It makes sense [Normandy crash scene support thread]

#951
Memnon

Posté 13 juin 2012 - 10:56

Members
1 405 messages

Saying that Javik could have changed his mind is not a strong counter-argument against him being in a test flight; neither does it explain why he would participate in a test flight to begin with. First off, destroying the Reapers was his only, single motivating force - he is the last of his race, all of his friends and allies are dead, his civilization barely a memory. The only thing that keeps him alive is the desire to destroy Reapers. He obsesses about it.

But, let's say he does decide not to commit suicide - why would he help the humans test a new relay? He would not be a part of any earth organization that didn't have Shepard leading it - he had nothing but disdain for all of the races of the current cycle because he remembered them in their infant state and considered them beneath him. He smack talked Liara mercilessly, and the Asari were the most technologically advanced of the cycle. If the humans made a new Normandy or new relays or a new Citadel. he wouldn't give a rip ... and he certainly wouldn't help them test it. He would think they would mess it up and become space dust.

So no, saying "he could have changed his mind" is not a strong counterargument ...

Modifié par Stornskar, 13 juin 2012 - 11:42 .

Retour en haut

#952
D24O

Posté 13 juin 2012 - 10:57

Members
7 579 messages

^lol

Retour en haut

#953
estebanus

Posté 13 juin 2012 - 10:59

Members
5 987 messages

EDIT: spam erased.

Modifié par estebanus, 14 juin 2012 - 07:59 .

Retour en haut

#954
estebanus

Posté 13 juin 2012 - 11:00

Members
5 987 messages

EDIT: spam erased.

Modifié par estebanus, 14 juin 2012 - 07:59 .

Retour en haut

#955
D24O

Posté 13 juin 2012 - 11:00

Members
7 579 messages

https://encrypted-tb...K9jWYAkq_pHdk9h

Retour en haut

#956
M Hedonist

Posté 13 juin 2012 - 11:02

Members
4 299 messages

Stornskar wrote...

Saying that Javik could have changed his mind is not a strong counter-argument against him being in a test flight; neither does it explain why he would participate in a test flight to begin with. First off, destroying the Reapers was his only, single motivating force - he is the last of his race, all of his friends and allies are dead, his civilization barely a memory. The only thing that keeps him alive is the desire to destroy Reapers. He obseesses about it.

But, let's say he does decide not to commit suicide - why would he help the humans test a new relay? He would not be a part of any earth organization that didn't have Shepard leading it - he had nothing but disdain for all of the races of the current cycle because he remembered them in their infant state and considered them beneath him. He smack talked Liara mercilessly, and the Asari were the most technologically advanced of the cycle. If the humans made a new Normandy or new relays or a new Citadel. he wouldn't give a rip ... and he certainly wouldn't help them test it. He would think they would mess it up and become space dust.

So no, saying "he could have changed his mind" is not a strong counterargument ...

Literally none of Seival's counter arguments in this thread are based on evidence or logical deduction. Instead he bases his baseless assumptions on more baseless assumptions and makes comparisons that are completely inappropriate.
Posted Image