116 réponses à ce sujet

[Harorrd]

his final gasp for air, before his body dies because of injury, and his implants exploded causing major dmg

[humes spork]

Eire Icon wrote...

I'm long past the stage of getting into the "Convince me the endings are logical arguments or I will instantly dismiss your opinion" arguments that have been going around these forums of late.

Hell, the arguments 'round these parts are long past that stage. It's more like "I'm going to WHARGARBL and instantly dismiss any differing opinion".

[Darman]

Guys, what intention has this thread?

Shepard. Lives. Thats the meaning of the scene. And he will go on living. He will not die and he will reunite. Officialy stated. He survived the collectors assault. He can survive again.

The whole endings don't seem "plausible" in first place. There are a lot of "How" and "why" questions. Yet they happen.

Btw, who would insert such a scene if not to show he survives -.-
It simply wouldn't make sense

[KiwiQuiche]

Oh it's just Bioware being lousy writers again.

[Sisterofshane]

Darman wrote...

Guys, what intention has this thread?

Shepard. Lives. Thats the meaning of the scene. And he will go on living. He will not die and he will reunite. Officialy stated. He survived the collectors assault. He can survive again.

The whole endings don't seem "plausible" in first place. There are a lot of "How" and "why" questions. Yet they happen.

Btw, who would insert such a scene if not to show he survives -.-
It simply wouldn't make sense

I believe what we are experiencing here is the continuing backlash of not giving us this kind of ending in the first place, instead letting it originally be ambiguous and nonsensical.

The pendulum has swung, and now some people will not accept anything unless it is specifically given to us within the narrative.  Trust has been broken, yada yada yada...

[Lockler]

I was forced to suspend disbelief on Shepard dying and then "voila!" back to life in ME2. Okay, it was more complicated than that, but still. Shepard makes a habit of not dying (unless you kill him at the end of ME2. You monster.), and given the implants he has now, I can again suspend disbelief that those little doohickey-jiggers revived him. Somehow. He clearly comes back to life, if just for a breathe, and that's canon... or at least a slim hope to the people who wanted him to live and have a LI reunion.

[Harorrd]

no, if they wanted sheppard to live, they would add a scene where sheppard emerges from the rubble smiling hugging the crew, and they all had icecream

[DGMockingJay]

EDITED AND REMOVED 

Modifié par DGMockingJay, 01 juillet 2012 - 08:37 .

[DGMockingJay]

Lockler wrote...

I was forced to suspend disbelief on Shepard dying and then "voila!" back to life in ME2. Okay, it was more complicated than that, but still. Shepard makes a habit of not dying (unless you kill him at the end of ME2. You monster.), and given the implants he has now, I can again suspend disbelief that those little doohickey-jiggers revived him. Somehow. He clearly comes back to life, if just for a breathe, and that's canon... or at least a slim hope to the people who wanted him to live and have a LI reunion.

Wait.. BioWare confirmed via twitter that "In Destroy ending, Normandy comes in like a raging bull, into Citadel, takes away Shep in just a nick of time, before the exploding tube engulfs Shepard, which should result in an imminent death. The breath scene is from Normandy med lab, which is apparently littered with concrete."

/sarcasm


There is only limited suspensin of disbelief I can muster up.. Hero surviving in a huge explosion which would kill anyone is such a cliche..

Modifié par DGMockingJay, 01 juillet 2012 - 08:38 .

[Leonia]

It was all just a dream.

[sH0tgUn jUliA]

With very high EMS Shepard dodges the brunt of the explosion. Miranda installed a defibrillator during project Lazarus. Shepard actually has a helmet on although you cannot see it because it was removed for dramatic purposes of the cutscene -- this is done throughout the game. Shepard does not fall to earth, but remains on the Citadel. Weekes also tweeted that there are kinetic barriers that protected anyone still alive on the Citadel from perishing during the activation.

The type of breath Shepard is taking is not the type of breath one takes when they are dying.

This is the way it is. Deal with it.

Modifié par sH0tgUn jUliA, 01 juillet 2012 - 09:22 .

[Lockler]

I'm rooting for a personal mass relay installed somewhere on Shepard's anatomy and he just jumped himself to Earth. More plausible than plausible!!

[RyanSoup]

Applepie_Svk wrote...

anorling wrote...


The breath scene supposedly takes place on the citadel. Not sure how Shepard survived the explosion though. And I gather I will never find out either. It was one thing I was hoping the EC would bring light upon. But now I guess the question will be left out there, unanswered. Forever.

You get answer on google, twitter or BSN ... that´s how we are recieving answers now... 

What.  Please relay these answers

[RyanSoup]

sH0tgUn jUliA wrote...
With very high EMS Shepard dodges the brunt of the explosion. Miranda installed a defibrillator during project Lazarus. Shepard actually has a helmet on although you cannot see it because it was removed for dramatic purposes of the cutscene -- this is done throughout the game. Shepard does not fall to earth, but remains on the Citadel. Weekes also tweeted that there are kinetic barriers that protected anyone still alive on the Citadel from perishing during the activation.

The type of breath Shepard is taking is not the type of breath one takes when they are dying.

This is the way it is. Deal with it.

It still makes no sense.  A minute ago he was limping as a result of being blown up an shot in the abdomen.  He could not have gotten away quickly enough to avoid the explosion.  The whole "kinetic barriers" argument is garbage as well.  The Crucible was designed around the Citadel, not the Citadel around the Crucible.  Why, then, are there kinetic barriers on the Citadel to prevent Shepard from being damaged by the Crucible's activation.  That makes no sense.. Defibrillators also cannot replace lost bodily fluids.  He'd been bleeding from his abdomen for a while there.  Even if he managed to stop the bleeding, he'd still have sepsis, simply due to the location of the gunshot and the lack of immediate treatment.

[RyanSoup]

Darman wrote...

Guys, what intention has this thread?

Shepard. Lives. Thats the meaning of the scene. And he will go on living. He will not die and he will reunite. Officialy stated. He survived the collectors assault. He can survive again.

The whole endings don't seem "plausible" in first place. There are a lot of "How" and "why" questions. Yet they happen.

Btw, who would insert such a scene if not to show he survives -.-
It simply wouldn't make sense

...  What is your argument?  You're blowing hot air, provide us with something substantial
We understand that it happens.  We all played the same game.  You see, what some people do after they watch a movie or play a game is they talk about it.  And you know what, that's okay

[DGMockingJay]

RyanSoup wrote...

Darman wrote...

Guys, what intention has this thread?

Shepard. Lives. Thats the meaning of the scene. And he will go on living. He will not die and he will reunite. Officialy stated. He survived the collectors assault. He can survive again.

The whole endings don't seem "plausible" in first place. There are a lot of "How" and "why" questions. Yet they happen.

Btw, who would insert such a scene if not to show he survives -.-
It simply wouldn't make sense

...  What is your argument?  You're blowing hot air, provide us with something substantial
We understand that it happens.  We all played the same game.  You see, what some people do after they watch a movie or play a game is they talk about it.  And you know what, that's okay

Shepard lives YES.... Its been confirmed countless times that Destroy lets Shep live with high enough EMS..
Does it makes sense for him yo live?? HELL NO... Forget Kinetic Barriers, or defiliberator or Normandy rescusing Shepard, even the fact that almighty CataKID said that Shepard would die should b enough to kill him.. But its not what happened!!
U see, BioWare is doing a fan service with this... And when fan service drives the plot, logic takes back seat!!!

Modifié par DGMockingJay, 01 juillet 2012 - 10:52 .

[v TricKy v]

DGMockingJay wrote...
U see, BioWare is doing a fan service with this... And when fan service drives the plot, logic takes back seat!!!

So ME3 was only fan service(sorry couldnt resist)