70 réponses à ce sujet

[Landon7001]

@Demonique see my post right above yours......id put ashley,wrex,liara plus every me 2 character minus zaeed ahead of those 2......if my percieved "petulance" irks you so, move on to the next post. We don't have to agree. And if complaints pertaining to me 3 is something new to you at this point I question the veracity of your own fandom

[grey_wind]

IsaacShep wrote...

capn233 wrote...

Don't be a ******.  That wasn't completely serious.  But they could have easily added more recruitable ME2 characters with only mild investment.

There are already 8 squadmates in the game, more would just result in the same thing as ME2 - zero squad banter.

Unless you bring Javik along, the squad banter is mostly the same between any two characters. It really wouldn't have been that hard to write some for a couple new characters.
Of course, that would require effort.

[DirtySHISN0]

There are only 2 things you need to look at on the case of ME2 to understand the direction of the games from then on. They are; Miranda and the EA logo.

Herdy derpdy diddley dumbdy derp.

Look at ME3 Ashley to see proof.

Modifié par DirtySHISN0, 01 juin 2012 - 07:17 .

[Landon7001]

......i liked my ash pre me 3 and shes still hot in me 3, no complaints here

[Tiberis]

You complained about people "hating" Jacob yet you make a whole thread to hate on Garrus and Tali?

[Errationatus]

Garrus doesn't suck.  He has no lips.

Tali likely sucks, but she probably gets sick after.  Unless you acclimatize her to it.  Probably takes awhile...  or would those backward knees get in the way?

Perhaps I've completely misconstrued OP's post, as it was extremely shallow and easily open to interpretation.

[DevilBeast]

Tealjaker94 wrote...

It's obvious that bioware intends to make a sitcom featuring shepard, liara, garrus, and tali. That's why they get so much attention. Bioware just needs to keep us focused on those characters.

If there should be an ME sitcom it should be Legion and Friends. Nuff said.

Modifié par DevilBeast, 01 juin 2012 - 08:50 .

[Landon7001]

JakeMacDon wrote...

Garrus doesn't suck.  He has no lips.

Tali likely sucks, but she probably gets sick after.  Unless you acclimatize her to it.  Probably takes awhile...  or would those backward knees get in the way?

Perhaps I've completely misconstrued OP's post, as it was extremely shallow and easily open to interpretation.

Have all the information before you speak ignorantly on a subject. In my first post I elaboarated and clarified as to exactly why I thought they sucked. If you are unfamiliar with the meaning of the word suck in this context youre not very aware of the english/american vernacular. 

[Landon7001]

Tiberis wrote...

You complained about people "hating" Jacob yet you make a whole thread to hate on Garrus and Tali?

lol....yeeeahhh....but Im more hating on the writers than the characters, they shafted alot of their own great characters

[Landon7001]

Tiberis wrote...

You complained about people "hating" Jacob yet you make a whole thread to hate on Garrus and Tali?

additionally, someone had to speak up on behalf of my boy jacob.....theres mooooore than enough garrus/tali fanatics

[DevilBeast]

Okay, I think I agree with Landon on this one (although I do find the all-caps-raging-thread-title a bit overboard and offensive. We all have our opinons but there is no need to rage against each others fav characters). Anyways, what I think was done "wrong" by BW is that they included Tali and Garrus as full time squadies in all three games. Now, before anyone says: "If you don´t want them in ME3 you can just kill them off in the SM", just let me explain:

Yes, you can remove both Tali and Garrus in ME3 by making certain choices in ME2. However my problem is not that I don´t want them in the game, only that they always have a reserved spot in the squad. Meaning even if they are dead in ME3 noone will replace them, their place on the team will just remain empty.
It´s like if you have a seat reservation in a concerthall and goes to the bathrooom or whatever. Even if you are gone it´s still your seat, and as such will remain empty untill you return (alright, that probably wasn´t a good comparison, but I hope you catch my meaning).

So, my point is that Tali and Garrus should, at the least, have been "switchable" with another character(s) in ME3 (much like with Samara and Morinth in ME2), even if they are alive.

Modifié par DevilBeast, 01 juin 2012 - 08:46 .

[teh DRUMPf!!]

BECAUSE LANDON TYPES THREAD TITLES IN ALL CAPS!!!

[Mr. Big Pimpin]

DevilBeast wrote...

Yes, you can remove both Tali and Garrus in ME3 by making certain choices in ME2. However my problem is not that I don´t want them in the game, only that they always have a reserved spot in the squad. Meaning even if they are dead in ME3 noone will replace them, their place on the team will just remain empty.
It´s like if you have a seat reservation in a concerthall and goes to the bathrooom or whatever. Even if you are gone it´s still your seat, and as such will remain empty untill you return (alright, that probably wasn´t a good comparison, but I hope you catch my meaning).

So, my point is that Tali and Garrus should, at the least, have been "switchable" with another character(s) in ME3 (much like with Samara and Morinth in ME2), even if they are alive.

If they were going to go to all the trouble to make additional squadmates in ME3, would it not be preferable for them to just add someone like Jack (whom most would be pleased to see back on the team) in addition to the current squad rather than design replacement characters for Tali and Garrus whom the majority would never meet or care about?

Modifié par Mr. Big Pimpin, 01 juin 2012 - 08:59 .

[Landon7001]

@ HYR 2.0 Im getting popular

[Apathy1989]

Being known on forums as an idiot is not something to take pride in.

[Landon7001]

DevilBeast wrote...

Okay, I think I agree with Landon on this one (although I do find the all-caps-raging-thread-title a bit overboard and offensive. We all have our opinons but there is no need to rage against each others fav characters). Anyways, what I think was done "wrong" by BW is that they included Tali and Garrus as full time squadies in all three games. Now, before anyone says: "If you don´t want them in ME3 you can just kill them off in the SM", just let me explain:

Yes, you can remove both Tali and Garrus in ME3 by making certain choices in ME2. However my problem is not that I don´t want them in the game, only that they always have a reserved spot in the squad. Meaning even if they are dead in ME3 noone will replace them, their place on the team will just remain empty.
It´s like if you have a seat reservation in a concerthall and goes to the bathrooom or whatever. Even if you are gone it´s still your seat, and as such will remain empty untill you return (alright, that probably wasn´t a good comparison, but I hope you catch my meaning).

So, my point is that Tali and Garrus should, at the least, have been "switchable" with another character(s) in ME3 (much like with Samara and Morinth in ME2), even if they are alive.

THE CAPS ARE MORE TO JUST GET PPLS ATTENTION  but I agree wholeheartedly on what you say....i had both garrus and tali die in various careers thinking that would make room for another character...but NOPE

[Landon7001]

Apathy1989 wrote...

Being known on forums as an idiot is not something to take pride in.

iF YOUVE ACTUALLY READ ANYTHING OF LENGTH IVE WRITTEN YOU WOULD NOT THINK ME AN IDIOT  the caps are to get ppls attention, im not really screaming at my screen. And fact is my threads get attention so....the majotrity of ppl on here speak with eloquence, thoughtfulness and are articulate and I mutually engage in it, like Star Trek  Mass Effect is an intellectual, cerebral, thoughtful franchise that attracts {mostly} like fans.....doesnt mean theres no room for fun though

[lillitheris]

Landon7001 wrote...
 the caps are to get ppls attention, im not really screaming at my screen. And fact is my threads get attention so...

I never read anything written in all caps, because years of experience have accurately demonstrated that the writing is rarely worth reading. Inability to write coherently is another good clue.

If you’re only opening threads to “get attention”, I’ll just report for trolling, then…

[Karrie788]

Problem is, when you put caps, people will always picture you screaming. I'd put my words in bold if I were you.

On topic, while I was absolutely extactic that Garrus got so much screen time, it's true I would have liked to have more interactions with my former ME2 squadmates, especially Miranda and Samara. For Tali... I dunno. She appears late in the game, just like in ME2.

[DevilBeast]

Mr. Big Pimpin wrote...

DevilBeast wrote...

Yes, you can remove both Tali and Garrus in ME3 by making certain choices in ME2. However my problem is not that I don´t want them in the game, only that they always have a reserved spot in the squad. Meaning even if they are dead in ME3 noone will replace them, their place on the team will just remain empty.
It´s like if you have a seat reservation in a concerthall and goes to the bathrooom or whatever. Even if you are gone it´s still your seat, and as such will remain empty untill you return (alright, that probably wasn´t a good comparison, but I hope you catch my meaning).

So, my point is that Tali and Garrus should, at the least, have been "switchable" with another character(s) in ME3 (much like with Samara and Morinth in ME2), even if they are alive.

If they were going to go to all the trouble to make additional squadmates in ME3, would it not be preferable for them to just add someone like Jack (whom most would be pleased to see back on the team) in addition to the current squad rather than design replacement characters for Tali and Garrus whom the majority would never meet or care about?

I don´t think they should "design" completely new characters maybe just let someone else from the ME2 squad
take either Garrus´ or Tali´s spot (although that someone(s) would probably get a ton of flak from the fans of the ME2 characters who aren´t switchable with Tali and/or Garrus).

But yes it could have "balanced" the game out a bit, if at least one character from ME2 (other than Tali/Garrus). Heck! It would probably have been even better if they reserved one spot on the squad for which ever character from the ME2 squad the player chooses. Would have made alot of people happy. But again, that would have been tremendous amount of work for the devs. and near impossible to execute, I think.
And it´s not like they are going to change anything like that, now that the game has been finished for months.

And that actually beckons the question: Why the hell am I talking about this:blink:??
 

[Ninja Stan]

You wanted attention, you got attention.

End of line.