Aller au contenu

Photo

Edge magazine (UK) reviews DA:O - scores it 5/10


  • Ce sujet est fermé Ce sujet est fermé
294 réponses à ce sujet

#201
Guest_eisberg77_*

Guest_eisberg77_*
  • Guests

chuckles471 wrote...

If only people used this hatred for the people who deserve it... Child molesters, rapists, serial killers, defence lawyers, war criminals. bankers, politicians etc.

Nope, the hatred is used on a games magizine who doesn't like Dragon age, any game that isn't a traditional wRPG and any one who prefers to play a console to a PC.

And who said people on the internet where level headed. ;)


Why add Defence lawyers to that list?

#202
Blank Syndrome

Blank Syndrome
  • Members
  • 52 messages

Skellimancer wrote...

Blank Syndrome wrote...



Eh. Don't mind Skelli.


Care to add to that? :)


Oh, not so much. Thank you, though.

#203
Skellimancer

Skellimancer
  • Members
  • 2 207 messages

Blank Syndrome wrote...

Skellimancer wrote...

Blank Syndrome wrote...



Eh. Don't mind Skelli.


Care to add to that? :)


Oh, not so much. Thank you, though.


Yeah i thought not.

Bayonetta (X360)

12/25/09
Review
10/10
Might and Magic: Clash of Heroes (DS)

12/01/09
Review
9/10
Go Edge! cheques in the mail.

Modifié par Skellimancer, 13 décembre 2009 - 05:00 .


#204
chuckles471

chuckles471
  • Members
  • 608 messages

eisberg77 wrote...

chuckles471 wrote...

If only people used this hatred for the people who deserve it... Child molesters, rapists, serial killers, defence lawyers, war criminals. bankers, politicians etc.

Nope, the hatred is used on a games magizine who doesn't like Dragon age, any game that isn't a traditional wRPG and any one who prefers to play a console to a PC.

And who said people on the internet where level headed. ;)


Why add Defence lawyers to that list?


I was a scene of crime officer (Brittish CSI) for a year and lets just say that most of the really sucessful defence lawyers are sub-human parasites that feed off other peoples misery(I cannot go into details or I could get myself in trouble).Image IPB

#205
feroxthegreywarden

feroxthegreywarden
  • Members
  • 52 messages

eisberg77 wrote...

There is already a whole thread about this. To put it shortly, hardly anyone cares about a non important magazine. Most people haven't even heard about this magazine.



which is EXACTLY why they can actually be honest in their reviews, rather then pander to the big game corporations.


I wouldn't give it a 5 out of 10 though, maybe 7 out of 10, its a decent game with a great story and world lore, but the game itself is just... old.

#206
Skellimancer

Skellimancer
  • Members
  • 2 207 messages
Might and Magic: Clash of Heroes (DS)

Take a look at what game Edge gave 9/10 www.youtube.com/watch

if only Morrowind and Dragon Age were as deep.


#207
Guest_Ethan009_*

Guest_Ethan009_*
  • Guests

Skellimancer wrote...

So Edge think that Dragon Quest 8 on PS2 is vastly superior to Dragon Age.
Image IPB
DQ8 9/10


Ah..100 hours of DQ8 on my first playthrough. Good times, good times.

Also: DQ8 is not a kids game>_>

I'm so sick of Wrpg fanatics acting like they don't have just as many annoying cliches as Jrpgs. Seriously it gets old and annoying really, really, fast.

There's Wrpgs with great stories and there's Jrpgs that blow those stories out of the water. Let's judge the game by its main genre RPG not where it came from. >_>

Modifié par Ethan009, 13 décembre 2009 - 05:11 .


#208
Guest_SirenCurse_*

Guest_SirenCurse_*
  • Guests
All i'm going to say is that i love Dragon age origins for my xbox 360 and that i could care less what the people of Edge magazine things.

#209
Guest_eisberg77_*

Guest_eisberg77_*
  • Guests

chuckles471 wrote...

eisberg77 wrote...

chuckles471 wrote...

If only people used this hatred for the people who deserve it... Child molesters, rapists, serial killers, defence lawyers, war criminals. bankers, politicians etc.

Nope, the hatred is used on a games magizine who doesn't like Dragon age, any game that isn't a traditional wRPG and any one who prefers to play a console to a PC.

And who said people on the internet where level headed. ;)


Why add Defence lawyers to that list?


I was a scene of crime officer (Brittish CSI) for a year and lets just say that most of the really sucessful defence lawyers are sub-human parasites that feed off other peoples misery(I cannot go into details or I could get myself in trouble).Image IPB


Just a pet peeve of mine.  I have a friend who is a defense lawyer.  Something he said to me one  day "Even the innocent need a defense lawyer"

#210
Original182

Original182
  • Members
  • 1 111 messages
That means I won't be relying on Edge's reviews to buy games that I want.

Personally, I thought Dragon Age deserves at least 9/10. But seeing as Edge's taste in games is different from mine, I cannot use them to buy the games that I want.

#211
Skellimancer

Skellimancer
  • Members
  • 2 207 messages

Ethan009 wrote...

Skellimancer wrote...

So Edge think that Dragon Quest 8 on PS2 is vastly superior to Dragon Age.
Image IPB
DQ8 9/10


Ah..100 hours of DQ8 on my first playthrough. Good times, good times.

Also: DQ8 is not a kids game>_>

I'm so sick of Wrpg fanatics acting like they don't have just as many annoying cliches as Jrpgs. Seriously it gets old and annoying really, really, fast.

There's Wrpgs with great stories and there's Jrpgs that blow those stories out of the water. Let's judge the game by its main genre RPG not where it came from. >_>


Please share with us! Tell us the great JRPG story.

#212
Guest_Ethan009_*

Guest_Ethan009_*
  • Guests

Skellimancer wrote...

Ethan009 wrote...

Skellimancer wrote...

So Edge think that Dragon Quest 8 on PS2 is vastly superior to Dragon Age.
Image IPB
DQ8 9/10


Ah..100 hours of DQ8 on my first playthrough. Good times, good times.

Also: DQ8 is not a kids game>_>

I'm so sick of Wrpg fanatics acting like they don't have just as many annoying cliches as Jrpgs. Seriously it gets old and annoying really, really, fast.

There's Wrpgs with great stories and there's Jrpgs that blow those stories out of the water. Let's judge the game by its main genre RPG not where it came from. >_>


Please share with us! Tell us the great JRPG story.


*facepalms* Ugh. I'm not even getting into this because its obvious flame bait. Everything boils down to personal tastes.

Though fyi: lumping a genres into heaps doesn't do anything for your argument.

Edit: Also it being rated higher doesn't mean it was "deeper." could just be that it was a GAME as in you know : fun?

Jeez all this bashing because the game you like didn't get a high score. Its like children being angry at a contest because despite their efforts being recongized by others and given several awards didn't get one from X company because it wasn't what they liked. NM the fact that they have valid opinions. >_>

Modifié par Ethan009, 13 décembre 2009 - 05:21 .


#213
VanDraegon

VanDraegon
  • Members
  • 956 messages

Skellimancer wrote...

Might and Magic: Clash of Heroes (DS)

Take a look at what game Edge gave 9/10 www.youtube.com/watch

if only Morrowind and Dragon Age were as deep.



rofl

#214
chuckles471

chuckles471
  • Members
  • 608 messages

eisberg77 wrote...

chuckles471 wrote...

eisberg77 wrote...

chuckles471 wrote...

If only people used this hatred for the people who deserve it... Child molesters, rapists, serial killers, defence lawyers, war criminals. bankers, politicians etc.

Nope, the hatred is used on a games magizine who doesn't like Dragon age, any game that isn't a traditional wRPG and any one who prefers to play a console to a PC.

And who said people on the internet where level headed. ;)


Why add Defence lawyers to that list?


I was a scene of crime officer (Brittish CSI) for a year and lets just say that most of the really sucessful defence lawyers are sub-human parasites that feed off other peoples misery(I cannot go into details or I could get myself in trouble).Image IPB


Just a pet peeve of mine.  I have a friend who is a defense lawyer.  Something he said to me one  day "Even the innocent need a defense lawyer"


Sorry off-topic.

I have been told that but I always reply "Yeah but a innocent person doesn't need a really expensive one with a history of getting cases throwing out on technicalities".

#215
Blank Syndrome

Blank Syndrome
  • Members
  • 52 messages

Ethan009 wrote...

*facepalms* Ugh. I'm not even getting into this because its obvious flame bait. Everything boils down to personal tastes.

Though fyi: lumping a genres into heaps doesn't do anything for your argument.

Edit: Also it being rated higher doesn't mean it was "deeper." could just be that it was a GAME as in you know : fun?

Jeez all this bashing because the game you like didn't get a high score. Its like children being angry at a contest because despite their efforts being recongized by others and given several awards didn't get one from X company because it wasn't what they liked. NM the fact that they have valid opinions. >_>


Psh. Your weeaboo RPG couldn't possibly have a plot as amazing as "SAVE THE LAND FROM THE BLIGHT!" ;)

Modifié par Blank Syndrome, 13 décembre 2009 - 05:24 .


#216
Guest_Ethan009_*

Guest_Ethan009_*
  • Guests

Blank Syndrome wrote...

Ethan009 wrote...

*facepalms* Ugh. I'm not even getting into this because its obvious flame bait. Everything boils down to personal tastes.

Though fyi: lumping a genres into heaps doesn't do anything for your argument.

Edit: Also it being rated higher doesn't mean it was "deeper." could just be that it was a GAME as in you know : fun?

Jeez all this bashing because the game you like didn't get a high score. Its like children being angry at a contest because despite their efforts being recongized by others and given several awards didn't get one from X company because it wasn't what they liked. NM the fact that they have valid opinions. >_>


Psh. Your weeaboo RPG couldn't possibly have a plot as amazing as "SAVE THE LAND FROM THE BLIGHT!" ;)


XD All your base are belong to us!

Good times, good times

But but, :"( Saving the world from NYX!!!! And, and, the embodiment of evil!!! The horde of villians!!! Tis totally not cliche'd or unoriginal at all!!!!

XD

Modifié par Ethan009, 13 décembre 2009 - 05:40 .


#217
Skellimancer

Skellimancer
  • Members
  • 2 207 messages

Ethan009 wrote...


XD All your base are belong to us!

Good times, good times

But but, :"( Saving the world from NYX!!!! And, and, the embodiment of evil!!! The horde of villians!!! Tis totally not cliche'd or unoriginal at all!!!!

XD


Image IPB

#218
zeejay21

zeejay21
  • Members
  • 226 messages
If you were asking me, I say I don't trust Edge magazine. They said Mario 64 is the best game ever made in the only one magazine I bought (never again after that) even eclipsing MGS (in a year where people go all action crazy!) - really, do they play games? Or just write their opinions no matter what? I never read Edge again - besides they put columns of articles that were boring to read.

I missed EGM.... :(

Modifié par zeejay21, 13 décembre 2009 - 05:58 .


#219
Guest_Ethan009_*

Guest_Ethan009_*
  • Guests

Skellimancer wrote...

Ethan009 wrote...


XD All your base are belong to us!

Good times, good times

But but, :"( Saving the world from NYX!!!! And, and, the embodiment of evil!!! The horde of villians!!! Tis totally not cliche'd or unoriginal at all!!!!

XD


Image IPB


LOL 

Both sides do it! It's equally hilarious. What irks me is when one side says the other doesn't: :lol:

http://gza.gameriot...._1257581825.png

You know I <3 you Bio. XD 

#220
Skellimancer

Skellimancer
  • Members
  • 2 207 messages

Ethan009 wrote...


LOL 

Both sides do it! It's equally hilarious. What irks me is when one side says the other doesn't: :lol:

http://gza.gameriot...._1257581825.png

You know I <3 you Bio. XD 




:) All RPG's are guilty of using the same material in some way.

#221
Sam -stone- serious

Sam -stone- serious
  • Members
  • 235 messages

Skellimancer wrote...

Might and Magic: Clash of Heroes (DS)

Take a look at what game Edge gave 9/10 www.youtube.com/watch

if only Morrowind and Dragon Age were as deep.


Lets see, Mario RPG 3 on the DS got universaly better scores from DAO  as well. Oh oh, you will not agree. That cant be true. A  "kids" game, with no blood, with no 3D visuals, with no "seriousness" that is out on the freakin DS is better than the mammoth masterpiece that the people at Bioware have worked for years?  Call the game police. I  DEMAND  for the Mario RPG 3 to be lowered in score just to make it seem that DAO  is better :whistle:

#222
ToJKa1

ToJKa1
  • Members
  • 1 246 messages

Ethan009 wrote...

There's Wrpgs with great stories and there's Jrpgs that blow those stories out of the water. Let's judge the game by its main genre RPG not where it came from. >_>


Indeed, the Xenosaga trilogy storyline for example was so complex that after several playtroughs i still haven't gotten it completely, not mention Xenogears :D

Dragon age is easy though, save the world from an undead dragon and it's horde of nasty creatures, that kill people because they've nothing better to do.

#223
Skellimancer

Skellimancer
  • Members
  • 2 207 messages

Sam -stone- serious wrote...

Skellimancer wrote...

Might and Magic: Clash of Heroes (DS)

Take a look at what game Edge gave 9/10 www.youtube.com/watch

if only Morrowind and Dragon Age were as deep.


Lets see, Mario RPG 3 on the DS got universaly better scores from DAO  as well. Oh oh, you will not agree. That cant be true. A  "kids" game, with no blood, with no 3D visuals, with no "seriousness" that is out on the freakin DS is better than the mammoth masterpiece that the people at Bioware have worked for years?  Call the game police. I  DEMAND  for the Mario RPG 3 to be lowered in score just to make it seem that DAO  is better :whistle:



If you prefer Super Mario bros arpeegee then you are welcome to it. I prefer a story deeper than saving the mushroom kingdom.

Also SMB3 on the NES is the only real Mario game worth noting. Amazing game that fended off the so called superior 16bit  Genesis for a long time in gameplay quality.

#224
Relshar

Relshar
  • Members
  • 682 messages
They rated Assassins Creed 8/10 and Call of Duty 9/10 you can see what kind of games they like. Ones without depth and rehashed missions like AC.

#225
MR-9

MR-9
  • Members
  • 300 messages

Skellimancer wrote...


Also SMB3 on the NES is the only real Mario game worth noting. Amazing game that fended off the so called superior 16bit  Genesis for a long time in gameplay quality.


This should be required American History in school. Super Mario Bros. 3 is beyond epic.