247 réponses à ce sujet

[ForThessia]

Garrus for Miranda
Kaidan(if i could ever leave ashley on virmire) for Samara

Edit: forgot- Javik for Thane

Modifié par ForThessia, 07 juillet 2012 - 04:52 .

[MongoNYC]

Kaidan/Ashley for Miranda. EDI for Kasumi.

And though I like James (he's a beast if you spec him right) I would trade him for Grunt or Wrex if they had the same specs.

[naes1984]

Vega for Grunt
Ashley for Zaeed
Liara for Samara
Allers for Kasumi
EDI for Jack
Javik for Miranda
You know what? I'll just go replay ME2

Modifié par naes1984, 07 juillet 2012 - 04:49 .

[savionen]

Get rid of Kaiden, Ashley, EDI or James, easy.

Bring on Kasumi, Wrex, Grunt or Legion

[Tank207]

I'd get rid of Vega(Sorry James, I like you and all, but I never use you)and bring back Kasumi.

I'd trade Allers for Emily Wong any day... it's a shame BioWare killed her off on freaking twitter.

[KingWrex]

Vega for Grunt, EDI for Jack, Tali for Zaeed

[SCJ90]

EDI or Vega for Jack or Grunt....

[ld1449]

I'd have james or Edi removed. James is really generic, the only interesting thing about him being his jokes and even in that he falls into the role of typical meathead marine. I would replace him with Zaeed.

Edi is irritating because no matter what she's with you anyway. She didn't need an avatar body to get squad interaction and such, they could have just had her talking through comms or something. I would have much preferred an option to have Jack in her place or Kasumi if you really needed another tech expert.

[Edorian27]

For me its's Edi for Kasumi (liked her most in ME2) or
Edi for Kal'Reegar. Would've loved him as Squadmate

[Father_Jerusalem]

Vega for Miranda.

Don't even have to think about it.

[Paula3337]

LogicGunn wrote...

Allers for Jack, Javik for Thane.

edit: why does everyone hate James? He rocked my socks! 

I liked James too, he was funny, sweet, good on my squad but very, very young and somewhat innocent.

Liara for Thane.

[ripslip]

Vega for Miranda.

[TamiBx]

EDI for Grunt. I miss my baby Krogan lol

[devSin]

EDI and James, to be replaced by Legion and Grunt.

Legion is a better bot than EDI could ever be, and Grunt is my boy.

None of the other squadmates are "new", and I would keep them anyway. I always liked the ME squad the best.

Javik stays. There needs to be DLC where you can just take control of Javik and run around talking smack to people.

Modifié par devSin, 07 juillet 2012 - 06:46 .

[Khajiit Jzargo]

EDI for Legion or Wrex.

[PhoenixAeon]

Well you would of all died if you didn't have EDI for that Cerberus Mission. Gotta keep her...and since we can only pick one as the title says..

James for Legion

James and Jacob had no compelling character development and were not worthy to be on the team.

Modifié par PhoenixAeon, 07 juillet 2012 - 06:50 .

[Forbry]

Well definitely not James!
I liked all the squad members of ME3 actually, there were just less than in ME2.
If there can only be 6/7:
Ashley/Kaidan for Mordin, Tali for Legion and maybe even Garrus or EDI for Grunt if Garrus and EDI would stick around, but just wouldn't be a squadmember anymore.

[Forbry]

Haven't played with Javik yet, but have a feeling I would trade him. For Grunt then.

[lboog_081284]

The least important squad members & crewmates (non-playable characters) I found in the Normandy in ME3 were:
James, Javik, EDI & Diana Allers

I would replace them for:
Miranda, Jacob, Jack & Grunt
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Why replace EDI? Having EDI in synthetic form was a great bonus & nice addition to the team - but if I could have her in synthetic form yet not as a playable character to make room for one of these four - I'd be fine with that decision.

Why replace Javik? Javik is a great addition to have on the Normandy for his insight on Prothean history & how civiliation has evolved since his cycle but I never play with Javik at all, nor do I want to - I just don't feel he fits with my sqaud. So I would rather him as a crewmate but not as a playable character.

Why replace Diana Allers? This was a easy decision - Diana Allers was different but honestly this was a waste of a spot on the Normandy because she's a reporter, non-LI - she's just there - her role could've been done anywhere so her spot on the Normandy is an easy replacement.

Why replace James? James is the toughest one to part ways with because he is a great solider & love having him as a playable character - but his lack of being input, aside from his history with the Collectors, that's all we really know about him so I feel Bioware missed the boat with really evolving this character which is why I would part ways with him.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Why take Miranda, Jacob, Jack & Grunt? Because Bioware actually took the time to create great background stories for these characters : even loyalty missions. These characters really grew on you & developed a love & appreciation for these characters:

*Jacob & his background with his father & wanting to not become what he was
*Miranda & her background with her father, her sister and the fact that Miranda was created
*Grunt & his desire to become a true krogan
*Jack with her abusive background, hard around the edges but deep down has a soft spot

All these things makes me really wanting to continue on with these characters & learn more about them and develop stronger relationships with them. You don't have that with James or Diana Allers - you can learn more about Javik & EDI which is good but I would rather keep them as non-playable characters though.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
HOWEVER... if I could have a squadmate back from ME1...and ONLY one, I would take Wrex over all those characters in a heartbeat.

Modifié par lboog_081284, 07 juillet 2012 - 07:02 .

[Forbry]

Yeah, of course Diana Allers. Would be the first one I drop, but she's not a squadmember, so...

[Conniving_Eagle]

It should be pretty obvious. Replace generic human squadmembers #1 and #2 (Kaidan/Ashley and Vega) with Thane Krios and Legion.

Modifié par Conniving_Eagle, 07 juillet 2012 - 07:00 .

[Mavqt]

I refuse to let Ashley and Kaiden back on everytime anyway. so dont need to kick them.
James for Legion or Samara. I thought we were going to get her as a squadmate at the end of her mission due to dialogue, "It must wait now that i can help oppose the Reapers, If you'll have me ofcause."

[TemplePhoenix]

James out, Miranda in.

[Baa Baa]

Vega for Legion
Ashley (only Ashley because I kind of like Kaiden) replaced by Jack
or, although I like Liara, I'd like Thane to replace her (Liara is ok but she's a creep at times in ME3)
As Zombie Inc 91 said, a husk on a leash to replace Allers would be great
EDIT: Also what the hell was with Tali not coming in until half way through the game? If you romanced her it would make more sense to get some news from her earlier on.

Modifié par Baa Baa, 07 juillet 2012 - 07:26 .