126 réponses à ce sujet

[darthnick427]

Mr. Gogeta34 wrote...

Hackett is very clear that all technology/machines that were destroyed can be rebuilt/recovered. That includes the Geth and EDI. Just a minor setback. Destroy is easily the best ending.

You lose nothing (for long) and Shepard survives (far as I know).

Exactly my thoughts on it. We can rebuild them. Destroy is obviously the best ending

[MerchantGOL]

Control. Easy.

[Bfler]

Destroy, same as before.

Control is scary with Shepards voice and the music.
Synthesis is against my principles.

[Creighton72]

Red, for pretty simple reasons actually. I don;t want to get in a circular debate about the logic problems and plot holes of the different endings so to keep it simple:

1. I have no reason to trust the Catalyst, given his actions I would rather see him and his giant death machines out buisness permanantly. I don't want them walking around, I don't want to use them, I want them destroyed. I have no idea if they are going to one day turn and start killing everyone. Consider it destroying weapons of mass destruction.

2. I think the Catalyst is an idiot and I refuse to take any advice from a little monster, forced advice at that. Advice at gun point so to speak. I don;t trust the other endings, generally being granted all the power or being given a push button utopia have come with a very dangerous price tag. The little monster created a cycle, created a problem, and then came up with the worst possible solution to a problem anyone could have come up with. His Solution to a problem he caused. No thank you

3. Third and final, I want revenge, I want a reckoning, I want to settle accounts. The Catalyst ran up a hefty debt of blood for countless cycles, and he is going to pay what he owes. His list of crimes reads like a demons resume. I may not be able to save everyone with the red ending, but you can be damn sure i'll avenge them.

That's right I ripped off the Avengers, cause it's freaking awesome. If Udson can rip off Deus X, I can rip off the Avengers.

[SmartRetard]

Control because it still was the best and only option to me. Don't understand the whole creepy shepard thing. I noticed that I got the good control ending and I was happy with that. My shepard would watch over the other races.

Here is the good control

Skip to 15:30

Bad Control in which shepard sounds evil

skip to 8:10

Modifié par SmartRetard, 27 juin 2012 - 07:15 .

[shin-zan]

The catalyst says Shepard will die too but we know that's not true so there's a precedence of him being full of it.

Moreso the geth are just programs, even if their platforms are destroyed the AI of them would survive, remember that if you made peace a bunch of them are uploaded into the Quarian's suits, then there's others uploaded into their cyber cities etc.

[tenojitsu]

Don't know, I really like them all now

[Creighton72]

SmartRetard wrote...

Control but it still was the best and only option to me. Don't understand the whole creepy shepard thing. I noticed that I got the good control ending and I was happy with that. My shepard would watch over the other races.

He isn't your Shepard anymore. Don't forget that, you no longer control him or have any imput.

[Starshadow2010]

The Red one, as usual. 
Have nothing against Control or Refusal, but Synthesis still feels the worst, despite authors attempts to make it look like the best ending. I respect the ideas of transhumanism, but, aside from moral issues with such choice, the entire mechanics behind the transformation is too much spacemagical to my taste

Modifié par Starshadow2010, 27 juin 2012 - 07:16 .

[Creighton72]

shin-zan wrote...

The catalyst says Shepard will die too but we know that's not true so there's a precedence of him being full of it.

Moreso the geth are just programs, even if their platforms are destroyed the AI of them would survive, remember that if you made peace a bunch of them are uploaded into the Quarian's suits, then there's others uploaded into their cyber cities etc.

So is Edi, can say reboot after you remove some bad programs. We are given the knowledge that we can actually enter a geth mainframe and remove reaper code., cause we do it in the game.

[SmartRetard]

Creighton72 wrote...

SmartRetard wrote...

Control but it still was the best and only option to me. Don't understand the whole creepy shepard thing. I noticed that I got the good control ending and I was happy with that. My shepard would watch over the other races.

He isn't your Shepard anymore. Don't forget that, you no longer control him or have any imput.

Ah yes true. I like to believe that with my shepard's memories and thoughts a part of him still lives on in the Reapers. The part that remembers the sacrifices it took to achieve this victory.

[ScreamingRaptor]

Conclusion, Bioware have been indoctrinated.

[TheDarkShape]

darthnick427 wrote...

Exactly my thoughts on it. We can rebuild them.

Sure, but they won't be them anymore than you can replace a dead child by knocking out another one.  EDI and the Geth are/were living things.

[Tommyspa]

Gotta admit, they made control sound really good.

[Creighton72]

Creighton72 wrote...

shin-zan wrote...

The catalyst says Shepard will die too but we know that's not true so there's a precedence of him being full of it.

Moreso the geth are just programs, even if their platforms are destroyed the AI of them would survive, remember that if you made peace a bunch of them are uploaded into the Quarian's suits, then there's others uploaded into their cyber cities etc.

So is Edi, can say reboot after you remove some bad programs. We are given the knowledge that we can actually enter a geth mainframe and remove reaper code., cause we do it in the game.

One other thing, the Relays are also Reaper tech and the game says we fix them in the red ending. If we can fix them we can fix the Geth and Edi.

[SimKoning]

Control was awesome

[darkchief10]

Control: I will use the reapers to protect the many.

[Rahmiel]

I liked synthesis before the EC, but now seeing the long term outcome.. I really dislike it. I dislike everything about it. Everything being synthetic, synthetics having emotions and knowing what it's like to be organic. It's just.. it pretty much kills the ME universe, imo. I mean, should they make another game in the series, how are they going to handle that?

Destroy keeps the universe in as much the same way as you started the series. No reapers. I like that. Sucks we destroy the geth and edi. That's the sacrifice though. Now the reaper threat is gone for good. We'll handle a synthetic crisis in the future.

The reject ending is of course, the best written/dialogue. Just has the worst outcome.

[Creighton72]

SmartRetard wrote...

Creighton72 wrote...

SmartRetard wrote...

Control but it still was the best and only option to me. Don't understand the whole creepy shepard thing. I noticed that I got the good control ending and I was happy with that. My shepard would watch over the other races.

He isn't your Shepard anymore. Don't forget that, you no longer control him or have any imput.

Ah yes true. I like to believe that with my shepard's memories and thoughts a part of him still lives on in the Reapers. The part that remembers the sacrifices it took to achieve this victory.

That I understand, I also understand the Catalyst has proven to be an evil manipulative monster and a master of AI's which Shepard becomes. I understand your choice, I won't argue it because it is your choice. Just wanted to make a couple of points. I don't like the idea of weapons of mass destruction walking around, that have the abilty to go crazy and start killing again at the drop of a dime. I would rather they were destroyed myself. You can't use a weapon for evil if the weapon is gone.

[XXIceColdXX]

Destroy by a country mile.The geth and edi can be rebuilt.

Followed by reject.

Followed by the other 2 creepy options.

[Seracen]

I'll just head-canon a hybrid of all three ending cutscenes. Give it a week, it'll be up on Youtube.

Barring that, still going with my fanfics, some of which actually factor in stuff like the rachni, etc...

[MystEU]

I went with destroy and I'm happy with that, although control is much cooler now than it was before. I just can't help but to think the power, time, and immortality might be corruptable down the line. Could all the good and memories driving shepard eventually be let go? I'm not taking any chances!

[s17tabris]

Reject, then Destroy (without the breath scene).

[What?]

I'll always stand beside the "Destroy" ending. At the end of things, the Geth and EDI are just constructs with binary "souls". They'll never be people in the sense you and I are. Everything they are, everything they do, is dictated by algorithms written and programmed by mathematicians. They don't feel emotion as we do or think as we do. It's mimicry, akin to a monkey trying to eat with a spoon because it sees its caretaking doing so. If sacrificing these glorified computers saves the galaxy, you can bet your last dime I'll take it. Machines can be rebuilt in just years or decades, but civilizations take centuries to create.

Modifié par VictorianTrash, 27 juin 2012 - 08:17 .