104 réponses à ce sujet

[From Tuchanka with Love]

Their game, their story. Their rules. Make your own game with a happy ending if you'd like.

[JBONE27]

From Tuchanka with Love wrote...

You realize you just proved the Catalyst's point, right? Besides, the Catalyst is right because Bioware says.

Deal with it.

So, what you're saying is that if the Catalyst said, "Tomorrow go out and rape 5000 children; then sacrifice them onto me," it would be justifide.

[From Tuchanka with Love]

No. Not to me. But, my morality is subjective. 

You're speaking in hypotheticals, building strawmen is a very weak debate method.

Modifié par From Tuchanka with Love, 18 mai 2012 - 02:20 .

[JBONE27]

From Tuchanka with Love wrote...

No. Not to me. But, my morality is subjective.

Then what the Catylist says isn't nessisarily justifide... It could be, as IT believers contend, Harbinger trying to convice the player using faulty logic.  It could also be that space brat is suffering from dementia (If you belive that he created the Reaper then he must be over 50,000 years old... probably millions of years old), and, as someone who has lived with someone sufferng from that disease, you shouldn't take anything he says seriously.

[From Tuchanka with Love]

Catalyst objectively has the ONLY solutions.

[JBONE27]

From Tuchanka with Love wrote...

Catalyst objectively has the ONLY solutions.

Except for the fact that he doesn't.

A real solution would be to use reaper tech to take away the ability to create synthetics.  It has been shown that reapers can control people's thoughts, why not have a subtle block to keep them from creating synthetics?  It's simple, eligant, and does not result in mass genocide.

[Sundance31us]

Shepard: Told you to take my hand, but no...now look where we are.

or

Shepard: That's great kid, now where are your parents?

or

Shepard: (Heading toward the red light) This WILL hurt you.

or

Shepard: Damn if I'd have know there would be a kid here I'd have brought the dog as a distraction. (think DAO PUPPIES!)

[Volus Warlord]

What would I have done?

*points pistol at head of godchild* "Who the **** are you?"

[LegionMan]

"I've had enough of your disingenuous insinuations"
*Points at red*
"I should go"

[Landon7001]

my shep to catalyst: so you said I then we, is it just you or are you from a race? if so, either way, what exactly are you? how can the citadel be your home and also be a part of you? please clarify. how does me disentigrating myself control reapers exactly? you know i just made peace between the geth and quarians right? edi and joker right? elaborate on synthesis. wy i gotta blow a pipe up to kill reapers and synthetics? hows that even work? you know any thing about dark energy/matter?.......you created synthetics to kill us every 50000 yrs before our own synthetics can kill us....huh?.....how exactly do ppl get turned/stored as reapers, liquid much elaboration required.....by the way i want to get out of her alive, my heart is aching/longing for my love Ashley,and I will be going home to her just to let ya know......no, you know what i dont buy any of this at any level, your a genocidal monster regardless of your reasons, many monsters through history think theyre doing the right thing.....so **** uou TIME TO DIE!!!

[flippedeclipse]

Xx_Belzak_xX wrote...

 Just for fun, let's assume there is no dialogue wheel. No dialogue wheel, no Bioware, no Artistic Integrity, none of it. Let's also assume that each one of us is our Shepard. How would you respond to the Catalyst and his...erm...ahem "logic"?

"You serious mah boy?"

If he says yes...

Modifié par flippedeclipse, 18 mai 2012 - 02:56 .

[Bluko]

I would respond to non-sense BS with my own non-sense BS. Probably like this...

(Warning Foul Language Kids!)

Modifié par Bluko, 18 mai 2012 - 02:53 .

[Icinix]

The same way I responded when player control was returned, shoot him in the head.

If that didn't work, order Hackett to disengage the Crucible and ram it into the Cidatel because starchild is controlling the Reapers, if we destroy him, Reapers may be disorganised enough to do some very serious damage before they (if) the reorganise themselves.

[JackRipper10]

I would beat his face in with a giant magnet.

[Landon7001]

OH MY GOD that if bioware wrote star wars page was absolutely hilarious and really claerly illustartes the idiocy of me 3 ending.....good job

[Thrillian]

*Checks pockets*

"Nope, no more f***s to give, sorry!"

[KingJason13]

I'd sick him with the Miniature Giant Space Hamster...

[Psycho0124]

This

[AlanC9]

JBONE27 wrote...
 It could also be that space brat is suffering from dementia (If you belive that he created the Reaper then he must be over 50,000 years old... probably millions of years old), and, as someone who has lived with someone sufferng from that disease, you shouldn't take anything he says seriously.

I didn't take him all that seriously. He always struck me as a damaged AI. He's obviously deluded since he thinks he controls the Reapers but he can't actually get them to do anything without the Crucible.

So how I'd respond to him is pretty much the way Shep does in game. Arguing with this thing would be as useless as arguing with Sovereign or the Noveria VI.

(That's probably why I didn't have a big problem with the ending)

Modifié par AlanC9, 18 mai 2012 - 05:13 .

[Gaurthurt]

i would call for pickup and then order them to shot into beam to relese red enrgy

[Isaidlunch]

By throwing a hanar into the Synthesis beam

[Milkovich]

Elegant and to the point.