302 réponses à ce sujet

[Lukanp]

No.

[Tirranek]

To the OP. I enjoyed it, yes. But these topics are like fly paper.

[General Skidog]

john_sheparrd wrote...

General Skidog wrote...

No, you silly fan boy.

It's my opinion you silly hater

Obviously, no need to restate the obvious by trying to validate your crappy taste in mediocre games.

[Chewin]

None of the ME games are masterpieces. Even if ME3 had been the best ending in history, it would still be crap b/c of the overall plot.

[Tirranek]

john_sheparrd wrote...

Tirranek wrote...

To the OP. I enjoyed it, yes. But these topics are like fly paper.

yeah maybe you are right but there are so much threads about Mass effecct 3 sucked here and Mass effect 3 sucked there so I was just curious if I'm the only one who really liked it

Yup, I'm sure there are plenty, the majority of whom are probably playing the game or have moved on to other things now that the ending is complete (as in, how it's going to stay). When the EC landed lots of people said they enjoyed it.

Then again I'm one of these freaks who actually didn't mind the original endings. I'd go so far to say that the original ones created a very different, and arguably more powerful feeling than the EC. I do enjoy what they did with them though.

[kolibri_]

john_sheparrd wrote...

yeah maybe you are right but there are so much threads about Mass effecct 3 sucked here and Mass effect 3 sucked there so I was just curious if I'm the only one who really liked it

It's good to see some positive thinking around here. Especially considering all the hating and crying that is going on in the forums. In my opinion, ME3 wasn't a masterpiece, but I really enjoyed it. The original ending hurt at first, but with EC it turned out pretty well.

[Iozeph]

john_sheparrd wrote...

 So who's with me ??
I didn't like the endings but with the ec I'm happy 
the other 95% of the game were epic 

Edit: It's just a masterpiece because of Me 1 and Me 2 the characters we met, the conflicts(genophage etc.)
It is a wonderful conclusion, so nobody'S with me??

[palician]

StrawberryRainPop wrote...

john_sheparrd wrote...

 So who's with me ??
I didn't like the endings but with the ec I'm happy 
the other 95% of the game were epic 

No.

Witcher 2 is a masterpiece.
Mass Effect 1&2 are masterpieces.

Mass Effect 3 is good, but a watered down version with better presentation, and a terrible ending, even with the EC.
Its not even close to being a masterpiece.

Plus the lack of replay value due to some big past choices not really making a difference(rachni,collector base ect).

[Dendio1]

KiwiQuiche wrote...

Ah, another one of these threads.

And to answer your topic, no ME3 isn't a masterpiece.

It's an okay game, not great, not fantastic. If anything it is mediocre.

Yea the ONLY ONE of these threads surrounded by those threads (forums is playing 1000 ways to dislike mass effect).

I'll stand by the OP
My initial run of mass effect 3 was breathtaking and amazing until the endings. EC makes the endings much better. I'm happy to consider ME3 a masterpiece. Mass effect series as a whole is a masterpiece. I'm sad to see it go

Modifié par Dendio1, 18 juillet 2012 - 11:38 .

[SpamBot2000]

Disagreed, OP.

Modifié par SpamBot2000, 18 juillet 2012 - 11:39 .

[The Eruptionist]

Masterpiece is a very strong word that I have reserved only for describing a few things in life such as Bruce Springsteen's album 'Born to Run'. That being said; the game is great with moments of absolute brilliance. These moments of brilliance exist throughout the game and throughout the ending. The collective Mass Effect series is something I would consider a masterpiece but I believe ME3, as a stand alone game, is just underneath that classification. An absolutely fantastic game by itself but only a masterpiece when combined with the ME1 and ME2.

Including you, John_shepard; I counted 3 people in this thread who share your perspective. I would like to add myself as the fourth. 

[Dendio1]

Sometimes you need overly strong words (masterpiece) to counter the overly negative words (turd) floating about.

[Tirranek]

I'd say it has some masterful moments, relatively speaking of course, since we're talking about games. Mordin, Tali finding home, Grunts almost last stand, all the shoutouts from previous games, it was a unique experience for me, and one of my favourites.

[Rhayak]

Although i'm not 100% happy about Mass Effect 3 as i was about the first and second, i am with you.

If anything, threads like yours rekindle some positivity in this forum of insipid nitpickers.

[The Angry One]

Rhayak wrote...

Although i'm not 100% happy about Mass Effect 3 as i was about the first and second, i am with you.

If anything, threads like yours rekindle some positivity in this forum of insipid nitpickers.

Yes, because blind praise is so much better. <_<
Also, science fiction is a nitpicky genre. Deal with it.

Modifié par The Angry One, 18 juillet 2012 - 11:52 .

[Dendio1]

Blind praise feels refreshing if nothing else. Forums got better when EC released, then delved even lower than ever.

Modifié par Dendio1, 18 juillet 2012 - 11:53 .

[Kamfrenchie]

Dendio1 wrote...

KiwiQuiche wrote...

Ah, another one of these threads.

And to answer your topic, no ME3 isn't a masterpiece.

It's an okay game, not great, not fantastic. If anything it is mediocre.

Yea the ONLY ONE of these threads surrounded by those threads (forums is playing 1000 ways to dislike mass effect).

I'll stand by the OP
My initial run of mass effect 3 was breathtaking and amazing until the endings. EC makes the endings much better. I'm happy to consider ME3 a masterpiece. Mass effect series as a whole is a masterpiece. I'm sad to see it go

a masterpiece ? with horrible antagonists (kai leng, stupid TIM, mute harbinger), EMS not mattering much ? Thessia's terrible boss fight ? hyper linear gameplay and corridors ? being forcd to bargain with a genocidal kid ?


Fallout 1 is a mastepiece, the baldur's gate serie also is. Mass effect 3 doesn't do anything well enoug to deserve such a title, at last I don't see how

[Dendio1]

Kamfrenchie wrote...

Dendio1 wrote...

KiwiQuiche wrote...

Ah, another one of these threads.

And to answer your topic, no ME3 isn't a masterpiece.

It's an okay game, not great, not fantastic. If anything it is mediocre.

Yea the ONLY ONE of these threads surrounded by those threads (forums is playing 1000 ways to dislike mass effect).

I'll stand by the OP
My initial run of mass effect 3 was breathtaking and amazing until the endings. EC makes the endings much better. I'm happy to consider ME3 a masterpiece. Mass effect series as a whole is a masterpiece. I'm sad to see it go

a masterpiece ? with horrible antagonists (kai leng, stupid TIM, mute harbinger), EMS not mattering much ? Thessia's terrible boss fight ? hyper linear gameplay and corridors ? being forcd to bargain with a genocidal kid ?


Fallout 1 is a mastepiece, the baldur's gate serie also is. Mass effect 3 doesn't do anything well enoug to deserve such a title, at last I don't see how

There was a great thread way back when that listed every single "problem" with the game and admitted that if the endings were good none of it would have mattered. Most people agreed

[Baronesa]

Total Biscuit wrote...

Mass Effect 1&2 are masterpieces.

Mass effect 3 in comparison is like a half finished sketch that someone else took the credit for, then blew their nose on it.

The EC wipes most of the snot off, but it's still stained with mucous, and it's never going to get finished.

You sir, explained it very well

[The Angry One]

Dendio1 wrote...

Blind praise feels refreshing if nothing else. Forums got better when EC released, then delved even lower than ever.

Blind praise should never be given for anything.

[ElementL09]

I wouldn't go as far as to this game is a master piece, I mean in my opinion its not the best entry in the trilogy.