742 réponses à ce sujet

[Mr. Big Pimpin]

I'm all for replacing a current squadmate with Jack, but Tali's not the one I'm thinking of. Here's a hint; he spends all his time exercising and sometimes uses Spanish words.

[dublin omega 223]

Mr. Big Pimpin wrote...

I'm all for replacing a current squadmate with Jack, but Tali's not the one I'm thinking of. Here's a hint; he spends all his time exercising and sometimes uses Spanish words.

I'd say have her replace Liara, never liked her character myself. Vega however I liked, the Loco nickname put a smile on my face.

[Arlionis]

Rip504 wrote...

Op your opinion is based on assumptions. I disagree with you. Tali is better then Jack and any other ME2 squaddie and any ME1 squaddie,o and also any ME3 squaddie. Because of the lack of development that was set aside for the better character Tali!!!

Also check out my gamer pic, I am a fan of Jack.
Hatorade drinkers.

Happy for you, for me Tali is as boring as a rock (and I'm not even talking about one of those flashy ones with crystals attached to them and weird shapes, just a normal, gray rock) 

Modifié par Arlionis, 15 mai 2012 - 11:08 .

[lillitheris]

Why is it always THERE IS TOO LITTLE OF MY FAVOURITE THEREFORE REMOVE EVERYBODY ELSE’S!!!1

Instead of, say, “Jack should be a squadmate too”?

[Arlionis]

lillitheris wrote...

Why is it always THERE IS TOO LITTLE OF MY FAVOURITE THEREFORE REMOVE EVERYBODY ELSE’S!!!1

Instead of, say, “Jack should be a squadmate too”?

It's not "remove everyone else", it's: remove a character that was already overused, was a squadmember in the three games and let other characters have some spothlight time. 

[Unholyknight800]

 This is still going on? Narrow minded fools! 

[OchreJelly]

And I used to wonder where the BioWare philosophy of "Someone doesn't like this or that element? REMOVE IT ENTIRELY!" came from.

[Sublyminal]

Arlionis wrote...

Rip504 wrote...

Op your opinion is based on assumptions. I disagree with you. Tali is better then Jack and any other ME2 squaddie and any ME1 squaddie,o and also any ME3 squaddie. Because of the lack of development that was set aside for the better character Tali!!!

Also check out my gamer pic, I am a fan of Jack.
Hatorade drinkers.

Happy for you, for me Tali is as boring as a rock (and I'm not even talking about one of those flashy ones with crystals attached to them and weird shapes, just a normal, gray rock) 

You should be shot and set on fire for these blasphemous comments! <_<

[4stringwizard]

Blasphemy! You can never have too much Tali!

I say, get rid of the squad member who was trying to stalk you every 15-20 minutes and had zero use as the Shadow Broker.

[What a Succulent Ass]

I honestly doubt Jack was at any time meant to be a permanent squadmate. She was likely redesigned simply because she's an author favourite.

[Generic Screen Name]

She got carried off by seeker swarms in my game. Nothing of value was lost.

[NoSpin]

Well Tali and I were just chatting, and it turns out she doesn't really like you either.

[Arlionis]

Generic Screen Name wrote...

She got carried off by seeker swarms in my game. Nothing of value was lost.

Yeah, but then all the resources that could have been used for another character in ME3 were "gone" for you, that's why I think she's way overused and it's time to let other characters get more love. Jack was my example because her redesign was obvious, but Miranda also deserves more development, Samara too, and, well, all of the ME2 cast. 


I hope the EC will make justice tio them, even the dead ones, I'd love to see a Thane romancing femShep reuniting with Kolyat to pay Thane a last goodbye ceremony in one of Earth's desert, Samara and Falere reuniting, someway fixing the mess they did with Jacob as a LI, etcetc. 


(Not to mention that if they don't include AT LEAST one of the Krogan songs honouring Shep I'll be very pissed :happy: ) 

[garrusfan1]

OchreJelly wrote...

And I used to wonder where the BioWare philosophy of "Someone doesn't like this or that element? REMOVE IT ENTIRELY!" came from.

hahhahhahhhaa

[garrusfan1]

Random Jerkface wrote...

I honestly doubt Jack was at any time meant to be a permanent squadmate. She was likely redesigned simply because she's an author favourite.

but why spend the resources on it because that isn`t a very valid reason in my opinion

[Arlionis]

SergeantSnookie wrote...

I agree.

Remove her, and then watch BioWare offices everywhere get burned to the ground by rabid, angry Talimancers.

Yeah, good luck with getting them outside of their basements 

[Garlador]

I like both characters.

But I bunked up with the girl wearing the bucket on her head.

I regret nothing.

[TomY90]

Random Jerkface wrote...

I honestly doubt Jack was at any time meant to be a permanent squadmate. She was likely redesigned simply because she's an author favourite.

From what I heard she was meant to be a full squad member but they decided against it during development because in ME2 she was not a very popular character, so they put her to a cameo role rather than have a full role. I think grissom Academy was meant to be a sort of recruitment mission like we did with Mars and Palaven but the change in direction caused it to change. (considering you use the mech for the 1st time guaranteed seemed like a tutorial to me)

But you can tell Tali was not meant to a full squad member considering how late she joins the crew and lack of development.

I do agree I with the topic though that I am tired of Tali and constant demands for her to be in everything (won't be surprised if she gets her own game or on cereal boxes (sorry Kai Leng) considering how much demand there is for more)

I think most characters in the series have much more development than Tali and much more interesting (the only interesting part is the mysteriousness of her appearance but turns out her entire race were photoshopped humans without realising it) I think even Jacob is more interesting at times and that is saying something.

[Arlionis]

TomY90 wrote...

Random Jerkface wrote...

I think most characters in the series have much more development than Tali and much more interesting (the only interesting part is the mysteriousness of her appearance but turns out her entire race were photoshopped humans without realising it) I think even Jacob is more interesting at times and that is saying something.

 

 

Indeed, and the fact that characters that were featured in just one game feel more developed and deep than a character that was in three games speaks volumes. 

Also, Jacob is way more interesting than what most people want to admit, he was pretty badass in the iOS game that had him as a protagonist. 

Modifié par Arlionis, 16 mai 2012 - 01:44 .

[Gen Petitt]

Oh no this thread again beginning to ignore.

[justafan]

It just isn't Mass Effect without Team Dextro. Tali and Garrus are hugely popular, thus they get to be in all the games. The Quarian/Geth war was obviously going to be a major arch in ME3, and Tali is essential to that, so she was going to be a big character regardless, and due to her popularity it makes sense to bring her back on the Normandy. Jack on the other hand never had that kind of following, and a lot of people didn't like her in ME2 unless they took the time to romance her. She was great in ME3, and in her short appearance had a lot of character development, but it seems highly unlikely she was replaced by Tali considering she was never all that important to the plot or a fan-favorite.

[garrusfan1]

Arlionis wrote...

SergeantSnookie wrote...

I agree.

Remove her, and then watch BioWare offices everywhere get burned to the ground by rabid, angry Talimancers.

Yeah, good luck with getting them outside of their basements 

dude I like tali but thats hilarious and scary because the talimancers are loyal to her But she isn`t my favorite so  

[Gen Petitt]

SergeantSnookie wrote...

Gen Petitt wrote...

Oh no this thread again beginning to ignore.

I dearly hope you're not implying Tali gets a lot of hate threads.

No just don't like it and wish to leave before I feed this person with satisfaction of my anger.