825 réponses à ce sujet

[F4H bandicoot]

It's below par for an ME game.
Fton what Bioware told us, it should have been so much more.

[Conniving_Eagle]

Should've seen atleast a 3 year development cycle. I still can't believe it was going to have a development cycle similar in length to DA2. They didn't learn their lesson?

[SpamBot2000]

Here's where artistic integrity would mean something other than a cynical flak shield. An artist would have told EA there's no way they were gonna release an unfinished ME3. EA would have had a choice to fire and replace them and take their chances with that for a marketing pitch OR allow them to finish it. But as we can see, the "art" is always secondary in this business.

Modifié par SpamBot2000, 27 juillet 2012 - 11:57 .

[Darth Death]

SpamBot2000 wrote...

Here's where artistic integrity would mean something other than a cynical flak shield. An artist would have told EA there's no way they were gonna release an unfinished ME3. EA would have had a choice to fire and replace them and take their chances with that for a marketing pitch OR allow them to finish it. But as we can see, the "art" is always secondary in this business.

The whole artistic integrity thing was just an excuse to defend themselves from angry fans. I doubt they truly believed in the concept, but if they did, then the naivety of their mental thinking as game designers (contradicting art) is indeed laughable.   

[Conniving_Eagle]

Yeah... www.youtube.com/watch

[Darth Death]

Conniving_Eagle wrote...

Yeah... www.youtube.com/watch

You good sir, win!

[CaptainCommander]

I just played through ME1 and then ME2 again and honestly ME3 is a terrible game in a trilogy! ME2 starts out with discussing your choices and seeing people you used to know. ME3 starts like a new game and ignores the past two games completely! And it just shows from EA trying to make this "The perfect games to jump into the series." Its like J.R.R. Tolken or J.K. Rowling making their 3rd books the perfect chance to start reading the series! Its meant to be compounding!! If ME3 was the first ME game it would be perfect but its not its a 3rd instalment with a big fan base, you don't then say lets start again! Its bad business and bad ethics! Its just very bad. Its literally like the used a whole new writing team to write this game. I'm just so disappointed! ME1 & 2 I've played through 8 times each at least. I've played ME3 through twice! And will never do a full playthrough again cause what was the point? Rachni choice didn't make any difference, nor did the Collector Base. The only part of ME3 that felt like a ME game was the Genophage because it took your relationship with Wrex in ME1 and your development and understanding of Mordin in ME2 and they all came together, your choices mattered and the game changed accordingly. Otherwise everything else was utter rubbish and just bad!

[chidingewe8036]

Bioware needs to go back to story telling school

The perfect game to jump into the series? oh Bioware you ****** me off so bad

[Ozida]

What CaptainCommander wrote... It reminds me of Fallout 3 a bit. It was a good game as stand alone and attracted many new players... But was mostly unplayable to older veterans as it had nothing to do with the first original 2 games.
It is sad that ME3 crushed my expectations so hard.

Modifié par Ozida, 29 juillet 2012 - 04:25 .

[Gemini1179]

It looks pretty and the combat is good. Other than that, it is simply not a very good game. I mean come on, the "Hospital" is a hallway. Oh my the creativity! It's a sad entry into the ME series. A sad entry.

[clarkusdarkus]

Gemini1179 wrote...

It looks pretty and the combat is good. Other than that, it is simply not a very good game. I mean come on, the "Hospital" is a hallway. Oh my the creativity! It's a sad entry into the ME series. A sad entry.

So ironic and weird that the citadel on ME1 felt alive and in ME3 its just hallways and basic........the hospital had about 4 rooms.....and the man who had to have his leg amputated was stuck outside on a bed..<_<... even C-sec who had a whole section in ME1 were reduced to a single room on the citadel........it's only when u look back on ME3 after completion and the ending backlash has waned that you truly realise how crap ME3 was and how lucky to some point they were the ending travesty masked the problems.......who messes up a journal....i mean really.....ME2 got it spot on.

Modifié par clarkusdarkus, 31 juillet 2012 - 07:18 .

[Oransel]

bad game is bad

[Eterna]

Yay, another hate fest circle jerk thread.

[zeypher]

citadel was a huge space station in ME1, you actually felt that people lived there. Come ME3 its nothing but a glorified airport. It even feels like a airport

[DeadpoolBub]

I'm DEFINITELY not seeing the "Game is short" thing. My ME3 playthroughs are just a little bit shorter than my ME2 playthroughs, which have all of the DLC on them & played.

I guess it's shorter than ME1, if you did in all the side quests in ME1. But who the hell wants to play the same four maps over & over again. People talk alot about the ME1 sidequests, but they were so damn boring. ME2 got the sidequest thing the bets.

[ShepnTali]

zeypher wrote...

citadel was a huge space station in ME1, you actually felt that people lived there. Come ME3 its nothing but a glorified airport. It even feels like a airport

Yeah, with unsettling music that drove me nuts. Something eerie there.

[Oransel]

For me ME3 was considerably shorter.

[jahaa]

ME3 is a good game.

I wish you could see it like i do. It is so... perfect!

[shepdog77]

Eterna5 wrote...

Yay, another hate fest circle jerk thread.

[TeasingJewel]

I agree with most other people in the thread, it is a good game in it's own right and would be a fantastic game *IF* it was not named "Mass Efect 3" but because it has the Mass Effect label stuck on it, it fails to be worthy of the name.

IMO the same thing can be said about DA2.

If confused about what I mean, think of a pair of skunk socks with the Calvin Klein label stuck on them.

Modifié par TeasingJewel, 02 août 2012 - 08:52 .

[Ansible]

Personally, I do think that ME3 is pretty bland,

Maybe not BAD, but certainly not great. Almost not even "good".

When compared to my rankings of "Great" and "Super Great" for ME1 and ME2, it looks horrible. But even by itself, it's still not all that great.

I could name all the reasons why I think that, but it is irrelevant and would cause more trouble than it's worth, I'm sure. So I think a good contribution to this thread would simply be

"I might have to agree"

[Ansible]

shepdog77 wrote...

Eterna5 wrote...

Yay, another hate fest circle jerk thread.

Every thread on BSN ends up being some kind of fest that involves a circle jerk.

Even all the guys that claim to always be positive, and love the game.

And the guys that hate the game.

And the IT people.

It all amounts to the same thing. Not one thread has ever come to something that wasn't a circle jerk.

Soon, someone will start a thread about all the ME haters and why ME3 is simply a great game. Everyone will get together and talk about how stupid other people are, and how awesome the game is.

Circle Jerk.