Dwailing wrote...
I'm with what pretty much everyone is saying right now about when the hallucination starts. There are kinky elements of Priority: Earth that Shepard is probably hallucinating, but the REALLY bizarre stuff only starts after the crash. And I say after the crash rather than after the beam for two reasons. One: it explains why there are shrubs and trees from the dreams before Shepard is hit, and two: it saves Anderson from the indignity of using Sarge's tactics.
I hear you loud and clear about the Sarge tactics that Anderson implements ... I remember face palming when he proposed his "strategy" to me... For a series so rich with military themes it can be a little unrealistic when it comes to plot based tactics.
BatmanTurian wrote...
This is my personal opinion. I think from the moment Shepard enters the room where the baby reaper is in Chronos, the way Shepard views reality warps a little. It's barely noticable at first but it begins to become cumulative until it becomes full-blown wtf-ery in London and then the shuttle crash or the beam just sends it all over the edge. I don't think the " hallucination" (for lack of a better term) has a cut-and-dry beginning. I think it comes in spurts and definitely starts ratcheting up on Earth.
HellishFiend wrote...
I think the most popular theory right now is that Cronos all the way up to the Mako crash are subject to partial hallucination, kind of like a waking dream, or schizophrenia. If you've ever seen A Beautiful Mind, that is a good example. I think that Shepard is knocked out at the Mako crash instead of by Harby's beam, and everything starting from the run to the beam is a full blown hallucination. Everything before the Mako crash is just partially hallucinated. At least thats the running theory I'm going by right now.
It's exciting stuff, because it gives us a lot more material to look at while we're waiting for the EC. [smilie]http://social.bioware.com/images/forum/emoticons/happy.png[/smilie]
I too am of a similar belief at the moment, I just was curious to see what the general consensus was. Interesting to find that we've all come to a similar conclusion.
Arian Dynas wrote...
I am torn between partial hallucination, culminating with the beam, which to be honest feels a bit cheap to me, since it makes us question EVERYTHING, and the other possibility I hold is the entirety of London is a hallucination Shepard has while in a comatose state, awaiting medical evac after the shuttle crashed on their way down to deal with the Hades Cannon.
Why do you feel the beam makes us question everything? Wouldn't it just be an instigator for increased levels of hallucination due to Shepard continuing to get closer to it? and hence sets him over the edge due to sheer proximity to it or during the completely glossed over Mako crash. Which reminds me so much of
this in fringe which was glossed over until the season 2 opener shown
here.
I must admit that I've never bought into the shuttle crash theory as the evidence supporting it I've always found a little thin but I'm happy to hear why you think it's a possibility.