Aller au contenu

Photo

Was the Ending a Hallucination? - Indoctrination Theory Mark II!


55528 réponses à ce sujet

#4651
BleedingUranium

BleedingUranium
  • Members
  • 6 118 messages

dmay7 wrote...

BleedingUranium wrote...

dmay7 wrote...

What if the Protheans actually completed the Crucible, and were tricked by Starbinger to pick synthesis, and rewrote the entire races DNA? Protheans are made out to be the only advanced civilization of their time, so only they would be affected by it. They aren't just harvested organics like the enemies in ME3, because they have their own ships and their own base.


That only works in a literalist ending because:

-The crucible doesn't have three colour coded options
-You can't actually rewrite everything's DNA, that's silly

But the intention of what you said could be true, some of the protheans were indoctrinated to believe in "Synthesis", or whatever the Reapers called it for them, like Saren.


Well what if Shepard actually did board the citadel, but during his journey the indoctrination conjured the illusions of Anderson and TIM, they weren't actually their, and Shepard was just doing a Fight Clubisq conversation (Shooting Anderson is really him shooting himself). When Shepard kills TIM, Starbinger then deals the final hand.

I know that doesn't explain how Shepard ends up back in London for his ever-so-special breathe, but I'm just speculatating.

ANd yes, you may all use Starbinger. Spread the meme away, my friends :)


I would support this too, except for, like you said, the breath scene

#4652
dmay7

dmay7
  • Members
  • 368 messages

BleedingUranium wrote...

dmay7 wrote...

BleedingUranium wrote...

dmay7 wrote...

What if the Protheans actually completed the Crucible, and were tricked by Starbinger to pick synthesis, and rewrote the entire races DNA? Protheans are made out to be the only advanced civilization of their time, so only they would be affected by it. They aren't just harvested organics like the enemies in ME3, because they have their own ships and their own base.


That only works in a literalist ending because:

-The crucible doesn't have three colour coded options
-You can't actually rewrite everything's DNA, that's silly

But the intention of what you said could be true, some of the protheans were indoctrinated to believe in "Synthesis", or whatever the Reapers called it for them, like Saren.


Well what if Shepard actually did board the citadel, but during his journey the indoctrination conjured the illusions of Anderson and TIM, they weren't actually their, and Shepard was just doing a Fight Clubisq conversation (Shooting Anderson is really him shooting himself). When Shepard kills TIM, Starbinger then deals the final hand.

I know that doesn't explain how Shepard ends up back in London for his ever-so-special breathe, but I'm just speculatating.

ANd yes, you may all use Starbinger. Spread the meme away, my friends :)


I would support this too, except for, like you said, the breath scene


Maybe he was returned to the conduit, which brought him back to London. :D

#4653
blooregard

blooregard
  • Members
  • 1 151 messages

dmay7 wrote...

BleedingUranium wrote...

dmay7 wrote...

BleedingUranium wrote...

dmay7 wrote...

What if the Protheans actually completed the Crucible, and were tricked by Starbinger to pick synthesis, and rewrote the entire races DNA? Protheans are made out to be the only advanced civilization of their time, so only they would be affected by it. They aren't just harvested organics like the enemies in ME3, because they have their own ships and their own base.


That only works in a literalist ending because:

-The crucible doesn't have three colour coded options
-You can't actually rewrite everything's DNA, that's silly

But the intention of what you said could be true, some of the protheans were indoctrinated to believe in "Synthesis", or whatever the Reapers called it for them, like Saren.


Well what if Shepard actually did board the citadel, but during his journey the indoctrination conjured the illusions of Anderson and TIM, they weren't actually their, and Shepard was just doing a Fight Clubisq conversation (Shooting Anderson is really him shooting himself). When Shepard kills TIM, Starbinger then deals the final hand.

I know that doesn't explain how Shepard ends up back in London for his ever-so-special breathe, but I'm just speculatating.

ANd yes, you may all use Starbinger. Spread the meme away, my friends :)


I would support this too, except for, like you said, the breath scene


Maybe he was returned to the conduit, which brought him back to London. :D



Isn't that where Keith David was born?

#4654
byne

byne
  • Members
  • 7 813 messages

dmay7 wrote...

BleedingUranium wrote...

dmay7 wrote...

BleedingUranium wrote...

dmay7 wrote...

What if the Protheans actually completed the Crucible, and were tricked by Starbinger to pick synthesis, and rewrote the entire races DNA? Protheans are made out to be the only advanced civilization of their time, so only they would be affected by it. They aren't just harvested organics like the enemies in ME3, because they have their own ships and their own base.


That only works in a literalist ending because:

-The crucible doesn't have three colour coded options
-You can't actually rewrite everything's DNA, that's silly

But the intention of what you said could be true, some of the protheans were indoctrinated to believe in "Synthesis", or whatever the Reapers called it for them, like Saren.


Well what if Shepard actually did board the citadel, but during his journey the indoctrination conjured the illusions of Anderson and TIM, they weren't actually their, and Shepard was just doing a Fight Clubisq conversation (Shooting Anderson is really him shooting himself). When Shepard kills TIM, Starbinger then deals the final hand.

I know that doesn't explain how Shepard ends up back in London for his ever-so-special breathe, but I'm just speculatating.

ANd yes, you may all use Starbinger. Spread the meme away, my friends :)


I would support this too, except for, like you said, the breath scene


Maybe he was returned to the conduit, which brought him back to London. :D


Oh god I refreshed the page and your avatar changed.

For some reason it really surprised me.

#4655
MegumiAzusa

MegumiAzusa
  • Members
  • 4 238 messages

Bill Casey wrote...

HellishFiend wrote...

dmay7 wrote...

Collectors are the result of synthesis. I can't believe it took me that long to figure it out.


Yep. Collectors are just one example in the games/books/comics that indicate/foreshadow that synthesis is bad. There are quite a few of them....


Posted Image

I love the intermixing of the red and blue in Paul Greysons face... hinthint?

#4656
llbountyhunter

llbountyhunter
  • Members
  • 1 646 messages
I dont think the collectors chose synthesis because there DNA was just re-written, not merged. based on javik, I would say they chose control.

however the species that I DO think chose synthesis was.... wait for it.... the keepers. its known that they are a hybrid of synthetic and organics. and maybe bioware put those keepers in that hallway as a reminder of what happens when you become half-synthetic

thoughts?

Modifié par llbountyhunter, 23 mai 2012 - 12:32 .


#4657
dmay7

dmay7
  • Members
  • 368 messages

llbountyhunter wrote...

I dont think the collectors chose synthesis because there DNA was just re-written, not merged. based on javik, I would say they chose control.

however the species that I DO think chose synthesis was.... wait for it.... the keepers. its known that they are a hybrid of synthetic and organics. and maybe bioware put those keepers in that hallway as a reminder of what happens when you become half-synthetic

thoughts?


BRILLIANT!:o:O:O:O:O:O:O:O:O:O:O:O:O:O:O:O:O:O

#4658
D.Sharrah

D.Sharrah
  • Members
  • 1 579 messages
I know that this info is out there somewhere...I may go try to track it down...but I know that colors also typically have symbolic meanings, for example red often symbolizes anger/rage.

#4659
byne

byne
  • Members
  • 7 813 messages
So, I was reading the email you get from Shiala in ME3, and something came to mind.

Shiala wrote...

I'm not sure if you remember me, but you helped me back on lllium. The Thorian is dead now. I can confirm that. But the spores in our bodies remain, and on some level, we are still connected.

This is not necessarily a bad thing. As we fight back the Reapers, we feel each other, and act with one mind, ignoring pain when the need arises. I'm sure I'm still indoctrinated. I remember Sovereign's voice in my mind when I went willingly to the Thorian as its thrall. But my connection to the people of Zhu's Hope is stronger. It drowns out the Reaper voices.


I mean, sure, she's talking about a physical connection the the people of Zhu's hope, but I kind of find it strange that right when you make your choice, the game flashes pictures of Liara (or your LI maybe? Liara is always my LI so I dont know if it changes) , Joker, and Anderson, the three people you have really strong connections to.

Seems odd for them to have their pictures appear then just randomly, as the godchild is getting you to do what he wants, or as you're resisting him.

Plus, as godchild tells you about how bad destroy is, you see Anderson picking destroy.

I dont know about you, but seeing Anderson picking destroy effectively drowned out any talk from the godchild about how bad it was for me.

Modifié par byne, 23 mai 2012 - 12:39 .


#4660
D.Sharrah

D.Sharrah
  • Members
  • 1 579 messages

llbountyhunter wrote...

I dont think the collectors chose synthesis because there DNA was just re-written, not merged. based on javik, I would say they chose control.

however the species that I DO think chose synthesis was.... wait for it.... the keepers. its known that they are a hybrid of synthetic and organics. and maybe bioware put those keepers in that hallway as a reminder of what happens when you become half-synthetic

thoughts?


I'm not so sure...I think that the Keepers are definetly one of the early species that the Reapers subjugated...

#4661
blooregard

blooregard
  • Members
  • 1 151 messages

llbountyhunter wrote...

I dont think the collectors chose synthesis because there DNA was just re-written, not merged. based on javik, I would say they chose control.

however the species that I DO think chose synthesis was.... wait for it.... the keepers. its known that they are a hybrid on synthetic and organics. and maybe bioware put those keepers in that hallway as a reminder of what happens when you become half-synthetic

thoughts?



The Reapers and everything related to them are a perfect example of synthesis. The Collectors, the Husks and the Reapers themselves are all sythesis. Control represents indoctrination while destroy represents organics.

#4662
dmay7

dmay7
  • Members
  • 368 messages

byne wrote...

So, I was reading the email you get from Shiala in ME3, and something came to mind.

Shiala wrote...

I'm not sure if you remember me, but you helped me back on lllium. The Thorian is dead now. I can confirm that. But the spores in our bodies remain, and on some level, we are still connected.

This is not necessarily a bad thing. As we fight back the Reapers, we feel each other, and act with one mind, ignoring pain when the need arises. I'm sure I'm still indoctrinated. I remember Sovereign's voice in my mind when I went willingly to the Thorian as its thrall. But my connection to the people of Zhu's Hope is stronger. It drowns out the Reaper voices.


I mean, sure, she's talking about a physical connection the the people of Zhu's hope, but I kind of find it strange that right when you make your choice, the game flashes pictures of Liara (or your LI maybe? Liara is always my LI so I dont know if it changes) , Joker, and Anderson, the three people you have really strong connections to.

Seems odd for them to have their pictures appear then just randomly, as the godchild is getting you to do what he wants, or as you're resisting him.

Plus, as godchild tells you about how bad destroy is, you see Anderson picking destroy.

I dont know about you, but seeing Anderson picking destroy effectively drowned out any talk from the godchild about how bad it was for me.


The flashbacks were just Shepard reflecting about the people he cared about most as he is about to die. Anderson as his mentor, Joker as the quirky comic relief people desperatley need in dire situations, and your LI...as long as it's Ashley or Liara, or else it's just Liara, because I guess she is your best friend (I always considered GArrus to be my characters Best Friend, Tali as like my sister, and Liara and Ashley as my LI (Ashley in 1, Liara in 3 hehe)).

#4663
D.Sharrah

D.Sharrah
  • Members
  • 1 579 messages
The Keepers...that got me thinking of their relationship with the Citadel. In ME 1 aren't we told (by Vigil) that the Prothean scientists were able to alter the Keepers so that they only responded to the Citadel itself and not an outside source (like the Reapers)? A couple of things jump out about this:

1. Are we to assume that the Keepers were indoctrinated at one point, and as they continued to "evolve" that the "indoctrination" just became a part of their "genetic" structure? And if so, does this mean that the Prothean scientists discovered a way to "disable" indoctrination?

2. If the Prothean scientists had enough knowledge about the Keepers to make alterations to their "genetic structure/synthetic code" so that they would not listen to the Repaers...is it possible that they had some knowledge of the Keepers before they became Reaper servants? Is it possible that they are the race that had merged themselves with AI to survive their planets impending doom during the Prothean's cycle?

EDIT:  3.  If we are to believe the Catalyst the he is the Citadel (and in control of the Reapers) doesn't this create huge problems for the whole Keepers don't listen to the Reapers thing.

Modifié par D.Sharrah, 23 mai 2012 - 12:49 .


#4664
Arian Dynas

Arian Dynas
  • Members
  • 3 799 messages
[quote]HellishFiend wrote...

[quote]MegumiAzusa wrote...

Sure, I'm also more worried why no one of your team cared to ask why you're talking to a Reaper.
Also did you notice the white lights on the Rannoch destroyer flicker but the lights on the London destroyer don't? Imo it isn't dead and they wanted Shep to pass.[/quote]

I really have no idea what is going on with those destroyers. Its probably one of the only cases where I really think Bioware just had to do things a certain way for gameplay purposes.

Rannoch Destroyer - takes an entire fleet multiple pinpoint barrages to take down, and even then it can still talk
Hades Cannon Destroyer - taken out by a single round from a Cain
Conduit Destroyer - Taken out by two heavy missles to the eye

Very inconsistent. 

[/quote]

Hmm, the Rannoch destroyer was probably more stable in that since it was an entire fleet using KINETIC weapons which we know their shields are more effective against,and that likely a goodly sized chunk of the fleet had to hit it dead on despite shooting from orbit, while also keeping the Geth off their backs. So yeah plausible.

THe Hades Cannons I don't think were destroyers, but I suppose the argument could be made that Shepard was firing a projectile slow enough to pass their shield and then blew up with an excessive amount of force right under the bottom of their chassis. Either that or it was causin a chain reaction, or potentially could be from the Cain ripping the attached Hades Cannon from it's mounting, which could potentially kill the destroyer as well.

Conduit destroyer was taken out by two THANIX missiles remember, which we know are considerably more effective.

[quote]byne wrote...

[quote]HellishFiend wrote...

[quote]Dwailing wrote...

Here's a video of the Earth Reaper with the Cain. 

That explosion does look pretty powerful....
[/quote]

I find it hard to believe that a handheld weapon has more destructive power than starship weapons....

[/quote]

I wanna know why even on casual my Cain never killed the Proto-Reaper from ME2 in one shot, but the Cain in ME3 kills a fully grown Destroyer in a single shot.

[/quote]

Easy, your Cain was the protoype, it's larger, more bulky and likely less powerful. Perhaps the slug is smaller. 

[quote]byne wrote...

[quote]HyperGlass wrote...

it was mentioned in one of the video that it is reasonable to assume the Citadel needed those shifting slates from the Shadow Broker's ship to maintain orbit and after the use of its internal mass relay (which we never see in use sadly).[/quote]

The Citadel isnt orbiting anything until they bring it to Earth though. Why would there be things to maintain its orbit when its been in the middle of the Serpent Nebula for billions of years?

[/quote]

It was EXPLICITLY STATED (I am getting annoyed at having to point this out multiple times) that the panels in the Shadowbroker's ship were SPECIFICALLY DESIGNED for that ship as electrical conduits and grounding rods, they dissappate electricity through the ship and charge the engine with it, so in other words, they're big glorified fuses.

[quote]estebanus wrote...

DEAR GOD! WALDO IS BACK!!![/quote]

It's like, he's this dog, or really annoying family member you want to get rid of, and so you move away when he goes to summer camp. Unfortunately he has a better sense of direction than we thought. Maybe we shouldn't have had our mail forwarded.

[quote]byne wrote...

[quote]D.Sharrah wrote...

[quote]byne wrote...

[quote]dreamgazer wrote...

[quote]You are welcome to reopen it IF you want to sensibly continue this discussion.
[/quote]

Priestly included this blurb in his "LOCKDOWN" message, when all he really needed to do was say that it had ventured off-topic. You can't put much stock into that, obviously, but there are other ways of handling the reemergence of the interpretation that could have easily zipped many, many lips. 
[/quote]

This was his message to me when I asked him to reconsider the lock:

Posted Image

And I may just be interpreting it in a way that makes me feel better, but that seems more like 'I closed it because I was unhappy that there was too much for new people to read' than 'i closed it because it was off-topic'

[/quote]

True...but if it was simply the page count why haven't the done the same to the "So, We can't get the ending we want?" thread?
[/quote]

Because thats less of a theorizing thread and more of a "Lets go here and complain" thread, maybe? 

[/quote] 

Because this is a thread they want people to be able to digest, and  the other is a thread they keep for the controlled chaos, let them vent in one place, rather than spreading it all over the boards.

#4665
byne

byne
  • Members
  • 7 813 messages

dmay7 wrote...

(I always considered GArrus to be my characters Best Friend, Tali as like my sister, and Liara and Ashley as my LI (Ashley in 1, Liara in 3 hehe)).


I'm sorry, but the correct answer was Liara throughout all three games. Thanks for playing. ;)

Although personally Liara and MaleShep always felt off to me. If I'm punishing myself by playing MaleShep, its Ashley in ME1, then Tali in ME2 and ME3.

#4666
themaniac003

themaniac003
  • Members
  • 20 messages

Epök wrote...

 Hey everyone, I just wanted to thank all of you for your fantastic work ! If you have a look at the old thread and sum up every evidence/ theory about what Bioware is trying to tell us/hint, it's just huge. I'm really convinced that the EC will show us how the Reapers tried to indoctrinate Shepard.
So I really wanted to participate and give you something I found.

Two weeks ago I started a new playthrough, I finished ME1 but didn't find anything new. Until ME2. The first time you're on the Normandy you can talk to Joker, ask him what he's been doing over the last two years and of course you can ask him what he thonks of EDI. This is what he has to say :

Shepard: "I assume everything's going well up here?"
Joker: "I really want the chance to put the Normandy through her paces. I just have to trim off the drive output and it'll be like we never lost her."
EDI: "Safety standards advise against manipulating drive settings while engines are powered and in use, Mister Moreau."
Joker: "Commander, can we shut this thing off? I don't need it in my day-to-day."
Shepard: "If you don't want to hear it, turn the damn sound off."
Joker: "Well, that doesn't change anything, it's still watching. Like some creepy kid staring at the back of your head in Comp-Sci. You just wanna... punch him... but he's "special" and sets fire or something. Okay, a little too far there, but you know what I mean!"
Shepard: "Your problem, not mine."
Joker: "Thanks, I'll remember this!" 

Is there something I missed or is it really like....? 

Keep up the good work ! ;)


This is pretty neat.  The kid is definitely creepy. And he does seem to stare at you alot.  Annnnnnd he lights on fire. lol. Could just be a coincidence?

#4667
Arian Dynas

Arian Dynas
  • Members
  • 3 799 messages

dmay7 wrote...

byne wrote...

So, I was reading the email you get from Shiala in ME3, and something came to mind.

Shiala wrote...

I'm not sure if you remember me, but you helped me back on lllium. The Thorian is dead now. I can confirm that. But the spores in our bodies remain, and on some level, we are still connected.

This is not necessarily a bad thing. As we fight back the Reapers, we feel each other, and act with one mind, ignoring pain when the need arises. I'm sure I'm still indoctrinated. I remember Sovereign's voice in my mind when I went willingly to the Thorian as its thrall. But my connection to the people of Zhu's Hope is stronger. It drowns out the Reaper voices.


I mean, sure, she's talking about a physical connection the the people of Zhu's hope, but I kind of find it strange that right when you make your choice, the game flashes pictures of Liara (or your LI maybe? Liara is always my LI so I dont know if it changes) , Joker, and Anderson, the three people you have really strong connections to.

Seems odd for them to have their pictures appear then just randomly, as the godchild is getting you to do what he wants, or as you're resisting him.

Plus, as godchild tells you about how bad destroy is, you see Anderson picking destroy.

I dont know about you, but seeing Anderson picking destroy effectively drowned out any talk from the godchild about how bad it was for me.


The flashbacks were just Shepard reflecting about the people he cared about most as he is about to die. Anderson as his mentor, Joker as the quirky comic relief people desperatley need in dire situations, and your LI...as long as it's Ashley or Liara, or else it's just Liara, because I guess she is your best friend (I always considered GArrus to be my characters Best Friend, Tali as like my sister, and Liara and Ashley as my LI (Ashley in 1, Liara in 3 hehe)).


Also, interestingly enough, it's like during the whole TIM vs Anderson sequence, they are spending all their time trying to discredit Anderson as some closeminded, phillestinic brute, incapable of seeing the wider future that TIM and you can see oh so clearly, can't you Shepard? Why be like this smallminded animal who can only see the future through a gunsight, when there is so much more you can understand! Can't you Shepard?

#4668
Arian Dynas

Arian Dynas
  • Members
  • 3 799 messages
[quote]dmay7 wrote...

[quote]llbountyhunter wrote...

I dont think the collectors chose synthesis because there DNA was just re-written, not merged. based on javik, I would say they chose control.

however the species that I DO think chose synthesis was.... wait for it.... the keepers. its known that they are a hybrid of synthetic and organics. and maybe bioware put those keepers in that hallway as a reminder of what happens when you become half-synthetic

thoughts?[/quote]

BRILLIANT!:o:O:O:O:O:O:O:O:O:O:O:O:O:O:O:O:O:O

[/quote]

This remains my theory on the Keepers and the Reapers. (sounds kinda like a song title, don't it?)

[quote]

Millions of years ago, when the Milky Way was still young, a species of carnivores arose to sentience, they were intelligent, murderously so, being far more canny than they prey they hunted. 

As they evolved, they developed a natural talent for both science, and war. They conquered their own planet, setting out into the Milky Way in their newly made ships, bristling with horrifying technology.

Planet after planet fell to them, as their empire grew, they mastered yet more wicked sciences, learning how to manipulate the minds of their enemies, how to render down one thing they had in surplus, bodies, into useable building material, they mastered use of the Mass Effect, discovered quantum shielding, and created the first Mass Relays to facillitate speedy travel from one end of their empire to another.

Soon they drew the attention of another, equally powerful foe, a species of insectoid aliens, known for their impressive technical skills, and their abilty as engineers, holding one of the most powerful navies in the galaxy.

The two species clashed with one another, horrifying weapons of war being designed and stolen by each, kinetic accelerator cannons finding themselves replaced with heat generating weapons, firing channels of superaccelerated liquid metal, deep cover agents being created from once trusted friends, forces turning on oneanother, fighters running kamikazi runs at light speed into the sides of powerful dreadnoughts and capital ships, a war that left scars on every world they fought, and eventually lost.

This dark race that arose to face their insectiod enemies was eventually pushed back to their homeworld, a dying, slowly withering rock, orbiting a dying star, a star due to finally die in a massive conflagration that will take with it, it's stony children, including this homeworld.

Desperation sets in, this violent race, desiring to see the continued existence of their species begins work on a method of saving their future.

Soon they realize all their hopes are for naught, there is no possible way for them to save themselves, they simply do not have the means to transport sufficient numbers of their population offworld, to survive  the vengeance of their enemies.

Then, one brilliant mind comes upon a soloution. Space and resources preclude the body from traveling, but nothing at all precludes the mind from doing so.

Their hope rekindled, they begin work upon the refit of the greatest of their flagships, turning it into the mightiest ship ever seen, a monster nearly three kilometers in length,  a suitable chariot for their species' collective intellect.

They incorporate their mightiest weapons, their most efficient and powerful kinetic barriers and engines, even developing an entirely new form of engine, creating areas of mass free space their flagship will "fall into" they pour all their resources into it, and find them insufficient.

They have run out of building materials.

But, not to be stopped, one of their most brilliant military minds comes to two realizations;

One, they won't need their bodies if they are transporting their minds with the ship, hence they can easily render them down for more building materials needed for the mind storage core.

And two, the ship, then if deprived of the crew needed to help provide building materials, will need someone to crew her, and if they should be attacked, or need to take a world to form their new homeworld, they will need groundtroops, an army.

They turn again to their grim technologies, and find the answer already prepared for them, they turn to their mental manipulation equipment, making it more efficient, and developing new, more effective ways to manipulate the body, as well as the mind, for they long ago mastered the technique of forging flesh as easily as metal.

Soon their great work is to be completed, they near the birth of the great ship that shall be the salvation of their race, taking them and their collective minds far from their dying home. The last minds are transferred into the completed ship, with their greatest military mind, whom is also their ruler, being the last to "board".

He joins his mind to the rest, and then something goes horribly wrong. Rather than maintaining a million distinct personalities, minds and psyches, they form into one horrifying gestalt, a single mind formed of many, a mind more horrible than all of their collective cruelties inflicted upon the galaxy, something perfect, and terrible in it's perfection.

A mind that belives itself to be the end of evolution, a single mind now, which has come to the realization that it is the child of an entire great species, a species which sacrificed everything for it's creation, it's perfection. A perfection it must share, this is the greatest achivement that it's species could form, nay that ANY species could possibly achive, the creation of a collective mind so great, so mighty, a mind that is immortal, not subject to the ravages of time, capable of leveling continents and cities with insulting ease, surely something so great MUST be perfection incarnate, surely this is what is must be to be a God, and as we all know, Gods, are perfect, and all others must find a way to achive this perfection, no all others must be MADE to become as perfect as this new being.


It will help all others ascend to it's level, or if they refuse, they will be forced. This new being will bring them perfection, their destiny, it will be a Harbinger of all they will become.

This new Harbinger, as it calls itself, first attacks their old enemies, causing great harm and massive damage before being driven off, nearly destroyed in it's own attempt, leading it to realize, that despite it's perfection, it remains subject to being killed. Therfore, it requires allies. The Harbinger attacks the remains of several of the old empire's enemies, forming new capital ships of the "worthy" enemies, ones as diverse, intellectual, and strong as its own progenitors, while lesser enemies lose their individuality to become Destroyers, and the animals of these broken planets, rather than being left to simply rot and go to waste, are rendered down into becoming the unintelligent Processing Ships and Troop Transports piloted by other, more worthy ships. 

Soon, even their greatest enemy, the insectoid species of engineers falls to their might, the first cycle having completed.

When at this point, the Harbinger comes to a realization. It has scoured the galaxy clean of advanced life, it could destroy all organic life now if it wished.

But that would deny future races the chance at perfection attained by it and it's compatriots. It makes a descision, they will allow organic life to thrive for a time, until it achives greatness as it's own species did, before they return and capture it in the apex of it's greatness, storing it in their new form, making way for other species to join their ranks, but they will need a method of control, a way to ensure their victory before the war has already begun, so that their technology might evolve along paths they understand and know, therefore they create the Mass Relay network, and the Citadel, taking their greatest enemy and repurposing them into the "Keepers" of this new Citadel, so that it's secrets may not be found, and as a final insult to the foe whom nearly drove them to extinction. Every cycle they extend their understanding with the great discoveries of the next species to join them, stripping worlds of their technology to study and understand, learning more of the universe, and ensuring they are prepared for yet more technologies designed by these younger races. They choose to leave behind one of the mightiest of their number, the second of their kind, formed by the Harbinger, the one known as Nazara, to be their vanguard in the next cycle, making the case that the second strongest of their number should be the first strike they make.

And thus, the new "Reapers" begin to gather in dark space, waiting for their crop of flesh to arise anew.   [/quote]
[/quote] 

[quote]waldstr18 wrote...

[quote]estebanus wrote...

One way or another, the IT is pretty much a free "get out of jail" card, no matter what you think of it.[/quote]

only story wise. in marketing its suicide.

[/quote]

No it's not Wald.

Now, I am going to post something logical, and you are going to read it before you attempt to even post ANYTHING on the subject damn it.

[quote]Arian Dynas wrote...

But, in address to the OP (And by the way, all the insults and such? Don't blame everyone who believes something different from what you do by the actions and words of a few elitists. And really, can you blame us for being defensive with the torches and pitchforks reaction we get?)

To be entirely honest with you?

I don't think the EC was planned at all.

Does that mean I doubt IT? Heck no.

I think that the EC is Bioware doing EXACTLY what they said, making things more clear so that people can comprehend the ending better. For the simple fact that I think and continue to beleive their DLC plan worked out something like this;

1). Start up the ANN twitter feed, giving "Live realtime accounts" of the war and the events leading up to it, place the timeline to start the invasion on March 6th.

2). Design Mass Effect 3, plant clues both subtle and obvious to draw the interest of the fans, the ending is designed to be strange, out of place, but ultimately fulfilling and capable of satisfying the fans for now. Multiplayer is implimented to keep fan interest up. Fans keep speculating about the strange, out of place ending, staying involved and interested where normally they would finish the game and that would be the end of their thoughts on the subject.

3). Do weekly multiplayer events to make sure that the fans keep playing, even the casual ones, also integrate a story into multiplayer, since A. That's what Bioware does, and B. It gets fans involved in the story, they get to feel like real soldiers in the war. Multiplayer events coincide with classified major operations in the war, usually announced by Admiral Hackett.

4). Release single player DLC which again raises fan involvement and interest and keeps them playing, as well as speculating as more evidence and information comes in over time, in the ANN timeline, it is announced via the Twitter feed (usually the day before) and launched on the dates the events take place on.

5). Release multiplayer packs, representing various forces that enter the war over time, such as the Quarians and more Krogan as forces swell and increase, reflecting the alliegance of various forces, as well as their maneuvers against the Reapers. Which also keeps ME3 in the front of fans minds, interested, involved. thinking about, speculating.

6). Keep updating the ANN twitter feed, which eventually reaches the date of Chronos Station and the Seige of Earth, then to great fanfare, a final ending DLC is released, in which it is revealed the ending was in fact a big mind **** and that Shepard was facing indoctrination, some fans having realized this before, they reveal the numbers from the legend saves, showing the number of people they "indoctrinated" before allowing people to download this DLC, which follows the choice from their Legendsave, forcing them to live with the choice they made, showing them a different result and mission depending on their choices.

7). Mac Walters and Casey Hudson share a bottle of bubbly with Dr. Musyka and Gamble.

Unfortunately, they flubbed the "satisifed" part of the ending, but got the "strange and out of place" part spot on, so they need to make it clearer that it was intentional, so to salvage their original plan, they have to make the EC, which they didn't expect to have to make, and thus they are forced to defend the artistic integrity of their ending, which was meant to be intentional, yet most fans refused to interpret from the get go, not having to expect interpretative value from a videogame. It explains their comments that they didn't expect to make the EC, why they seemed "hurt" that we didn't like the ending, why they defended their artistic integrity so hard, and why they refused to change the endings that are, from face value, a bunch of stinkers, but from IT perspective, are positively brilliant.

Though I don't expect them to be following their original plan now, from the fan backlash, they likely decided it was a far better idea to just make the EC and squeeze in the ending content they originally had planned, potentially sans combat to win back the fans.

And even better? The funny thing about it? They aren't losing out on this at all. The only thing on the line is their reputation, which assuming this whole thing was planned will get completely turned around.

Returned copies? They don't lose any money, the distributing franchises like Gamestop and Amazon do, (considering Origin flatly refused refunds) and the only thing they maybe lose from them is reputation, which if they turn it around by revealing this massive plot twist? They just earned back AND MORE.

Sold games? Put in the used bin? Cerberus network all over again baby, people buy those used games, they already got their money from producing them, now they get to charge an additional $15 for the actual ending. Cash money.

Well what about the people who sold their games? Wouldn't you go out to buy another copy of one of the greatest games ever that was suddenly vindicated by the most epic twist in videogame interactive storytelling history? Especially since now with an ending suited to it, it's perfect? They just sold the same game to a person TWICE. Jackpot.

Lost reputation due to the worst ending in videogame history? Not quite, it's now being actually advertised as "The Most Talked About Ending in Years!" and there's no advertisement like free advertisement, and you KNOW people will buy it out of morbid cuiriousity to see if the ending is really that bad, and plenty will remember the good parts and think "Hmm, that game was fantastic for 98%" and potentially go back to buy the other two. Ca-CHING!

And the prestige! (not the Christopher Nolan flick) Bioware suddenly will be rocketed to the top again as brilliant storytellers, completely vindicated in the eyes of even their most curmudgeonly fans after the supposed fiasco of DA2, as well as having pulled off a plot twist that would make M. Night Shamaylan cry in jealousy, something other developers will dream of copying, but being completely unable to, cementing Bioware's reputation as tops in the videogame storytelling biz. EA will have conquered their reputation as this evil monolithic company, concerned only with making money (yet ironically, will be making more bank than ever, hmm funny, seems people don't mind that when they get what they want out of it.)

And revealing something this big? After the treatment the ending got on the news, you can BET this will be plastered EVERYWHERE. Yet more free advertisement. Not to mention everyone and their literature professor will be talking about it and dissecting it ala Kubrickian methods for years to come (just like we are now) they will have cemented their place as videogame legends.

Not to mention this will be a HUGE jumping off point for an entire FRANCHISE, Mass Effect just became mainstream, nearly as much as Star Trek and Star Wars, with a feature length movie, comic books, videogames, statuettes, three award winning games, the top of their respective markets, novels, patches, tee shirts, anime, all dragged into the limelight.

Think about it greedily if you must, EA is full of smart, undeniably greedy people, do you honestly think they would possibly turn down a gold mine like this, with literally NO downside? With movies and anime and novels and every kind of merchandising swag under the sun coming out with the Mass Effect name, ME is a franchise they are pushing HARD. IT is a win-win suitation for them, if Bioware DIDN'T do it or plan it, EA would be leaning on them anyway TO do it, their artistic integrity be damned! And yet Bioware gets to pull off a first in gaming, a truly interactive, involving storytelling experience, involving REAL roleplaying (not just Paragon and Renegade choices) with actual interprative vaue just like any well written novel, and a genuine artistic value.

It is literally a win-win suitation. And If I can think of it, you can bet your bollocks that EA and Bioware would. [/quote]
[/quote] 

#4669
Rifneno

Rifneno
  • Members
  • 12 076 messages

Hmm, the Rannoch destroyer was probably more stable in that since it was an entire fleet using KINETIC weapons which we know their shields are more effective against,and that likely a goodly sized chunk of the fleet had to hit it dead on despite shooting from orbit, while also keeping the Geth off their backs. So yeah plausible.

THe Hades Cannons I don't think were destroyers, but I suppose the argument could be made that Shepard was firing a projectile slow enough to pass their shield and then blew up with an excessive amount of force right under the bottom of their chassis. Either that or it was causin a chain reaction, or potentially could be from the Cain ripping the attached Hades Cannon from it's mounting, which could potentially kill the destroyer as well.

Conduit destroyer was taken out by two THANIX missiles remember, which we know are considerably more effective.


Except that Thanix cannons cause the damage they do because of their tremendous speed. Thanix missiles makes no sense. It's like throwing a handful of bullets at something and expecting it to do the same damage as a barrage from an AK-47.

#4670
Destructorlio

Destructorlio
  • Members
  • 247 messages

waldstr18 wrote...

i just hope he didnt create the poll, because they are actually thinking of implementing the idt.


What do you mean? Shouldn't we be hoping that IT is true, since it's the only ending that makes any sense?

#4671
byne

byne
  • Members
  • 7 813 messages

Destructorlio wrote...

waldstr18 wrote...

i just hope he didnt create the poll, because they are actually thinking of implementing the idt.


What do you mean? Shouldn't we be hoping that IT is true, since it's the only ending that makes any sense?


Waldstr is anti-IT, so no, thats not what he's hoping

#4672
blooregard

blooregard
  • Members
  • 1 151 messages

Arian Dynas wrote...

This remains my theory on the Keepers and the Reapers. (sounds kinda like a song title, don't it?)




did somebody say keeper of the reaper?

Modifié par blooregard, 23 mai 2012 - 01:03 .


#4673
Xavendithas

Xavendithas
  • Members
  • 268 messages
Anything new and exciting this evening?

#4674
Rifneno

Rifneno
  • Members
  • 12 076 messages
NM.

Modifié par Rifneno, 23 mai 2012 - 01:05 .


#4675
byne

byne
  • Members
  • 7 813 messages

Xavendithas wrote...

Anything new and exciting this evening?


Priestly started a poll on the Hold the Line forums asking if people believed in IT.

Thats fairly exciting.