Aller au contenu

I like this game a lot but I have a little bone to pick with an issue of copying voices and faces of people without telling them


243 réponses à ce sujet

#176
Darth_Shizz

Darth_Shizz
  • Members
  • 672 messages

Skellimancer wrote...

http://www.theconsol...Sun in game.bmp
More plagiarism.
This old game has a party of FOUR characters! DA:O has a party of FOUR characters!

This is BS.


Not to mention Duncan was obviously based on the warrior.

Concept Morrigan may or may not have been based on the rogue...perhaps this is the reason for the drastic change come the final release?

#177
Guest_Legacy_QuEsT_*

Guest_Legacy_QuEsT_*
  • Guests

Skellimancer wrote...

Image IPB
More plagiarism.
This old game has a party of FOUR characters! DA:O has a party of FOUR characters!

This is BS.


FIXED :innocent:

#178
Guest_MrHimuraChan_*

Guest_MrHimuraChan_*
  • Guests
Oh no! Even Oghren got Plagiated!

Image IPB

#179
Skellimancer

Skellimancer
  • Members
  • 2 207 messages

Legacy_QuEsT wrote...

Skellimancer wrote...


More plagiarism.
This old game has a party of FOUR characters! DA:O has a party of FOUR characters!

This is BS.


FIXED :innocent:


:D

#180
Bibdy

Bibdy
  • Members
  • 1 455 messages
Image IPB



Leliana, too!

#181
Skellimancer

Skellimancer
  • Members
  • 2 207 messages

Bibdy wrote...
Image IPB


Leliana, too!


fixed!

#182
Guest_Tassiaw_*

Guest_Tassiaw_*
  • Guests
As a troll, I give you 6/10. You suckered a lot of people.

#183
Darth_Shizz

Darth_Shizz
  • Members
  • 672 messages
 Image IPB

I believe I found Shale.

Modifié par Darth_Shizz, 18 décembre 2009 - 01:17 .


#184
Guest_MrHimuraChan_*

Guest_MrHimuraChan_*
  • Guests
THIS THREAD WINS EVERYTHING!

Image IPB


And Legacy... I'm begginning to really like this guy :D
Image IPB

Modifié par MrHimuraChan, 18 décembre 2009 - 01:22 .


#185
Bibdy

Bibdy
  • Members
  • 1 455 messages

Skellimancer wrote...


fixed!


"Heya! Its me, Imo-huURUURRK!"

*pulls sword from Imoen's neck*.

#186
chuckles471

chuckles471
  • Members
  • 608 messages
I hope Legacy_QuEsT is like this in real life. It would make the earth a better place to live. His ability not to concede defeat and keep his opinion even though it is crazy would be great in real life. He is definitely not a follower of people and I respect him for that.



Somebody is copying someone's voice, he speaks up like a real revolutionary agaist the majority.

Somebody has a beard? Obviously they copied Gerard Butler.



He my friends, is a free-thinker and one of the reason's that the human race is so varied.



(Sorry for earlier comments, I really hope you are real)




#187
Rostas7

Rostas7
  • Members
  • 83 messages

Darth_Shizz wrote...

 Image IPB

I believe I found Shale.



Nah,THIS IS SHALE!

Image IPB


Me vs Darth_Shizz ..FIGHT!!! 

#188
Guest_Legacy_QuEsT_*

Guest_Legacy_QuEsT_*
  • Guests

chuckles471 wrote...

I hope Legacy_QuEsT is like this in real life. It would make the earth a better place to live. His ability not to concede defeat and keep his opinion even though it is crazy would be great in real life. He is definitely not a follower of people and I respect him for that.

Somebody is copying someone's voice, he speaks up like a real revolutionary agaist the majority.
Somebody has a beard? Obviously they copied Gerard Butler.

He my friends, is a free-thinker and one of the reason's that the human race is so varied.

(Sorry for earlier comments, I really hope you are real)



implausably utterly unthinkably outrageously impossible to ever consider the possibility that I am a human being with an opinion. This world is filled with psuedo-realistic immitations of shadowy figures not possibly called humans. To add to this categorical truism(truth abounds), we must add the fact that the word "opinion" is foreign to this galaxy, and on the internet? phoee what a load of fooligarbagness. unbelievable fabrications of impossible conditions that we must find ourselves thrusting forward with the obvious truth that will sheer away all fabrications of falsehoods, that u sir, mr_legacy r just like everything else in this galaxy, unreal... and.. and.. u don't have an opinion either! liar!

(why does this sound so similar to the mad hermit guy in the game :) )

#189
Guest_MrHimuraChan_*

Guest_MrHimuraChan_*
  • Guests

Rostas7 wrote...

Darth_Shizz wrote...

 Image IPB

I believe I found Shale.



Nah,THIS IS SHALE!

Image IPB


Me vs Darth_Shizz ..FIGHT!!! 



Sorry Rostas7, but i think Darth_Shizz wins, here is proof:

Image IPB

#190
mousestalker

mousestalker
  • Members
  • 16 945 messages
 The sad reality is that this game, characters and artwork is really a shameless ripoff of OotS.

Proof

Image IPB

#191
Rostas7

Rostas7
  • Members
  • 83 messages

Legacy_QuEsT wrote...

chuckles471 wrote...

I hope Legacy_QuEsT is like this in real life. It would make the earth a better place to live. His ability not to concede defeat and keep his opinion even though it is crazy would be great in real life. He is definitely not a follower of people and I respect him for that.

Somebody is copying someone's voice, he speaks up like a real revolutionary agaist the majority.
Somebody has a beard? Obviously they copied Gerard Butler.

He my friends, is a free-thinker and one of the reason's that the human race is so varied.

(Sorry for earlier comments, I really hope you are real)



implausably utterly unthinkably outrageously impossible to ever consider the possibility that I am a human being with an opinion. This world is filled with psuedo-realistic immitations of shadowy figures not possibly called humans. To add to this categorical truism(truth abounds), we must add the fact that the word "opinion" is foreign to this galaxy, and on the internet? phoee what a load of fooligarbagness. unbelievable fabrications of impossible conditions that we must find ourselves thrusting forward with the obvious truth that will sheer away all fabrications of falsehoods, that u sir, mr_legacy r just like everything else in this galaxy, unreal... and.. and.. u don't have an opinion either! liar!

(why does this sound so similar to the mad hermit guy in the game :) )


Trully deep,I shall make a stunningly attempt at deriving these rants ,further plunging amidst the real meanings of this world,engulfed by the seemingly ignorant people on the internet,and to that end,opinions are welcome,even if they include unexpected and unchecked parts of anything for that matter.Considering all of this,you sir have leapt into the womb that is to this point,according to everything you have said,a downright opinion of what is thoroughly unimportant to the people who don't seem the react to this sort of problem.I humble your attempt and encourage such self-driven expectations of things to come,in this game,and beyond.So,before further ado,I shall make anonimously drunken jokes ,with my invisible yet engaging yet to be or not friend,Darth_Shizz,who is amazingly and amuzingly answering to my lame but heart-felt jokes which conduct this bland thread to a new peak.The peak of monstruous laughter. Yes,it's for the LOLs.

P.S: Has anyone understood what I just said?No? Ok...Legacy is still a master of opinions.FIRST!

#192
DragonRageGT

DragonRageGT
  • Members
  • 6 070 messages

trueKieran wrote...

That's the most ridiculous "complaint" I've read in a forum for quite some time, thanks for the laughs.


+1

igniteip wrote...

David Gaider wrote...

I do not think that word means what you think it means.
Though, to give you credit, this is the silliest argument I've heard this week -- and that's really saying something.


Plagiarism is the use without crediting the source.  Bioware listed the sources of its voice actors so there is no plagiarism.  Unless the OP meant to say that there is intellectual property in the voice itself.  Voice actor makes a living from providing a voice to a character.  It is unlikely they would want to sue the very clients that they work for.


It does happen a lot with music too. And some people gets rich from it. Let the damaged parties claim their right in a court of law... if they dare... (Like Rod Steward had to pay a lot to Jorge Ben for a "tete-tete-rete" thing in one song, and it had been done before in a song called Taj Mahal... and Jorge Ben had to change his name to Jorge Ben Jor because George Benson didn't like how the brazilian guy name sounded similar to his and won)


Sloth Of Doom wrote...

This is perhaps the stupidest thread I have seen on these forums yet. In fact, I think it deserves some sort of internet stupidity award.


This is the Mother Troll thread of all the troll threads I've ever seen! And it's quite a plagiarism of them too... OP, you could be sued for zillion dollars by lots of trolls!!!

Modifié par RageGT, 18 décembre 2009 - 01:43 .


#193
Guest_MrHimuraChan_*

Guest_MrHimuraChan_*
  • Guests

Rostas7 wrote...

Legacy_QuEsT wrote...

chuckles471 wrote...

I hope Legacy_QuEsT is like this in real life. It would make the earth a better place to live. His ability not to concede defeat and keep his opinion even though it is crazy would be great in real life. He is definitely not a follower of people and I respect him for that.

Somebody is copying someone's voice, he speaks up like a real revolutionary agaist the majority.
Somebody has a beard? Obviously they copied Gerard Butler.

He my friends, is a free-thinker and one of the reason's that the human race is so varied.

(Sorry for earlier comments, I really hope you are real)



implausably utterly unthinkably outrageously impossible to ever consider the possibility that I am a human being with an opinion. This world is filled with psuedo-realistic immitations of shadowy figures not possibly called humans. To add to this categorical truism(truth abounds), we must add the fact that the word "opinion" is foreign to this galaxy, and on the internet? phoee what a load of fooligarbagness. unbelievable fabrications of impossible conditions that we must find ourselves thrusting forward with the obvious truth that will sheer away all fabrications of falsehoods, that u sir, mr_legacy r just like everything else in this galaxy, unreal... and.. and.. u don't have an opinion either! liar!

(why does this sound so similar to the mad hermit guy in the game :) )


Trully deep,I shall make a stunningly attempt at deriving these rants ,further plunging amidst the real meanings of this world,engulfed by the seemingly ignorant people on the internet,and to that end,opinions are welcome,even if they include unexpected and unchecked parts of anything for that matter.Considering all of this,you sir have leapt into the womb that is to this point,according to everything you have said,a downright opinion of what is thoroughly unimportant to the people who don't seem the react to this sort of problem.I humble your attempt and encourage such self-driven expectations of things to come,in this game,and beyond.So,before further ado,I shall make anonimously drunken jokes ,with my invisible yet engaging yet to be or not friend,Darth_Shizz,who is amazingly and amuzingly answering to my lame but heart-felt jokes which conduct this bland thread to a new peak.The peak of monstruous laughter. Yes,it's for the LOLs.

P.S: Has anyone understood what I just said?No? Ok...Legacy is still a master of opinions.FIRST!


HEAD...HURTS :(



LOL!:D

Modifié par MrHimuraChan, 18 décembre 2009 - 01:52 .


#194
Guest_Legacy_QuEsT_*

Guest_Legacy_QuEsT_*
  • Guests

Rostas7 wrote...

Legacy_QuEsT wrote...

chuckles471 wrote...

I hope Legacy_QuEsT is like this in real life. It would make the earth a better place to live. His ability not to concede defeat and keep his opinion even though it is crazy would be great in real life. He is definitely not a follower of people and I respect him for that.

Somebody is copying someone's voice, he speaks up like a real revolutionary agaist the majority.
Somebody has a beard? Obviously they copied Gerard Butler.

He my friends, is a free-thinker and one of the reason's that the human race is so varied.

(Sorry for earlier comments, I really hope you are real)



implausably utterly unthinkably outrageously impossible to ever consider the possibility that I am a human being with an opinion. This world is filled with psuedo-realistic immitations of shadowy figures not possibly called humans. To add to this categorical truism(truth abounds), we must add the fact that the word "opinion" is foreign to this galaxy, and on the internet? phoee what a load of fooligarbagness. unbelievable fabrications of impossible conditions that we must find ourselves thrusting forward with the obvious truth that will sheer away all fabrications of falsehoods, that u sir, mr_legacy r just like everything else in this galaxy, unreal... and.. and.. u don't have an opinion either! liar!

(why does this sound so similar to the mad hermit guy in the game :) )


Trully deep,I shall make a stunningly attempt at deriving these rants ,further plunging amidst the real meanings of this world,engulfed by the seemingly ignorant people on the internet,and to that end,opinions are welcome,even if they include unexpected and unchecked parts of anything for that matter.Considering all of this,you sir have leapt into the womb that is to this point,according to everything you have said,a downright opinion of what is thoroughly unimportant to the people who don't seem the react to this sort of problem.I humble your attempt and encourage such self-driven expectations of things to come,in this game,and beyond.So,before further ado,I shall make anonimously drunken jokes ,with my invisible yet engaging yet to be or not friend,Darth_Shizz,who is amazingly and amuzingly answering to my lame but heart-felt jokes which conduct this bland thread to a new peak.The peak of monstruous laughter. Yes,it's for the LOLs.

P.S: Has anyone understood what I just said?No? Ok...Legacy is still a master of opinions.FIRST!


TLDR!

<-- explains

#195
Darth_Shizz

Darth_Shizz
  • Members
  • 672 messages
 Image IPB

Sorry to defile such a magnificent piece of artistry, but the depiction of male genitalia in stone is not adequate for such an upstanding thread.

I still prefer my original vision of Shale :(

Modifié par Darth_Shizz, 18 décembre 2009 - 01:48 .


#196
Guest_MrHimuraChan_*

Guest_MrHimuraChan_*
  • Guests

Darth_Shizz wrote...

 Image IPB

Sorry to defile such a magnificent piece of artistry, but the depiction of male genitalia in stone is not adequate for such an upstanding thread.

I still prefer my original vision of Shale :(


Gee thanks! Now there is Pepsi all over my monitor! :P

#197
DeIssan

DeIssan
  • Members
  • 91 messages

Legacy_QuEsT wrote...
the question is, are all opinions illogical or just my opinion, and in that case, is that your opinion? and if that is your opinion than how do we know that the facts are that your opinion is that my opinion is illogical and not the facts be that in fact all opinions are illogical? Please answer sir.


I would say just yours. The prevailing feeling on this board is that you're way off and there's not yet a single voice to defend any part of your asumptions or statements.
Have to give you credits for sticking to your guns though no matter how flawed and ill informed your arguments might be.

#198
DeIssan

DeIssan
  • Members
  • 91 messages

Legacy_QuEsT wrote...

the difference is they paid the guy to be the voice actor and for his likeness. They did NOT pay the person who's voice they copied for Bherat

Who said they paid any real or historical persons for likeness? They BASED some models on known images I think, that's not copying and the model created may be similar to, but is not in fact, the known image. For those images willingly based on a  known entity I think they were credited.

Legacy_QuEsT wrote...
if they are obviously copying people and paying some and ignoring and not telling others about their copies than why r people denying that the copying is going on. it obviously is even by your own admission of pictures. the only difference is that they paid some and they didn't pay others, and that is what my issue is. they should pay everyone they copy. that is my OPINION end of story.


First, PLEASE stay off the lyrium, you've had enough already!
Second, please at least try to grasp the concepts of likeness and copy and the fact that they differ.
Voice actors was paid to come up with characters for varius roles in the game, chain ends there. What the VAs based their basic character on doesn't realy matter as it's doesn't come within the areas of copyrights.
As you say they DO credit sources, so there's two plausible answers here.

A. It's a devilish conspiracy to crush this unknow actor by estimating his portrayal of a charter in a b-movie and depriving him of his natural born rights to be the only one using those manerisms and tonal qualities and blatantly denying him any recognition.

B. They don't know he excist and the VAs voice just coicidentally happened to sound similar.

As they didn't credit him as the source, what do you think is the most likely of the answers (remember Occam's razor).

#199
XoltriX

XoltriX
  • Members
  • 1 messages

Tonya777 wrote...

Yeah sure and its plagerism too because

Alistair kind of looks like Chris Jericho
Wynne looks like your grandma
Loghain looks like your grandpa
The dog resembles that dog from that one movie
Sten looks like Will Smith 40 years in the future
Zevran looks like Link from Zelda
Lelianna looks like my little sisters friends mom
Shale looks like that pile of rocks in your front yard
Ogrehn looks like Mario Batali

ITS ALL PLAGERISM THEN! (GASP!)


QFT

#200
Rostas7

Rostas7
  • Members
  • 83 messages
Yeah,and Morrigan looks like your still-to-be excentric and pampered ex-girlfriend.I'm just sayin.