Okies, finally fully completed all three endings and I had to take a step back and let it all sink in.
Now, I made no secret that I really hated the original ending and there are many valid reason why I did so.
So, please bear with me as I go through each and from each ending my thoughts on them.
I will have to say firstly though that while the many dialogues did in fact lessen the "wtf" moments and did try to explain or at least lessen the "wtf" reaction one had with the original ending it still boils down to this: Starbrat is a construct that is flawed. It created the first Reapers murdering the original organics that created it (starbrat).
Thus he fulfil his own "the created will always rebel against their creators" and then follows up by "reaping" sentient races every 50k years or so.
At this point, listening to it, it is obvious that it is insane.
So, thus we come to the one choice that would have made sense and kept true to Shepard's character whether Paragon or Renegade.
Reject.
Shepard, especially femshep delivered his her lines so beautifully, it was a fist pumping, tears to the eye moment.
Then, immediately following that high note, the middle finger.
Let me clarify that I went into the game with 15,000++ ems at 100% Galactic readiness. So EMS wasn't the issue.
Simply put, the writers just said "FU! Shepard is going to die, you wanted this "reject option" you got it!"
While I have to say that it was something I suggested, as I do remember posting a scenario exactly like this early on in the old "endings : we are listening" thread, it was a suggestion in context of a "no win scenario", meaning no matter what we did, Shepard dies, war is lost. And thus to see this ending used in context to the ending where Shepard is principly true to character, kept his integrity and honor, to see this "you die no matter what! Too bad!" is both sad and blatant in its message to us fans.
What that message is, I'll leave to your own interpretation.
I do recommend however talking to the catalyst and get Shepard to choose that REJECT all the above choices instead of agreeing then shooting the starbrat.
Trying to shoot the starbrat immediately puts it in "tantrum mode".
Shepard's lines are amazing. IF only for 10 seconds.
Then its game over. You all die, some other cycle with Liara's gift won the war against the reapers. *writers raspberry at you!*
Now assuming if you like me, don't care anymore about just how rediculous it is to accept ANY choice made and given by an insane contruct and "went with the flow" just to see what you get, both control and destroy has been cleaned up quite significantly.
Control probably the least revolting of the lot.
Since you do not have to betray the Geth, don't have to murder EDI and actually puts you in position to be the guardian of the galaxy.
Right.
Actually Control isn't half bad if you allow for some inconsistancies and pull a thicker wool of suspension of disbelief over your eyes.
So with that said, it was the ONLY one of the original three that I would have chosen, taking into consideration that you will be willfully ignoring the fact that you, both the player and Shepard now know that the Catalsyst ;
1) is insane
2) is flawed
3) would kill you if you do not follow its agenda (reject option for the player, it tells you that it murdered its creators to make them unwilling reapers for Shepard)
Anyways.
I am not going to go on with the other 2 options as while they are nicely done and actually make some sense now, they are still very much against what my Shepard stood and fought for.
IF I could ignore that little point.
Again, as I have said before, its a much better ending then what we originally got.
So.
Is the EC worth it.
Yes. I'd canon on the reject option, or maybe Control (if I figure my Shepard is stoned out of his mind due to battle fatique) and the EC did give a certain ammount of satisfaction based ont THOSE endings.
Would I replay the game, maybe.
It really depends on my mood, depending how tolerant I think I'll be feeling but it is for certain the endings as a whole, has rob me of any enthusiasm in wanting to replay the game much.
Bottom line, the message is clear from the writers that they want Shepard to die no mater what, I have no more interest in furthering the "middle portion" of this saga but always, in the end see Shepard die.
Thanks but I don't need to punish myself that way.
I do need to say thank you Bioware, for at least trying, though I am pretty sure there were a few digs at us fans, but whatever. You had your fun.
Now I'll go find mine, elsewhere.
Modifié par Archonsg, 27 juin 2012 - 08:50 .