129 réponses à ce sujet

[DGMockingJay]

Seriously, even with the little flaws the game has and most of all, the bad ending.. The game is simply marvelous... But right uptil the end....

Modifié par DGMockingJay, 21 mai 2012 - 04:34 .

[Micah3sixty]

Agreed. ~30 epic story, followed by 10 minutes of burning bridges.

[Unholyknight800]

All I have to say is it's a good game. Certainly not great though.

[Leafs43]

Diablo 3's story is a joke. It's so bad, so predictable and so corny.

[legion999]

Metacritic is a joke. Does it really matter what the scores on it say?

[Adamantium93]

Diablo 3 has a very poor DRM system and the majority of complaints arise from that.

[RavenEyry]

At least we were able to play our single-player game on release day.

[Prosarian]

RavenEyry wrote...

At least we were able to play our single-player game on release day.

+1000

[Seival]

No matter the scores, Diablo III (and most other Blizzard games) are epic fail... Not in terms of money making of course, but in terms of artistic value. Blizzard makes trashy and completely outdated games, no matter how long does it take... It's just a fact...

...But ME3, and the entire ME Trilogy... Despite all disadvantages ME Trilogy has the highest artistic value among ALL games in game development history.

So please, do not compare ME3 to Diablo3 please...

Modifié par Seival, 21 mai 2012 - 04:57 .

[GreyLycanTrope]

RavenEyry wrote...

At least we were able to play our single-player game on release day.

True, but at least Diablo 3 had an actually coherent ending.
That being said I still prefer Mass Effect to Diablo, did find diablo fun though.

Modifié par Greylycantrope, 21 mai 2012 - 04:51 .

[Zardoc]

Diablo received bad scores for other reasons than the story. And Mass Effect 3 is an okay game, not marvelous. Untill the end, that is.

Seival wrote...

No matter the scores, Diablo III (and most other Blizzard games) are epic fail... Not in terms of money making of course, but in terms of artistic value. Blizzard makes trashy and completely outdated games, no matter how long does it take... It's just a fact...

...But ME3, and the entire ME Trilogy... Despite all disadvandages ME Trilogy has the highest actistic value among ALL games in game development history.

So please, do not compare ME3 to Diablo3 please...

 


People don't buy games because they're artsy fartsy, they buy them because they are fun to play and have a good story (though admittedly, nowadays most games don't). So screw your art.

Modifié par Zardoc, 21 mai 2012 - 04:53 .

[Hudathan]

It's metacritic.

[NM_Che56]

I played Diablo 1 years ago. It was fun but got old after a little while. I never finished it because it felt like a modern version of Gauntlet.

[Chief Commander]

Ehm talking bout Diablo in a ME3 forum?

[wicked_being]

Well to be fair...if you can't connect to the servers, you're screwed. And we all know how D3's servers are...

[mango smoothie]

It doesn't deserve the user score it has on Metacritic, but Mass Effect 3 is definitely the worse of the trilogy for me and not just because of the endings. It's still a good game, but in my opinion Mass Effect 1 and 2 were better.

[jsadalia]

Metacritic is silly.

[Lonsecia]

Seival wrote...

No matter the scores, Diablo III (and most other Blizzard games) are epic fail... Not in terms of money making of course, but in terms of artistic value. Blizzard makes trashy and completely outdated games, no matter how long does it take... It's just a fact...

...But ME3, and the entire ME Trilogy... Despite all disadvandages ME Trilogy has the highest actistic value among ALL games in game development history.

So please, do not compare ME3 to Diablo3 please...

I'd say Quantic Dream games have higher artistic value than the ME series, albiet not in a way that particularly forwards games as an art form in their own right.
Likewise I'd say Rockstar are close, too. Perhaps not to the level of other studios, though primarily because their focus is on violent settings, and not really as much characterisation as I'd like. I still love Red Dead Redemption and L.A. Noire though, despite their flaws.
I'd also argue that there are some nuggets of interesting story in Blizzard games, but the lack of decent writing stymies any progress towards validation as art. 

On saying this, however, one must consider www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/art/news/blank-canvas-london-gallery-unveils-invisible-art-exhibition-7767057.html . If that can be called art, then pretty much anything can, especially those people have been championing for so long.

Modifié par Lonsecia, 21 mai 2012 - 09:20 .

[Seival]

Zardoc wrote...

Diablo received bad scores for other reasons than the story. And Mass Effect 3 is an okay game, not marvelous. Untill the end, that is.

Seival wrote...

No matter the scores, Diablo III (and most other Blizzard games) are epic fail... Not in terms of money making of course, but in terms of artistic value. Blizzard makes trashy and completely outdated games, no matter how long does it take... It's just a fact...

...But ME3, and the entire ME Trilogy... Despite all disadvantages ME Trilogy has the highest artistic value among ALL games in game development history.

So please, do not compare ME3 to Diablo3 please... 

 


People don't buy games because they're artsy fartsy, they buy them because they are fun to play and have a good story (though admittedly, nowadays most games don't). So screw your art.

Artistic value is not just art value. It's value of all game's aspects, including the story.

[Vaneke]

i play games because i like them.
not one purchase of mine was ever influenced by a pre -,review or some score on a website or magazine.
i never visited metacritic, but i did now out of curiosity, and really, a difference by 1% ...
if going by score, for me anyway, ME3 got rated way to high.

[crimzontearz]

uh...yeah but the reason the score is lower is not the same as Mass Effect's

[paralitos]

well truly diablo got a bad rating because you have to be online to play single player and there was a lot of problems with the servers in the first two days of launch and there still are... just like mass effect's case in metacritic people tend to rush to put a 0 rating when they are angry about something forgeting all the other aspects of the game ..imo metacrtitic's user reviews are a joke

ps. diablo was never about the story. loot, loot, loot