95 réponses à ce sujet

[Surberus]

As there is a topic claiming DA:O to be THE best rpg of all time, I would love to get a tally of what people consider to be the best of all time.

List your top 5, #1 is worth 5 pts, #2 = 4pts, #3 = 3pts, #4 = 2pts, and #5 = 1pt

As the thread carries on, I will continue to upgrade the tally in this post.

My Top 5:
1) Morrowind
2) Mass Effect
3) Chrono Trigger
4) Neverwinter Nights
5) Dungeon Siege 2



Forum Top 5: (Ive caught up to SKI's post - you guys are costing me game time  ;0P )
1) Dragon Age: Origins
2) Baldur's Gate 2
3) Planescape: Torment
4) Morrowind
5) Fallout 3


The top 2 are opening a bit of a gap at this point

Modifié par Surberus, 09 décembre 2009 - 07:02 .

[Giltspur]

1) Dragon Age (This is a tough call with BG2. I'm giving DAO the edge on the strength of the Morrigan and Alistair characters and further development of some of my favorite elements of BG2.. As the newness of DAO wears off, maybe BG2 will challenge again.)

2) Baldur's Gate II: Shadows of Amn/Throne of Bhaal

3) Planescape: Torment.

4) Final Fantasy VII

5) Icewind Dale



Now I'm pretty heavy on Infinity-era Bioware/Black Isle games. I left out BG1 mostly just to be fair and get one console RPG in there.

[Badittude2you]

Top five)

1) Planescape Torment

2)Fallout 3

3)Baldurs Gate 2

4)Mass Effect

5)Dragon Age

[BramAlam12345]

1) Morrowind

2) Dragon Age

3) KOTOR

4) Fallout 3

5) Neverwinter Nights 2

[-Solrek-]

1) Baldur's Gate II: Shadows of Amn
2) Planescape: Torment
3) Dragon Age: Origins
4) Fallout 3
5) Morrowind

Modifié par -Solrek-, 09 décembre 2009 - 06:04 .

[deathwing200]

1) Baldur's Gate 2

2) Dragon Age

3) FF 7

4) FF 8

5) Neverwinter Nights 2

[Staylost]

1) Planescape: Torment.

2) Baldur's Gate 1.

3) Morrowind.

4) Baldur's Gate 2.

5) Xenosega.

Edit: List still the same.

Ignoring MGeezer because that isn't a list of a top five...

Here is the tally of everyone's votes up to Rehpotsirhc on page 2:
1)DA:0
2) BG2
3)Morrowind
4)Planescape: Torment
5)Fallout 3

Modifié par Staylost, 09 décembre 2009 - 07:46 .

[miltos33]

1) Morrowind

2) Fallout 3

3) Dragon Age

4) NWN2

5) The Witcher

[Sp0gg]

1. BG2
2. BG1
3. Fallout 2
4. The Witcher
5. Morrowind

Mass Effect? Fallout 3? Are you kidding me?

Edit:  Whoops, how could I forget the Witcher!

Modifié par Sp0gg, 09 décembre 2009 - 06:12 .

[sjibben]

1) KOTOR

2) Mass Effect

3) Dragon Age

4) KOTOR 2

5) Jade Empire

[Sam -stone- serious]

My top 5 RPG's of all time.



1. Deus eX (the first one)

2. Baldurs Gate 2 saga

3. Planescape Torment

4. Xenosaga (including Xenogears which is the supposed 5th part)

5. Disgaea hour of darkness (i know this is a strategy RPG but still an RPG)

[Soretooth]

1) Dragon Age

2) Fallout 3

3) Diablo II

4) Hellgate: London

5) Bard's Tale (I/II/III)

[oYOSSARIANo]

1. Morrowind
2. Fallout 2
3. DA:O
4. KotOR
5. Baldurs Gate 2

Modifié par oYOSSARIANo, 09 décembre 2009 - 06:16 .

[Flamesz]

1) Dragon Age

2) Fallout 3

3) Final Fantasy X

4) Final Fantasy 7

5) Mass Effect



My friend just gave me KOTOR 2 so i'l see how that goes.

[bjdbwea]

1. Mass Effect
2. Baldur's Gate 2 + ToB
3. Fallout 3
4. DA:O
5. KotoR

Modifié par bjdbwea, 09 décembre 2009 - 06:17 .

[Elizabeth Sterling]

1 - Baldur's Gate Trilogy
2 - Fallout 2
3 - Gothic 2 (Most involved and taxing combat of any game ever, rich quests and environments. NOTR was lower quality sadly)
4 - Planescape Torment (classic but didn't offer that much replayability)
5 - Fallout 3 (The only bethsoft game that really delivers much on the hype IMHO)

I have played Final Fantasy 1 through 9 but I find the stories rather asinine and the gameplay not only outdated but nearly missing. The typical JRPG format seems about as interesting as using a spreadsheet and the storylines make me feel like I'm trapped in some bad fanfiction, especially from 5 onwards.

Similarly I don't rate the Icewind Dale games because they didn't involve me. The fact your ONLY sidequests were the 5 odd you picked up in the VERY FIRST TOWN and other than that it was straight combat bored me to tears. I never got past that tower with the shadow orcs without giving up to save me from more tedium.

The Elder scrolls series has its moments but Oblivion's gameplay and immersion were utterly broken and the constant questing in to the Oblivion gates made me uninstall it. Mods or nay it was fundamentally flawed. Morrowind is still my favorite in the series and has given a few good playthroughs but again lacks that immersive quality the games in my top 5 had.

Zelda games... I'm not sure why these are considered RPGs, they've always struck me as fantasy action games these days but either way they seem very ho-hum. The last one I gave a crap about was Zelda 3 and 2 remains my fast favorite.

Ultima games offered nice if bland fantasy and a real incentive for exploration but they still had the worst game interfaces known to man and that makes revisiting them a distant thought.

Neverwinter Nights 1 was a failed if bold experiment and Neverwinter Nights 2 was, to my mind at least, plain and simple garbage and what it took to get me to look kindly on NWN1 in the first place.

MMOs? Not for me, thanks.

Modifié par Elizabeth Sterling, 09 décembre 2009 - 06:22 .

[Gargain]

1. World of warcraft



2. DA



3. Diablo 2



4. Kotor



5. Neverwinter Nights 2

[Brako Shepard]

Its a very good game, but over-shadowed in terms of thinsg you can do. The likes of Fallout 3 and Elder Scrolls, will always be the kings of RPG's.



Dragon Age just doesn't have enough in it to make it last long, but it is still a good game.

[Krudolin]

1) TES III: Morrowind
2) Fallout 3
3) Dungeon Siege
4) Dragon Age: Origins
5) Diablo II

Edit: If MMO's count WoW get's Fallout's place and everything moves down one place, leaving Diablo II out.

Modifié par Krudolin, 09 décembre 2009 - 06:25 .

[Dranearian]

wow yall fail. No earthbound, no Chrono triggers, No FF3/6? Yeah this list is bogus.

Seriously people... MAss Effect, Fallout 3 over games like CT FF3/6, earthbound or any of the old greats? Are you kidding me?

Modifié par Dranearian, 09 décembre 2009 - 06:24 .

[ChickenDownUnder]

1. Planescape Torment
2. Baldur's Gate II
3. Suikoden II
4. Might & Magic
5. Chrono Trigger

I suddenly feel old.

Modifié par ChickenDownUnder, 09 décembre 2009 - 06:31 .

[Brako Shepard]

Dranearian wrote...

wow yall fail. No earthbound, no Chrono triggers, No FF3/6? Yeah this list is bogus.

Seriously people... MAss Effect, Fallout 3 over games like CT FF3/6, earthbound or any of the old greats? Are you kidding me?

No one fails, and no one is kidding you. Its about personal choice.

What could be a great game for you, could be a steaming pile of gaming crap for someone else.

[Sam -stone- serious]

My only gripe is with WoW. I cant even see how this game is an RPG other than the "customazation" of your toon with epics and then more epics and then more epics and then some titles and then some more titles....i just dont get it.



Either i am old or there is indeed something seriously wrong with WoW.

[Dranearian]

Brako Shepard wrote...


No one fails, and no one is kidding you. Its about personal choice.

What could be a great game for you, could be a steaming pile of gaming crap for someone else.

No I am sorry to say, anyone who claims those games as "best rpgs ever" ARE kidding themselves.   Are they decent RECENT games? Sure, which leads to the only conclusion that these people have never played, or are too young to appreciate games that don't have l337 graphics.

[Staylost]

Dranearian wrote...

Brako Shepard wrote...


No one fails, and no one is kidding you. Its about personal choice.

What could be a great game for you, could be a steaming pile of gaming crap for someone else.

No I am sorry to say, anyone who claims those games as "best rpgs ever" ARE kidding themselves.   Are they decent RECENT games? Sure, which leads to the only conclusion that these people have never played, or are too young to appreciate games that don't have l337 graphics.

Please stop ruining this thread with your opinion.