27 réponses à ce sujet

[Cybercat999]

- 72 

He was humming and stammering and trying to tell my PC he loves her for like 13th time, so I just told him I find his joke very funny. Went from *adore* to zero in single hit.

I admit I never saw that much disapprovement yet. What is your best minus score? Is there a way to get more?

Modifié par Cybercat999, 11 décembre 2009 - 04:47 .

[Kurt5777]

-86 by Lelianna all because I told her Morrigan was better in bed. Some just can't handle the truth

[Cybercat999]

Oh boy I have to play male once just to see that...

[ijmorris]

That is outstanding - you can do that with a female character to I s'pose, right?

[Rathalin]

-100 with Morrigan. I ended it with her, then finished by saying "Good it's done".

[XOGHunter246]

he don't like people taking the ****** out of him in romance he can take minor jokes but he already sensitive in relationships and you make fun of him not surprised lol

[NatOreN]

And here I thought I had it bad. The best minus score I've ever recieved was a -24 from Alistair.

[Invalidcode]

That much? Wow I have to reload some of my old saves to see it myself.

Poor Alistair, he pull his heart out for the PC and it just got stomped on the ground.

[Adria Teksuni]

-100 when Al asked me about my relationship with Zev and I told him I was going with Mr. Puss in Boots instead of him.

*reload previous save*

I think if you're in a romance with a character and end it, it resets their approval rating to 0.  The negative number is just how much approval you had with them up to that point.  You lose it ALL.

Modifié par Adria Teksuni, 11 décembre 2009 - 05:35 .

[LdyShayna]

Not always, at least not in the PC version. I just ran through with my mage choosing Zevrean over Alistair (difficult for me as a player!), I actually got a +1 from Alistair when I talked to him about it and ended the romance.

[Fishy]

I'm happy you don't have approbation bar in real life.



Hey WIFE .. Get the trash out

- 100

Next day Divorce and my house gone.

[Servant of Nature]

Alistair can be kind of hard to get a read on, actually. He loves jokes and such but there's a certain point where he just shuts down and takes everything seriously. It doesn't help that some of 'mean' responses can get you a joking response while others get a sadface Alistair.



Example: After making love..

Alistair: You know, according to all the sisters in the monastery, I should have been struck by lightning by now.

PC: Not for that performance.

Alistair: Meaning I was so good the Maker Himself couldn't punish me for it? Right? Right? Aww.



It's really quite confusing, as some of the 'mean' responses could just as easily be playful teasing as well.

[Vajarra]

Wow yeah, I wouldn't -dare- use that option. He doesn't get pissy if you say that? How strange.

[Dolomite808]

I lost something like 21 points with Al for letting the kid's mom sacrifice herself to open the fade. I didn't realize Alistair would take it so hard, and besides, she volunteered.

Modifié par Dolomite808, 11 décembre 2009 - 06:37 .

[XOGHunter246]

Alistair hated me for siding with branka some reason what it got to do with him >>

[Servant of Nature]

XOGHunter246 wrote...

Alistair hated me for siding with branka some reason what it got to do with him >>

I don't think he likes the idea of using living people for golems.  He isn't a very good Warden, to be honest.  Doesn't get the whole 'do whatever it takes' thing.  He doesn't like sacrificing the few to save the many, which is why he refuses to be in a leadership position.

[XOGHunter246]

I hope if Alistair ever is in sequel they make him more confident and more grown up he shouldn't be the follower people should be following him. He needs to wake up and smell the coffee and stop whining and do what needs to be done.

Modifié par XOGHunter246, 11 décembre 2009 - 06:51 .

[Cybercat999]

Invalidcode wrote...

That much? Wow I have to reload some of my old saves to see it myself.
Poor Alistair, he pull his heart out for the PC and it just got stomped on the ground.

Ok lets see. We are in some kind of medieval times with knights running around respecting innocent virgin and being gentlemen and all that jazz (at least I got such impression, maybe I am wrong).

So here comes a guy raised in Chanrty and taught all the manners towards noble girl, and what does he do? After getting few ohhh shinies he is so much in love he cant wait anymore and has to get into her pants. We may all be dead tomorrow so lets have some fun kinda talk. Now since we dont die tomorrow or the day after, what would proper behavior for honorable young knight be? To marry the girl he "spoiled" of course, asap. Not this honorable guy focussed on duty though - when he realizes the girl actually expects him to *do something about it* he starts talking about honor and duty being something to drive them apart eventually. Yeah, right, I heard that kind of excuse already

I havent stomped him to the ground as he deserves yet, I am not gonna be happy until I get him to leave before Landsmeet (I dont know if its an option but a girl can always dream, yes?)

[Doomnova01]

Alistair reminds me of Duncan during the Calling. I honestly think (depending on your choices) will turn out quite a bit different if we say dropped in on him say 5-10 years down the road.

[pc6311]

I think my record was -99 when I turned down Alistair's invitation telling him he was a funny man.

I reloaded of course....

[Adria Teksuni]

As far as the Golems thing goes, I can def see from his POV. The Darkspawn take over corpses and are essentially slaves of the Archdemon with no real free will or choice. Golems are dwarves forced to take over stone bodies and are slaves of whomever has their control rods.



I can very much understand that the ends does not justify the means disapproval from Alistair.



And LdyShayna, that's too funny that you got approval from Al when you dumped him. So will have to try that. Maybe I'm just too mean when I end relationships.

[LdyShayna]

Vajarra wrote...

Wow yeah, I wouldn't -dare- use that option. He doesn't get pissy if you say that? How strange.

Of course he doesn't.  I've never read it as having a negative connotation, though, but the  very, very positive one that he also takes it as (IE, the performance was a GOOD one).  I think that one it depends a great deal on what you imagined the tone of voice to be when you first read it. 

EDIT: To be honest, I never had trouble 'reading' Alistair.  It is Zevran that is confusing me.  I"ll have what seems to be a perfectly amiable conversation, end up with something like a -7, and have no idea what I had said that made him so angry.  Heh.

Modifié par LdyShayna, 11 décembre 2009 - 08:23 .

[Servant of Nature]

LdyShayna wrote...


Of course he doesn't.  I've never read it as having a negative connotation, though, but the  very, very positive one that he also takes it as (IE, the performance was a GOOD one).  I think that one it depends a great deal on what you imagined the tone of voice to be when you first read it. 

EDIT: To be honest, I never had trouble 'reading' Alistair.  It is Zevran that is confusing me.  I"ll have what seems to be a perfectly amiable conversation, end up with something like a -7, and have no idea what I had said that made him so angry.  Heh.

Yeah, I always saw it as a sort of "Mmm, not for that performance, love" sort of thing, but I never chose it because I was afraid it'd be taken the wrong way and get me a sadface Alistair.  There really needs to be some notes to the side of the answers.  (Playfully) or (Hostile) or something.  Oh well.

With Zevran, he's definitely the hardest character to get any sort of read on, at all, I thought he was extremely well done in that respect, despite how frustrating it can be. 

[LdyShayna]

Neat.