294 réponses à ce sujet

[CrazyRah]

I gave my feedback to Bioware for ME3 and it wasn't sunshine and bunnies positive feedback. I was honest and said exactly what i thought and why i thought just that. I was constructive without being positive and they were happy for the feedback. You don't have to be positive to be constructive, that's just ridiculous. Like so many others have said in the thread that criticism help Bioware to learn what was good and not good. The worst thing for them would be if everyone just said yes we love it to everything they made, they wouldn't develop and improve.

[Grimwick]

Seival wrote...

Grimwick wrote...

Seival wrote...

Archontor wrote...

To be honest I don't hate Bioware I still remember their greater works (namely all the others since dragon age)

I'm growing less fond of Speculations however.

So let's support BioWare. I'm sure the endings is the only thing you don't like in ME3 right now. And I'm sure EC will fix that...

...But fixing doesn't has to mean removal of scenes which have a great potential. They just need to uprise such scenes to a new level and make them more detailed.

Supporting BW doesn't mean blindly agreeing to all they produce.

Criticism will help BW to learn from their mistakes and produce a better quality product the next time around.
What they don't need is a group of yes-men fanatics who believe everything BW touches is gold.

I don't agreeing with anything blindly. A had a lot of days to think about some particular parts of the ending, including this one. There was enough criticism already. Both constructive and unconstructive. And now it's time for support, because EC is already in production and will be released very soon.

...I'm sure they will not remove the scene from the game. I'm sure they will use its potential to make a great epilogue. And I support that.

How can you support something which completely undermines the whole trilogy as a child's story. Made worse by poor writing and a background which they downloaded from the internet.

It has potential alright. Potential to mar and ruin any decent epilogue they could make as obsolete.

[Seival]

Grimwick wrote...

Seival wrote...

Grimwick wrote...

Seival wrote...

Archontor wrote...

To be honest I don't hate Bioware I still remember their greater works (namely all the others since dragon age)

I'm growing less fond of Speculations however.

So let's support BioWare. I'm sure the endings is the only thing you don't like in ME3 right now. And I'm sure EC will fix that...

...But fixing doesn't has to mean removal of scenes which have a great potential. They just need to uprise such scenes to a new level and make them more detailed.

Supporting BW doesn't mean blindly agreeing to all they produce.

Criticism will help BW to learn from their mistakes and produce a better quality product the next time around.
What they don't need is a group of yes-men fanatics who believe everything BW touches is gold.

I don't agreeing with anything blindly. A had a lot of days to think about some particular parts of the ending, including this one. There was enough criticism already. Both constructive and unconstructive. And now it's time for support, because EC is already in production and will be released very soon.

...I'm sure they will not remove the scene from the game. I'm sure they will use its potential to make a great epilogue. And I support that.

How can you support something which completely undermines the whole trilogy as a child's story. Made worse by poor writing and a background which they downloaded from the internet.

It has potential alright. Potential to mar and ruin any decent epilogue they could make as obsolete.

I didn't have such a vision of the scene even when I've seen it for the first time and was angry about the endings in general. I don't know how did you come to such conclusions. Maybe because of that silly thread about "devs have stolen the epilogue from some dark metal band's song"?

[Grimwick]

Seival wrote...

Grimwick wrote...

Seival wrote...

Grimwick wrote...

Seival wrote...

Archontor wrote...

To be honest I don't hate Bioware I still remember their greater works (namely all the others since dragon age)

I'm growing less fond of Speculations however.

So let's support BioWare. I'm sure the endings is the only thing you don't like in ME3 right now. And I'm sure EC will fix that...

...But fixing doesn't has to mean removal of scenes which have a great potential. They just need to uprise such scenes to a new level and make them more detailed.

Supporting BW doesn't mean blindly agreeing to all they produce.

Criticism will help BW to learn from their mistakes and produce a better quality product the next time around.
What they don't need is a group of yes-men fanatics who believe everything BW touches is gold.

I don't agreeing with anything blindly. A had a lot of days to think about some particular parts of the ending, including this one. There was enough criticism already. Both constructive and unconstructive. And now it's time for support, because EC is already in production and will be released very soon.

...I'm sure they will not remove the scene from the game. I'm sure they will use its potential to make a great epilogue. And I support that.

How can you support something which completely undermines the whole trilogy as a child's story. Made worse by poor writing and a background which they downloaded from the internet.

It has potential alright. Potential to mar and ruin any decent epilogue they could make as obsolete.

I didn't have such a vision of the scene even when I've seen it for the first time and was angry about the endings in general. I don't know how did you come to such conclusions. Maybe because of that silly thread about "devs have stolen the epilogue from some dark metal band's song"?

Because it's a terrible scene?

Also, look up the images - I'll edit with the links - you'll be amazed and astounded about how much work actually went into that scene.

ipadfreakz.com/apple-tablet/ipad-wallpapers/landscape-mode/space-wallpapers/

This looks familiar... 

Modifié par Grimwick, 10 juin 2012 - 12:12 .

[Seival]

Grimwick wrote...

Seival wrote...

Grimwick wrote...

Seival wrote...

Grimwick wrote...

Seival wrote...

Archontor wrote...

To be honest I don't hate Bioware I still remember their greater works (namely all the others since dragon age)

I'm growing less fond of Speculations however.

So let's support BioWare. I'm sure the endings is the only thing you don't like in ME3 right now. And I'm sure EC will fix that...

...But fixing doesn't has to mean removal of scenes which have a great potential. They just need to uprise such scenes to a new level and make them more detailed.

Supporting BW doesn't mean blindly agreeing to all they produce.

Criticism will help BW to learn from their mistakes and produce a better quality product the next time around.
What they don't need is a group of yes-men fanatics who believe everything BW touches is gold.

I don't agreeing with anything blindly. A had a lot of days to think about some particular parts of the ending, including this one. There was enough criticism already. Both constructive and unconstructive. And now it's time for support, because EC is already in production and will be released very soon.

...I'm sure they will not remove the scene from the game. I'm sure they will use its potential to make a great epilogue. And I support that.

How can you support something which completely undermines the whole trilogy as a child's story. Made worse by poor writing and a background which they downloaded from the internet.

It has potential alright. Potential to mar and ruin any decent epilogue they could make as obsolete.

I didn't have such a vision of the scene even when I've seen it for the first time and was angry about the endings in general. I don't know how did you come to such conclusions. Maybe because of that silly thread about "devs have stolen the epilogue from some dark metal band's song"?

Because it's a terrible scene?

Also, look up the images - I'll edit with the links - you'll be amazed and astounded about how much work actually went into that scene.

There are tons of art that looks similar, so what? Moreover, they can improve the scene to become full-scale non-interactive dialogue... Or at list the scene will become something similar to DA:O "static-art-epilogue".

[Shepard Wins]

Seival wrote...

Grimwick wrote...

Seival wrote...

Grimwick wrote...

Seival wrote...

Grimwick wrote...

Seival wrote...

Archontor wrote...

To be honest I don't hate Bioware I still remember their greater works (namely all the others since dragon age)

I'm growing less fond of Speculations however.

So let's support BioWare. I'm sure the endings is the only thing you don't like in ME3 right now. And I'm sure EC will fix that...

...But fixing doesn't has to mean removal of scenes which have a great potential. They just need to uprise such scenes to a new level and make them more detailed.

Supporting BW doesn't mean blindly agreeing to all they produce.

Criticism will help BW to learn from their mistakes and produce a better quality product the next time around.
What they don't need is a group of yes-men fanatics who believe everything BW touches is gold.

I don't agreeing with anything blindly. A had a lot of days to think about some particular parts of the ending, including this one. There was enough criticism already. Both constructive and unconstructive. And now it's time for support, because EC is already in production and will be released very soon.

...I'm sure they will not remove the scene from the game. I'm sure they will use its potential to make a great epilogue. And I support that.

How can you support something which completely undermines the whole trilogy as a child's story. Made worse by poor writing and a background which they downloaded from the internet.

It has potential alright. Potential to mar and ruin any decent epilogue they could make as obsolete.

I didn't have such a vision of the scene even when I've seen it for the first time and was angry about the endings in general. I don't know how did you come to such conclusions. Maybe because of that silly thread about "devs have stolen the epilogue from some dark metal band's song"?

Because it's a terrible scene?

Also, look up the images - I'll edit with the links - you'll be amazed and astounded about how much work actually went into that scene.

There are tons of art that looks similar, so what? Moreover, they can improve the scene to become full-scale non-interactive dialogue... Or at list the scene will become something similar to DA:O "static-art-epilogue".

Ah yes, art. We have dismissed that claim.

[Seival]

Shepard Wins wrote...

Seival wrote...

Grimwick wrote...

Seival wrote...

Grimwick wrote...

Seival wrote...

Grimwick wrote...

Seival wrote...

Archontor wrote...

To be honest I don't hate Bioware I still remember their greater works (namely all the others since dragon age)

I'm growing less fond of Speculations however.

So let's support BioWare. I'm sure the endings is the only thing you don't like in ME3 right now. And I'm sure EC will fix that...

...But fixing doesn't has to mean removal of scenes which have a great potential. They just need to uprise such scenes to a new level and make them more detailed.

Supporting BW doesn't mean blindly agreeing to all they produce.

Criticism will help BW to learn from their mistakes and produce a better quality product the next time around.
What they don't need is a group of yes-men fanatics who believe everything BW touches is gold.

I don't agreeing with anything blindly. A had a lot of days to think about some particular parts of the ending, including this one. There was enough criticism already. Both constructive and unconstructive. And now it's time for support, because EC is already in production and will be released very soon.

...I'm sure they will not remove the scene from the game. I'm sure they will use its potential to make a great epilogue. And I support that.

How can you support something which completely undermines the whole trilogy as a child's story. Made worse by poor writing and a background which they downloaded from the internet.

It has potential alright. Potential to mar and ruin any decent epilogue they could make as obsolete.

I didn't have such a vision of the scene even when I've seen it for the first time and was angry about the endings in general. I don't know how did you come to such conclusions. Maybe because of that silly thread about "devs have stolen the epilogue from some dark metal band's song"?

Because it's a terrible scene?

Also, look up the images - I'll edit with the links - you'll be amazed and astounded about how much work actually went into that scene.

There are tons of art that looks similar, so what? Moreover, they can improve the scene to become full-scale non-interactive dialogue... Or at list the scene will become something similar to DA:O "static-art-epilogue".

Ah yes, art. We have dismissed that claim.

Yes, art. And ME Trilogy is a Masterpiece.

[The Angry One]

Seival wrote...

Yes, art. And ME Trilogy is a Masterpiece.

I've just felt a great disturbance. As if millions of true artists from all of Earth's history cried out in disbelief and were suddenly silenced.

[Taboo]

The Angry One wrote...

Seival wrote...

Yes, art. And ME Trilogy is a Masterpiece.

I've just felt a great disturbance. As if millions of true artists from all of Earth's history cried out in disbelief and were suddenly silenced.

That was me.

[scott1118]

Apathy1989 wrote...

The Night Mammoth wrote...

Grimwick wrote...

Oh my word... this thread can't exist, can it?

First the Normandy scene, now this? 

LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

My spider sense is tingling. 

lol OP is a troll.

Old Man and kid scene was the icing on the cake for an overall terrrible ending. I struggle to think how they could have made it more insulting.

"Shepard has become a legend, you can continue that legend through DLC - Buy DLC now"

[Seival]

scott1118 wrote...

Apathy1989 wrote...

The Night Mammoth wrote...

Grimwick wrote...

Oh my word... this thread can't exist, can it?

First the Normandy scene, now this? 

LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

My spider sense is tingling. 

lol OP is a troll.

Old Man and kid scene was the icing on the cake for an overall terrrible ending. I struggle to think how they could have made it more insulting.

"Shepard has become a legend, you can continue that legend through DLC - Buy DLC now"

I have a feeling, that all ME3 DLCs will be free...

[Joe Del Toro]

Taboo-XX wrote...

The Angry One wrote...

Seival wrote...

Yes, art. And ME Trilogy is a Masterpiece.

I've just felt a great disturbance. As if millions of true artists from all of Earth's history cried out in disbelief and were suddenly silenced.

That was me.

HA. Keep dreamin', lad!

[M Hedonist]

Seival wrote...

I have a feeling, that all ME3 DLCs will be free...

And I thought your "the Citadel is half-organic" post was crazy.

[M Hedonist]

Seival wrote...

Yes, art. And ME Trilogy is a Masterpiece.

This coming from the one saying Deus Ex: Human Revolution would have been better with a proper Deus Ex Machina.

[Seival]

Sauruz wrote...

Seival wrote...

I have a feeling, that all ME3 DLCs will be free...

And I thought your "the Citadel is half-organic" post was crazy.

BioWare have an excellent money maker called ME3 Multiplayer. So my feeling about free DLCs is not unreasonable.

Sauruz wrote...

Seival wrote...

Yes, art. And ME Trilogy is a Masterpiece.

This coming from the one saying Deus Ex: Human Revolution would have been better with a proper Deus Ex Machina.

Yes.

Modifié par Seival, 10 juin 2012 - 11:53 .

[Seival]

The Angry One wrote...

Seival wrote...

Yes, art. And ME Trilogy is a Masterpiece.

I've just felt a great disturbance. As if millions of true artists from all of Earth's history cried out in disbelief and were suddenly silenced.

Some particular art can't be understood right away. It needs time to be processed.

[Seival]

filetemo wrote...

extended cut:

camera zooms in and grandpa and son are husks

Maybe... in case of Synthesis ending  

[M Hedonist]

Seival wrote...

Sauruz wrote...

Seival wrote...

I have a feeling, that all ME3 DLCs will be free...

And I thought your "the Citadel is half-organic" post was crazy.

BioWare have an excellent money maker called ME3 Multiplayer. So my feeling about free DLCs is not unreasonable.

That's the reason why MP DLC is for free. They still get enough money from people who pay real money for boosters trying to get the new characters and weapons. However, they gain nothing from releasing single player DLC for free other than good reputation, but they get enough of that for all the MP DLCs they release for free.

[Montana]

Yay, Shepard was so important we can't even be bothered to remember his name!

[Seival]

Sauruz wrote...

Seival wrote...

Sauruz wrote...

Seival wrote...

I have a feeling, that all ME3 DLCs will be free...

And I thought your "the Citadel is half-organic" post was crazy.

BioWare have an excellent money maker called ME3 Multiplayer. So my feeling about free DLCs is not unreasonable.

That's the reason why MP DLC is for free. They still get enough money from people who pay real money for boosters trying to get the new characters and weapons. However, they gain nothing from releasing single player DLC for free other than good reputation, but they get enough of that for all the MP DLCs they release for free.

I still think that ME3 Multiplayer might be the reason for all DLCs to be free. Well, it will depend on how good this money maker will really be of course... I already spent how many? Something like 200$ or so there. And I'm planning to spend even more.

Modifié par Seival, 11 juin 2012 - 12:02 .

[Seival]

The scene is not a "bad art" or "bad writing". It's just too short... And maybe they should place it before the titles, not after.

[The Night Mammoth]

Seival wrote...

The scene is not a "bad art" or "bad writing". It's just too short... And maybe they should place it before the titles, not after.

It's both. 

[Peranor]

The Angry One wrote...

Seival wrote...

Yes, art. And ME Trilogy is a Masterpiece.

I've just felt a great disturbance. As if millions of true artists from all of Earth's history cried out in disbelief and were suddenly silenced.

LOL

But truly, there is no art involved in the ending of Mass Effect 3 what so ever. Only pretentious bullcrap.

Modifié par anorling, 11 juin 2012 - 01:39 .

[Jenonax]

Seival wrote...

The scene is not a "bad art" or "bad writing". It's just too short... And maybe they should place it before the titles, not after.

Its both.  Its disconnected.  We have no idea who these people are, where they are, their relationship to each other, how much time has passed or anything else of value.

Utterly pointless and robs us of our actual conclusion, the one with the people we actually give a damn about, actually have an emotional connection with.

[tekkaman fear]

Scene=awful.