143 réponses à ce sujet

[Adragalus]

Kailord wrote...

I wonder what the CD timer % is with only the Regaar equipped on a vanguard...

About 110% with the first capacity upgrade, at level 1. With the shotgun weight reduction, and a higher-level gun, much less of an issue.

Also, charge -> melee -> melt -> charge.

[IanLai]

Kronner wrote...

Agreed with the
original post. This weapon is clearly broken. That said, I find it super
boring to use, so it does not bother me as I am not gonna use it
anyway.

though I respect your opinion and reasons. I disagree on this

The
Carbine may be OP for some. But playing with the Krogan Battlemaster on
Gold is very difficult for some (like me) since my play style is CQC. 
And this is mainly what the KV is for. Silver maps are much easier to
play as this character. But for Gold is hard unless you have a weapon
that can take enemies ie Reapers down quickly. I find this the best
weapons for: Reapers on Gold for KV

Plus i see the balance is in it's shortage of ammo supply. evne with the lvl 5 spare ammo - it goes quickly.
And
also, it's disadvantage that you have to be close to Enemies (Reapers)
to take them down. Brutes and Banshees easily can Instant Kill .Ceberus
Phantoms Instant Kill

IMO that's where the balance lies in. It's Very Powerful but also Very Risky

but that's just my thoughts on it now. I'm still learning the ropes on Gold, but this is what I see with it

u said what i think
totally agree,
banshee arm range is enough to instantly kill u, phantom still can approach u easily while u shooting her
so this wepaon is nothing OP.
in gold u alwayas want to stay a distance with whatever enemies and close range weapon make this become limited use , just like melee in gold

and i am not 100% sure but i don't think ammo pierce /shredder work with it as it should be a projectle weapon .

Modifié par IanLai, 30 mai 2012 - 12:00 .

[Influ]

I don't really know if the damage is where it should be, but I can see it being nerfed to uselessness from all the crying already. Considering the limited range, beyond which the gun does absolutely nothing, it really needs to be powerful close up. Again, I don't know if it should be quite as powerful, it does melt enemies ridiculously fast. But ammo is also a problem, both clip size to a lesser degree and spare ammo count.

I really hope this weapon doesn't get totally ruined. It's completely unique from all the other weapons and I'll embrace all the variety I can get in this game.

[BXpress2]

ehh seriously with Human Inf on Gold + Cryo Blast i take off the entire shields and the half of an Atlas' armor by unloading one clip.there is a line between great weapon and easy mode.and yes i played the pre nerf Falcon.doesnt even compare to it.this is probably the most OP thing ive ever seen in any game, PvP or Coop.my teammates didnt even have a chance to kill an Atlas or Phantom.i took everything.

[RxP4IN]

BXpress2 wrote...

ehh seriously with Human Inf on Gold + Cryo Blast i take off the entire shields and the half of an Atlas' armor by unloading one clip.there is a line between great weapon and easy mode.and yes i played the pre nerf Falcon.doesnt even compare to it.this is probably the most OP thing ive ever seen in any game, PvP or Coop.my teammates didnt even have a chance to kill an Atlas or Phantom.i took everything.

Yup, like I said in the OP, only 1.5 clips to kill an Atlas. And that's without rail amps, which I am unfortunately out of at the time. With the right consumables, I can see taking an Atlas down in one clip.

[Indenter]

It also doesn't actually deal loads of damage at once, it does it over time.

It's hard to use. You can't be too close, or you won't hit anything. The crosshair has to be on the target, or you don't hit anything either.

Half the time I spent simply waisting clips. Might be stupid on infiltrators. But then what isn't?

[ElectroNeonPanda]

1. Bioware gives us free DLC and new weapons to play with.
2. Players complain new toys are too good.
3. ...
4. Fail

[PreGy]

Steelgrave wrote...

So you guys complain about GOOD weapons too????

Is there anything you guys don't complain about?

I think BSN is not a "mind-hive", and every user has a opinion of his own. Should the OP not talk about something because a different user talked a different thing in a different post?


Logic = null

Modifié par PreGy, 30 mai 2012 - 12:15 .

[nevets187]

Moonphos87 wrote...

I find the ammo consumption a problem, but I love the Reegar Carbine itself.

What he said.

[Ogrinash]

Range sucks and the ammunition pool has no water in it.

Apart from that, it pretty much turns you into a Geth Pyro with all of your others points there.

[Petrikles]

Adragalus wrote...

Kailord wrote...

I wonder what the CD timer % is with only the Regaar equipped on a vanguard...

About 110% with the first capacity upgrade, at level 1. With the shotgun weight reduction, and a higher-level gun, much less of an issue.

Also, charge -> melee -> melt -> charge.

Thanks for that reply.

Though I doubt that 110% is fast enough... I usually get along with a CD of 180% on my Novaguard, but not lower. If that weapon is good enough to entirely replace Nova' s stagger with its electrical arc, then I am all game for that weapon. I could finally switch to a different race vanguard or even try Phoenixguard...

[Kronner]

aaronisbla wrote...

Gonna have to disagree with you. As others have pointed out, it has its flaws. It is powerful though.

Weren't you recently stating that the gun would be weaksauce since its the shotgun version of the arc pistol before we all had a chance to see how powerful it can be? lol, the irony

I said the gun was gonna be a quarian PoS, which it is imho. I also said it will be unshotgun, which it is. The fact that it is clearly broken makes it super boring to use, at least for me. So yea.

The ammo is not a problem since there is an ammo crate on every corner and maps are small. The range is not a problem either because nothing can withstand teh lazor for more than 2-3s.

[BXpress2]

i cant believe people are complaining about ammo and range when this thing melts through everything in a matter of a few seconds.

you know there Steven Seagal kickass and then there is Chuck Norris kickass.no weapon should ever be Chuck Norris.and Reegar is.

agree with Kronner,absolutely boring no skill weapon."but the range" lol...

[RxP4IN]

BXpress2 wrote...

i cant believe people are complaining about ammo and range when this thing melts through everything in a matter of a few seconds.

you know there Steven Seagal kickass and then there is Chuck Norris kickass.no weapon should ever be Chuck Norris.and Reegar is.

agree with Kronner,absolutely boring no skill weapon."but the range" lol...

New DLC. Zorah Carbine --> OHKO anything. Downside: must be within 0.5 meters of target, only holds enough ammo to kill 5 enemies (which can be remedied by consumables, mods, gear, or the infinite ammo on the map).

Sounds awful, huh?

[BXpress2]

ElectroNeonPanda wrote...

1. Bioware gives us free DLC and new weapons to play with.
2. Players complain new toys are too good.
3. ...
4. Fail

i really doubt that it is Bioware's interest to make this game easy mode,dont you think?otherwise they wouldn't have nerfed te Falcon which was by no means as OP as the Reegar is.

[Quxorda]

Kick In The Door wrote...

For the sake of the lore I hope they don't do anything to it. Kal Reegar was a bad motherf**ker and so should be the weapon that's named after him.

I call mine Vera.

[RxP4IN]

Quxorda wrote...

Kick In The Door wrote...

For the sake of the lore I hope they don't do anything to it. Kal Reegar was a bad motherf**ker and so should be the weapon that's named after him.

I call mine Vera.

Lol. I named my QI "Jayne"

[Johnsen1972]

This weapon is supposed to be an Ultra Rare. Why should Bioware nerf it?
I have version II and it sucks because of the limited ammo.

[BYC]

It's good, but I'm not sure it should be nerfed.

- Low ammo really hurts, and this thing eats ammo fast.
- Very poor range.  Unlike the geth pyro, this thing has low range.  I was running through gunfire in gold to be able to use it (I had no other guns at the time).  Against instant kill enemies, this is a bad gun.
- Slow reload times prevents it from taking out entire rooms.
- It seems to work poorly against barriers.  I could not take down a full phantom with it, which was odd since I was taking out centurions without too much trouble.

It's great at extremely close range (the range just outside of melee), but that's a range that most players do not want to be at in gold.  It's fast ammo consumption, low ammo count, and slow reload makes it so if you do kill one enemy, others will get you.

[Dorje Sylas]

Krogan Vanguard + Charge weapon damage boost + Ammo Capacity Mod + Shredder Mod Inferno Ammo + Shotgun AMP or Shotgun/Melee boost equipment

Scorchy toasty roasty electric flame thrower.

Johnsen1972 wrote...

This weapon is supposed to be an Ultra Rare. Why should Bioware nerf it?
I have version II and it sucks because of the limited ammo.

Yes, the limited ammo threw me at first but you can learn ways around that.

Keep in mind that the reload is actually rather fast and if your going balls out on something like a Vanguard or Korgan you can actually reload cancel quite well by throwing in a charge or melee (heavy) in between discharges. Equipped right and most of the dangerous things even on gold melt like butter in Haestrom's sun. Buddy up with a Vorcha Pryo maniac and things really die fast. Find a good choke point with an ammo box and watch as things turn to charred crisps or ionized ash.

Modifié par Dorje Sylas, 30 mai 2012 - 02:27 .

[Moonphos87]

I finally played more with this gun yay!

BTT - I tried with Asari VG for a couple rounds. Its a good gun with VG, although because of AV's ability stats, I carried GPsmg to compensate for range fights (Hacking objectives, or if the fight zone is too hot for charging).

This thing simply chews through shields. Phantoms melt to this gun, Banshee shield drops so fast, but I leave Banshees for my other teammates' heavier firepower for the Armor Bar. Didn't have enough Geth games tonight.

Didn't have Shredder mod on, but I'm considering dropping EB for it, while sporting Spare Ammo mod. I'm more of a gunplay player.

This gun is really strong, but I'm downed by the fact that ammo count is low. I suppose that's for balancing reason.

[AdmLancel]

Not everyone will like the Reegar Carbine due to it requiring you to be in their faces, and a generally poor ammo supply. I frequently had to drop by an ammo crate on silver, and ran out of ammo on the later objective waves. Then I got the extra ammo mod and it was k.

I think used well it should have enough ammo to fulfill your purposes, just get used to timing your bursts to kill what you're aiming at and avoid overkill.

To me the most impressive ability of this weapon is its ability to hose down Geth Hunters. Extraction on Silver with three Geth Hunters rushing in and causing great fear in my team until I walked up with Reegar, emptied a heat sink, and all three melted. I repeated this twice after for confirmation of effectiveness.

Not as good against armor, but usable. Biggest trouble there is that you're at close range and it has one of the longer reload times.

It does do horrific amounts of damage though.