234 réponses à ce sujet

[d-boy15]

7/10

[IntoTheDarkness]

story: 4/10
gameplay: 9/10
replayability: 7/10

8/10 total. A slight improvement from DA2.

Modifié par IntoTheDarkness, 15 juin 2012 - 01:34 .

[SwiftSlash]

Hard to think about the game's score without the ending. I would give it a 9-9.5 without the current ending, however I am extremely biased. I love the series. Its idea, execution, and carryout has had me sold since just after Eden Prime (the first time, you know, story content included on the disc).

Also, I give games their final verdict on how much I enjoyed them. Yeah, the lack of customization was there, and yeah the fetch quests and appropriate tracking of said quests is apparent; did that take away from my enjoyment of the game? No. Do I wish they did things differently? Some. As an effort from Bioware, I stand by my score sans ending.

With ending? 7.5ish. It effects what I feel, but doesn't change the 30 hour roller-coaster I just got derailed from.

All that aside, I've played 1&2 5-6 times, and on their scale I would be wrapping up my third or fourth runs right about meow (like I'd planned since I got the release date)....I finished my second with no will to keep going.

Modifié par SwiftSlash, 15 juin 2012 - 01:36 .

[ref]

I'd say a 6.5 or 7. Still lots of flaws, some parts are really good, others aren't.

[hoodaticus]

Without the ending, it would have gotten a 10/10, if 10 means "superlative" rather than "perfect". If 10 means "perfect", then they get a 7/10 because of 1) rushed storytelling (tried to tell the story of an entire galactic war in a single game - and it shows) and 2) some inattention to detail in several glaring places that contributes further to the sense that the game was born prematurely.

They get seven points because this game did achieve perfection in combat and atmosphere, music and graphics and more.  Lately I can't get through a play through because I keep replaying the first few missions because they are so thoroughly enjoyable.  The game is truly awesome in many ways, unfortunately that does not include any part of the plot in any way, shape, or form.  I just watched my YouTube video of me2 ending and i have to say - it's far more glorious than The entirety of me3.

Modifié par hoodaticus, 15 juin 2012 - 02:07 .

[PyroMattFTW]

7/10

Ending aside, there are still a number of issues which set the game back for me, even on the first run (where I tend to ignore many of them).

[Darc_Requiem]

7/10

Even setting the ending a side there are number of problems that annoy me about ME3. The auto dialog severely limits your control of Shepard's personality. The ME2 cast is reduced to cameo status with only two members actually having importance to the story. The neutral dialog option is MIA. The eavesdropping side quest mechanic is off putting. The quest journal is an abomination.

Modifié par Darc_Requiem, 15 juin 2012 - 02:23 .

[DaAce3252]

9.9/10 ... ME1, 2 & 3 are still my favorite games by far

[o Ventus]

DaAce3252 wrote...

9.9/10 ... ME1, 2 & 3 are still my favorite games by far

So how did you feel effectively destroying the galaxy?

[The_Other_M]

GLR-0053 wrote...

Mdoggy1214 wrote...

It's a 7.5/10 for me. Even without the weaksauce ending, it's the weakest entry in the trilogy for me, and i'll quickly list off my reasons:

1. Bad journal system
2. Auto Dialogue
3. Side quests reduced to boring eavesdropping scanning quests
4. Romance scenes for most characters are pitiful
5. Final mission is rushed and anticlimatic
6. Intro is rushed and sloppy
7. No exploration
8. No boss fight
9. A lot of choices didn't amount to anything
10. Too much emphasis on MP
11. Vent kid
12. Day 1 DLC

This is why I got a bit of a problem when people say the first 99% of the game is perfect.

^^^This although I wouldn't give it a 7.5 though. I'd give it a plain old 7.0

^^Ditto. ---Though my list would have #9 occupy the #1 spot.
Other than that I'd give ME3 a 6.0

[UpDownLeftRight]

Around six or seven out of ten. It is a fun as a 'pew pew' game.

[PencilManners]

Well without the ending, its okay but I would say it'd the worst of the series.

While the combat is the best, we only fight against Cerberus, Geth and Reapers, which makes some of the game play feel abit repetitive.
The game feels incredibly linear, and the plot sometimes forces my Shepard to be what he's not (i.e. mourning for the kid in particular out of everyone else who has died)
There are barely any side missions, I am not counting those lazy fetch quests.
the dialogue wheel gets confusing sometimes, as in sometimes options on the left side of the wheel continue the conversation or open up other options (I still haven't made the illusive man shoot himself yet)
Less companions than me2, understandable but annoying, didn't like Vega, he was only interesting for one conversation in sparring but that was it. It also seems I am missing out on an entertaining squad mate, to bad he was day 1 dlc.

I am not saying it hasn't got its good points. Theres Tuchanka, Rannoch, drunk Tali, Multiplayer etc.

overall I say its a 7 out of 10

[ElectroNeonPanda]

christrek1982 wrote...

the worst part of it was when I tried to start a new ME1 play through got to the character creation screen and just thought "what's the point shepards only going to die in the end and nothing good happens at the end" then I turned it off

so it's killed all three games for me.

Yeah, this is how I feel with ME2 now let alone another ME3 playthrough.  Why bother when the expected epic arse-kicking is reduced down to Shep having to make three decisions that go counter to everything that came before it and just left you feeling cold.  Even now I'm still waiting for my fourth option where I get to kick the Reapers in their space fruits and head off to recapture Omega so I can have some wild blueberry craziness with Aria. 

Modifié par ElectroNeonPanda, 15 juin 2012 - 05:17 .

[zambot]

8.5/10. I have to ding it for tying MP to SP, and I felt the overhearing fetch quests were a step backwards rather than forwards. Overall though the gameplay was smooth and enjoyable, and the story was very compelling, especially around Tuchanka and Rannoch.

[saturos2]

with the ending- 4.5/10
without the ending- a 6/10
for a hyped AAA title from a well know developer, ME3 turned out to be a flop with fans.
tuchanka was worth it, but the rest of the game is bug ridden and filled with bad writing and i felt
like i was being forced to care about the characters and situations.

[Toki]

7/10. Some strong missions, crap journal and side missions, squadmates really blow, overerall really rushed game (which means missing features or lacking squadmates/missions (such as Earth)

The missions were really amazing; usually emotional or well-written, while the side missions sucked (besides the N7 missions) as they were 90% fetch quests.

The squadmates really suck. It's ME1 + Sexbox -Wrex + James. EDI was a terrible idea imo, James is like Jacob as you forget he's there/don't care. Tali and Garrus are good characters (I have a personal distaste for Tali, but she's good and should stay). Liara is as boring and annoying as ever. Ashley/Kaiden doesn't even have proper dialogue aboard the Normandy. Javik is good, but not everybody has access to him. Seriously, it's hard to enjoy other playthroughs of this game because I'm always using Garrus and Javik/Ashley because I can't stand anybody else. Every single ME2 character is tossed aside that should have joined you (Miranda, Grunt, Legion shouldn't die as the choice should be Geth (Legion) vs. Quarians (Tali) as squadmates, Thane should have been cured and not forgotten about). It irks me as my reason for not wanting to replay is for my distaste in the squad choices. In ME1 I liked Ashley, Wrex, and Garrus, which leaves me in the same situation but I don't mind it as much for some reason.

Allot of autodialogue and some stupid things like Shepard being Earth-centric, only allowing to care about Kaiden/Ashley, not able to agree with the Illusive Man ever, ect. It seems way too streamlined and way too rushed of a game. It's fun, don't get me wrong, but not playing through it seven tims worthy like ME2.

The multiplayer is loads of fun, and I'm loving all of the DLC that's coming out for it. I'm surprised by how much I'm enjoying it, actually. It's not perfect, but it's definitely fun. 

Modifié par Vulsamee, 15 juin 2012 - 07:12 .

[eoinnx03]

I can't really decide. The ending is one thing, Biowares response just made me angry, so I can't think properly about the game. Maybe in a few years I might play it again and reflect.

[TheKevinShow]

Overall, I give it an 8/10. No, the game is not perfect, but the overall package is good... up until the ending.

It's still fun for me. Regardless of the ending, I'm still enjoying doing my 1-2-3 playthrough.

[Fireblader70]

I'm going to be shocking here and say that, despite some small flaws, I would give ME3 - as a standalone game - a 9/10. Yes, the journal sucks. Yes, there are plenty of fetch quests. However, there are also plenty of great missions where you can take part in the vastly improved gameplay, and the autodialogue is hardly a crime when you can still shape your Shepard however you wish.

The Citadel is bursting with atmosphere, the Normandy feels darker and more suited to the tone of the game, squad members have their own lives, dialogue and voice acting is mostly excellent, choices are not always 'good or evil' (due to reputation system), writing is mostly excellent, all of your previous squad members and acquaintances return, gameplay is more action-heavy to fit the tone, your choices are reflected and the context behind missions can dramatically change.

The actual plot is pretty simple - the Reapers attack Earth in force, while also attacking other areas of the galaxy. Since Earth is hit the hardest, and humanity is the species chosen to be truly harvested into a Reaper, Shepard attempts to unite a galaxy and build the Crucible to hopefully end the war. I can't find many genuinely narrative shattering plot holes in the main body of the story, but there are one or two niggles and mysteries that are never explained directly.

Overall, I found it to be a thrilling, emotional ride that stands as high as its predecessors. And, yes, I prefer those fetch quests to the mind-numbingly half-assed side quests in the first game, as I have found out from my recent playthrough of the whole trilogy...

[The Sacred One]

With the ending: 3/10
Without the ending: 7/10

I enjoyed Mass Effect more for the story than the gameplay, and I felt that ME3 lacked that a lot. Sure many aspects of combat were improved and I enjoyed that, but is that what made Mass Effect the series it was? I wanted to feel what I felt when I first played ME1. It was like escaping into an alternative life, but ME3 just didn't make this happen. The ending took away any replayability (haven't played it since my first playthrough) and that feeling where none of your choices really matter makes ME3 such a repulsive game.

[warrior256]

I think that even without the endings, I would have to rate ME3 around a 6.5 out of 10. I'm sorry, but this game has a LOT of flaws. Autodiologue, terrible side quests, shorter story, glitches etc. all add up to an ok game at best. Even if the ending had been great, I think I would still have to force myself to play through ME3. I would still be able to, don't get me wrong, but it would still be the black sheep of the trilogy.

[Shiroshibal]

Gameplay itself and also just playing through it it was extremely fun, just for that I could rate it 9/10 or higher...

But then, especially after playing ME1 abit again, the autodialogue is extremely disappointing, not even on Insane difficulty it is anyhow challenging, barely any sidequests, exploration etc.

So I'd put it on 8/10, the worst of the 3 games unfortunately only getting alot worse with the ending.

[julio77777]

I'd give it a 7/10, good game but rushed and it shows it would have greatly benefited from a little more polishing. Shame.

[AlienWolf728]

8/10... good game, but not the godsend that people try to make it out to be; certainly not worth the "75 perfect scores!"

Modifié par AlienWolf728, 16 juin 2012 - 12:21 .