219 réponses à ce sujet

[Ghost Lightning]

lol neither. I think Michael Beattie was the best.

[HBC Dresden]

Why are you doing this OP?

[Random Geth]

It astonishes me that Meer has so many votes. It disgusts me that so many people praise such awful "acting".

[sackyhack]

Random Geth wrote...

It astonishes me that Meer has so many votes. It disgusts me that so many people praise such awful "acting".

"Stop liking things I don't like!!"

[CroGamer002]

I refuse to vote.

Why?

Because they're both just as good.

Modifié par Mesina2, 08 juillet 2012 - 05:01 .

[Joryn01]

Liz Sroka or Ash. I guess she changed her name at some point. Either way, she's great!

Modifié par Joryn01, 08 juillet 2012 - 05:56 .

[BioWareM0d13]

Random Geth wrote...

It astonishes me that Meer has so many votes. It disgusts me that so many people praise such awful "acting".

I prefer Meer as Shepard.
Commander Shepard throughout the series has often reminded me of some Staff NCos Mustangs (officers that are prior enlisted) that I knew in the Marine Corps. While part of that is the writing, part of what was also Meer's excellent delivery.

While Jennifer Hale was very good as well, compared to Meer I think she occasionally emotes too much. The result for me was that her version of Shepard occasionally felt like the VA was trying too hard, and as a result  the character seemed less authentic.

Out of the two I found Meer's performance as Shepard to be more believable.

Modifié par Han Shot First, 08 juillet 2012 - 06:31 .

[FlamingBoy]

meer really had the voice down in me3, to bad there were no dialogue option to choose from

[Forbry]

Meer got better in ME3???!!! Man, he must have been extremely terrible in ME1 and ME2 then!! (Never tried male Shep in those games).

Modifié par Forbry, 08 juillet 2012 - 07:50 .

[BioWareM0d13]

Forbry wrote...

Meer got better in ME3???!!! Man, he must have been extremely terrible in ME1 and ME2 then!! (Never tried male Shep in those games).

He is better than Hale in all 3.

[Eain]

Random Geth wrote...

It astonishes me that Meer has so many votes. It disgusts me that so many people praise such awful "acting".

This poll was doomed to be a "vote for the gender you play" poll. Hale cannot win this by definition, but considering the ratio male vs female sheps is terribly skewed in favour of the former, we should at least acknowledge that Hale's score is due in part to manshep players acknowleding who the better VO really is. The fact that it's still relatively 50/50 speaks in Hale's favour.

[Zaalbar]

I felt Jennifer was the best Renegade Shep while Mark for me made the best Paragon Shep.

[Kiadaw]

I NEVER get to hear Jennifer Meer in my game, as the PROMISED free voiceover pack for non English copy never came!

I think they made the same promise for ME2.....oh well.

[Fredvdp]

zaalbar76 wrote...

I felt Jennifer was the best Renegade Shep while Mark for me made the best Paragon Shep.

I think it's the other way around. I love Mark Meer's renegade because of his deadpan delivery. I think Jennifer Hale emotes too much as a renegade, making her lines seem less threatening.

[Epsilon330]

Hale just sounded bored from ME2 onwards.
Meer did a magnificent job, improving greatly from ME1-2, and then putting the cherry on the top in ME3. He's especially notable when you consider he was originally just a placeholder voice for MShep.

[BioWareM0d13]

Epsilon330 wrote...


Meer did a magnificent job, improving greatly from ME1-2, and then putting the cherry on the top in ME3. He's especially notable when you consider he was originally just a placeholder voice for MShep.

Interesting. I had never heard that.

Was it ever announced who they originally had in mind to voice Male Shep?

[Epsilon330]

Han Shot First wrote...

Epsilon330 wrote...


Meer did a magnificent job, improving greatly from ME1-2, and then putting the cherry on the top in ME3. He's especially notable when you consider he was originally just a placeholder voice for MShep.

Interesting. I had never heard that.

Was it ever announced who they originally had in mind to voice Male Shep?

I don't think so. They recast Meer before making a preemptive desicion.

[res27772]

Jennifer Hale... I always thought Meer sounded bored and like he'd rather be doing something else.

[Lisa_H]

Jennifer Hale was best, but I think Meer did a huge improvment in ME2 and ME3

[Galbrant]

The Election is rigged I tell you there is no way Mark Meer can have that many votes.... Unless he went around saying "We'll Bang Okay!?" Damn smooth talker.... I heard one of those eggs belonged to Eve had distinct Shepard features. So he's been busy.

[Saodade]

Keithe Farley

[Pacifien]

Saodade wrote...
Keithe Farley

I like this human; she understands.

[Anthadlas]

Meer, I like his dry sarcastic delivery as a renegade shep. Hale is too emotional in her delivery and puts really heavy emphasis and dramatic pauses in places where it shouldn't be. Her voice doesn't suit a soldier