Aller au contenu

Photo

Was the Ending a Hallucination? - Indoctrination Theory Mark II!


55528 réponses à ce sujet

#15651
Big Bad

Big Bad
  • Members
  • 1 717 messages
Happy weekend, everybody! Anything interesting happen in the last 12 hours?

#15652
paxxton

paxxton
  • Members
  • 8 445 messages

Dwailing wrote...

bigstig wrote...

MaximizedAction wrote...

bigstig wrote...

I have tried Gold a few times(failed everytime) I just don't have the skills to be of any use and don't want to bring the team down myself. I have Rambo'd both Silver and Bronze but it usally only lasts a wave or two before the rest of the team catch up. I always want to slap the players who are like 4-5times ahead of the rest of the team(unless the rest of the team are really useless of course)Posted Image


I felt like that about teammates with Reegars.


I have seen that gun a lot, can't say I have it yet though. There is another sniper rifle(geth I think) that basically acts as a cannon simply shoot near the target and it does damage(it's my favourite sniper rifle mainly because I suck)


Are you thinking about the Turian Krysae sniper rifle?  I really want that.

It might sound weird but I don't like that the HUD in MP doesn't make me invincible for the time it's visible allowing me to take my time and carefully choose what power and on whom I want to use.

Modifié par paxxton, 09 juin 2012 - 04:18 .


#15653
Stigweird85

Stigweird85
  • Members
  • 733 messages

Big G13 wrote...

MaximizedAction wrote...

Big G13 wrote...

paxxton wrote...
snip

EDIT: This. http://dictionary.re...wse/fourth wall

Thanks for linking that. For some reason I have never heard of that before. I understand the idea (Ferris Bueller) but never gave it any thought outside of comedy. I think it gives more weight to Dwailing's idea. I made the comment 3 months ago that Bioware is playing their own version of eXistenZ. ME3 is the gooie intestine that connects to the brain and we are all characters in an alternate reality game. Not a great analogy but it's all I got right now.


Some sitcoms use that now and then.
Recent example is Two and a half men: Jon Cryer does a dramatic chipmunk into the camera.
classic example is Fresh Prince: Will does that multiple times.
More on topic example: Fight Club has Brad Pitt and Edward Norton doing that. Edward Norton's character even explains the principle of cutting film rolls together to the audience.
In ME3: we assume that Admiral Anderson looks into the cam (aka the player) when he says "No, they're controlling you!".

So in cinema and tv it's a common tool, since it originated theater. In video games...not so common. Hence, though a very powerful technique but in video games the audience doesn't know what to do with it, yet.

YET. Dun dun duuuuuunnn. Seriously though, if Hudson and Co. are breaking down that fourth wall then the future of gaming may get interesting.


Best example of breaking the 4th wall. Marvel vs Capcom Deadpool(would it be anyone else) rips down his health bar and beats his opponent with itPosted Image

#15654
Dwailing

Dwailing
  • Members
  • 4 566 messages

bigstig wrote...

Big G13 wrote...

MaximizedAction wrote...

Big G13 wrote...

paxxton wrote...
snip

EDIT: This. http://dictionary.re...wse/fourth wall

Thanks for linking that. For some reason I have never heard of that before. I understand the idea (Ferris Bueller) but never gave it any thought outside of comedy. I think it gives more weight to Dwailing's idea. I made the comment 3 months ago that Bioware is playing their own version of eXistenZ. ME3 is the gooie intestine that connects to the brain and we are all characters in an alternate reality game. Not a great analogy but it's all I got right now.


Some sitcoms use that now and then.
Recent example is Two and a half men: Jon Cryer does a dramatic chipmunk into the camera.
classic example is Fresh Prince: Will does that multiple times.
More on topic example: Fight Club has Brad Pitt and Edward Norton doing that. Edward Norton's character even explains the principle of cutting film rolls together to the audience.
In ME3: we assume that Admiral Anderson looks into the cam (aka the player) when he says "No, they're controlling you!".

So in cinema and tv it's a common tool, since it originated theater. In video games...not so common. Hence, though a very powerful technique but in video games the audience doesn't know what to do with it, yet.

YET. Dun dun duuuuuunnn. Seriously though, if Hudson and Co. are breaking down that fourth wall then the future of gaming may get interesting.


Best example of breaking the 4th wall. Marvel vs Capcom Deadpool(would it be anyone else) rips down his health bar and beats his opponent with itPosted Image


OK, that might be the coolest thing I've heard all day.  Also, on an unrelated note, I just bought Dragon Age 2.  I think I'm going to just start it and work on it while I'll play DA:O.

#15655
paxxton

paxxton
  • Members
  • 8 445 messages

Big Bad wrote...

Happy weekend, everybody! Anything interesting happen in the last 12 hours?

So to you. On the previous page we discussed eye movement.

#15656
RavenEyry

RavenEyry
  • Members
  • 4 394 messages
If you've not heard there's a potential possibly maybe leak of a MP pack with Earth maps coming out around the same time as EC. Fits Arian's gameplan if true.

#15657
Dwailing

Dwailing
  • Members
  • 4 566 messages

paxxton wrote...

Big Bad wrote...

Happy weekend, everybody! Anything interesting happen in the last 12 hours?

So to you. On the previous page we discussed eye movement.


And a page or two before that, I came up with a surprisingly popular idea.  Check it out!

#15658
Dwailing

Dwailing
  • Members
  • 4 566 messages

RavenEyry wrote...

If you've not heard there's a potential possibly maybe leak of a MP pack with Earth maps coming out around the same time as EC. Fits Arian's gameplan if true.


That dude is brilliant.  Seriously, no offence to Byne, but I think he might be the finest of us.

Modifié par Dwailing, 09 juin 2012 - 04:23 .


#15659
paxxton

paxxton
  • Members
  • 8 445 messages

Dwailing wrote...

paxxton wrote...

Big Bad wrote...

Happy weekend, everybody! Anything interesting happen in the last 12 hours?

So to you. On the previous page we discussed eye movement.


And a page or two before that, I came up with a surprisingly popular idea.  Check it out!

I didn't actually get it. Posted ImagePosted Image

Modifié par paxxton, 09 juin 2012 - 04:27 .


#15660
Dwailing

Dwailing
  • Members
  • 4 566 messages

paxxton wrote...

Dwailing wrote...

paxxton wrote...

Big Bad wrote...

Happy weekend, everybody! Anything interesting happen in the last 12 hours?

So to you. On the previous page we discussed eye movement.


And a page or two before that, I came up with a surprisingly popular idea.  Check it out!

LOL. I didn't actually get it.


I admit, I probably could have spaced and/or phrased it better.  I'll see if I can bump it so others can consider it.

#15661
Dwailing

Dwailing
  • Members
  • 4 566 messages

Dwailing wrote...

 OK, I had an idea last night in the shower around 12:30 a.m. so it's a little crazy, but I think it's worth sharing.  We've all talked about how the gun represents Shepard's willpower and Anderson represents the unindoctrinated section of Shepard's mind.  So, I was thinking last night about this, and I realized that it's possible that the scene where we see Anderson holding the gun has meaning as well.  (Just as a heads up, you guys should know by now that I'm of the opinion that the hallucination started right after the crash.  Also, I'm going to go with an idea that popped up earlier that the beams being fired by Harbinger represent his attempts to invade Shep's mind.)  

Now, we first see the gun in Anderson's hand.  To me, this could represent that the unindoctrinated part of Shepard's mind is able to fight back against indoctrination.  It's armed and in control.  Then, the beam comes, and "Shepard" gets knocked out and Anderson disappears.  When he comes to, he finds the gun, his willpower.  

So now, I'm going to share the REALLY crazy idea.  What if, Casey Hudson was being quite literal about the player being Shep?  Meaning, what if the Shepard that we control in the end sequence is LITERALLY a representation of the player.  We have Shepard's willpower litterally in our hands, and it's up to us what we do with it.  Jump to the end, now, you, the player, are completely in control.  You have to decide what to do with Shepard's willpower.  Do you throw it away by choosing Control or Synthesis.  Or do you use it to stay strong, stick to Shepard's beliefs, and win this battle?  

I think this could be an explanation for the presence of an actual representation of Shepard.  I mean, think about it.  Anderson is the unindoctrinated part of Shep's mind.  TIM is the representation of the indoctrinated part of Shep's mind.  What could the actual Shepard that we see and control be?  A representation of the player.  Yeah, I know it's kind of crazy, but I figured it wouldn't hurt to share.

Edit: Wow, I think I actually made a wall of text.  Wasn't sure I'd ever make one of those.  Glad I was wrong.


Bumping and tweaking slightly.

#15662
Corik

Corik
  • Members
  • 471 messages
Just finished my second playthrough. Feels much better to shoot the tubes now than the first time. Most notable thing to talk about... the whispers during Anderson-Shepard-TIM conversation. Just the same whispers as in the dreams. Also, the oily bushes after getting hit by Harby are weird. Don't look normal. Don't even look "real" bushes, more like illusions... can't explain :P

#15663
Big Bad

Big Bad
  • Members
  • 1 717 messages

paxxton wrote...

Big Bad wrote...

Happy weekend, everybody! Anything interesting happen in the last 12 hours?

So to you. On the previous page we discussed eye movement.


Cool, I'll check it out!

#15664
Stigweird85

Stigweird85
  • Members
  • 733 messages

Dwailing wrote...

bigstig wrote...

MaximizedAction wrote...

bigstig wrote...

I have tried Gold a few times(failed everytime) I just don't have the skills to be of any use and don't want to bring the team down myself. I have Rambo'd both Silver and Bronze but it usally only lasts a wave or two before the rest of the team catch up. I always want to slap the players who are like 4-5times ahead of the rest of the team(unless the rest of the team are really useless of course)Posted Image


I felt like that about teammates with Reegars.


I have seen that gun a lot, can't say I have it yet though. There is another sniper rifle(geth I think) that basically acts as a cannon simply shoot near the target and it does damage(it's my favourite sniper rifle mainly because I suck)


Are you thinking about the Turian Krysae sniper rifle?  I really want that.


That's it, it kicks ass. It needs to be buffed though can easily no scope people with it.

#15665
Big Bad

Big Bad
  • Members
  • 1 717 messages

Dwailing wrote...

 OK, I had an idea last night in the shower around 12:30 a.m. so it's a little crazy, but I think it's worth sharing.  We've all talked about how the gun represents Shepard's willpower and Anderson represents the unindoctrinated section of Shepard's mind.  So, I was thinking last night about this, and I realized that it's possible that the scene where we see Anderson holding the gun has meaning as well.  (Just as a heads up, you guys should know by now that I'm of the opinion that the hallucination started right after the crash.  Also, I'm going to go with an idea that popped up earlier that the beams being fired by Harbinger represent his attempts to invade Shep's mind.)  Now, we first see the gun in Anderson's hand.  To me, this could represent that the unindoctrinated part of Shepard's mind is able to fight back against indoctrination.  It's armed and in control.  Then, the beam comes, and "Shepard" gets knocked out and Anderson disappears.  When he comes to, he finds the gun, his willpower.  So now, I'm going to share the REALLY crazy idea.  What if, Casey Hudson was being quite literal about the player being Shep?  Meaning, what if the Shepard that we control in the end sequence is LITERALLY a representation of the player.  We have Shepard's willpower litterally in our hands, and it's up to us what we do with it.  Jump to the end, now, you, the player, are completely in control.  You have to decide what to do with Shepard's willpower.  Do you throw it away by choosing Control or Synthesis.  Or do you use it to stay strong, stick to Shepard's beliefs, and win this battle?  I think this could be an explanation for the presence of an actual representation of Shepard.  I mean, think about it.  Anderson is the unindoctrinated part of Shep's mind.  TIM is the representation of the indoctrinated part of Shep's mind.  What could the actual Shepard that we see and control be?  A representation of the player.  Yeah, I know it's kind of crazy, but I figured it wouldn't hurt to share.

Edit: Wow, I think I actually made a wall of text.  Wasn't sure I'd ever make one of those.  Glad I was wrong.


Nice, I like it!  :happy:

#15666
Stigweird85

Stigweird85
  • Members
  • 733 messages

Dwailing wrote...

paxxton wrote...

Big Bad wrote...

Happy weekend, everybody! Anything interesting happen in the last 12 hours?

So to you. On the previous page we discussed eye movement.


And a page or two before that, I came up with a surprisingly popular idea.  Check it out!


And a couple of pages before that we questioned why Reapers can create but not be tied to the whole created will rebel thing

#15667
Dwailing

Dwailing
  • Members
  • 4 566 messages

Big Bad wrote...

Dwailing wrote...

 OK, I had an idea last night in the shower around 12:30 a.m. so it's a little crazy, but I think it's worth sharing.  We've all talked about how the gun represents Shepard's willpower and Anderson represents the unindoctrinated section of Shepard's mind.  So, I was thinking last night about this, and I realized that it's possible that the scene where we see Anderson holding the gun has meaning as well.  (Just as a heads up, you guys should know by now that I'm of the opinion that the hallucination started right after the crash.  Also, I'm going to go with an idea that popped up earlier that the beams being fired by Harbinger represent his attempts to invade Shep's mind.)  Now, we first see the gun in Anderson's hand.  To me, this could represent that the unindoctrinated part of Shepard's mind is able to fight back against indoctrination.  It's armed and in control.  Then, the beam comes, and "Shepard" gets knocked out and Anderson disappears.  When he comes to, he finds the gun, his willpower.  So now, I'm going to share the REALLY crazy idea.  What if, Casey Hudson was being quite literal about the player being Shep?  Meaning, what if the Shepard that we control in the end sequence is LITERALLY a representation of the player.  We have Shepard's willpower litterally in our hands, and it's up to us what we do with it.  Jump to the end, now, you, the player, are completely in control.  You have to decide what to do with Shepard's willpower.  Do you throw it away by choosing Control or Synthesis.  Or do you use it to stay strong, stick to Shepard's beliefs, and win this battle?  I think this could be an explanation for the presence of an actual representation of Shepard.  I mean, think about it.  Anderson is the unindoctrinated part of Shep's mind.  TIM is the representation of the indoctrinated part of Shep's mind.  What could the actual Shepard that we see and control be?  A representation of the player.  Yeah, I know it's kind of crazy, but I figured it wouldn't hurt to share.

Edit: Wow, I think I actually made a wall of text.  Wasn't sure I'd ever make one of those.  Glad I was wrong.


Nice, I like it!  :happy:


Thanks mate!  I wasn't sure if I was crazy or not, but I guess I wasn't.  Personally, I'm just glad I could contribute something original and plausible.  For a bit, I was beginning to feel like Marauder Shields.  Really popular, but not really THAT important.

#15668
Dwailing

Dwailing
  • Members
  • 4 566 messages

bigstig wrote...

Dwailing wrote...

paxxton wrote...

Big Bad wrote...

Happy weekend, everybody! Anything interesting happen in the last 12 hours?

So to you. On the previous page we discussed eye movement.


And a page or two before that, I came up with a surprisingly popular idea.  Check it out!


And a couple of pages before that we questioned why Reapers can create but not be tied to the whole created will rebel thing


Wait!  I know this!  Bad writing!  No?  Then I've no idea unless IT is true and it (That business about the created always rebelling.) is all a load of crap.  Which one of those seems more likely to you?

Edited for clarity.

Modifié par Dwailing, 09 juin 2012 - 04:38 .


#15669
paxxton

paxxton
  • Members
  • 8 445 messages

Dwailing wrote...

Dwailing wrote...

 OK, I had an idea last night in the shower around 12:30 a.m. so it's a little crazy, but I think it's worth sharing.  We've all talked about how the gun represents Shepard's willpower and Anderson represents the unindoctrinated section of Shepard's mind.  So, I was thinking last night about this, and I realized that it's possible that the scene where we see Anderson holding the gun has meaning as well.  (Just as a heads up, you guys should know by now that I'm of the opinion that the hallucination started right after the crash.  Also, I'm going to go with an idea that popped up earlier that the beams being fired by Harbinger represent his attempts to invade Shep's mind.)  

Now, we first see the gun in Anderson's hand.  To me, this could represent that the unindoctrinated part of Shepard's mind is able to fight back against indoctrination.  It's armed and in control.  Then, the beam comes, and "Shepard" gets knocked out and Anderson disappears.  When he comes to, he finds the gun, his willpower.  

So now, I'm going to share the REALLY crazy idea.  What if, Casey Hudson was being quite literal about the player being Shep?  Meaning, what if the Shepard that we control in the end sequence is LITERALLY a representation of the player.  We have Shepard's willpower litterally in our hands, and it's up to us what we do with it.  Jump to the end, now, you, the player, are completely in control.  You have to decide what to do with Shepard's willpower.  Do you throw it away by choosing Control or Synthesis.  Or do you use it to stay strong, stick to Shepard's beliefs, and win this battle?  

I think this could be an explanation for the presence of an actual representation of Shepard.  I mean, think about it.  Anderson is the unindoctrinated part of Shep's mind.  TIM is the representation of the indoctrinated part of Shep's mind.  What could the actual Shepard that we see and control be?  A representation of the player.  Yeah, I know it's kind of crazy, but I figured it wouldn't hurt to share.

Edit: Wow, I think I actually made a wall of text.  Wasn't sure I'd ever make one of those.  Glad I was wrong.


Bumping and tweaking slightly.

What you are talking about is actually the main premise of Indoctrination Theory. Battle Shepard's willpower wages to save his mind's unindocrinated part (Anderson) and destroy the Reapers' influence in his mind (TIM). Then his wounded mind (willpower joined with the unindoctrinated part) is once more attempted to be compromised by the Reapers in the Starchild's Chamber.

Modifié par paxxton, 09 juin 2012 - 04:37 .


#15670
Corik

Corik
  • Members
  • 471 messages
Another evidence of ReaperBieber being in fact a reaper (harbinger probably... or bad writting xD). He says "The catalyst is my home" but two lines after, when talking about how they left humans alone in the last cycle he says "the last time we were here". Okay, Reaperbieber... if you live in the citadel, you haven't moved from here "since the last time they were here". In fact... if you control the reapers and live in the Citadel, why you didn't fix your "home" 3 years ago when Sovereing tried to open the relay to Dark Space? Your arguments are sinking! :P

#15671
MaximizedAction

MaximizedAction
  • Members
  • 3 293 messages

Corik wrote...

Another evidence of ReaperBieber being in fact a reaper (harbinger probably... or bad writting xD). He says "The catalyst is my home" but two lines after, when talking about how they left humans alone in the last cycle he says "the last time we were here". Okay, Reaperbieber... if you live in the citadel, you haven't moved from here "since the last time they were here". In fact... if you control the reapers and live in the Citadel, why you didn't fix your "home" 3 years ago when Sovereing tried to open the relay to Dark Space? Your arguments are sinking! :P


Wouldn't it be great if an english teacher could look through those 16 lines of dialog and let the red marker speak.:devil:

Modifié par MaximizedAction, 09 juin 2012 - 04:46 .


#15672
paxxton

paxxton
  • Members
  • 8 445 messages

MaximizedAction wrote...

Corik wrote...

Another evidence of ReaperBieber being in fact a reaper (harbinger probably... or bad writting xD). He says "The catalyst is my home" but two lines after, when talking about how they left humans alone in the last cycle he says "the last time we were here". Okay, Reaperbieber... if you live in the citadel, you haven't moved from here "since the last time they were here". In fact... if you control the reapers and live in the Citadel, why you didn't fix your "home" 3 years ago when Sovereing tried to open the relay to Dark Space? Your arguments are sinking! :P


Wouldn't it be great if an english teacher could look through those 16 lines of dialog and let the red marker speak.:devil:

I have four words for you: Starchild's logic makes sense. YYYEEEEEAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted Image

Modifié par paxxton, 09 juin 2012 - 04:57 .


#15673
MaximizedAction

MaximizedAction
  • Members
  • 3 293 messages

paxxton wrote...

MaximizedAction wrote...

Corik wrote...

Another evidence of ReaperBieber being in fact a reaper (harbinger probably... or bad writting xD). He says "The catalyst is my home" but two lines after, when talking about how they left humans alone in the last cycle he says "the last time we were here". Okay, Reaperbieber... if you live in the citadel, you haven't moved from here "since the last time they were here". In fact... if you control the reapers and live in the Citadel, why you didn't fix your "home" 3 years ago when Sovereing tried to open the relay to Dark Space? Your arguments are sinking! :P


Wouldn't it be great if an english teacher could look through those 16 lines of dialog and let the red marker speak.:devil:

I have four words for you: Starchild's logic makes sense. YYYEEEEEAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!


Yeah, I know, this thread and it's predecessor have already seen a discussion about the Catalyst's words in terms of pure logic. It's just that he often switches words in odd ways and uses his infamous 'yo dawg'-logic.
Thus, mostly making sense if you put his talk under a rigorous analysis, but not if you're in Shepard's fried shoes where he's battleworn and tired.
I know what it's like. I, too, have morning lectures. :P

Modifié par MaximizedAction, 09 juin 2012 - 05:04 .


#15674
Corik

Corik
  • Members
  • 471 messages

MaximizedAction wrote...

paxxton wrote...

MaximizedAction wrote...

Corik wrote...

Another evidence of ReaperBieber being in fact a reaper (harbinger probably... or bad writting xD). He says "The catalyst is my home" but two lines after, when talking about how they left humans alone in the last cycle he says "the last time we were here". Okay, Reaperbieber... if you live in the citadel, you haven't moved from here "since the last time they were here". In fact... if you control the reapers and live in the Citadel, why you didn't fix your "home" 3 years ago when Sovereing tried to open the relay to Dark Space? Your arguments are sinking! :P


Wouldn't it be great if an english teacher could look through those 16 lines of dialog and let the red marker speak.:devil:

I have four words for you: Starchild's logic makes sense. YYYEEEEEAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!


Yeah, I know, this thread and it's predecessor have already seen a discussion about the Catalyst's words in terms of pure logic. It's just that he often switches words in odd ways.
Thus, making sense if you put his talk under a rigorous analysis, but not if you're in Shepard's fried shoes where he's battleworn and tired.
I know what it's like. I, too, have morning lectures. :P


I think he was kidding.

#15675
D.Sharrah

D.Sharrah
  • Members
  • 1 579 messages

ivenoidea wrote...

Big G13 wrote...

MaximizedAction wrote...

Big G13 wrote...

paxxton wrote...
snip

EDIT: This. http://dictionary.re...wse/fourth wall

Thanks for linking that. For some reason I have never heard of that before. I understand the idea (Ferris Bueller) but never gave it any thought outside of comedy. I think it gives more weight to Dwailing's idea. I made the comment 3 months ago that Bioware is playing their own version of eXistenZ. ME3 is the gooie intestine that connects to the brain and we are all characters in an alternate reality game. Not a great analogy but it's all I got right now.


Some sitcoms use that now and then.
Recent example is Two and a half men: Jon Cryer does a dramatic chipmunk into the camera.
classic example is Fresh Prince: Will does that multiple times.
More on topic example: Fight Club has Brad Pitt and Edward Norton doing that. Edward Norton's character even explains the principle of cutting film rolls together to the audience.
In ME3: we assume that Admiral Anderson looks into the cam (aka the player) when he says "No, they're controlling you!".

So in cinema and tv it's a common tool, since it originated theater. In video games...not so common. Hence, though a very powerful technique but in video games the audience doesn't know what to do with it, yet.

YET. Dun dun duuuuuunnn. Seriously though, if Hudson and Co. are breaking down that fourth wall then the future of gaming may get interesting.


VERY interesting indeed. I actually only know one other game that does this. Secret Files, a point-and-click adventure. The female lead has several remarks that break the fourth wall, such as "The lead designer did not allow us to put in timed puzzles." And stuff like that. At one point she speaks about being in a game too :D

Edit: And of course Monkey Island. I'm a ****ing retard.


I was just playing Monkey Island (Xbox Live version  -as an aside love it, have both MI and MI 2: Le'Chuck's Revenge)...and they break the 4th wall several times...