58 réponses à ce sujet

[Thor Rand Al]

So I've been thinking about who the fellow survivor for Return to Ostagar might be.  I'm thinking it might have something to do with maybe someone you already talked to before the battle.  This is just a theory.

Possible people:
The Quartermaster
The Kennel Master
The guy who's in the cage for desertion (The Hungry Deserter)
The Ash Warrior guy
The dying soldier that you find in the Wild's
The soldier who greets you as you go into the camp
I'm pretty sure there might be a few others that I never did talk to but I'm guessing that it has to be someone that you've already met at the camp before the battle.
Anybody else have someone else they think might be showing up from Ostagar. 
Feedback welcome

[Herr Uhl]

We can cross off the cage guy and the wounded one in the wilds since you can kill them.

[Nobody Important]

The cage guy is dead look at the screenshots you see his corpse in the cage. Everyone else you listed is possible I guess.

[Thor Rand Al]

Oops I forgot about that prob because I never did kill them lol

[Herr Uhl]

I'm personally hoping for Walter, the slightly cowardly Tower Guard.

[Bullets McDeath]

The Circle Mage temp companion the game gives you for the Tower of Ishal is another possibility. If you are a human Noble and have Dog in your party, you only get him whereas if you aren't/don't you get him and the guy who was standing guard before, but no matter what, everybody partied with that Circle Mage on their way to Ogre. So... possible.

Also, don't forget: Duncan!

Modifié par outlaworacle, 14 décembre 2009 - 11:52 .

[Herr Uhl]

outlaworacle wrote...

The Circle Mage temp companion the game gives you for the Tower of Ishal is another possibility. If you are a human Noble and have Dog in your party, you only get him whereas if you aren't/don't you get him and the guy who was standing guard before, but no matter what, everybody partied with that Circle Mage on their way to Ogre. So... possible.

Mage does not get the circle mage.

Edit: Thus, Walter is the only one of them, Tower Guard, Circle Mage and Soldier featured to everybody.

Modifié par Herr Uhl, 14 décembre 2009 - 11:58 .

[LaztRezort]

Duncan!



Little did we know, he actually has the Feign Death skill... er, maybe not.



I also vote for Walter. But my instinct tells me it will be the Quartermaster, as a supplier.

[Nobody Important]

Kennel Master is my bet. They are giving us another chance to get dog if we don't have him. So maybe the kennel guy is alive with a bunch of war dogs?

[Skydiver8888]

Oh yes, i'm sure it will be Headless Duncan.  And he'll be riding the game's first horse. <_<

And his only speaking line will be "ICHABOD!"  who cares that it doesn't fit and there's no one named Ichabod anywhere near Ostagar.

Fergus Cousland gets my vote (though he technically wasn't AT Ostagar for the battle)

[Thor Rand Al]

If it was Duncan though wouldn't that spoil the rest of the game cause that would mean he'd be in charge now instead of the main pc. Unless he croaks as he's giving you whatever info you need to return to Ostagar lol... Can you imagine Alistair's reaction to find Duncan still alive after he's thought him dead n mourned him... Eeks lol

[Jayce]

Who says it has to be someone you've met? Even though Morrigan says the army was wiped out, there are at least two Ostagar veterans you meet in Denerim not counting those who were with Loghain. So I doubt the army was killed to a man, otherwise how did Wynne and Uldred return to the Circle afterward, or the chanters and the Reverend Mother?

[Thor Rand Al]

Jayce F wrote...

Who says it has to be someone you've met? Even though Morrigan says the army was wiped out, there are at least two Ostagar veterans you meet in Denerim not counting those who were with Loghain. So I doubt the army was killed to a man, otherwise how did Wynne and Uldred return to the Circle afterward, or the chanters and the Reverend Mother?

Like I said it's just a theory... I've been kinda curious as to who the fellow survivor maybe since I've heard about the DLC... Just something to think about while patiently waiting for the release lol

[Bullets McDeath]

Herr Uhl wrote...

outlaworacle wrote...

The Circle Mage temp companion the game gives you for the Tower of Ishal is another possibility. If you are a human Noble and have Dog in your party, you only get him whereas if you aren't/don't you get him and the guy who was standing guard before, but no matter what, everybody partied with that Circle Mage on their way to Ogre. So... possible.

Mage does not get the circle mage.

Edit: Thus, Walter is the only one of them, Tower Guard, Circle Mage and Soldier featured to everybody.

Quit bringing facts into my theory!!

[Herr Uhl]

outlaworacle wrote...

Quit bringing facts into my theory!!

Never!

[SxShadows]

My guess is a fellow Grey Warden

[The Angry One]

SxShadows wrote...

My guess is a fellow Grey Warden

Would torpedo the entire plot unless he dies immediately.

[1xs3thx1]

My guess is Sandal.

[SxShadows]

The Angry One wrote...

SxShadows wrote...

My guess is a fellow Grey Warden

Would torpedo the entire plot unless he dies immediately.

It said you find a survivor. If it is indeed a Grey Warden he doesn't have to survive the DLC. You go back to Ostagar, find him, later he dies. It's possible.

[Herr Uhl]

The Angry One wrote...

SxShadows wrote...

My guess is a fellow Grey Warden

Would torpedo the entire plot unless he dies immediately.

Well, Avernus is also a living GW.

[Marcus Aurelius]

I don't think its the ash warriors as they escaped earlier or so the bandit leader tells you if you questions him outside lothering

[The Angry One]

Herr Uhl wrote...

The Angry One wrote...

SxShadows wrote...

My guess is a fellow Grey Warden

Would torpedo the entire plot unless he dies immediately.

Well, Avernus is also a living GW.

Avernus doesn't follow your foolish mortal rules!

[The Angry One]

Captain Cosmos wrote...

I don't think its the ash warriors as they escaped earlier or so the bandit leader tells you if you questions him outside lothering

Logically then you should be able to find some of them around, I always did wonder what happened to them, they seemed significant at the time but.. er.. aren't.
They'd be a good choice I think. But I bet it'll be someone we've never seen before.

[ChickenDownUnder]

It's clearly Random Soldier A.

[JaegerBane]

Herr Uhl wrote...

The Angry One wrote...

SxShadows wrote...

My guess is a fellow Grey Warden

Would torpedo the entire plot unless he dies immediately.

Well, Avernus is also a living GW.

Is Avernus technically 'living'? I couldn't quite figure out if he was halfway to being DA:O's equivalent to a Liche.