168 réponses à ce sujet

[The Spamming Troll]

1. ME1

the rest.....meh.

[kitteh-1]

ME1 and ME2 are basically the same for me. The pros and cons add up to make them essentially neutral, so to give a better answer I'd have to rank them by certain categories (i.e. gameplay, story, characters)
I didn't enjoy ME3 as much as those. I enjoyed it, don't get me wrong, but there were a lot of things that could've been better. Not sure who to blame, but let's just say Bioware has been hanging out with the wrong crowd (EA).

EDIT: KotOR is my favorite overall. 

Modifié par kitteh-1, 28 mai 2012 - 02:58 .

[ev76]

1- star wars knights of the old republic ( not to be confused with the new mmo)
2- mass effect
3- dragon age
4- mass effect 2
5- mass effect 3 (if they can implement war assets better to the priority earth then it would be tied for third.

Honorable mention dragon age 2. Never played baldur gate, neverwinter nights or jade empire.

[CSly]

Dead last.

[-Skorpious-]

1. Mass Effect
2. Dragon Age Origins
3. KotOR
4. Mass Effect 2
5. Mass Effect 3
6. Dragon Age II

Note - just because ME3 ranks higher than DA2 doesn't necessarily mean that I was more disappointed with DA2 than I was with ME3, quite the opposite. ME3 is the fundamentally better game (imo), but both suffer from serious design flaws such as lack of character control compared to previous games, player choices made irrelevant, major emphasis on improving gameplay at the expense of a quality narrative, rushed final acts, bizarre endings, ect..

[Il Divo]

jreezy wrote...

wastelander75 wrote...

6. Jade Empire
7. ME3
8. DA2

Thank you for sharing.

 I...I don't understand how that's possible.

It's not as strange as you might think. Especially at release, Jade Empire was really considered the black sheep of the Bioware RPGs. It had that same narrative/dialogue focus, but the action-RPG gameplay was so odd compared to their other stuff. But then, so was MDK2/Shattered Steel.

[HallucinationEnd]

 Okee.. 

LOVED: <3

1.  Dragon Age : Origins ( played 10-13 times )

2.  Mass effect 1 (played 6 times )

3.  Mass effect 2 ( playes 8 times )

4. Mass effect 3 ( played 3 times )

5.  Dragon Age 2 ( played 4 times )




HATED: 

Mass Efect 3 ENDING ( watched 2 times )

Dragon Age 2 Levle Design ( see it to often )

sry that must be now : 

Modifié par HallucinationEnd, 28 mai 2012 - 03:14 .

[Mr.House]

1:Baldurs Gate 2
2:Dragon Age: Origins
3:The Old Republic
4:Mass Effect
5:Knights of the Old Republic
6:Jade Empire
7:Mass Effect 3
8:Dragon Age 2
9:Shattered Steal
10:MDK 2
11: Baldurs Gate
12:Mass Effect 2
13:NWN
14:Sonic

Modifié par Mr.House, 28 mai 2012 - 03:15 .

[Nefla]

Hmm let's see:

1)DA:O
2)KoTOR
3)ME2
4)ME1
5)Jade Empire
6)ME3
7)DA2

I haven't played the older games.

[Bluko]

Hmm well this looks like a great way for me to yet again prove I'm a Baldur's Gate fanboy and have people insult me that I'm blinded by nostalgia. Anywho...

1) Baldur's Gate + Tales of the Sword Coast
2) Baldur's Gate II: Throne of Bhaal
3) Baldur's Gate II: Shadows of Amn
4) Mass Effect
5) Knights of the Old Republic
6) Mass Effect 2
7) Dragon Age: Origins
8) Mass Effect 3
9) Shattered Steel*
*Don't really remember much besides shooting flying insect aliens with missiles.



I will say the combat/environments are pretty good in ME3. Just be nice if Thermal Clips weren't involved and that Liara (and Javik?) could actually were a freaking helmet. Funny enough I've always been told how overheating weapons couldn't work... 

That said I really do not care for the simplification of the dialogue system. While it doesn't ruin the game it does noticeably diminish player choice  in"roleplaying" and makes replay value pretty minimal. It also doesn't help many of your decisions are canonized as well. I honestly don't see any point in even replaying ME1 or ME2 since it won't change much of anything. Also it got kind of obvious the writers were basically just killing off characters to make things convenient. If they were trying to be dramatic it was awfully ham-fisted. There's also a disturbing number of conversation glitches that just any wreck immersion as well. Then you got all the lame fetch quests that make up a good third of the game with Cmdr. Creeper. And finally there's the ending which basically just pulls the plug on the Mass Effect Universe. So yeah... very glad I passed on the Collectors Edition this time.

[FROST4584]

1. Mass Effect 1
2. KOTOR
3.Dragon Age 1
4.Mass Effect 3
5. Mass Effect 2

[HallucinationEnd]

Bluko wrote...




number of conversation glitches that just any wreck immersion as well. Then you got all the lame fetch quests that make up a good third of the game with Cmdr. Creeper. And finally there's the ending which basically just pulls the plug on the Mass Effect Universe. So yeah... very glad I passed on the Collectors Edition this time.

yea I wish I could say the same ... 

But hey , I  see it positively, I can beat down Casey with the collectors Edition ( steel frame ) if I see him . 

Modifié par HallucinationEnd, 28 mai 2012 - 03:55 .

[Scalabrine]

1.ME1
2.ME3
3.ME2

Im not a big fan of ME 2 for 2 big reasons:

-The lack of wrex hurts me- after being my super bro and going with him in almost every playthrough i was broken when i found out he wasn't a squadmember.

-They deviated from the enigmatic, mystic and alien feeling of the first one along with the rpg elements. Many people see it as the best one, i don't.

[Cyne]

Tied second with ME2. DAO holds first spot.

[What a Succulent Ass]

1) Shattered Steel LOL JK

1. Baldur's Gate II / Mass Effect 1
2. Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic / Dragon Age: Origins
3. Jade Empire / Baldur's Gate
4. Neverwinter Nights
5. Mass Effect 2





6. Mass Effect 3
7. Dragon Age II

[VinWizzy]

Only played the Mass Effect games so:
1. Mass Effect
2. Mass Effect 2
3. Mass Effect 3

2 and 3 are interchangeable though when it comes to it's pros/cons and flaws.

I don't have a gaming pc so which bioware games should I play besides KOTOR?

Modifié par VinWizzy, 28 mai 2012 - 04:56 .

[Terror_K]

1. Baldur's Gate II
2. Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic
3. Dragon Age: Origins
4. Neverwinter Nights
5. Baldur's Gate
6. Mass Effect
7. Jade Empire
8. Star Wars: The Old Republic
9. Sonic Chronicles
|
|
B
I
G

G
A
P
|
|
10. Mass Effect 2
11. MDK2
|
|
G
A
P
|
|
12. Mass Effect 3
|
|
L
A
R
G
E

G
A
P
|
|
13. Dragon Age 2

[Evo_9]

My all time favourite games...

1) ME1
2) ME3
3) ME2

[JBONE27]

1. ME2
2. ME
3. Jade Empire
4. KotOR
5. DA2
6. DA:0
7, TOR
8. ME3

I haven't played any of the other ones.

[ItsTheTruth]

1. KOTOR
1. DA:O (tie)
3. ME
4. Jade Empire
5. ME2
.
50. ME3
.
.
99. DA2

[zapphoman24]

Great...another "lets hate on the Mass Effect 3 ending thread. Let me join...

1. Mass Effect 2
2. Mass Effect 3
3. Star Wars KOTOR
4. Dragon Age Origins
5. Jade Empire
6. Dragon Age 2

Haven't played The Old Republic because I find making an installment of a great single player franchise into a MMO repulsive and I never played any of the Neverwinter games.

Any hate you have to throw at me for my list can be directed to that imaginary wall beside you.

[Lord Phoebus]

1. BG 2
2. BG
3. NWN
4. KotOR
5. DA:O
6: ME2
7. JE
8. ME3
9. ME
10. DA2