207 réponses à ce sujet

[shepskisaac]

masster blaster wrote...

Or EA would think they could get a lot of money if they go with IT and charge about 10 to 15 bucks to download the IT dlc.

So why didn't they make IT DLC and instead wasted time and money polishing fake dream? I bet in a year people will still be going "yeah, ME3 DLC stopped coming out but that doesn't mean there can never be IT DLC because never say never!". No. The devs have released the ending they intended and then they've spent additional months and millions of $ to expand on that ending. It's done, over.

Modifié par IsaacShep, 20 juillet 2012 - 04:50 .

[CoolioThane]

IsaacShep wrote...

CoolioThane wrote...

Finance...they'd gain shedloads from an IT DLC...

No they wouldn't. Only a part of the most hardcore fanbase wants IT DLC. The rest wants to move on finally.

Not to mention that they would never spend months and millions of $ just to polish the fake/trick 'dream'/hallucination, especially after how big and damaging the entire controversy was. Time to face the reality. This is what they intended.

Haha, you don't get it do you? The hardcor fanbase would all buy the DLC. It's Mass Effect. Just because you don't agree with IT doesn't mean a lot of people who think the same wouldn't be interested in buying a DLC.

The hardcore fans are the ones who spend the most money on ME anyway; they buy books, comics, figures etc. it'd make sense to  keep them interested

They would. The controversy is over, people have settled after the EC. The IT being released in the future would shock people, get people talking again, people would go back and buy the ME games...more money. "FAce reality, this is what they intended" <-- That's pretty dismissive and you're talking in definites even though you don't know for certain.

I'm talking in opinions and views, you're being quite dismissive.

shepdog77 wrote...

CoolioThane wrote...

Are you used to getting everything your own way, Shepdog?

When someone disagrees with you do you get upset and throw a hissy? (No need to answer that, we all know that's true)

Again and again, you continually throw out remarks like that towards me, when I have done nothing specifically inflammatory towards you.  I am simply requesting Bioware to move the IT thread to its rightful place.  I don't want it locked or removed from society or anything like that.  If they choose not to that's Bioware's prerogative, but there's no need to tell me I'm "throwing a hissy" for simply making a simple and logical request.

 

You have insulted me by calling the IT a fanfic. It's "rightful" place is at the to of the story and campaign discussion forum...where it is! You're throwing a hissy fit, it's not logical either 

[Haiyato]

No need to move the IT thread. Let it stay. I find the stuff interesting. Alot of stuff in game can easily point to being indoctrinated.

[cyrslash1974]

Honnestly, I don't see the interest of this kind of petition, excepted if the OP wants an official "civil war" on BSN between players.

Pro-IT, anti-IT, we don't care ! We are the fanbase, together (and I'm not a pro-IT, if you want to know).

[shepdog77]

Let's keep this discussion on why the IT thread should be moved to it's rightful place in the Fan Creation forum, and not whether the endings contain bad writing or not.

Modifié par shepdog77, 20 juillet 2012 - 04:52 .

[RavenEyry]

IsaacShep wrote...

masster blaster wrote...

Or EA would think they could get a lot of money if they go with IT and charge about 10 to 15 bucks to download the IT dlc.

So why didn't they make IT DLC and instead wasted time and money polishing fake dream? I bet in a year people will still be going "yeah, ME3 DLC stopped coming out but that doesn't mean there can never be IT DLC because never say never!". No. The devs have released the ending they intended and then they've spent additional months and millions of $ to expand on that ending. It's done, over.

Since they plan to expand the ending with further DLC it is not beyond the realms of possibility that they plan an IT DlC at some point.

[RR1107]

shepdog77 wrote...

Let's keep this discussion on why the IT thread should be moved to it's rightful place in the Fan Creation forum, and not whether the endings contain bad writing or not.

I'm really hoping that the Mods decide to put you in your rightful place, which is banned for incitement.

[RavenEyry]

shepdog77 wrote...

Let's keep this discussion on why the IT thread should be moved to it's rightful place in the Fan Creation forum, and not whether the endings contain bad writing or not.

You keep saying 'rightful place' even though several people have objectively told you it is already in the right place. There is no need for further discussion on the topic which is why posters have started to drift off.

[shepskisaac]

CoolioThane wrote...

They would. The controversy is over, people have settled after the EC. The IT being released in the future would shock people, get people talking again, people would go back and buy the ME games...more money.

No it wouldn't cause any big stir or anything. Only hardcore fans care at this point. And hardcore fans ain't enough. Hardcore fans weren't able to support DA2 long enough even for 3rd DLC.

[RavenEyry]

IsaacShep wrote...

CoolioThane wrote...

They would. The controversy is over, people have settled after the EC. The IT being released in the future would shock people, get people talking again, people would go back and buy the ME games...more money.

No it wouldn't cause any big stir or anything. Only hardcore fans care at this point. And hardcore fans ain't enough. Hardcore fans weren't able to support DA2 long enough even for 3rd DLC.

And hardcore fans will buy DLC whether it's IT related or not.

[shepdog77]

RR1107 wrote...

shepdog77 wrote...

Let's keep this discussion on why the IT thread should be moved to it's rightful place in the Fan Creation forum, and not whether the endings contain bad writing or not.

I'm really hoping that the Mods decide to put you in your rightful place, which is banned for incitement.

So I should be banned because my request disagrees with your views?  How mature.

Modifié par shepdog77, 20 juillet 2012 - 04:57 .

[CoolioThane]

IsaacShep wrote...

CoolioThane wrote...

They would. The controversy is over, people have settled after the EC. The IT being released in the future would shock people, get people talking again, people would go back and buy the ME games...more money.

No it wouldn't cause any big stir or anything. Only hardcore fans care at this point. And hardcore fans ain't enough. Hardcore fans weren't able to support DA2 long enough even for 3rd DLC.

That's your opinion...though I'm pretty sure ME3 is still pretty popular...people still playing mp will still have the discs in drives...and will see advertisements etc...

ME3 is a much, much, much bigger game than DA2 anyway

[syropbananowy]

shepdog77 wrote...

Let's keep this discussion on why the IT thread should be moved to it's rightful place in the Fan Creation forum, and not whether the endings contain bad writing or not.

Well, a lot of people, including me, explaind to you that it is in it's rightful place. Find a definition of the word interpretation.

[shepskisaac]

RavenEyry wrote...

And hardcore fans will buy DLC whether it's IT related or not.

Yes they will. But hardcore fans ain't enough, like I said. If they were, 3rd DA2 DLC wouldn't get cancelled

[masster blaster]

IsaacShep wrote...

CoolioThane wrote...

They would. The controversy is over, people have settled after the EC. The IT being released in the future would shock people, get people talking again, people would go back and buy the ME games...more money.

No it wouldn't cause any big stir or anything. Only hardcore fans care at this point. And hardcore fans ain't enough. Hardcore fans weren't able to support DA2 long enough even for 3rd DLC.

It's because lots of people thought dragon age two was going to be like a Mass effect game, where you import your DA;O character/Awakinging and play as your greywarden, but you didn't.

Modifié par masster blaster, 20 juillet 2012 - 04:59 .

[CoolioThane]

IsaacShep wrote...

RavenEyry wrote...

And hardcore fans will buy DLC whether it's IT related or not.

Yes they will. But hardcore fans ain't enough, like I said. If they were, 3rd DA2 DLC wouldn't get cancelled

And like I said, ME3 is a much, much  bigger game than DA2 and all of the casual palyers still playing MP are obviously still interested in the game and would buy DLC if they hear people talking about it 

[RR1107]

shepdog77 wrote...

RR1107 wrote...

shepdog77 wrote...

Let's keep this discussion on why the IT thread should be moved to it's rightful place in the Fan Creation forum, and not whether the endings contain bad writing or not.

I'm really hoping that the Mods decide to put you in your rightful place, which is banned for incitement.

So I should be banned because me request disagrees with your views?  How mature.

Actually, if you read my previous post you would see that I neither agree with or deny the IT; I really have no opinion on it.  You should be banned because you are intentionally trying to agitate people with your nonsense thread about an "offical" (which it is clearly not) petition to move the IT thread out of the forum to which it obviously belongs.  YOUR thread is in fact the one that does not belong in this forum.  Create a project and put your thoughts in there, if you feel so inclined, but your thread has NOTHING at ALL to do with the campaign or the story of Mass Effect 3.  The Indoctrination Theory, agree with it or not, has EVERYTHING to do with the Campaign and Story of Mass Effect 3.
In the event that you are in fact not attempting to incite people, then I can only conclude that you aren't intellegent enough to understand that discussion about events that happen within the game and making opinions about those events is relevant to discussion about the Story and Campaign of Mass Effect 3.  Since I would rather not insult your intellegence, I will assume that your intent is to aggravate people.  If that is the case, you should be banned in my opinion.

Modifié par RR1107, 20 juillet 2012 - 05:09 .

[shepdog77]

RR1107 wrote...

shepdog77 wrote...

RR1107 wrote...

shepdog77 wrote...

Let's keep this discussion on why the IT thread should be moved to it's rightful place in the Fan Creation forum, and not whether the endings contain bad writing or not.

I'm really hoping that the Mods decide to put you in your rightful place, which is banned for incitement.

So I should be banned because me request disagrees with your views?  How mature.

*snip rambling*

Well thanks for not insulting my intelligence.  <_<

[RR1107]

shepdog77 wrote...

RR1107 wrote...

shepdog77 wrote...

RR1107 wrote...

shepdog77 wrote...

Let's keep this discussion on why the IT thread should be moved to it's rightful place in the Fan Creation forum, and not whether the endings contain bad writing or not.

I'm really hoping that the Mods decide to put you in your rightful place, which is banned for incitement.

So I should be banned because me request disagrees with your views?  How mature.

*snip rambling*

Well thanks for not insulting my intelligence.  <_<

How mature...

Call my explaination "rambling" if you want, but you still don't explain at all how discussion about the Indoctrination Theory is not valid Campaign and Story discussion.  Just because your opinion is that it isn't a valid theory, doesn't mean that it isn't a valid discussion of the story of the game.

Modifié par RR1107, 20 juillet 2012 - 05:13 .

[TSA_383]

IsaacShep wrote...

masster blaster wrote...

Or EA would think they could get a lot of money if they go with IT and charge about 10 to 15 bucks to download the IT dlc.

So why didn't they make IT DLC and instead wasted time and money polishing fake dream? I bet in a year people will still be going "yeah, ME3 DLC stopped coming out but that doesn't mean there can never be IT DLC because never say never!". No. The devs have released the ending they intended and then they've spent additional months and millions of $ to expand on that ending. It's done, over.

EC wasn't the only thing they were working on in that time in the SP front. You really think a few animated sequences and a bunch of slides took a competent development studio 3 months?

Leviathan DLC is finished.
Priestly said the other day he's been playing through it

shepdog77 wrote...

syropbananowy wrote...

shepdog77 wrote...

Applepie_Svk wrote...

Eterna5 wrote...

Anyone who thinks IT is real at this point are in serious denial.

Than you accept bad writing...

Bad writing is an opinion, not fact.  IT is just false, though.

I
really don't understand why do you care so much. Don't you have better
things to do? If you don't like the IT thread just don't read it.
Problem solved.

Because IT'ers are the bane of BSN.  I like to talk about the game, not people's head canon.

Cool Story bro.
Protip:

If you don't want to read IT stuff...
Stay out of the IT thread

I know this idea may stagger your little mind with its complexity, but I assure you it will be most effective

[CoolioThane]

This thread is a prime example of "OP fails"

[mjboldy]

shepdog77 wrote...

CoolioThane wrote...

Jesus H Christ. Why is it people who don't see the game the way we ITers see it are so hostile towards us. Get a life.

I have shown no hostility towards anybody.  You, on the other hand, have been very inflammatory to me and others several times because your precious theory has come into question.  Look in the mirror pal.

Right... Lets take a look at another thread real quick...

shepdog77 wrote...

liggy002 wrote...

C'mon, Harbinger DID say something, anyone who tells me otherwise is not being truthful. There was a clear moment between him and Shepard. To say that it was just sound effects is just ridiculous.

The audio team confirmed he didn't say anything, yet you call it a lie.  You, sir, are an idiot.

You reported someone calling your idea lame because it was a personal attack? So what you did right there was a professional mature assessment of an opinion.

Reported for personal attack 

(Not really, but hypocritical much? Don't act like your a victime here.)

Modifié par mjboldy, 20 juillet 2012 - 05:18 .

[shepdog77]

CoolioThane wrote...

This thread is a prime example of "OP fails"

Please, insult me again.  Your words hurt so good.

[Xellith]

shepdog77 wrote...

RR1107 wrote...

shepdog77 wrote...

Let's keep this discussion on why the IT thread should be moved to it's rightful place in the Fan Creation forum, and not whether the endings contain bad writing or not.

I'm really hoping that the Mods decide to put you in your rightful place, which is banned for incitement.

So I should be banned because my request disagrees with your views?  How mature.

This coming from a someone who supposedly reported a person for responding to the thread saying "lame"?

Modifié par Xellith, 20 juillet 2012 - 05:17 .

[shepdog77]

mjboldy wrote...

shepdog77 wrote...

CoolioThane wrote...

Jesus H Christ. Why is it people who don't see the game the way we ITers see it are so hostile towards us. Get a life.

I have shown no hostility towards anybody.  You, on the other hand, have been very inflammatory to me and others several times because your precious theory has come into question.  Look in the mirror pal.

Right... Lets take a look at another thread real quick...

shepdog77 wrote...

liggy002 wrote...

C'mon, Harbinger DID say something, anyone who tells me otherwise is not being truthful. There was a clear moment between him and Shepard. To say that it was just sound effects is just ridiculous.

The audio team confirmed he didn't say anything, yet you call it a lie.  You, sir, are an idiot.

You reported someone calling your idea lame because it was a personal attack? So what you did right there was a professional mature assesment of an opinion.

Reported for personal attack 

(Not really but hypocritical much. Don't act like your a victime here.)

Well denying something that is a known fact would be described as idiocy, no?

Edit: Also, I reported no one, it was sarcasm.

Modifié par shepdog77, 20 juillet 2012 - 05:22 .