Landon7001 wrote...
3DandBeyond wrote...
Although I tended to most often save Ashley, it is still bugging me. Her first appearance was kind of scary-ME1 hair. But in ME3, she's really shocking. If you look at her hair behind her right ear, her head has some black smudging on it. Worst of all is her "uniform". I recently took another look at it and it looks like her uniform has designs on the legs meant to look like she's wearing stockings and garters. Apparently for women in the Alliance, the new look is straight out of Trashy Women Today. And what is up with her dialogue? "Sorry for keeping you out of the loop."
Still and all, I did feel sorry for her in ME1, liked Kaidan until he tried to insinuate Shepard was being unprofessional in getting friendly with Liara, and then he started expressing feelings for Shepard. Oh well. I did like his final words to Shepard if they have a romance, and maybe the EC will give Kaidan lovers some reunion as well as all the other LIs.
ok you guys are pissing me off....ash is my all time favorite me character and main LI, shes not racist or whiny.....you clearly werent paying attention when she rejected shepard in me 2 for working for pro human extremists
Sorry didn't mean to ****** you off-I never saw her as racist and I actually was trying to say I liked her. I don't dislike Kaidan either-I just thought some of the dialogue was "off". In ME1, I liked her too and some of the conversations my Shepard had with her were some of the most poignant-"Ash how long are you going to.....", you know where Shepard keeps telling her she doesn't have to pay for what happened with her grandfather. My Shepard had her back and wanted her to be a real member of the team. I chose her instead of Kaidan because of some of the stupid dialogue set up for Kaidan, but because my Shepard said to Ash she'd choose Kaidan if it was about using the brain, and choose her if it was about the heart. It made me want to cry a bit.
I fully understood why she rejected Shepard in ME2-in fact, I see her as someone Shepard helped find redemption. Ashley was hurt and confused by what Shepard had done. In fact, her continued reference to how Shepard might have been changed was more because she cared and was afraid for Shepard as I see it, than anything else.
I just didn't like it that they tried to make her appear stupid in some scenes. That opening part is funny if your character never romanced Ashley. A friend of mine was over when I was creating a truly horrible looking female Shepard for my renegade. I played the opening and Ashley looks like she loves Shepard, even my ugly disinterested female one. It could be seen as hero worship, but the dialogue is also "off" when she says that, "sorry for keeping you out of the loop, ma'am." To me, it just sounded funny. But, the look she gives Shepard is kind of in context with her statement in ME2 about Shepard being a god-she just worries along the way that she's wrong about that.
I don't think they did her justice is all, but then that's true of a lot of the characters-in many places Liara looks scary and looks spacey and her dialogue doesn't match events in the game. I've said this and I most often chose her for the LI. There's the initial meeting for Liara and Shepard on Illium in Liara's office where I think they are supposed to be kissing or something and Liara is like rubbing her nose in the air. It's weird. Kaidan has similar moments of odd dialogue.
And as far as trashy looks go-I will say they did this with all the females and then threw James in as some counter measure I guess. I said as much in the other thread we participated in. But to make it more equal they should have put James in a speedo with a codpiece.
Modifié par 3DandBeyond, 24 juin 2012 - 05:02 .