Aller au contenu

Photo

Fanfic Writers’ Support Group


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
9962 réponses à ce sujet

#3126
xIxDarkWolfxIx

xIxDarkWolfxIx
  • Members
  • 526 messages

hot_heart wrote...

Yeah, it doesn't hamper reading it or anything. I was just offering advice on simple stuff while I could spare a moment. Not meant as disparagement or anything.


I know. Thank you, for your assistance. 
I enjoyed your story involving Miranda and Jack, Firm Friends. The banter was good, funny with a hint of bickering but not overly so. 

#3127
hot_heart

hot_heart
  • Members
  • 2 682 messages

xIxDarkWolfxIx wrote...
I enjoyed your story involving Miranda and Jack, Firm Friends. The banter was good, funny with a hint of bickering but not overly so.

Oh, thank you. :D
I'd be interested to hear what you think about the Miranda story. Though that has quite a hefty word count now. It moves at a fair pace if that helps...

#3128
JadeDragonMTR

JadeDragonMTR
  • Members
  • 110 messages

hot_heart wrote...

xIxDarkWolfxIx wrote...

I just finished my first chapter and it has been posted on Fan-Fiction.net.
Here is the link if you wish to check it out, any feedback will be greatly appreciated.

http://www.fanfictio..._Effect_Refusal

Thanks to lillitheris for your feedback. =)

Always nice to see more Miranda fans. ^_^

As it's a short chapter, when I have more time later, I shall give it a lookover later and offer some proper constructive feedback rather than just pointing out little errors or suggestions. At a quick glance, I can see a few places I would use commas, for clarity's sake. Also, I think you have a typo of 'continues' when you meant 'continued' (I'm assuming a mid-sentence change of tense was not intentional).

In general terms, I'm always a little uneasy with even Shepard referring to Miranda as Miri. I think only Niket ever used that nickname, and she might resent hearing it any more (I believe even Oriana uses 'Randa'). Also, in the games, Shepard tends to refer to her as Miranda or, when playful, Ms. Lawson.


I always play FemShep, so Miranda isn't available as LI in canon, and my fshep always feels respect but distant from Miranda, until in one ME3 playthrough I saw Miranda die (didn't have the 3rd convo), and I was so sad, and had to replay the part to have a 3rd convo so the game  has to take her death back! LOL.

I will read your stories to see what your Miranda is like! Thanks!

Modifié par JadeDragonMTR, 19 juillet 2012 - 09:58 .


#3129
xIxDarkWolfxIx

xIxDarkWolfxIx
  • Members
  • 526 messages

hot_heart wrote...

xIxDarkWolfxIx wrote...
I enjoyed your story involving Miranda and Jack, Firm Friends. The banter was good, funny with a hint of bickering but not overly so.

Oh, thank you. :D
I'd be interested to hear what you think about the Miranda story. Though that has quite a hefty word count now. It moves at a fair pace if that helps...


I've just started it. I should finished it by tomorrow afternoon. :)

#3130
hot_heart

hot_heart
  • Members
  • 2 682 messages

xIxDarkWolfxIx wrote...
I've just started it. I should finished it by tomorrow afternoon. :)

Oh, wow. Much appreciated. Cheers!

#3131
Seracen

Seracen
  • Members
  • 1 178 messages

fainmaca wrote...

I also just noticed the discussion on Batarian women above. In my most recent chapter, I had to write about one. I tried to keep the description vague enough that readers could develop their own ideas of what she looked like, but also gave enough details to give a general gist of her appearance.

This is what I went with:

A slight figure stepped through the door, walking slowly with the short, wide-barrelled pistol still held in a firm grasp. Shepard's eyes widened as he realised that he was looking at a Batarian woman. She wasn't the first Batarian female he had seen, but he'd never seen one performing any kind of military action. It seemed as though the Hegemony considered women beneath such occupations, something that didn't sit well with the rest of the galactic community.

This particular specimen stood at about five and a half feet, her body shapely and toned. Four glimmering red eyes stared at the Commander and his allies with barely concealed menace. Her Batarian features were somewhat softer than those of the males, host to their own strange kind of beauty, and her skin was a vibrant yellow, tinged with brown, complemented by the sheer black combat armour she wore, red highlights running along its seams. As she stepped forward, Etarn gasped.



Thanks again!  Oh man, I am trying so hard not to make my Batarian chapters similar to yours.  Your story is too darn good!!!

When you get to the Hegemony, I forced myself to stop reading, just so I could develop my own ideas on how I wanted the story to flow.

#3132
Seracen

Seracen
  • Members
  • 1 178 messages

fainmaca wrote...

Hey guys.
I was away from my keyboard over the weekend, so I've kind of fallen behind on both this board and my writing. Will try to catch up, if RL will give me a break any time soon.
In the meantime, if any of you have the spare time I could do with somebody having a read of chapter 46 of my fic and then participating in the poll at the end of the chapter. Kind of at a stalemate right now, and I could do with somebody breaking the tie.
If you have a chance, the chapter is here, and the poll can be found here.

P.S. Any reviews that can be left would be greatly appreciated. Really hurting for some critiques of my work.

Fainmaca out.


Again, loving your work, but I am skimming over the recent chapters, lest it affect my work overmuch.  At any rate, well crafted dilemma!  I suppose I'd go with whichever saves the most lives, overall, at that moment.  I mean, having a fleet is great, but pointless if the standing population is decimated.

Conversely, saving the people is great, but pointless if the majority of citizens were in the fleet.  So yeah, I'll pull a Kiritsugu Shirou (from Fate Zero) and say whichever saves the most lives, at that moment.

#3133
nitefyre410

nitefyre410
  • Members
  • 8 944 messages

Seracen wrote...

fainmaca wrote...

Hey guys.
I was away from my keyboard over the weekend, so I've kind of fallen behind on both this board and my writing. Will try to catch up, if RL will give me a break any time soon.
In the meantime, if any of you have the spare time I could do with somebody having a read of chapter 46 of my fic and then participating in the poll at the end of the chapter. Kind of at a stalemate right now, and I could do with somebody breaking the tie.
If you have a chance, the chapter is here, and the poll can be found here.

P.S. Any reviews that can be left would be greatly appreciated. Really hurting for some critiques of my work.

Fainmaca out.


Again, loving your work, but I am skimming over the recent chapters, lest it affect my work overmuch.  At any rate, well crafted dilemma!  I suppose I'd go with whichever saves the most lives, overall, at that moment.  I mean, having a fleet is great, but pointless if the standing population is decimated.

Conversely, saving the people is great, but pointless if the majority of citizens were in the fleet.  So yeah, I'll pull a Kiritsugu Shirou (from Fate Zero) and say whichever saves the most lives, at that moment.

 
Off-Topic: 
"With this Command Spell I command you  destory the  Holy Grail." 

Saber::o :blink:   :crying:

That series was great though the only mino, tiny, little, nitpicky knock I have is how they handled the Saber/Beserker fight... must get my hands on the novel. 

Modifié par nitefyre410, 19 juillet 2012 - 10:48 .


#3134
Seracen

Seracen
  • Members
  • 1 178 messages

fluffywalrus wrote...

I made oatmeal raisin cookies today, but they didn't turn out like I hoped. I think my mom is a wizard or something because she does the same things I do to make them and uses the same equipment basically, and hers are just magical and mine are...underwhelming. :?

But yay 3000! :wizard:
As for community options on ffnet, I don't think I'd ever use them. Didn't really notice them until recently.

And I think Batarian women would probably be better off without hair on their heads, imo.


You should totally add cinnamon to the cookies, & butter/shortening if they need moistening.

Also, yay for 3000!!!  Cookies for eveyone???  Maybe multicolored cupcakes, haha!

#3135
Seracen

Seracen
  • Members
  • 1 178 messages

gearseffect wrote...

Hey everyone I'm back and I've been on a creative roll, I am planing to dumb lots of new Fanfic Content in a short period of time. However I will stagger it out so as I don't flood my readers at once.

Anyway that's not the issue I am hung up on, the issue I am hung up on is Ashley Williams. Now Jake Shep didn't romance her EVER. But Ashley is a very important character and friend.
...

Okay back on task
Thanks for any advice or words of encouragement on writing Ashley as not looking like ME3 Ashley, and writing her as classic looking tanned skin, brunette, bad@ss, @sskicking action chick Ashley, you know the classic ME look.


In my headcanon, the only reason Ash looks like she does is because she's having to pander to politicians.  She was smart enough, or forced through circumstance, to use her natural beauty to get past the otherwise bigoted idiot officials, hence the look.  Also, first impressions as a Human Spectre and all that as to why she kept the look.

So, once she's through the crap, and is just doing her job, why not revert to ME2 Ash, or whatever?

Shep: "back to the old look?"
Ash: "yeah, not dealing with a-hole politicians anymore"
Shep: "I like you better this way"

#3136
Seracen

Seracen
  • Members
  • 1 178 messages

dpMeggers wrote...

fluffywalrus wrote...

I think a quick note in the author's notes would work to inform readers of your decision. I don't think reverting her appearance will rub anyone the wrong way.


Out of laziness, I'm quoting flufffy (sorry). Basically this. If you think Ash should look more like ME1/ME2 Ash, go for it.

I've run into a problem of my own working on Conversation. Spoilers follow, so if you havn't been following and want to, look away now.

...

Usually I know what I want to do, it's just a matter of getting it on paper. This is...something new entirely. And it's incredibly unpleasant. I don't know what to do. Thoughts? (Not so much on how she'll react - not asking anyone to write her for me. Just on how to get past this.)


* End Spoilers*

Spoiler free version: worst case of writer's block/ character non-cooperation I've ever experienced and ARGH.


Had this problem with a few of my OC's in my ME4 fic (not posted yet, currently WIP).  I ended up doing worksheets for each of the characters, referring to the notes whenever I hit a wall.

Not only did this help me hone my characters, it helped me work past plot situtations I had previously been unable to resolve.

#3137
Seracen

Seracen
  • Members
  • 1 178 messages

Lilivati wrote...

I guess I'm looking for some help and I'm not quite sure where to go.

My fanfic: Mass Effect: Beginnings

It starts shortly before ME1 and then chronicles those events from the perspective of my Shepard. I basically wanted to go deeper with the story, and I am having fun writing it, but I'm not sure what I'm doing wrong. Going too deep into it? Too much dialog? Following the story too closely? I don't know.

Any insight anyone could offer would be appreciated. I'm sort of new to the whole fanfic thing.


I love your characterizations, the dioalogue flows naturally.

My only suggestion would be to break up some of the earlier conversation a bit, separate the action from the words, as the diologue seemed to be a long run on sentence (in my head anyway).

Still, good stuff!

#3138
Seracen

Seracen
  • Members
  • 1 178 messages

Icyflare wrote...

JadeDragonMTR wrote...

Do you know if there is forum here or anywhere where fanfic writer can get advices on their stories, chat about technic/factual stuff, etc.?  There are a lot of stories with shepard having tortured past, but I want to write a shepard who has happy upbringing and an optimistic views, at least to start with. It would be nice to chat with people about ideas. 


*Coughs politely. Looks at thread's name*

Edit: That was weird. Board was down for a while. Anyways, fluffy and Drussius got to it first. Feel free anytime to ask questions and we'll answer to the best of our ability.

On another note, picked up a copy of William Faulkner's The Sound and the Fury. Am considering using extensive confusing stream-of-consciousness techniques. Feel this is highly unadvised.


Are you kidding?  After the "art and drama" in those endings, not to mention ANY of Phillip Dick's or William Gibson's novels, go nuts, try it out.  You'll learn something, even if it's just what to avoid.  And who knows, maybe you'll enjoy it and create a new style for yourself!

#3139
Seracen

Seracen
  • Members
  • 1 178 messages

hot_heart wrote...

Seracen wrote...
The stigma of having hair when Batarians hate humans is not something I'd considered, but I'd not really fleshed out the idea of prosthetic hair, as it still seems wierd to me.

Maybe batarian females do have hair but then humans appeared, settling in their systems as well as showing off their superior lustrous and genetically-diverse hairstyles, so bitterness and jealousy took over.

As a result, batarian females locked themselves away and took to writing ****y gossip columns about human fashion.


Haha, it's even more amusing that you say that with Miranda for an avatar!  I can totally picture a pissed off Miri saying that.

#3140
Obsidian Gryphon

Obsidian Gryphon
  • Members
  • 2 412 messages
All this thread are belong to ... Seracen. Posted Image Posted Image 

#3141
hot_heart

hot_heart
  • Members
  • 2 682 messages

Seracen wrote...
Haha, it's even more amusing that you say that with Miranda for an avatar!  I can totally picture a pissed off Miri saying that.

Now I'm remembering the few days after I arrived on the forums, when people were under the impression I was female. :blink:

I guess my secret to writing Miranda is that I sound a lot like her. Problematic...

#3142
Seracen

Seracen
  • Members
  • 1 178 messages

hot_heart wrote...

xIxDarkWolfxIx wrote...

I just finished my first chapter and it has been posted on Fan-Fiction.net.
Here is the link if you wish to check it out, any feedback will be greatly appreciated.

http://www.fanfictio..._Effect_Refusal

Thanks to lillitheris for your feedback. =)

Always nice to see more Miranda fans. ^_^

As it's a short chapter, when I have more time later, I shall give it a lookover later and offer some proper constructive feedback rather than just pointing out little errors or suggestions. At a quick glance, I can see a few places I would use commas, for clarity's sake. Also, I think you have a typo of 'continues' when you meant 'continued' (I'm assuming a mid-sentence change of tense was not intentional).

In general terms, I'm always a little uneasy with even Shepard referring to Miranda as Miri. I think only Niket ever used that nickname, and she might resent hearing it any more (I believe even Oriana uses 'Randa'). Also, in the games, Shepard tends to refer to her as Miranda or, when playful, Ms. Lawson.


You know, I really think Miranda got the best deal out of the ME2 romances, all things considered.  This, however, leads me to a dilemma.

In a universe where Shep romanced someone else, who else is worthy of Miranda?

It sure as heck isn't Jacob!

For that matter, I think the only decent non-Shep pairing is Garrus/Tali.  Of course, there's the whole Joker/Edi thing.

I can't think of anyone else for...anyone else.

Although, in my current fic, I am proud of my intended pairing of....

(drum roll)

Falere and Kolyat...

Yeah, I ran that my my surrogate sis, who flipped out considering that one.

"But...how does it work?"

"Oh that's easy, I'm having it so that when a Drell enters sollipsism, he doesn't get his brain fried."

"That...actually sounds plausible...Samara's gonna be PISSED!!!"

"Yeah...Garrus is going to have to lock her up in the brig until she calms down...haha!"

#3143
Seracen

Seracen
  • Members
  • 1 178 messages

hot_heart wrote...

Seracen wrote...
Haha, it's even more amusing that you say that with Miranda for an avatar!  I can totally picture a pissed off Miri saying that.

Now I'm remembering the few days after I arrived on the forums, when people were under the impression I was female. :blink:

I guess my secret to writing Miranda is that I sound a lot like her. Problematic...


Oh pish, you're just like minded and have strong opinions.  All this means is that you'd be perfect material for hitting on her and not failing like that one dude from LotSB! :P

#3144
hot_heart

hot_heart
  • Members
  • 2 682 messages

Seracen wrote...
Oh pish, you're just like minded and have strong opinions.  All this means is that you'd be perfect material for hitting on her and not failing like that one dude from LotSB! :P

Ha. I appreciate it, but I doubt my medical record would be up to scratch...

Miranda is too damn fussy for anyone but Shepard. [smilie]http://social.bioware.com/images/forum/emoticons/lol.png[/smilie]

#3145
Seracen

Seracen
  • Members
  • 1 178 messages

nitefyre410 wrote...
Off-Topic: 
"With this Command Spell I command you  destory the  Holy Grail." 

Saber::o :blink:   :crying:

That series was great though the only mino, tiny, little, nitpicky knock I have is how they handled the Saber/Beserker fight... must get my hands on the novel. 



I think what makes the show so compelling is the story.  I kind of enjoy how Saber is made to see her flaws by Kiritsugu's strong personality, how his conviction shows her another path in life.

Also, check out Mirror Moon (google search).  Not only did they translate the FS/N game (visual novel), they also translated the novel for Fate Zero.

Fate Hollow TL wiki for most of that game translated.  PM me if you need anything else, as I don't want to derail the thread. :P


Obsidian Gryphon wrote...

All this thread are belong to ... Seracen. Posted Image Posted Image 


Haha, sorry, I'm doing my catch up and reply in phases. :whistle:

PS: Seriously, nobody else is WORTHY of pairing up with ANY of the LI's except Shep.  In some characters' cases, this is really depressing for them.

Thane would die alone, and Jack?  Crap, the Jack "rejection" scene from ME2 is so bad, I swear she's going downstairs to commit suicide...:crying:

Modifié par Seracen, 19 juillet 2012 - 11:44 .


#3146
hot_heart

hot_heart
  • Members
  • 2 682 messages
Damn you, Seracen. Had a glimpse at chapter 24 of your fic and it looks really well-written, and now I have to catch up on that story as well. Some day...

#3147
Seracen

Seracen
  • Members
  • 1 178 messages

hot_heart wrote...

Damn you, Seracen. Had a glimpse at chapter 24 of your fic and it looks really well-written, and now I have to catch up on that story as well. Some day...


HAHA, well, thank you!  I AM pandering to every LI audience in my epilogues (barring the Yeomen and Cortez, as I felt those romances to be lacking).

Hope you enjoy it, and to be fair, you're only having to read about 10 of those chapters, as it's a branching fic depending on choices in the game.

EDIT: also, I am about to post a requested ending that I'd originally scrapped, involving Shep, Jack, and Liara.  No telling how the breakdown on THAT one is going to work.

It's interesting to note, however, the traffic I've seen per chapter.  My highest reader ratio, for the LI endings, goes...

EDIT (checked new figures): Miranda, Liara, Tali, Jack, Ashley

I suppose her Shep hatred in ME2 and 3 counted against Ash...

Also, I padded Miranda's numbers by putting author's notes in with it, for folks who care about such things.

Go figure though, Miranda's chapter was the hardest for me to write, by far.  It was the absolute LAST thing I wrote, barring this new chapter I'm finalizing.

Modifié par Seracen, 20 juillet 2012 - 12:31 .


#3148
Lilivati

Lilivati
  • Members
  • 108 messages
 

Sweawm wrote...

Lilivati wrote...
I guess I'm looking for some help and I'm not quite sure where to go.
My fanfic: Mass Effect: Beginnings
It starts shortly before ME1 and then chronicles those events from the perspective of my Shepard. I basically wanted to go deeper with the story, and I am having fun writing it, but I'm not sure what I'm doing wrong. Going too deep into it? Too much dialog? Following the story too closely? I don't know.
Any insight anyone could offer would be appreciated. I'm sort of new to the whole fanfic thing.

I'm not usually into the Sheperd fics at all, but this is fantastic. Dialog is great, the story is fine. I found no bits I skipped over because of lack of interest. I believe this may beyond my skill to critque. If you continue with quality such as this, you'll do fine. 

Thank you!  I'm really happy you enjoyed it.  I guess it just feels like there's something missing to me and I can't quite put my finger on it.  It's starting to drive me a little nuts.

Drussius wrote...Welcome! I will certainly add your fanfic to the list of fics I plan to check out. However, even though I post in this thread frequently, I'm still a relative newcomer. I have a long list of fics to read from the many wonderful writers here. I will get there eventually, but I can't add much insight right now. Just wanted to say what I see has already been said. As long as you're enjoying writing the story, that's the most important part.

I appreciate it.  There's a lot of good fics out there and there's only so much time available.  I will keep your advice in mind. :)

fluffywalrus wrote...
 A new Pre-ME Shep fic? WHOOOO(If you cannot tell, I am a huge fan of these kinds of stories, I love learning abot other Shepards).I'll give it a read :) I'm fluffywalrus here, but on FFnet, I'm thedeadflag (someone took my precious username...)I'll try to give some opinions on the questions you asked in a review.
But so long as you're having fun writing it, you're good. Everything else, all the technical and structural stuff...that can be worked on later if necessary. The important part is that you enjoy the process.

There's some pre-ME stuff at the start, and then some more mixed in. I'd appreciate any criticism you can offer.  The biggest things worrying me at the moment are that the story is too tired, or the dialogue is too rampant.  

Seracen wrote...I love your characterizations, the dioalogue flows naturally.
My only suggestion would be to break up some of the earlier conversation a bit, separate the action from the words, as the diologue seemed to be a long run on sentence (in my head anyway).
Still, good stuff!

Thank you!  I'm kind of a dialogue fiend, I know I lean on it way too heavily to try to tell a story.  Probably comes of too many forum-based D&D games. :P  I'm trying to rein it in a bit as I go.


Thanks everyone who took the time to reply!  I really appreciate it.  I hope I didn't miss anyone.  My work blocks BSN (and FFN, as it happens) so I can't do any quick checks/replies.  

Modifié par Lilivati, 20 juillet 2012 - 12:31 .


#3149
Spiritwolf1

Spiritwolf1
  • Members
  • 669 messages
Jeez go away for a day and end up with hours of catching up

#3150
Drussius

Drussius
  • Members
  • 1 061 messages

Spiritwolf1 wrote...

Jeez go away for a day and end up with hours of catching up


Tell me about it. Go out to dinner and a movie with the family, spend an hour trying to finish Chapter Six, check the board and there's a page and a half of new posts!

Mostly by Seracen Posted Image

Seriously though, It's nice that this thread gets so much love. I don't think I've ever seen it dip past the halfway point of the first page before someone says something about something to someone...

Did that make any sense? Posted Image