133 réponses à ce sujet

[Palladin123]

I think the weapon is fine as it is. The minimal range balances out the damage output. While other shotguns are also more effective at short range, they at least do some damage at medium range especially with the accuracy attachment. The carbine though does absolutely no damage beyond close-in range.

[friedricethem0n]

Phantom-busters would be a better name for the Reeger Carbine.

"I'm afraid of no phantom..."

[Fisterbear]

Feneckus wrote...

Of course it is, I can't believe some people argue otherwise.

Especially OP in the hands of an infiltrator or vanguard.

Drell Vanguard with Reegar and Adrenaline Module III is just ridiculous.

I want to unlock the male quarian infiltrator PREEETY bad to pair him with this gun.

[Kronner]

I think the Krysae Rifle is even better.

The Reegar is a niche weapon that is extremely effective up close, but sucks otherwise. I couldn't care less if it's OP as I do not like it anyway.

Claymore/GPS/Wraith/Graal are still better overall shotguns IMHO.

Modifié par Kronner, 31 mai 2012 - 08:25 .

[sirus1988]

friedricethem0n wrote...

Phantom-busters would be a better name for the Reeger Carbine.

"I'm afraid of no phantom..."

Don't cross the lines!! It's so much fun when you have two or more players with the carbine.

[panda5onix]

sirus1988 wrote...

friedricethem0n wrote...

Phantom-busters would be a better name for the Reeger Carbine.

"I'm afraid of no phantom..."

Don't cross the lines!! It's so much fun when you have two or more players with the carbine.

+1

Ghost busterrrr!!

[NucularPikinic]

 You're right. I'd rather have a gun that has no real range, burns through ammo clips quickly, and does less damage than it currently does now. Yep.

Nope.

I don't see how the gun is broken. It works as it should be expected to. It isn't an insta-win button. If it could kill groups of enemies that were swarming you, and I mean kill them very very quickly... then there would be something. But that's not how it works right now. On an infiltrator ("broken") you still can't kill groups of enemies in one go. You have to do the standard hit-and-run tactics in order to compensate for the ammo.

[Klokos]

How is the tread where you wanted the Claymore to stagger and penetrate cover going Stardusk ?

[spudspot]

Klokos wrote...

How is the tread where you wanted the Claymore to stagger and penetrate cover going Stardusk ?

No offense Stardusk, but this is a very valid point.

But on topic: I don't think its broken and I don't want it to be nerfed (actually I don't use it). With the range limitation I can't really see how to decrease its efficiency without making it completely uselesss.  If you need to get that close to do any damage, you also desperately need to kill stuff fast and that is exactly what the Carbine provides.

I also think you (that is Stardusk) could make anything (Drell Melee guide on the way?) work just fine, but rest assured, there are many decent players out there who can't/don't want to risk going all CQC. My point? Something that is broken in your hands may well be a deathrap for many other players. So while nerfing the Reegar Carbine to semi-destructional at close range would make it more balanced for top-tier players, it would - and I'm pretty certain about that - however make it useless for anybody else. How is that balanced?

Maybe I overestimate my self a little by simply assuming that the majority of players (which is not represented by the BSN-community!) can't handle it any better than I do, but I die infinitely more using the Carbine than with the Claymore/GPS/Graal/whatever. Furthermore you have made the same mistake assuming it is broken based on your skill. I mean, have you played a PUG recently? Do you think the Carbine is OP there?

The only way a nerf could work is by increasing the range while decreasing the damage, but then again this would have to be done very, very carefully. 

Modifié par spudspot, 31 mai 2012 - 09:18 .