231 réponses à ce sujet

[Syokhan]

I'm not too concerned about the animation quality, Production I.G's usually really good so I'm sure they'll pull through. The character design doesn't seem too bad, but yeah those krogan look weird.
The voice acting, however... well, that voice-over was cheesy, hope the rest of the voice acting is better. As for the writing, wait and see I guess?

[iSousek]

Arsenic Touch wrote...

Animation? looks okay.
Voice overs? holy hell that was bad. Are they trying to make chobot look good?

What was bad vith voice over exactly? It was a trailer narration, they are all the same. You can't really evaluate VO without the context of the scene or without the context of the emotions of the character in certain situation.

There is some guy talking something.

That's it.

[Himo]

The VO just seemed really kinda forced to me, but the animation looks good and I'll probably give it a watch. Not watched anime in years though, and I don't think I've EVER seen a western anime before. Be interesting to see where this goes.

[Virginian]

UGLY!

[krizalid9999]

Very low quality animation , poorly detailed art , krogans look nothing like they should...
This isn't looking good.
I'll pass.

[macrocarl]

Sounds fun. Looks fine.

[NRieh]

I liked GitS, I can't call myself big anime fan, but I like some.

And here it looks like either they could not make proper trailer, that may attract people, or all the anime itself is poor.

I'd love to see something from ghibli, I know it's not really "their" kind of story, but hey, they did "on your mark".

[Atakuma]

That looks mediocre.

[wafflez]

Narrator sounds like a poor man's Keith David.

[Weak Sauce Hype]

wafflez wrote...

Narrator sounds like a poor man's Keith David.

more like a starving child's Keith David

[FoxholeHunter]

So you create an exceptional new sci-fi world from scratch, with well written and rounded characters that people love, with fantastic voice actors and then you create a manga film and don't use them............riiiiiiiiiiiiiggghhhtttt!

[rapscallioness]

wafflez wrote...

Narrator sounds like a poor man's Keith David.

See, I thought that was Keith David. I hope it wasn't.

I'm confused, though. If this is a prequel (highly-anticipated, no less....), why is Vega holding a Forever Normandy pin/badge..thing. Wistfully. And narrator quoting Shepard?

Where did Vega get that? Why does he have it? Did he get it out of a cereal box? Where can I get one?

But yeah, um...Idk about this one. I don't understand what's going on here. Why are we fighting these Krogan? Where are we? Is this just some random battle stuff with Vega? They're Special Ops? Was Vega Special Ops before he met Shepard?

The animation itself looks..... Idk about this one guys.

[Mylia Stenetch]

Animation is not too bad for this. It looks about the average I have seen recently, a little more akin to the old style I feel. While it did not show much else on other scenes aside from dirt, so I will wait judgement on that. With just narration trying to hype it I can ignore it, since I assume they just hired a guy cheaply for that.

I will watch and see if I want to buy it or not, like anything else I am interested in.

[Massakkolia]

rapscallioness wrote...

I'm confused, though. If this is a prequel (highly-anticipated, no less....), why is Vega holding a Forever Normandy pin/badge..thing. Wistfully. And narrator quoting Shepard?

Where did Vega get that? Why does he have it? Did he get it out of a cereal box? Where can I get one?

Admittedly the badge looks dodgy at best (as does the whole trailer) but they probably made all sorts of memorial stuff after Shepard's death. The anime is a prequel to ME3, not the whole series. I'm guessing at least parts of the anime take place around Shepard's death. He could have also kept the badge from those days. Vega seems to idolize Shepard a bit so it's natural.

That being said, the animation looks horrendous and the voice over is cheesy. I'm not sure who's the target audience of this. It looks incredibly juvenile and I even like well made anime. The production team seems solid but they are seriously running on a low budget and it shows. Why bother if you're not going to make it properly?

Modifié par Ria, 13 juillet 2012 - 06:12 .

[rapscallioness]

Ria wrote...

rapscallioness wrote...

I'm confused, though. If this is a prequel (highly-anticipated, no less....), why is Vega holding a Forever Normandy pin/badge..thing. Wistfully. And narrator quoting Shepard?

Where did Vega get that? Why does he have it? Did he get it out of a cereal box? Where can I get one?

Admittedly the badge looks dodgy at best (as does the whole trailer) but they probably made all sorts of memorial stuff after Shepard's death. The anime is a prequel to ME3, not the whole series. I'm guessing at least parts of the anime take place around Shepard's death. He could have also kept the badge from those days. Vega seems to idolize Shepard a bit so it's natural.

That being said, the animation looks horrendous and the voice over is cheesy. I'm not sure who's the target audience of this. It looks incredibly juvenile and I even like well made anime. The production team seems solid but they are seriously running on a low budget and it shows. Why bother if you're not going to make it properly?

And that's what confuses me. Because Vega had nothing to do with the Normandy before ME3. Right? And Shepard's fate is really the end of the game. So...And Vega wasn't a N7 Special Ops until midway in ME3? I'm nitpicking I guess. It just threw me off.

[warzone25]

 looks decent, probably its the trailer that was badly put together 

[MASSEFFECTfanforlife101]

Guys, it's Anime! When creating Anime based on something else, the creators of said Anime tweak o few of the designs of the Characters, hence the reason why the Krogan look like that. As fellow fans, I thought you wouldn't mind seeing Mass Effect in Different  forms LIKE Anime and Comics. These animators are professionals, who wanted to give Mass Effect a look of their design, hence the Krogan Design. And there was only one voice over heard so far. You can't call the voice over in total horrible. We haven't heard the other characters yet.

You can't just automatically assume that it sucks. 

It's like some of you are saying, "The Krogan look different, so I already hate this even though I've never seen it yet. Since the narration is bad the film has to be bad." 

....Really?

Modifié par MASSEFFECTfanforlife101, 13 juillet 2012 - 08:02 .

[Massakkolia]

rapscallioness wrote...

And that's what confuses me. Because Vega had nothing to do with the Normandy before ME3. Right? And Shepard's fate is really the end of the game. So...And Vega wasn't a N7 Special Ops until midway in ME3? I'm nitpicking I guess. It just threw me off.

Vega's not N7. His whole character arc in ME3 is about wavering whether he wants to accept the invitation to N7 training or not. He's just a soldier. I haven't read all the books and comics but as far as I know he didn't really have anything to do with Normandy or Shepard before the end of ME2 but it's likely he idolized Shepard (the savior of Citadel) after the events of ME1. Hence the badge. Of course there could be many explanations. 

Edit: If I understood you correctly, you seem to think Vega's an N7 in the trailer. I don't see any N7 logos. That team's just Alliance kids. 

Modifié par Ria, 13 juillet 2012 - 09:11 .

[Blueprotoss]

 

Forsythia wrote...

This looks really bad an cheezy. The voice over is ridiculous and James looks like a baby. Do not want!

And how is this 'highly anticipated'? /facepalm

He had a baby face in ME3.

Captain_Obvious_au wrote...

A cartoon is a cartoon, and this one is drawn realllly badly.

Yet I could say the samething about most of the cartoons that I loved or watched in the 80s and 90s.  

mythlover20 wrote...

Oh, dear gods. What the hell?

I liked GotS, I thought the work was thought-provoking and intelligent. This though, does NOT give me any hope for this pos.

Agreed, the va is terrible, it looks cheezy and amateurish, especially for an anime which I've always found childish and amateurish, and frankly, it took me the ENTIRE trailer to figure out that the monster was supposed to be a Krogan.

Bioware.... seriously? *headdesk.... repeatedly until the wood is covered with brain matter*

I see that you missed that this was done by Funimation not by Bioware but they also did Halo: Legends, Dead Space: Downfall, Dead Space: Aftermath, and Dragon Age: Dawn of the Seeker.

Modifié par Blueprotoss, 13 juillet 2012 - 09:16 .

[Massakkolia]

Filament wrote...

oh god why, why is there a stereotypical anime guy with glasses as the f*#&ing engineer.

Not to mention a gruff voice-over stating not particularly to anyone: "You ladies may be well-trained special forces..." Can we please have more anime and macho clichés clumped together? This trailer is not yet cheesy enough to be relevant.

[Blueprotoss]

  

XqctaX wrote...

Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within was quality
this looks cheap. and its the second least liked character as protagonist

looks like its going to get youtubed or torrented rather than bought by people
cus i dont see anyone wanting to pay for it.

also a prequell to me3 no thanks. prequell to me1 would have been a smarter move
like the first contact war.

i dont see how screwing the fans over in the third game and then making stuff 
about caracters most didnt like and then also makin it look cheap beeing a good way 
to regain fans within the franshise lol

Ignorance must be blissful for you especially when Spirits is CGI and Paragon is an Anime, which are apples and oranges. Btw you do know that Paragon takes place in during ME2 right? 

Roamingmachine wrote...

Crypticqa wrote...

Why everything has to be anime these days...

Because once you reach the bottom with your franchise, you might as well keep on digging till you hit China. Dawn of the seeker at least doesn't look like like Little Timmy made it in kindergarden.

Haters gonna hate and its pretty clear that you don't watch that much animation whether or not its Anime based.

[Neeh]

Aslong as they don't overdo it..a normal squad of Alliance marines running around doing flips and dual wielding guns and blasting things to bits left and right with biotics seems very non-MEish to me atleast.

[GSGJens]

Terrible, just terrible... and lightyears away from anything I associate with the Mass Effect Universe.

[mauro2222]

Arcian wrote...

Animation and art looks painfully cheap.

This. And why the Krogan looks like a shark?