234 réponses à ce sujet

[mambastyle]

I'd rate it a 7/10. It gets dinged for the endings and the SP/MP tie in. Most of the smaller issues that the game has gets balanced out by the things BW finally got right with the game that I particularly enjoyed. But still, in the end, all together, a 7. Decent, maybe even good, but nowhere near great.

[D1ck1e]

7

[_aLucidMind_]

ME3 with the ending- 6

ME3 ignoring the ending- 8

Modifié par _aLucidMind_, 16 juin 2012 - 05:48 .

[TookYoCookies]

5/10 game sucked.

Was like a futuristic call of duty, decisions sucked, auto dialogue, Linear, fetch quests.. A bunch been there done that.

[Hackulator]

9.5/10 if we're not including the ending, one of my favorite games of all time.

[huntsman2310]

Yeah I loved the story and dialogue, and the combat only added to it.

8.5

[EnvyTB075]

5-6/10, or if you're like me and hate numerical grading systems, C-....don't ask what it would be with the ending added on.

No, i'm not trolling nor am i trying to be an ass. The story is hopeless from the get go, dialogue was scaled back to the point where the dialogue wheel should have been omitted altogether, the Renagade/Paragon styles were made utterly irrelevant, vehicle sections are gone, mini-games for opening boxes and doors n'stuff are no where to be seen, only one hub world whose colour pallet gives me headaches and i'm struggling to differentiate the basic combat from every other 3rd person cover shooter out there.

The other thing i actually enjoy in this game is the MP, just because i can play as a Turian. As for the rest, ME2 is vastly superior in every form, except perhaps the visuals but thats just rivet counting.

If ME3 had turned out to be a re-skinned ME2, i would not have been unhappy. The combat, the dialogue, the game environment, the weapons, none of that actually needed such drastic changes, just some tidying around the edges and it would have been fine.

Modifié par EnvyTB075, 16 juin 2012 - 06:50 .

[Asharad Hett]

First play 8/10
Replay value 3/10

[SaladinDheonqar]

7.

[QwertyMusicMan]

Mdoggy1214 wrote...

It's a 7.5/10 for me. Even without the weaksauce ending, it's the weakest entry in the trilogy for me, and i'll quickly list off my reasons:

1. Bad journal system
2. Auto Dialogue
3. Side quests reduced to boring eavesdropping scanning quests
4. Romance scenes for most characters are pitiful
5. Final mission is rushed and anticlimatic
6. Intro is rushed and sloppy
7. No exploration
8. No boss fight
9. A lot of choices didn't amount to anything
10. Too much emphasis on MP
11. Vent kid
12. Day 1 DLC

This is why I got a bit of a problem when people say the first 99% of the game is perfect.

This. I would give it around a 7/10 overall, even without the ending. It was a good game the first time through, but after thining about it for a while and playing it a second time, just becaue it was so underwhelming compared to ME2 I might give it a 6/10.

[Ravenard]

Without ending 8.5/10 it's a good game, not a masterpiece

[AlexPorto111]

10 out of 10

Yeah,i am not kidding.I loved ME3,even with the problems.Playing the game was a fantastic and unforggetable experience.

[Aurora313]

Some of the immersion breaking content, such as shoving Liara down my throat and forcing me to be her friend when I've been completely renegade to her in the last few games really pisses me off (Aethyta calling me her boyfriend when I'm romancing/loyal to Ash pisses me off majorly too.). But I'd rate it in the 8/8.5 range.

Modifié par Aurora313, 16 juin 2012 - 07:21 .

[StElmo]

7

[Iceyonline]

Emotion wise: 9/10. I laugh, I cried and I cared about the characters. (except the kid... who was he again? Why should I care about him?)
Gameplay: 6/10. Sides questions and scanning knocked it down. Minor bugs here and there. Didn't really bring anything new.
With Ending: 3/10. In truth, it was going to be 1/10 but I decided to give you a point for each horrible ending choice. You can colour each with your favourite colour (limited to red, green or blue)

[Xamufam]

6/10

[What a Succulent Ass]

5 - 6.

[naddaya]

6/10. Didn't like the story, didn't like the autodialogue.

[SpamBot2000]

Not really one to stick a number on things, all I know I was really into it - and then suddenly and horribly not. I don't normally go all nuts on a game developer's forum, so read what you will into that.

[Herr Igor]

6.5/10 and BIOWARE should be thankful for that.

[Forbry]

ME1: 7,5 or 8

ME2: 9 or 9,5

ME3: 8,5 or 9

Best game (series) of all time for me! (I don't grade high that easy/quick )

Modifié par Forbry, 01 juillet 2012 - 08:01 .

[AlexPorto111]

Forbry wrote...

ME1: 7,5 or 8

ME2: 9 or 9,5

ME3: 8,5 or 9

Best game (series) of all time for me! (I don't grade high that easy/quick )

Yeah same for me.The only games that deserves a 10/10 IMO are MGS4,Zelda Ocarina of Time,ME2 and ME3.

ME1: 9,5
ME2: 10
ME3: 10

Best trilogy ever made indeed.

[Dendio1]

As a fan of the series, who has seen its characters grow from episode 1, I'd give it a 9.

For first timers i'd give it an 8.

I agree with the poster above. This is by far the best trilogy i've ever played.

Modifié par Dendio1, 01 juillet 2012 - 08:10 .

[flipyap343]

I'll give it an 8/10 if you don't count the ending (it's practically a separate game for me anyway)

It had superb voice-acting, the combat felt fluid (even on MP), and the cinematography, combined with the amazing score and (usually) great writing, made it an unforgettable experience. The "lazy" graphics didn't really bother me, as I'd rather have those resources put into the story anyway.

However, the game is bogged down by the relative lack of choices, horrible journal system, occasional plot holes, and limited sidequests.

Modifié par flipyap343, 01 juillet 2012 - 08:11 .

[2Shepards]

8.5  7.8

The one thing that actually pi**ed me off other then the endings, was the freaking journal/active mission or rather lack there of.


-also forgot auto dialogue and no exploration.

Modifié par 2Shepards, 01 juillet 2012 - 08:15 .