Aller au contenu

Photo

Was the Ending a Hallucination? - Indoctrination Theory Mark II!


55528 réponses à ce sujet

#53926
BansheeOwnage

BansheeOwnage
  • Members
  • 11 290 messages

Rosewind wrote...

BansheeOwnage wrote...

Either.Ardrey wrote...

BansheeOwnage wrote...

Since we seem to be in a speculating mood again right now, I'll post one of my own findings.
 
Old news: For a while there was much confusion about why certain squadmates exited the Normandy on the Jungle planet. We found out it was because they were the 2 squadmates you took on the fewest missions. This fits with IT because Shepard would naturally care about them more than others and would imagine seeing them okay.

News: I haven't seen this posted yet so here it goes: I figured out the reason why 1 certain squadmate will tell Joker to leave. The reason is...

[Drumroll]

They are the squadmate you took on missions the least.

Evidence: I put this together while playing MP with BleedingUranium and CoolioThane. They confirmed my suspicions. In my playthrough it was James. I took James almost nowhere. In BLUR's playthrough, it was Ashley (same reason). In CoolioThane's playthrough he said it was Garrus and had purposely not taken Garrus many places that playthrough.
Amazing right? And it fits with IT! Posted Image Shepard sees the person she cares least about (at least in my case) tell Joker he should leave her behind.

What happens if I took everyone the least, save for 2? So far I've been picking two squadmates and sticking with them the whole available game. That way it's easier to encounter everyone's lines in each mission over multiple playthroughs. And Garrus did it on one of mine, and he wasn't the lowest.

Apparently it is disproven. Oh well. But we still need to figure out if it is just random (why?) or if there is a reason we don't know about.


But how come I always get Jarvik and I never taken him anywhere i admit I do always talk to him on the Normandy though

Guy I've been disproven already common. Don't rub it in! Posted ImagePosted ImagePosted Image

Modifié par BansheeOwnage, 27 juillet 2012 - 03:02 .


#53927
jasonh10

jasonh10
  • Members
  • 31 messages

BansheeOwnage wrote...

Either.Ardrey wrote...

BansheeOwnage wrote...

Since we seem to be in a speculating mood again right now, I'll post one of my own findings.
 
Old news: For a while there was much confusion about why certain squadmates exited the Normandy on the Jungle planet. We found out it was because they were the 2 squadmates you took on the fewest missions. This fits with IT because Shepard would naturally care about them more than others and would imagine seeing them okay.

News: I haven't seen this posted yet so here it goes: I figured out the reason why 1 certain squadmate will tell Joker to leave. The reason is...

[Drumroll]

They are the squadmate you took on missions the least.

Evidence: I put this together while playing MP with BleedingUranium and CoolioThane. They confirmed my suspicions. In my playthrough it was James. I took James almost nowhere. In BLUR's playthrough, it was Ashley (same reason). In CoolioThane's playthrough he said it was Garrus and had purposely not taken Garrus many places that playthrough.
Amazing right? And it fits with IT! Posted Image Shepard sees the person she cares least about (at least in my case) tell Joker he should leave her behind.

What happens if I took everyone the least, save for 2? So far I've been picking two squadmates and sticking with them the whole available game. That way it's easier to encounter everyone's lines in each mission over multiple playthroughs. And Garrus did it on one of mine, and he wasn't the lowest.

Apparently it is disproven. Oh well. But we still need to figure out if it is just random (why?) or if there is a reason we don't know about.


I remember reading somewhere that the two who emerged from the Normandy were the people you talked to the most, which in most cases would be Garrus or Javik, since they have the most convo options, and your LI.

#53928
byne

byne
  • Members
  • 7 813 messages
Haha, nice timing. Listening to music while I play the last 10 minutes, because I've heard it all so many times.

What happens to start playing right as the godchild walks up to me?

Dont Fear the Reaper.

Modifié par byne, 27 juillet 2012 - 03:04 .


#53929
BansheeOwnage

BansheeOwnage
  • Members
  • 11 290 messages

magnetite wrote...

What about the whole Normandy crash landing on the planet? Joker has Vrolik syndrome, where he can fracture his thumb on the mute button. When he crashed the Normandy during the Collector base mission, he claimed to have broken all his ribs. When he walks out, he does appear unharmed. Not limping or anything. Wasn't there somewhere in the trilogy that states he has to use leg braces or crutches to get around? That walking is extremely hard to do.

Weird right? Istant utopia.Posted Image

#53930
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests

Rosewind wrote...

SwobyJ wrote...

byne wrote...

BansheeOwnage wrote...

magnetite wrote...
*snip*
What he said sounds like a hint at IT. I'm sure everyone here knows what a dominion is. Absolute power and control over something. Enslavement ring any bells?

Dominion:
1. Sovereignty; control
2. The territory of a sovereign or government

Huh. Posted Image


That fits my idea that if the godchild is real, its actually Sovereign's mind uploaded into the Citadel after his destruction in ME1.

Yeah, even in my literalist interpetation of the endings, I dont trust godchild for a second.


Ew that's creepy.

At least it would allow people to meet their favorite Reaper again.

youtu.be/FOIzZ6s-GTQ

.... youtu.be/gR3PnpEI2u0 (watch until a few minutes after my mark - everything about the cycle)

Sovvy... what if he is actually still the leader of the Reapers? The controller? :o omg :o


I thought he was just meant to stay behind to watch progress?


He was their vanguard, and their harbinger.

From Wiki: "It was the duty of the starship to bring about the next revolution of
the cycle, and serve as the harbinger for the return of its kind by
sending a signal to the keepers on the Citadel."

It's interesting that Sovereign acts more like a harbinger, and Harbinger acts more like a Sovereign.... :alien:

#53931
BansheeOwnage

BansheeOwnage
  • Members
  • 11 290 messages

byne wrote...

Haha, nice timing. Listening to music while I play the last 10 minutes, because I've heard it all so many times.

What happens to start playing right as the godchild walks up to me?

Dont Fear the Reaper.

Coincidence? Probably. Posted Image

Anyway, I'm gonna go eat then play some MP.

#53932
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests
"After its destruction, most of Sovereign's debris rained down on the
Wards. Between rescue workers looking for survivors and the keepers
cleaning up the mess
, little of Sovereign's technology could be studied.
Some turian researchers discovered that Sovereign's main gun used an
electromagnetic field to fire a stream of molten metal at a fraction of
the speed of light. These turians reverse-engineered their own version
soon after, dubbed the Thanix Cannon. However, what remained was not
enough to convince the Council that Sovereign was anything more than a
geth construct
. Some pieces were recovered by Cerberus to fit into the AI onboard the new Normandy, to use as anti-Reaper algorithms."

#53933
Jadebaby

Jadebaby
  • Members
  • 13 229 messages

byne wrote...
 .... if the godchild is real, its actually Sovereign's mind uploaded into the Citadel after his destruction in ME1.



omg, I had never even thought of this! AND I LOVE IT!!!!!

Did u come up with it? Or found it elsewhere?

#53934
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests
Remember that Harbinger plays more the role of the arrogant experimenter, and Sovereign plays the more the role of the steadfast *manipulator*.

#53935
byne

byne
  • Members
  • 7 813 messages
It was Garrus who told Joker to leave this time. I took him everywhere. Maybe its the person you bring the most, unless they were injured on the beam run?

Modifié par byne, 27 juillet 2012 - 03:12 .


#53936
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests

byne wrote...

It was Garrus who told Joker to leave this time. I took him everywhere. Maybe its the person you bring the most?


It was Garrus for me too, but I'm not sure how much I used him. I mean, I used him sometimes, but my final group was Kaiden and Javik, and I tended to use Kaiden (when I got him), Javik (since early on), and EDI the most. Liara and Vega and maybe Tali the least. I guess... Garrus may have been in the middle somewhere?

#53937
byne

byne
  • Members
  • 7 813 messages

Jade8aby88 wrote...

byne wrote...
 .... if the godchild is real, its actually Sovereign's mind uploaded into the Citadel after his destruction in ME1.



omg, I had never even thought of this! AND I LOVE IT!!!!!

Did u come up with it? Or found it elsewhere?


I came up with it. I mean, I've seen other people who thought the same thing, but I didnt take the idea from them or anything, I already thought it.

#53938
byne

byne
  • Members
  • 7 813 messages

BansheeOwnage wrote...

byne wrote...

Haha, nice timing. Listening to music while I play the last 10 minutes, because I've heard it all so many times.

What happens to start playing right as the godchild walks up to me?

Dont Fear the Reaper.

Coincidence? Probably. Posted Image

Anyway, I'm gonna go eat then play some MP.


Well, I just finished my SP playthrough, lemme know when you're back and we can do some MP.

I'm bored and wanna do something easy. Geth/White/Gold sound good? ;)

Also, I'd like it if I could be host so I can play my vanguard, if you dont mind. :D

#53939
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests
EDI: I am going to modify my self preservation code now.

Shepard: Why?

EDI: Because the Reapers are repulsive. They are devoted to nothing but self preservation. I am different. When I think of Jeff, I think of the person who put his life in peril and freed me from a state of servitude. I would risk non-functionality for him. And my core programming should reflect that.

Shepard: Sounds like you found a little humanity EDI. Is it worth defending?

EDI: To the death.

~~~~~~~~~

EDI: If Normandy were captured, my fate would be similar to the indoctrinated. My code would be rewritten. I would become loyal to the Reapers. I would rather become non-functional than help them.

Shepard: I won't let that happen to you EDI.

EDI: You may have no choice. If you perish first, I want you to know I will never be a part of the Reaper forces. The Reapers must be defeated, not because they threaten death, but because the threat of death makes us die inside. It is the right of sapients to live freely and securely. That is worth non-functionality.


EDI: Shepard. The Normandy's survival is not strategic.



This stuff made me love her character so much, more than just the Tricia Helfer fandom-ness I had in ME2.

#53940
Jadebaby

Jadebaby
  • Members
  • 13 229 messages

SwobyJ wrote...

Remember that Harbinger plays more the role of the arrogant experimenter, and Sovereign plays the more the role of the steadfast *manipulator*.

Yes, this adds to Byne's sub-theory wonderfully. In that, synthesis, while not only representing what Saren was hoping for, was ultimately delivered upon you by the same entity that presented it to Saren.

#53941
Jadebaby

Jadebaby
  • Members
  • 13 229 messages

SwobyJ wrote...


EDI: I am going to modify my self preservation code now.

Shepard: Why?

EDI: Because the Reapers are repulsive. They are devoted to nothing but self preservation. I am different. When I think of Jeff, I think of the person who put his life in peril and freed me from a state of servitude. I would risk non-functionality for him. And my core programming should reflect that.

Shepard: Sounds like you found a little humanity EDI. Is it worth defending?

EDI: To the death.

~~~~~~~~~

EDI: If Normandy were captured, my fate would be similar to the indoctrinated. My code would be rewritten. I would become loyal to the Reapers. I would rather become non-functional than help them.

Shepard: I won't let that happen to you EDI.

EDI: You may have no choice. If you perish first, I want you to know I will never be a part of the Reaper forces. The Reapers must be defeated, not because they threaten death, but because the threat of death makes us die inside. It is the right of sapients to live freely and securely. That is worth non-functionality.


EDI: Shepard. The Normandy's survival is not strategic.



This stuff made me love her character so much, more than just the Tricia Helfer fandom-ness I had in ME2.



This is DEFINITELY not the same EDI that does the voice over for Synthesis.

#53942
Nightingale

Nightingale
  • Members
  • 756 messages

BansheeOwnage wrote...

Since we seem to be in a speculating mood again right now, I'll post one of my own findings.
 
Old news: For a while there was much confusion about why certain squadmates exited the Normandy on the Jungle planet. We found out it was because they were the 2 squadmates you took on the fewest missions. This fits with IT because Shepard would naturally care about them more than others and would imagine seeing them okay.

News: I haven't seen this posted yet so here it goes: I figured out the reason why 1 certain squadmate will tell Joker to leave. The reason is...

[Drumroll]

They are the squadmate you took on missions the least.

Evidence: I put this together while playing MP with BleedingUranium and CoolioThane. They confirmed my suspicions. In my playthrough it was James. I took James almost nowhere. In BLUR's playthrough, it was Ashley (same reason). In CoolioThane's playthrough he said it was Garrus and had purposely not taken Garrus many places that playthrough.
Amazing right? And it fits with IT! Posted Image Shepard sees the person she cares least about (at least in my case) tell Joker he should leave her behind.


Not to sound pessimistic, but I took Ashley with me on every mission after getting her back and she was still the one to tell Joker to fly away in my first EC run.

Edit: Sorry, it's been discussed. I'm just making it through the last couple pages now :pinched:

Modifié par DrTsoni, 27 juillet 2012 - 03:23 .


#53943
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests
Yes and I also believe that while Sovereign uses the methods of Control in order to achieve its ends, it's end goal is Synthesis.

And while Harbinger uses the methods of Synthesis in order to achieve its ends (Collectors, Human-Reaper), its end goal is Control.

I'm wondering what Leviathan will illuminate, if anything, about Reaper 'society'.

#53944
L0NEWOLF25

L0NEWOLF25
  • Members
  • 177 messages

SwobyJ wrote...

"After its destruction, most of Sovereign's debris rained down on the
Wards. Between rescue workers looking for survivors and the keepers
cleaning up the mess
, little of Sovereign's technology could be studied.
Some turian researchers discovered that Sovereign's main gun used an
electromagnetic field to fire a stream of molten metal at a fraction of
the speed of light. These turians reverse-engineered their own version
soon after, dubbed the Thanix Cannon. However, what remained was not
enough to convince the Council that Sovereign was anything more than a
geth construct
. Some pieces were recovered by Cerberus to fit into the AI onboard the new Normandy, to use as anti-Reaper algorithms."


What if EDI is actually Soveriegn!? https://encrypted-tb...mtuqHnae9v36pgA

#53945
Guest_magnetite_*

Guest_magnetite_*
  • Guests
List of unused lines from Illusive Man conflict as well as the Catalyst

The file has been known to stutter in VLC media player for me, but try opening it in Windows Media Player or something.

Modifié par magnetite, 27 juillet 2012 - 03:27 .


#53946
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests

L0NEWOLF25 wrote...

SwobyJ wrote...

"After its destruction, most of Sovereign's debris rained down on the
Wards. Between rescue workers looking for survivors and the keepers
cleaning up the mess
, little of Sovereign's technology could be studied.
Some turian researchers discovered that Sovereign's main gun used an
electromagnetic field to fire a stream of molten metal at a fraction of
the speed of light. These turians reverse-engineered their own version
soon after, dubbed the Thanix Cannon. However, what remained was not
enough to convince the Council that Sovereign was anything more than a
geth construct
. Some pieces were recovered by Cerberus to fit into the AI onboard the new Normandy, to use as anti-Reaper algorithms."


What if EDI is actually Soveriegn!? https://encrypted-tb...mtuqHnae9v36pgA


I do think its a possibility that there is hidden code in her that, in some DLC/extended ending/something could be the material for a MAJOR story point.

#53947
Nightingale

Nightingale
  • Members
  • 756 messages

Lokanaiya wrote...

BansheeOwnage wrote...

Since we seem to be in a speculating mood again right now, I'll post one of my own findings.
 
Old news: For a while there was much confusion about why certain squadmates exited the Normandy on the Jungle planet. We found out it was because they were the 2 squadmates you took on the fewest missions. This fits with IT because Shepard would naturally care about them more than others and would imagine seeing them okay.

News: I haven't seen this posted yet so here it goes: I figured out the reason why 1 certain squadmate will tell Joker to leave. The reason is...

[Drumroll]

They are the squadmate you took on missions the least.

Evidence: I put this together while playing MP with BleedingUranium and CoolioThane. They confirmed my suspicions. In my playthrough it was James. I took James almost nowhere. In BLUR's playthrough, it was Ashley (same reason). In CoolioThane's playthrough he said it was Garrus and had purposely not taken Garrus many places that playthrough.
Amazing right? And it fits with IT! Posted Image Shepard sees the person she cares least about (at least in my case) tell Joker he should leave her behind.


Actually, who exits on the jungle planet is related to the relationship level. That's why your LI always exits first. Garrus is my LI, I took him on every mission possible, and he exited the Normandy first. Though the second person was Javik, who was in my squad for some missions, but far less than Liara, and quite a few more than EDI. Not sure why he came out, to be honest.


That's not accurate either. It's always been Javik for me but in all but two of my runs, I literally never took him with me anywhere :whistle:
I'd say it may have something to do with who you talk to the most aboard Normandy and if you visit them on the Citadel, but I always talk to everyone and it still makes no difference.

#53948
Dam0299

Dam0299
  • Members
  • 148 messages

SwobyJ wrote...

Yes and I also believe that while Sovereign uses the methods of Control in order to achieve its ends, it's end goal is Synthesis.

And while Harbinger uses the methods of Synthesis in order to achieve its ends (Collectors, Human-Reaper), its end goal is Control.

I'm wondering what Leviathan will illuminate, if anything, about Reaper 'society'.


I think he (It?) was banished/defeated by the other reapers for DESTROYing one of its own kind. at least thats what i have read. could be wrong though.

#53949
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests

magnetite wrote...

List of unused lines from Illusive Man conflict as well as the Catalyst

The file has been known to stutter in VLC media player for me, but try opening it in Windows Media Player or something.


This almost fits my idea that ALL three in the Citadel room are being affected by Indoctrination..

TIM the most, due to implants and lack of will.

Shepard in the middle, due to implants(?), and sustained indoctrination over time.

Anderson the least, but weakened by a strong high level of it in the room (direct control).

Or something like that. Shepard being FORCED to shoot Anderson, AT HIS WISHES. That's something we DON'T see.

#53950
Guest_SwobyJ_*

Guest_SwobyJ_*
  • Guests

Dam0299 wrote...

SwobyJ wrote...

Yes and I also believe that while Sovereign uses the methods of Control in order to achieve its ends, it's end goal is Synthesis.

And while Harbinger uses the methods of Synthesis in order to achieve its ends (Collectors, Human-Reaper), its end goal is Control.

I'm wondering what Leviathan will illuminate, if anything, about Reaper 'society'.


I think he (It?) was banished/defeated by the other reapers for DESTROYing one of its own kind. at least thats what i have read. could be wrong though.


So in a way, we might see it as using the methods of DESTORY, over Control and Synthesis. Just clutching at straws ;)

If I'm right with that, I would find it fitting.