builds, it starts weak and gets stronger, there isnt button you push to indoctrinate someone, unless you turn them into husks


Just wanted to clarify Shiala's situation. I fully understand and agree with how long term indoctrination works. Sorry for the misunderstanding.

#37809
Arian Dynas

Arian Dynas
  • Members
  • 3 799 messages

RampantAndroid wrote...

On point 1, yes, that is my point. The game wouldn't END with it. You're saying here there's a hidden "LOL you're indoctrinated and let them live!" ending.

On point 2, they broke free and ONLY shot themselves, or were taken back over. No one has become free again.

On 3, Shep needed to be indoctrinated by Sovereign, the dead reaper, or during Arrival then. All of which I doubt to be true. Esp since the Prothian VI doesn't say you're indoctrinated.

On 4, link to canon to back that up. Regardless though, Shep has not been in contact with the reaper tech for days, and it's indicated he resisted it in arrival. He either was indoctrinated before ME3 meaning ME3 is a total joke on the player, or somehow not shown in ME3.


1. No Mass Effect game has ever "ended" until the Sequel is less than 6 months from release. Not since ME2.

2. This isn't about Shepard breaking free. This is about not getting into the situation to begin with.

3."Security protocols overwritten. I will comply."

4. Object Rho. Contact for two days. Object Rho is canon, don't argue it, comics say so, and all the Mass Effect Comics are canon. Period. If your Shepard did NOT experience Arrival, then they are non-canon. ME3 is us going through the process of slow indoctrination.

#37810
HellishFiend

HellishFiend
  • Members
  • 5 546 messages

Arian Dynas wrote...

paxxton wrote...

No, they are mentally impaired. Posted Image
Drama -> tragedy -> the end Posted Image


Well, to be honest, I read Romeo and Juliet, and I can't disagree with him on that count.


I would not be able to facepalm hard enough to fully express my reaction to that statement without injuring myself. 

#37811
paxxton

paxxton
  • Members
  • 8 445 messages

HellishFiend wrote...

plfranke wrote...

HellishFiend wrote...

plfranke wrote...

I have to say though Hellish I still really don't understand why exactly Legion had to die. I'm all for "what the author intended" but they could have at least explained it better.


The explanation lies within the fact that the lore states a sentient computer program can not simply be copied (insert boromir meme). They are unique. And in order for the entirety of the Geth race to make full use of the reaper code upgrades and gain full sentience, he had to disseminate his programming across the entire consensus. Beyond that, we dont need to know the exact specifics, because it's a fictional universe. 

So it's okay when that isn't explained but not synthesis?


Are you really drawing a comparison between a complex series of ones and zeroes interacting with each other and the universal rewriting of the genetic structure of every living thing to somehow magically incorporate synthetics, plus somehow giving artificial things an organic genetic structure?

Is there really a difference other than scale?

Modifié par paxxton, 03 juillet 2012 - 12:49 .


#37812
BansheeOwnage

BansheeOwnage
  • Members
  • 11 290 messages

plfranke wrote...

HellishFiend wrote...

plfranke wrote...

I have to say though Hellish I still really don't understand why exactly Legion had to die. I'm all for "what the author intended" but they could have at least explained it better.


The explanation lies within the fact that the lore states a sentient computer program can not simply be copied (insert boromir meme). They are unique. And in order for the entirety of the Geth race to make full use of the reaper code upgrades and gain full sentience, he had to disseminate his programming across the entire consensus. Beyond that, we dont need to know the exact specifics, because it's a fictional universe. 

So it's okay when that isn't explained but not synthesis?

It is almost fully explained, unlike synthesis which is pure space-magic.

#37813
plfranke

plfranke
  • Members
  • 1 404 messages

HellishFiend wrote...

plfranke wrote...

HellishFiend wrote...

plfranke wrote...

I have to say though Hellish I still really don't understand why exactly Legion had to die. I'm all for "what the author intended" but they could have at least explained it better.


The explanation lies within the fact that the lore states a sentient computer program can not simply be copied (insert boromir meme). They are unique. And in order for the entirety of the Geth race to make full use of the reaper code upgrades and gain full sentience, he had to disseminate his programming across the entire consensus. Beyond that, we dont need to know the exact specifics, because it's a fictional universe. 

So it's okay when that isn't explained but not synthesis?


Are you really drawing a comparison between a complex series of ones and zeroes interacting with each other and the universal rewriting of the genetic structure of every living thing to somehow magically incorporate synthetics, plus somehow giving artificial things an organic genetic structure?

There are living star ships, artificial intelligence programs can die and spread their programming across every other artificial intelligence unit of the same kind and give them intelligence, many things are possible, "beyond that, we don't need to know the exact specifics, because it's a fictional universe."

#37814
plfranke

plfranke
  • Members
  • 1 404 messages

paxxton wrote...

HellishFiend wrote...

plfranke wrote...

HellishFiend wrote...

plfranke wrote...

I have to say though Hellish I still really don't understand why exactly Legion had to die. I'm all for "what the author intended" but they could have at least explained it better.


The explanation lies within the fact that the lore states a sentient computer program can not simply be copied (insert boromir meme). They are unique. And in order for the entirety of the Geth race to make full use of the reaper code upgrades and gain full sentience, he had to disseminate his programming across the entire consensus. Beyond that, we dont need to know the exact specifics, because it's a fictional universe. 

So it's okay when that isn't explained but not synthesis?


Are you really drawing a comparison between a complex series of ones and zeroes interacting with each other and the universal rewriting of the genetic structure of every living thing to somehow magically incorporate synthetics, plus somehow giving artificial things an organic genetic structure?

Is there a difference other than scale?

no there isn't. shepard died as legion did and spread the new code across every organic and synthetic

#37815
BansheeOwnage

BansheeOwnage
  • Members
  • 11 290 messages

HellishFiend wrote...

Arian Dynas wrote...

paxxton wrote...

No, they are mentally impaired. Posted Image
Drama -> tragedy -> the end Posted Image


Well, to be honest, I read Romeo and Juliet, and I can't disagree with him on that count.


I would not be able to facepalm hard enough to fully express my reaction to that statement without injuring myself. 

Don't worry Hellish
http://desmond.image...jpg&res=landing
Liara's here to help Posted Image

#37816
Arian Dynas

Arian Dynas
  • Members
  • 3 799 messages

HellishFiend wrote...

Arian Dynas wrote...

paxxton wrote...

No, they are mentally impaired. Posted Image
Drama -> tragedy -> the end Posted Image


Well, to be honest, I read Romeo and Juliet, and I can't disagree with him on that count.


I would not be able to facepalm hard enough to fully express my reaction to that statement without injuring myself. 


Romeo and Juliet is the story of a horny thirteen year old girl who gets killed because of a misunderstanding involving her overly dramatic 30 or so year old boyfriend.

Come on man. Yes its Shakespeare, but, well, the difference between tragedy and comedy is sympathy, and I was feeling little sympathy for the characters in this one.

#37817
HellishFiend

HellishFiend
  • Members
  • 5 546 messages

plfranke wrote...

There are living star ships, artificial intelligence programs can die and spread their programming across every other artificial intelligence unit of the same kind and give them intelligence, many things are possible, "beyond that, we don't need to know the exact specifics, because it's a fictional universe."


Does your suspension of disbelief also allow for the events of Alice in Wonderland to occur within reality? Because that's basically the level of suspension of disbelief you're talking about with the face-value interpretation of synthesis. 
 
Understanding the facets of the lore behind Legions death requires a mere fraction of the suspension of disbelief compared to synthesis. You cant argue that. 

#37818
HellishFiend

HellishFiend
  • Members
  • 5 546 messages

Arian Dynas wrote...

HellishFiend wrote...

Arian Dynas wrote...

paxxton wrote...

No, they are mentally impaired. Posted Image
Drama -> tragedy -> the end Posted Image


Well, to be honest, I read Romeo and Juliet, and I can't disagree with him on that count.


I would not be able to facepalm hard enough to fully express my reaction to that statement without injuring myself. 


Romeo and Juliet is the story of a horny thirteen year old girl who gets killed because of a misunderstanding involving her overly dramatic 30 or so year old boyfriend.

Come on man. Yes its Shakespeare, but, well, the difference between tragedy and comedy is sympathy, and I was feeling little sympathy for the characters in this one.


I need to back out of this conversation before I say something insulting. 

#37819
Arian Dynas

Arian Dynas
  • Members
  • 3 799 messages

HellishFiend wrote...

plfranke wrote...

There are living star ships, artificial intelligence programs can die and spread their programming across every other artificial intelligence unit of the same kind and give them intelligence, many things are possible, "beyond that, we don't need to know the exact specifics, because it's a fictional universe."


Does your suspension of disbelief also allow for the events of Alice in Wonderland to occur within reality? Because that's basically the level of suspension of disbelief you're talking about with the face-value interpretation of synthesis. 
 
Understanding the facets of the lore behind Legions death requires a mere fraction of the suspension of disbelief compared to synthesis. You cant argue that. 


Less actually.

Alice in Wonderland is better established than Synthesis is.

#37820
plfranke

plfranke
  • Members
  • 1 404 messages

HellishFiend wrote...

plfranke wrote...

There are living star ships, artificial intelligence programs can die and spread their programming across every other artificial intelligence unit of the same kind and give them intelligence, many things are possible, "beyond that, we don't need to know the exact specifics, because it's a fictional universe."


Does your suspension of disbelief also allow for the events of Alice in Wonderland to occur within reality? Because that's basically the level of suspension of disbelief you're talking about with the face-value interpretation of synthesis. 
 
Understanding the facets of the lore behind Legions death requires a mere fraction of the suspension of disbelief compared to synthesis. You cant argue that. 

I'm not going to answer to the first half of your post because you're comparing two things that are totally unrelated (you do that a lot most notably with lord of the rings Posted Image)
But yes I can argue that it's like paxxton said it's the same thing on a larger scale using both organics and synthetics. You just have a personal problem with synthesis.

#37821
Andromidius

Andromidius
  • Members
  • 2 997 messages
To explain Legion's 'death', these are the basic details.

Firstly, he tried to copy the subroutines that his platform was running to safely make use of Reaper upgrades. This proved impossible, possibly due to his unique nature - the codes simply wouldn't work for their operating systems.

So instead he does the only thing he can think of - disessemble his essembled Geth AI's, each with a copy of the Reaper code, and distributed it to Geth mainframes for them to be copied and integrated into standard Geth AI's.

Basically it would be like a skin graft, only on a massive scale. In the end, there was nothing left of the AI mainframe called 'Legion'.

#37822
Arian Dynas

Arian Dynas
  • Members
  • 3 799 messages
Oh, by the way, thought you guys would appreciate this; Posted Image

#37823
HellishFiend

HellishFiend
  • Members
  • 5 546 messages

plfranke wrote...

HellishFiend wrote...

plfranke wrote...

There are living star ships, artificial intelligence programs can die and spread their programming across every other artificial intelligence unit of the same kind and give them intelligence, many things are possible, "beyond that, we don't need to know the exact specifics, because it's a fictional universe."


Does your suspension of disbelief also allow for the events of Alice in Wonderland to occur within reality? Because that's basically the level of suspension of disbelief you're talking about with the face-value interpretation of synthesis. 
 
Understanding the facets of the lore behind Legions death requires a mere fraction of the suspension of disbelief compared to synthesis. You cant argue that. 

I'm not going to answer to the first half of your post because you're comparing two things that are totally unrelated (you do that a lot most notably with lord of the rings Posted Image)
But yes I can argue that it's like paxxton said it's the same thing on a larger scale using both organics and synthetics. You just have a personal problem with synthesis.


No, this is about understanding plots, themes, and how to wield them without an excessive requirement of suspension of disbelief in order to avoid breaking immersion. It's nothing personal beyond each individual's immersion tolerance.

Modifié par HellishFiend, 03 juillet 2012 - 01:01 .


#37824
plfranke

plfranke
  • Members
  • 1 404 messages

Andromidius wrote...

To explain Legion's 'death', these are the basic details.

Firstly, he tried to copy the subroutines that his platform was running to safely make use of Reaper upgrades. This proved impossible, possibly due to his unique nature - the codes simply wouldn't work for their operating systems.

So instead he does the only thing he can think of - disessemble his essembled Geth AI's, each with a copy of the Reaper code, and distributed it to Geth mainframes for them to be copied and integrated into standard Geth AI's.

Basically it would be like a skin graft, only on a massive scale. In the end, there was nothing left of the AI mainframe called 'Legion'.

if it had been explained in the game half as well as you just did we wouldn't be having this explanation. the problem is I could give the exact same explanation for synthesis but the haters would just deny it and say "lol space magic"

#37825
BansheeOwnage

BansheeOwnage
  • Members
  • 11 290 messages

HellishFiend wrote...

plfranke wrote...

HellishFiend wrote...

plfranke wrote...

There are living star ships, artificial intelligence programs can die and spread their programming across every other artificial intelligence unit of the same kind and give them intelligence, many things are possible, "beyond that, we don't need to know the exact specifics, because it's a fictional universe."


Does your suspension of disbelief also allow for the events of Alice in Wonderland to occur within reality? Because that's basically the level of suspension of disbelief you're talking about with the face-value interpretation of synthesis. 
 
Understanding the facets of the lore behind Legions death requires a mere fraction of the suspension of disbelief compared to synthesis. You cant argue that. 

I'm not going to answer to the first half of your post because you're comparing two things that are totally unrelated (you do that a lot most notably with lord of the rings Posted Image)
But yes I can argue that it's like paxxton said it's the same thing on a larger scale using both organics and synthetics. You just have a personal problem with synthesis.


No, this is about understanding plots, themes, and how to wield them without an excessive requirement of suspension of disbelief in order to avoid breaking immersion. It's nothing personal beyond each individual's immersion tolerance.

"Let's move on." - Pvt. Leonard Chruch