368 réponses à ce sujet

[Joe1962]

Original: 2/10

EC: 8/10

[GreyLycanTrope]

Before: 3
Now: 5

[Letozan]

Original: Not worth rating.
EC: I'd give it a 10/10 for giving me a well needed laugh. For actual content, I'll give BW a few points for turning Starchild into Mac Walters passive aggressive avatar (credit to whomever first said that), but not much else. The larger problems are still there,

[secretagentbw]

Before: 2
Now: 9

[Flyprdu]

Vanilla: 2

EC: 5

[IndridColdx]

Before: 0
Now: 0 (Way to listen to your fans bioware, seems to me you didn't do much "listening" as you did fixing things that should have already been in your game in the first place)

Modifié par IndridColdx, 28 juin 2012 - 02:55 .

[Ender99]

Vanilla: -1

EC: 6

[istle]

Original 01/10
-
Extended Cut 02/10

It's still a turd-ending... but with sprinkles on top this time around.
(translation: It looks more appealing visually and the music... but that's all really)

[BDelacroix]

Before: 1
After: 4

[DeepChild]

Before:  2

After:  8

Refusal ending gets a 2 though.  What was the point of that?

[Victia]

Before 0
Ec 3

Better but too little, too late

[a load of stanton]

before 1
now 1.2

needs more space battles

[Pottumuusi]

Before: sqrt(minus a lot)
Now: 4/10

[RyuGuitarFreak]

Original: -1
EC: 7

It is muuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuch better. First of all, the NEEDED closure. Thank you.
Secondly, the improvements on the Catalyst dialog. I was very positvely surprised for how that got better. I couldn't believe I bought the Xzibit Pimp my Ride logic. I believed in that conflict. I wasn't expecting that.
There are still problems, and pictures as feedback for choices was facepalm worthy but I think I can actually finish ME3 a second time now. Huge improvement.

Modifié par RyuGuitarFreak, 28 juin 2012 - 09:56 .

[cyrslash1974]

Before : 0
After : 7

[gao gao]

before: 4.
now: 0.

let me explain: the extended ending is better than the original, but with the passing of time, the experience was diminished severely. the sour taste of the original ending was merely "clarified" by this extended ending, making it all for the worse.

it was honestly more interesting being incredibly disappointed back when i first beat the game than to experience this pointless extension to a pointless ending. the only emotional response i had to the new ending was a jaded, "oh."

[free17]

Original Ending: 1/10
Extended Cut: 7/10

[Trebor1969]

Before 2
Ec 4

it's big increase but still below 5 and far away from ME1 or ME2 quality.

[SCJ90]

sporeian wrote...

Originally, I would give the ending a 2/10

but now, I'd give it a 6/10

you?

Looks about right

[vasametropolis]

Before: 0
Now: 7 (average of the endings. some better, some worse)

Overall: Pleasantly surprised and mostly satisfied. If it had originally released like this, there would be debate and some wouldn't like the turn still, but there would have been no uproar. at. all.

Modifié par xCaptainAmazing, 28 juin 2012 - 10:04 .

[jsar72]

Before 1
Now 5

[joshko]

Before: 5-5.9
Now:8-8.9

[Silent_Thunder01]

Original: 6/10
Extended: 9/10

[joshko]

Pottumuusi wrote...

Before: sqrt(minus a lot)
Now: 4/10

So the first ending was imaginary?

[Ghrelt]

Before: 2
After: 6