The Angry One wrote...
TheBlackBaron wrote...
Likely somewhere along the line from its original programming to "hey guys, let's kill them to save them" (incidentally, this is the exact logic you're using to justify Reject) something went out of whack. Destroy is within its design parameters. Standing down is not.
My only logic with reject is that the galaxy is fighting for it's freedom from the Reapers, not to gleefully submit to them.
No, your logic with Reject is that "because it's morally messy to use the Crucible, I'm going to kill them so they can be saved from the Reapers".
Don't get angsty with me because I poked a hole in your logic, you're beginning to sound like the Catalyst.
No. This is on the Catalyst's shoulders. It is the psychopath that decides to murder everyone if Shepard refuses to buy into it's BS. It is the one who puts up death camps and watches people suffer and die in the name of it's agenda.
It is. Do not yell at me because I call out the war criminal in the room.
-You- are given the ability to save trillions of lives.
-You- choose to not use this ability.
-You- are responsible for their deaths, if not totally then it part.
-You- are at the very least an accomplice to a war criminal, and if I understand how the Hague handles such things, that makes -you- one yourself.
-You- apparently cannot accept that. So you wrap yourself in emotion, stick your head in the sand, and cry that anybody that says otherwise is "angsty".
I will damn well yell at you for that.
The Reapers are being controlled, you don't know what their parameters are.
Neither do you.
So again, little more than speculation and invented details supports the idea that the Reapers would stop fighting and make a conventional victory possible.
Not addressed at all. The Reapers had somewhere to go at Palaven, and the Turians were fighting to defend the planet.
This is a fight to save the galaxy, all bets are off.
*facepalm*
Those tactics only worked because of a unique set of circumstances that have not been duplicated.
Do try and actually read what I say.
Modifié par TheBlackBaron, 30 juin 2012 - 11:18 .