327 réponses à ce sujet

[Tommyspa]

It never left the running.

[Doom972]

The year isn't over yet, but with the EC I would nominate it GOTY 2012.

Modifié par Doom972, 01 juillet 2012 - 05:10 .

[Facemelter91]

Eluril wrote...

Again I'm throwing down the gauntlet to those who scoff at this winning Game of the Year from reputable gaming sites (Ign, gameinformer, Xbox magazine, Playstation magazine). Start naming games that are superior and will win GOTY over it.

Unfortunately they arn't released yet, but more than likely these 6, at least in my opinion have a far better chance than this train wreck.

Boarderlands 2 (moneys on this one)
Resident Evil 6
MoH: Warfighter
Assassins Creed 3
Halo 4
Darksiders 2

[Seifer006]

@OP

you know. it's not just the ending that made ME3 bad. There's lots of other reasons ME3 fell so short as GOTY worthy.

Maybe you should think this thread a little harder

[Eluril]

Facemelter91 wrote...

Eluril wrote...

Again I'm throwing down the gauntlet to those who scoff at this winning Game of the Year from reputable gaming sites (Ign, gameinformer, Xbox magazine, Playstation magazine). Start naming games that are superior and will win GOTY over it.

Unfortunately they arn't released yet, but more than likely these 6, at least in my opinion have a far better chance than this train wreck.

Boarderlands 2 (moneys on this one)
Resident Evil 6
MoH: Warfighter
Assassins Creed 3
Halo 4
Darksiders 2

Diablo shooter clone but still a good game.
Not going to be classic survival horror
Did you play the first one? If any shooter is paint by numbers it was that one.
No
No
No

[Whatshisnameagain]

Seifer006 wrote...

@OP

you know. it's not just the ending that made ME3 bad. There's lots of other reasons ME3 fell so short as GOTY worthy.

Maybe you should think this thread a little harder

Lmao....this right here.

[Dawson14]

Sam Anders wrote...

ioannisdenton wrote...

i d vote it. up to now which other game is better this year??

Diablo 3, and when they're out Guild Wars 2 (if in this case) and Black Ops 2.

Lol, Diablo 3 is NOT GOTY quality. You should feel ashamed you even said that.

[Facemelter91]

Eluril wrote...

Facemelter91 wrote...

Eluril wrote...

Again I'm throwing down the gauntlet to those who scoff at this winning Game of the Year from reputable gaming sites (Ign, gameinformer, Xbox magazine, Playstation magazine). Start naming games that are superior and will win GOTY over it.

Unfortunately they arn't released yet, but more than likely these 6, at least in my opinion have a far better chance than this train wreck.

Boarderlands 2 (moneys on this one)
Resident Evil 6
MoH: Warfighter
Assassins Creed 3
Halo 4
Darksiders 2

Diablo shooter clone but still a good game.
Not going to be classic survival horror
Did you play the first one? If any shooter is paint by numbers it was that one.
No
No
No

Thats a nice opinion you have there, so easy to write off games when they havent even been released yet. Lol @ boarderlands being compared to Diablo 3. Now iv seen everything . If Boarderlands doesent get it, then either Halo 4 or AS3 will get it. But hey I could be wrong, they are however already better than ME3 in my eyes, at least their developers don't lie through their teeth.

[Eluril]

Dawson14 wrote...

Sam Anders wrote...

ioannisdenton wrote...

i d vote it. up to now which other game is better this year??

Diablo 3, and when they're out Guild Wars 2 (if in this case) and Black Ops 2.

Lol, Diablo 3 is NOT GOTY quality. You should feel ashamed you even said that.

LOL and Black ops 2. Guild Wars is an MMO right? Instantly disqualified in my opinion, and yes, I am biased!!!

[RE2_Apocalypse]

Dendio1 wrote...

The major problems with the endings have largely been fixed and in a timely manner all things considered.

Some people will never be satisfied. Too bad for them.

It deserves game of the year consideration if not more imo.

Someone who I totally agree with, and undertstand your language. Kudos to you Sir

[Fresnor]

Assassin's Creed 3, Guild Wars 2, and Darksiders 2 probably have the best chances of being GOTY... I'd vote Lollipop Chainsaw over most of the others, especially ME3 and Diablo 2.... Just how bad those two ended up

[Reofeir]

I'd vote for it. Though I doubt it would win against other popular games. It's up to chance!

[77boy84]

Guild Wars 2 and Dishonored will end up being my picks for GOTY.
No way in hell would I call ME3 game of anything.

Even if you ignore the terrible ending (with or without EC) it's still just not that good. It doesn't measure up to ME1 or 2 by any stretch of the imagination, and it's kind of an insult to the whole damn franchise.

[clos]

ME3 winning goty would be an absolute travesty.

[StevenG_CT]

Eluril wrote...

Start naming games that have been released within 2012 that are better than ME3, that push gaming as an art form/cinematic storytelling form further than ME3. You can't because there are none and will be none. Objectively there are zero games that have been released or are going to be that can compete with it. I'll bet $1,000 IGN gives ME3 game of the year.

If your primary criteria is a game that is inovative and advances the medium as an art form then there are better options out there than ME3 in this regard. In terms of inovation ME3 didn't bring anything to the table that wasn't there with ME2 back in 2010.

Of the games I've played that were released this year I'd say a more interesting choice would be "The walking Dead" released by Telltale Games. It is a hybrid adventure/RPG game. There are some action elements and some puzzle-solving elements as well as a lot of interactive dialogue. What has impressed me about the game is that most of the decisions are on a timer (usually a rather quick one) so you are generally forced to make a quick "gut" decision rather than sitting back and pondering the potential ramifications of each option. I haven't seen this mechanic used much in this type of game before and I have never seen it implemented as well as it is in this game.

In many cases the repurcussions of a decision aren't immediately clear but what you do see immediately is a change in the way the various NPC's react to you. I often found myself conflicted over who to support and have seen my perception of some of the NPC's change drastically. On subsequent playthrough of the first 2 episodes (5 are planned, only 2 released so far) I have found that making different choices can have provide a rather different experience. The story itself doesn't change (as of yet) but the mood certainly does as everyone treats you differently. This is a good thing as it adds a lot of replay value. It's certainly a nice change of pace from all of the auto-dialogue in ME3.

To summarize, ME3 was a decent game and relatively well polished (still feels half finished to me) but didn't really push any boundaries as far as innovation. "The Walking Dead" by Telltale isn't nearly as polished (relatively primitive graphics, controls can be a bit glitchy at times) but is innovative and makes use of a decision making mechanic rarely seen and rarely well implemented (and does a damn good job of it). If your main criteria for picking a "Game of the Year" is innovation then "The Walking Dead" is a better choice than ME3 since it actually did try to be innovative.

[HBC Dresden]

I don't know, we aren't arguing this on the forums of another game...

[PadawanMage71]

 it came out when? March, right?

I'd rather give it Game of the Month...

[hammerfan]

Eluril wrote...

Again I'm throwing down the gauntlet to those who scoff at this winning Game of the Year from reputable gaming sites (Ign, gameinformer, Xbox magazine, Playstation magazine). Start naming games that are superior and will win GOTY over it.

And please, stop using the "oh it's just a weak year for games" excuse. Every year there are maybe 3-5 games that realistically have a chance of being named GOTY. I'll give three for this year: ME3, Diablo 3, Batman Arkham City. ME3 is far and away better than those other two games.

IGN...reputable gaming site...funniest thing I've heard all day 

[Slayer299]

ME3 being GOTY is as far from reality as it can get.

[o Ventus]

Tommyspa wrote...

It never left the running.

That's because it was never in the running to begin with.

[ericjdev]

I don't think it deserves consideration, a series of fetch quests and a bunch of auto dialogue followed by a terrible ending followed by massive trolling of the fan base.

[tomcplotts]

i think AC is finally going to get its due this year. as long as Ubi doesn't screw this up, I like their chances. regardless if ME3 gets it or not, they *should* have gotten it by default if they had just turned in a standard, old school Bioware performance.

DIablo 3 is just a shoot and loot game, and those don't win very often. On the other hand, AC3 is taking some huge chances by time warping into the revolutionary war. i can seethat going really, really wrong.

[UBER GEEKZILLA]

the game will definitely win SOME GOTY. not the most. but some. im almost certain IGN will give it GOTY. maybe X-play and possibly gameinformer

[EnvyTB075]

Hell no, even if you liked the ending it wasn't that good a game at all.