Aller au contenu

Photo

Was the Ending a Hallucination? - Indoctrination Theory Mark II!


55528 réponses à ce sujet

#5676
HellishFiend

HellishFiend
  • Members
  • 5 546 messages

MaximizedAction wrote...

BTW, tried to play Arrival without music on and heard those high pitch notes already in the hangar while Kenson was hacking that elevator.
You know, the notes that were posted about yesterday (while the Crucible beam is charging).

So +1 from me for the Crucible acting like something along the lines of Object Rho.


Really? How certain are you that it's the same sound? Could be significant. 

#5677
HellishFiend

HellishFiend
  • Members
  • 5 546 messages

EpyonX3 wrote...

Shepard was on the Crucible! Not the Citadel, I shall render evidence of this shortly.


Yeah, good luck with that. 

#5678
D.Sharrah

D.Sharrah
  • Members
  • 1 579 messages

blooregard wrote...

D.Sharrah wrote...

Two notes...

1. Isn't there a QE comm on the Normandy where Shepard refers to Anderson as Admiral...only to have Anderson tell him not to be so formal? Can't remember the exact timing of it in game, but I want to say that is shortly after leaving Earth, mayber after finishing the mission on Menae...

2. I'm not convinced that the Crucible itself is the trap...I think that the Conduit is the trap (in fact I think that it is a device similar to the Reaper indoctrination device from Aequitas and Object Rho). I get the feeling that the "Waking Nightmare Theory" could very well be in play (in that what we see during the entire game is a mix of reality and hallucination) and that at the very least Shepard's indoctrination began with the events on Arrival (canon be damned).

As ME 3 progresses the Reapers learn of the Crucible and that it very well maybe the key to their defeat. They also learn that we do not have/know everything that we need to complete it - so they start to lay the groundwork for a plan meant to play on the galaxy's desperation . It starts with using their indoctrinated agent TIM, to create another opponent to distract us from finding what it is we need to finish the Crucible. While also moving their pawn into the position that not only can he steal the data that we need, but be in the position to plant false (or partially false) information for us to follow...which leads to the revelation that Citadel is the catalyst.

At this point, they enact the last stage of their devious plan. They move the Citadel to Earth's orbit, close the arms and leack false intel that makes it appear that the "Conduit" is the only way to access the Citadel. Of course this is all done as a trap to lure the united fleet and more specifically Shepard in their trap - a trap designed with two purposes in mind, bring all of their enemies to one front and give them one last opportunity to complete the indoctrination of what would be their ultimate sleep agent.




If this is the case I'd actually be pretty mad. This IMO would be worse then the endings we got where we still "beat" the Reapers. This ending we have defeat, defeat, or defeat. The only way this could work is if the Reapers could be beaten conventionally (and while our cycle certainly has the best chance out of everyone it still seems unlikely)


Not exactly...it still fits with the rest of the general ideas from IT.  Control/Synthesis = Indoctrination = Defeat, Destroy = Resist Indoctrination = Chance at victory (degree of victory to be determined by EMS and specifc War Assets).  One idea is that with high EMS and strong Citadel Defense War Asset, Bailey and crew are able to open the Citadel arms the crucible docks and we still have our "deus ex machina" to defeat the Reapers.

#5679
DJBare

DJBare
  • Members
  • 6 510 messages

EpyonX3 wrote...

OK guys and gals here it is.

http://i49.tinypic.com/dousck.png


What is this object sticking out of the Crucible before it dock? Notice that it's round like a pillar and doesn't look like the prongs we see right as it is connecting. It's possible that this ejects into the citadel just as it docks.

Check this out. If Shepard was on the Citadel, then where are all of the features of the decision room?
http://i48.tinypic.com/ncfrq0.png


They're not there because it's not part of the Citadel. I'll produce an image later but the energy that comes from the crucible flows down a cylindrical structure similar to that of the first image.

And look at this!
http://i50.tinypic.com/29kt0ux.png

The prongs seem so expand but that cylinder is still visible. Shepard is standing on the cylinder. If this is true, this will explain how:

1) Shepard is breathing after he picks destory, the crucible has its own life support
2) How there are items from the normandy on the platform
3) And how Shepard is breathing before picking an option (Point 1)

Seriously. play it again, then when you are up with starbinger, look up, you will see the crucible above you.

#5680
EpyonX3

EpyonX3
  • Members
  • 2 374 messages

DJBare wrote...

EpyonX3 wrote...

OK guys and gals here it is.

http://i49.tinypic.com/dousck.png


What is this object sticking out of the Crucible before it dock? Notice that it's round like a pillar and doesn't look like the prongs we see right as it is connecting. It's possible that this ejects into the citadel just as it docks.

Check this out. If Shepard was on the Citadel, then where are all of the features of the decision room?
http://i48.tinypic.com/ncfrq0.png


They're not there because it's not part of the Citadel. I'll produce an image later but the energy that comes from the crucible flows down a cylindrical structure similar to that of the first image.

And look at this!
http://i50.tinypic.com/29kt0ux.png

The prongs seem so expand but that cylinder is still visible. Shepard is standing on the cylinder. If this is true, this will explain how:

1) Shepard is breathing after he picks destory, the crucible has its own life support
2) How there are items from the normandy on the platform
3) And how Shepard is breathing before picking an option (Point 1)

Seriously. play it again, then when you are up with starbinger, look up, you will see the crucible above you.


Yes it is above you, but the platform is the crucible as well. The platform sits at the base of the citadel but you are on the crucible technically.

#5681
MaximizedAction

MaximizedAction
  • Members
  • 3 293 messages

HellishFiend wrote...

MaximizedAction wrote...

BTW, tried to play Arrival without music on and heard those high pitch notes already in the hangar while Kenson was hacking that elevator.
You know, the notes that were posted about yesterday (while the Crucible beam is charging).

So +1 from me for the Crucible acting like something along the lines of Object Rho.


Really? How certain are you that it's the same sound? Could be significant. 


You know what? I'm gonna try to look into the pcc files of that level and see if I find it. If not, well, then I was wrong.

Nothin' better than cold hard scientific evidence.

#5682
blooregard

blooregard
  • Members
  • 1 151 messages

EpyonX3 wrote...

OK guys and gals here it is.

http://i49.tinypic.com/dousck.png


What is this object sticking out of the Crucible before it dock? Notice that it's round like a pillar and doesn't look like the prongs we see right as it is connecting. It's possible that this ejects into the citadel just as it docks.

Check this out. If Shepard was on the Citadel, then where are all of the features of the decision room?
http://i48.tinypic.com/ncfrq0.png


They're not there because it's not part of the Citadel. I'll produce an image later but the energy that comes from the crucible flows down a cylindrical structure similar to that of the first image.

And look at this!
http://i50.tinypic.com/29kt0ux.png

The prongs seem so expand but that cylinder is still visible. Shepard is standing on the cylinder. If this is true, this will explain how:

1) Shepard is breathing after he picks destory, the crucible has its own life support
2) How there are items from the normandy on the platform
3) And how Shepard is breathing before picking an option (Point 1)




You get an A for effort.

#5683
LazyTechGuy

LazyTechGuy
  • Members
  • 715 messages
Wait ... was this known?


Quote from the Rebellion MP Pack announcement:



"Ex-Cerberus Vanguard:

When the Illusive Man turned to indoctrination in order to ensure the loyalty of his troops, many Cerberus operatives defected and joined the Alliance in order to stop the Reapers. Now that we’re on the same team, Ex-Cerberus Vanguards (along with their new Lash attack) are quickly proving their worth."

Modifié par LazyTechGuy, 24 mai 2012 - 04:29 .


#5684
D.Sharrah

D.Sharrah
  • Members
  • 1 579 messages

DJBare wrote...

D.Sharrah wrote...
2. I'm not convinced that the Crucible itself is the trap...I think that the Conduit is the trap (in fact I think that it is a device similar to the Reaper indoctrination device from Aequitas and Object Rho). I get the feeling that the "Waking Nightmare Theory" could very well be in play (in that what we see during the entire game is a mix of reality and hallucination) and that at the very least Shepard's indoctrination began with the events on Arrival (canon be damned).

I'm answering this one seperately, I'm convinced it's a trap after we fitted it with a human reaper heart, not to mention it's a war asset the player cannot avoid, it's forced upon you.


I am not sure...doesn't the codex say that the heart is the power device...now if the power device is synonymous with indoctrination device you have got a point...but I got the feeling from the game that they were trying to point out that there are differnces in "Reaper Tech" and not all "Reaper Tech" leads to indoctrination...hence why I am always ok with Legion using the "reaper code" (ie software) to upgrade the Geth - the software itself does not indoctrinate or make it any more likely that they will get indoctrinated - you still need that piece of the puzzle (or tech) for that to happen.

#5685
Dwailing

Dwailing
  • Members
  • 4 566 messages

Dwailing wrote...

RavenEyry wrote...

Dwailing wrote...
 "Oh look, we're going to design the Crucible so that you have to shoot a tube to activate it!"

"While we're at it, let's paint a mural of the crucible on the control rooms ceiling!"


"Brilliant!  And oh yeah, while we're doing that, let's make it so that in order for it to be activated in any other way you have to either jump into a beam of energy and dissolve, or you have to grab two electrical things and disintigrate!" 


Reposting this to show just how ludicrous the idea that Shepard is on the Crucible is.  I mean come ON.  The finest minds in the galaxy came up with THIS?  I know that they were working off of schematics created by previous races but SERIOUSLY.

#5686
Dwailing

Dwailing
  • Members
  • 4 566 messages

blooregard wrote...


EpyonX3 wrote...

OK guys and gals here it is.

http://i49.tinypic.com/dousck.png


What is this object sticking out of the Crucible before it dock? Notice that it's round like a pillar and doesn't look like the prongs we see right as it is connecting. It's possible that this ejects into the citadel just as it docks.

Check this out. If Shepard was on the Citadel, then where are all of the features of the decision room?
http://i48.tinypic.com/ncfrq0.png


They're not there because it's not part of the Citadel. I'll produce an image later but the energy that comes from the crucible flows down a cylindrical structure similar to that of the first image.

And look at this!
http://i50.tinypic.com/29kt0ux.png

The prongs seem so expand but that cylinder is still visible. Shepard is standing on the cylinder. If this is true, this will explain how:

1) Shepard is breathing after he picks destory, the crucible has its own life support
2) How there are items from the normandy on the platform
3) And how Shepard is breathing before picking an option (Point 1)




You get an A for effort.


Yeah, I'll give him that much.

#5687
HellishFiend

HellishFiend
  • Members
  • 5 546 messages
 

D.Sharrah wrote...
*snip*
.... at the very least Shepard's indoctrination began with the events on Arrival (canon be damned).


You do know Arrival is canon, right? It's absolutely fair game for speculation. 


Dwailing wrote...

RavenEyry wrote...

Dwailing wrote...
 "Oh look, we're going to design the Crucible so that you have to shoot a tube to activate it!"

"While we're at it, let's paint a mural of the crucible on the control rooms ceiling!"


"Brilliant!  And oh yeah, while we're doing that, let's make it so that in order for it to be activated in any other way you have to either jump into a beam of energy and dissolve, or you have to grab two electrical things and disintigrate!" 


"And lets not forget the animated mockup of what the battle between the allied fleet and the Reapers will look like!  And Earth!"
"Why Earth?"
"Just cuz"

#5688
Dwailing

Dwailing
  • Members
  • 4 566 messages

LazyTechGuy wrote...

Wait ... was this known?


Quote from the Rebellion MP Pack announcement:



"Ex-Cerberus Vanguard:

When the Illusive Man turned to indoctrination in order to ensure the loyalty of his troops, many Cerberus operatives defected and joined the Alliance in order to stop the Reapers. Now that we’re on the same team, Ex-Cerberus Vanguards (along with their new Lash attack) are quickly proving their worth."


That's very interesting.  Also, why aren't they making the new guns available in singleplayer?  They look awesome. :crying:

#5689
DJBare

DJBare
  • Members
  • 6 510 messages

D.Sharrah wrote...
I am not sure...doesn't the codex say that the heart is the power device...now if the power device is synonymous with indoctrination device you have got a point...but I got the feeling from the game that they were trying to point out that there are differnces in "Reaper Tech" and not all "Reaper Tech" leads to indoctrination...hence why I am always ok with Legion using the "reaper code" (ie software) to upgrade the Geth - the software itself does not indoctrinate or make it any more likely that they will get indoctrinated - you still need that piece of the puzzle (or tech) for that to happen.

It's reaper tech, and more importantly it's attuned to humanity since it was created from human colonist, I believe it was the heart that completed TIM's indoctrination while he stood staring at it, my theory is the crucible amplifies the effects of the heart, the reapers do have a particular interest in human genetic diversity.

#5690
MaximizedAction

MaximizedAction
  • Members
  • 3 293 messages

LazyTechGuy wrote...

Wait ... was this known?


Quote from the Rebellion MP Pack announcement:



"Ex-Cerberus Vanguard:

When the Illusive Man turned to indoctrination in order to ensure the loyalty of his troops, many Cerberus operatives defected and joined the Alliance in order to stop the Reapers. Now that we’re on the same team, Ex-Cerberus Vanguards (along with their new Lash attack) are quickly proving their worth."


It's free!

EDIT: It's not so much that I'm pro MP content, but more that it doesn't contradict Arian's idea of Bioware's plan

Modifié par MaximizedAction, 24 mai 2012 - 04:41 .


#5691
llbountyhunter

llbountyhunter
  • Members
  • 1 646 messages

Dwailing wrote...

blooregard wrote...


EpyonX3 wrote...

OK guys and gals here it is.

http://i49.tinypic.com/dousck.png


What is this object sticking out of the Crucible before it dock? Notice that it's round like a pillar and doesn't look like the prongs we see right as it is connecting. It's possible that this ejects into the citadel just as it docks.

Check this out. If Shepard was on the Citadel, then where are all of the features of the decision room?
http://i48.tinypic.com/ncfrq0.png


They're not there because it's not part of the Citadel. I'll produce an image later but the energy that comes from the crucible flows down a cylindrical structure similar to that of the first image.

And look at this!
http://i50.tinypic.com/29kt0ux.png

The prongs seem so expand but that cylinder is still visible. Shepard is standing on the cylinder. If this is true, this will explain how:

1) Shepard is breathing after he picks destory, the crucible has its own life support
2) How there are items from the normandy on the platform
3) And how Shepard is breathing before picking an option (Point 1)




You get an A for effort.


Yeah, I'll give him that much.



shortly after this Epyon will make a SOCT (shepard on crucible theory) thread, that he will shamelesly advertise but will be largely ingnored. 

Modifié par llbountyhunter, 24 mai 2012 - 04:35 .


#5692
RavenEyry

RavenEyry
  • Members
  • 4 394 messages
I think Epyon is saying the 'choice chamber' opens from the front of the crucible and connects to the flat tower base. In this case looking up would show the rest of the crucible, would show stars to the side and could even have a life support field. It actually makes a lot of sense.

#5693
LazyTechGuy

LazyTechGuy
  • Members
  • 715 messages
No yeah, that's awesome. But I mean the part about the Illusive Man turning to indoctrination to ensure troop loyalty. Was that known?

#5694
HellishFiend

HellishFiend
  • Members
  • 5 546 messages

EpyonX3 wrote...

OK guys and gals here it is.


What is this object sticking out of the Crucible before it dock? Notice that it's round like a pillar and doesn't look like the prongs we see right as it is connecting. It's possible that this ejects into the citadel just as it docks.

Check this out. If Shepard was on the Citadel, then where are all of the features of the decision room?


They're not there because it's not part of the Citadel. I'll produce an image later but the energy that comes from the crucible flows down a cylindrical structure similar to that of the first image.

And look at this!

The prongs seem so expand but that cylinder is still visible. Shepard is standing on the cylinder. If this is true, this will explain how:

1) Shepard is breathing after he picks destory, the crucible has its own life support
2) How there are items from the normandy on the platform
3) And how Shepard is breathing before picking an option (Point 1)


Firstly, if you want to take the pictures so seriously, then take a picture of the Citadel as it's blowing up after the Crucible activates. The Crucible is GONE. Not there. Vanished. Explain that?

Moreover, explain why the "catalyst" tells Shepard he's on the Citadel when he asks where he is. 

Additionally, I just feel your rationalization as to why Shepard is on the Crucible is highly implausible, given the visual evidence we have to the contrary. 

#5695
dreamgazer

dreamgazer
  • Members
  • 15 765 messages
I'm still wondering if they cooked up multiplayer just to keep folks blissfully occupied until the release of the extended cut. (laughs)

#5696
Dwailing

Dwailing
  • Members
  • 4 566 messages

RavenEyry wrote...

I think Epyon is saying the 'choice chamber' opens from the front of the crucible and connects to the flat tower base. In this case looking up would show the rest of the crucible, would show stars to the side and could even have a life support field. It actually makes a lot of sense.


That's.... surprisingly possible.  That doesn't fix the obvious problems with the designs for actually ACTIVATING it, though....

#5697
dreamgazer

dreamgazer
  • Members
  • 15 765 messages

LazyTechGuy wrote...

Wait ... was this known?


Quote from the Rebellion MP Pack announcement:



"Ex-Cerberus Vanguard:

When the Illusive Man turned to indoctrination in order to ensure the loyalty of his troops, many Cerberus operatives defected and joined the Alliance in order to stop the Reapers. Now that we’re on the same team, Ex-Cerberus Vanguards (along with their new Lash attack) are quickly proving their worth."


There's a stray line of dialogue on the Cerberus base---from EDI---that suggests as such, I believe, shortly before you enter into the general area where the human Reaper is stored. 

#5698
EpyonX3

EpyonX3
  • Members
  • 2 374 messages
The decision chamber is more visible in this picture. Come really think about it.

Posted Image

#5699
IronSabbath88

IronSabbath88
  • Members
  • 1 810 messages
I'm totally glad I'm not the only one who uses the Daniel Bryan YES! gifs on this thread to express my happiness. xD

#5700
Dwailing

Dwailing
  • Members
  • 4 566 messages

dreamgazer wrote...

LazyTechGuy wrote...

Wait ... was this known?


Quote from the Rebellion MP Pack announcement:



"Ex-Cerberus Vanguard:

When the Illusive Man turned to indoctrination in order to ensure the loyalty of his troops, many Cerberus operatives defected and joined the Alliance in order to stop the Reapers. Now that we’re on the same team, Ex-Cerberus Vanguards (along with their new Lash attack) are quickly proving their worth."


There's a stray line of dialogue on the Cerberus base---from EDI---that suggests as such, I believe, shortly before you enter into the general area where the human Reaper is stored. 


And they're OBVIOUSLY implanted with Reaper tech Paul Grayson style.