squee365 wrote...
What, Dark Souls? I doubt you have.Grubas wrote...
squee365 wrote...
If the Witcher 2 is mature and "intelligent" then Dark Souls is doctoral level intelligence and maturity.
Did you even play that game?
I think Dark Souls is intelligent and mature because the story is behind the narrative, you basically have to put together the pieces of the story yourself and actually have to have some imagination behind it to really figure out what happened. (in other words, its not spoon fed to you like 90% of videogames -- INCLUDING the Witcher)
That is just unfounded. You act as if spoon feeding is a flaw to narrative technique. Mystery is good, yet all it brings is speculation, and speculation isn't solid. I like G.R.R Martin's way of enigma, but to the point where your imagination is the only thing keeping a nonsensical narrative together? No, that's not good at all. The Witcher doesn't spoon feed you at all, it keeps you guessing too. Why is Raymond suddenly suspicious? Was he actually that kid? Will Iorvevth come back? What the hell happened with Letho and the sorcerreses lodge?
Both games have their flaws; yet their narratives are almost perfect. I've never seen such solid story-telling from a video game apart from Planescape: Torment and Baldur's Gate 1 and 2. Yet BG2 went for a more simpler approach, whilst TW2 (and the first one in some respects) is ASOIAF with Dwarves and Elves.





Guest_simfamUP_*
Retour en haut





