825 réponses à ce sujet

[Adugan]

corporal doody wrote...

anorling wrote...

Adugan wrote...

corporal doody wrote...

anorling wrote...

corporal doody wrote...





hmm.....disagree OP.

all that you listed aint fact...

Some of the things listed are indeed facts

like i said...ALL that you listed aint facts.

just cuz you mix in gripes & moans dont make them any more factal..

this is another..I DONT LIKE THE GAME AND HERE IS WHY IT SUCKS...aka I THINK THEREFORE YOU SHOULD

Isnt that what you are doing? I DONT LIKE THIS THREAD AND HERE IS WHY IT SUCKS?

Yeah. No. It's just the same as the "I LOVE THE ENDINGS/GAME AND HERE IS WHY YOU SHOULD TOO" threads.
This thread is just as relevant as those threads.

All threads are "I think this and you should too". If you didnt want other people to think it too, you would keep it to yourself and not post it. You want others to critique it and ultimately agree with you because you want to win the argument. Thats the point of debate.

[Oransel]

Adugan wrote...

All threads are "I think this and you should too". If you didnt want other people to think it too, you would keep it to yourself and not post it. You want others to critique it and ultimately agree with you because you want to win the argument. Thats the point of debate.

Reaching a consensus

[GreenFlag]

Oransel wrote...

That's right. It's a bad, mediocre game. 

Redeeming features:

Garrus
Tuchanka arc
Rannoch arc
Weapon mods
Smooth combat system

What makes it bad? (bolded the parts that are intolerable)

Auto-dialogue. Canon Shep.
Almost no side missions, but tons of fetch quests.
No Galaxy exploration. No vehicles.
No ME2 characters as a squadmates or even proper LI's.
Game is very short, compared to previous games. 
Crucible.
Choices did not matter.
Introduction/beginning.
Catalyst's existence.
Overall plot is very weak - Kai Leng power armor, Cerberus and so on.
Bugs. Tons of them. 
Journal.
Endings.
Artistic integrity.
that stupid kid, and Shepard's nightmares about him.
the rest of the games are irrelevant.
Insults from Bioware.

Bad game is bad.

If you really don't like this game, you'd be long gone as any other hater from BSN, but you are still here. So the game is not enaugh so bad for you.

Yes, I agreed with you there are some things, which are awful...
But I believe, some of them have a reason for future game. (I mean, only the story matters)

Modifié par GreenFlag, 13 juillet 2012 - 11:30 .

[tanisha__unknown]

It's not bad at all. It's just not great.

[Brovikk Rasputin]

What a laughable post, OP. No ME3 is not a bad game.

[CR121691]

Not this thread again.

[Hexley UK]

Its a 7/10 nothing more which i'd be ok with if it was just about any other series & developer.

[Hendrik.III]

As a stand-alone game, it's not bad at all. As a conclusion to a choice-based, story-telling series, it's crap. Too bad they wanted it to be the first, so they could attract a bigger audience (and with it a bigger sack of $$$).

[Dendio1]

Brovikk Rasputin wrote...

What a laughable post, OP. No ME3 is not a bad game.

[Roamingmachine]

Dendio1 wrote...

Brovikk Rasputin wrote...

What a laughable post, OP. No ME3 is not a bad game.

Yes it is.

[PSUHammer]

LOL...here I come back over to this forum after a while living in the MP forum only to STILL find redundant threads like this with more griping. I mean, seriously, it is time to move on. After the hundreds of "look at me!" whine posts that just regurgitate the same points over and over, it is time to discuss something else.

None of the opinions in this thread are adding anything new to this topic. They have all been stated and debated.

Modifié par Hammer6767, 13 juillet 2012 - 11:55 .

[Simotech]

Indeed

[Adugan]

Hammer6767 wrote...

LOL...here I come back over to this forum for a while after living in the MP forum only to STILL find redundant threads like this with more griping. I mean, seriously, it is time to move on. After the hundreds of "look at me!" whine posts that just regurgitate the same points over and over, it is time to discuss something else.

None of the opinions in this thread are adding anything new to this topic. They have all been stated and debated.

Can you make a ME3-relevant post that hasnt been said already? These forums would be dead if we werent allowed to repost, 90% of this spoilers forum is the same topic over and over.

[PSUHammer]

Adugan wrote...

Hammer6767 wrote...

LOL...here I come back over to this forum for a while after living in the MP forum only to STILL find redundant threads like this with more griping. I mean, seriously, it is time to move on. After the hundreds of "look at me!" whine posts that just regurgitate the same points over and over, it is time to discuss something else.

None of the opinions in this thread are adding anything new to this topic. They have all been stated and debated.

Can you make a ME3-relevant post that hasnt been said already? These forums would be dead if we werent allowed to repost, 90% of this spoilers forum is the same topic over and over.

Yes...you can.  And I see them in the Gameplay and MP forums.  But this story forum is becoming a joke.  It is a constant parade of whining on the same topics.

It is at the point of masochism.  It isn't THAT bad of a game.  The endings left some things to be desired, sure, but they are ok now.  Even if you still hate them...move on to something else in life!  Enter a 12 step program.  Grief counsoling...whatever.

[Oransel]

Bad game is bad

[corporal doody]

Adugan wrote...

corporal doody wrote...

anorling wrote...

Adugan wrote...

corporal doody wrote...

anorling wrote...

corporal doody wrote...





hmm.....disagree OP.

all that you listed aint fact...

Some of the things listed are indeed facts

like i said...ALL that you listed aint facts.

just cuz you mix in gripes & moans dont make them any more factal..

this is another..I DONT LIKE THE GAME AND HERE IS WHY IT SUCKS...aka I THINK THEREFORE YOU SHOULD

Isnt that what you are doing? I DONT LIKE THIS THREAD AND HERE IS WHY IT SUCKS?

Yeah. No. It's just the same as the "I LOVE THE ENDINGS/GAME AND HERE IS WHY YOU SHOULD TOO" threads.
This thread is just as relevant as those threads.

All threads are "I think this and you should too". If you didnt want other people to think it too, you would keep it to yourself and not post it. You want others to critique it and ultimately agree with you because you want to win the argument. Thats the point of debate.

oh...in that case...

THIS THREAD SUCKS

[Memnon]

Whether a game is good or bad is obviously a matter of opinion - and I actually agree with the bolded points. For me personally, if a game is good I will replay it - I can't bring myself to replay ME3, so that's my verdict

[v TricKy v]

Lets reach a middle ground. It´s mediocre.
Their marketing on the other hand is bad. If you have to lie about your product instead of telling the truth and the strengths of your product, you deserve a slap in the face in my opinion.

[Grimwick]

grey_wind wrote...

Objectively, ME3 is a good game, not great, taken as a stand alone title.
But compared to what came before it and what the devs made it out to be, it's a turd.

This says it all.

[legion999]

It's a bad Mass Effect game.

It's not Fable 3 or Mindjack bad.

[corporal doody]

legion999 wrote...

It's a bad Mass Effect game.

It's not Fable 3 or Mindjack bad.

Alpha Protocol was a BAD game!! and I disliked it very very much!!

Onechanbara was a BAD game!! BUT I LOVED IT!!!

HALO was a great game!! but im not fond of it.

Fallout 3 was a great game!! but i cant bring myself to beat cuz i get bored with it.

Modifié par corporal doody, 13 juillet 2012 - 01:05 .

[stonbw1]

Thanixmaster wrote...

ME 1 and ME 2 are true masterpieces in their own right, while ME 3 is "just" a good game. Pretty good as a standalone title but nothing compared to the first two games in the series.

ME1 was a true masterpiece in my opinion; ME2...I thought the combat/gameplay was great (the rest was mediocre..again in my opinion).  What I don't understand is your statement above: don't most people say that ME3 was a hybrid of ME1 (story, RPG elements) & ME2 (polished gameplay/graphics) and by alegebra, ME3 would be similarly great, no??  Maybe not masterpiece, but great and certainly not "bad" as OP suggests.

[PSUHammer]

I concur, but people also forget the absolute moanfest on these boards when ME2 came out. It is all of a sudden retconned as a "great" game.

[Galbrant]

Eh... Mass Effect 3 is a good game... but its vastly inferior product to the first two games. Not a Great or Outstanding game.... just good. Nothing memorable, except the endings in a very bad way.

[Brovikk Rasputin]

Hammer6767 wrote...

LOL...here I come back over to this forum after a while living in the MP forum only to STILL find redundant threads like this with more griping. I mean, seriously, it is time to move on. After the hundreds of "look at me!" whine posts that just regurgitate the same points over and over, it is time to discuss something else.

None of the opinions in this thread are adding anything new to this topic. They have all been stated and debated.

Move on? MOVE ON?!?? No!! It''s our duty as consumers to complain about the same thing over and over again! Our duty!!!! It's the only option. Moving on is simply not possible!

...