51 réponses à ce sujet

[Ticonderoga117]

BuzzShepardN7 wrote...

Yeah while the paragons were probably crying their eyes out, I needed a renegade interrupt or option where Shepard suddenly turns away and shakes his/her head and mutters- "Should have let me help you, you stupid kid. Joker, get us out of here, this place is hopeless."

Even my paragon Shep wanted to do this.

I give exactly 0 cares for anyone who died on Earth/Palaven/Thessia/Kar'shan/Sur'Kesh.
Why? Because I've been telling these guys for three years... but OH NO, don't believe Commander Shepard. Yeah well I told you so! Enjoy space squids.

[Sajuro]

Taboo-XX wrote...

Ozida wrote...

Taboo-XX wrote...
HOW DARE YOU QUESTION MAC WALTERS WRITING CRETIN.

THE ONLY PERSON THAT MATTERS TO SHEPARD IN ME3 IS BILLY THE ****ING KID.

Wait... YOU KNOW HIS NAME? I think you are the only person who actually does.

****** McGee was already taken.

What about ****** mcglobicus?

[Necrotron]

I don't know about everyone else, but my Shepard felt nothing for the freaky Reaper kid.

Modifié par Bathaius, 23 juillet 2012 - 07:38 .

[MetioricTest]

Bathaius wrote...

I don't know about everyone else, but my Shepard felt nothing for the freaky Reaper kid.

SO BE IT!

[Zardoc]

MetioricTest wrote...

You spend the entire game dreaming about that one kid and then make that kid the image of the leader of the enemies

What about these poor guys? They died too



Honestly if I had nightmares about giant shadowy asses in the foreground with a hot girl in the background after sleeping with my girlfriend... I wouldn't be too bothered. But dreaming about little boys after ****ing Tali just seems wrong somehow. Especially considering I just risked her life by ****ing her.

Stupid kid, making my Shepard do weird things.

You didn't though.

[sH0tgUn jUliA]

Yeah, Shepard is going to dream about one kid. Shepard isn't going to dream about because EDI kept saying the IFF is almost ready in ME2 that Shepard did one last little side mission before the Suicide Mission, because of some stupid glitch in the save game.

Shepard got to watch Kelly die in the tube. You remember Kelly. "I always have time for you, Commander." You know, the one who may have had dinner with you and fed your fish? Her. Shepard got to watch her screaming and pounding helplessly as she was turned into mush on the Collector Base.

Or Thane Krios, whom she actually came to love, and got to watch him taken by seeker swarms.

Shepard is going to dream about some kid she's seen once, because Mac Walters said "this is a child and you will care about him, and I will beat you over the head with this kid every XX game hours until you're sympathetic enough to be sympathetic to my ending."

[Arturia Pendragon]

But....but...this is a child. And it's dead. FEEL SAD!

[incinerator950]

Feel bad for the millions of people trapped on Worlds where the Reapers are forcing them to surrender. Or the Millions being blasted from Orbital Bombardment on Factory Cities and Industrial planets.

[eternalnightmare13]

It was just weird, cause after 2 games you finally see a kid, a shallow one dimensional kid none the less, and he's supposed to be the chosen emotional connection to the game. What about your LI or someone like Garrus/Tali/Liara getting killed in front of your Shepard. Oh...wait...Mac...Walters...no balls...nevermind...

[Ledgend1221]

I could not care less about the kid.
Anderson would have been a better choice to kill off.

Remember in ME2 when Shepard and the Normandy got spaced? Thats how its done.

[v TricKy v]

Why dont you care for the Child?
Appreciate my "art"

*slaps you in the face with "Artistic Integrity"*

[Red Panda]

Arturia Pendragon wrote...

But....but...this is a child. And it's dead. FEEL SAD!

Is it bad I lol'd at the kid dying because he refused help from Shepard?

[MetioricTest]

incinerator950 wrote...

Feel bad for the millions of people trapped on Worlds where the Reapers are forcing them to surrender. Or the Millions being blasted from Orbital Bombardment on Factory Cities and Industrial planets.

The ones I feel bad for are the ones on the Citadel.  Sure some escaped but  surely the Reapers killed the rest (the majority even)


Somebody told me somebody important on Twitter (I hate Twitter btw) said that most people on the Citadel survived by hiding out in small sections, defended by C-sec that the Reapers ignored because they had control of the station.

But that sounds even worse. Millions being trapped with a dwlinding defense force as super-powered aliens pick you off and control where you live sounds like the plot of a horror movie. Especially for the ones still alive but who are not inside the defended sections.

If I had the means I'd make a movie with this plot. A guy trapped on the Citadel trying to survive this hell could be entertaining

[The Angry One]

MetioricTest wrote...

If I had the means I'd make a movie with this plot. A guy trapped on the Citadel trying to survive this hell could be entertaining

Wouldn't that just be Dead Space?

[shodiswe]

MetioricTest wrote...

arial wrote...

well, to most mature people the death of a child is much more tragic then the death of an Adult.

I apologize for my immaturity 

Next time I will only care for one of the victims when a large amount of people are murdered so I can be a better person.

I don't know about that, to me it depends on who they are.. I really think defenseless civilians in general makes for a good tragedy in general, in normal wars children are innocents who had nothing to do with the war since they had no say in it. However when it commes to the reapers it's more like a Tsunami or a similar natural dissaster.

If the adults are out there fighting a stupid war then it's slightly different but they were defenseless people.

A lot of parrents or grandparents might think their child is more important to them therefor the idea of children first since they are also more vulnerable and the future, the continuation of their parrents.

I know I was a little bit conflicted about that I-robot movie, there it wasn't even about choosing between two people, it was about choosing between someone who had lost conciousness with waterfilled lungs and likely woudln't survive the ascent to safety and survive long enough to recive first aid, or someone who was still concious and had a good chance to survive if helped but who wouldn't survive unless helped. The sensitive part here was that the likely already dead person was a little girl and the robot saved the man that seemed to have good survival odds(but not without the robots intervention).

Avoid two toombstones and get only one by saving who can be saved or save who likely can't be saved and hope for a miracle to only get one toombstone?

In most cases adults have an easier time to save themselves which is why children needs more help.
The Adult reaction would be to protect their children, it's in the genes since those who cared for their children had an easier time to have their genes passed on, therefor it becommes the most prevalent point of view, and also most accepted.

[shodiswe]

MetioricTest wrote...

incinerator950 wrote...

Feel bad for the millions of people trapped on Worlds where the Reapers are forcing them to surrender. Or the Millions being blasted from Orbital Bombardment on Factory Cities and Industrial planets.

The ones I feel bad for are the ones on the Citadel.  Sure some escaped but  surely the Reapers killed the rest (the majority even)


Somebody told me somebody important on Twitter (I hate Twitter btw) said that most people on the Citadel survived by hiding out in small sections, defended by C-sec that the Reapers ignored because they had control of the station.

But that sounds even worse. Millions being trapped with a dwlinding defense force as super-powered aliens pick you off and control where you live sounds like the plot of a horror movie. Especially for the ones still alive but who are not inside the defended sections.

If I had the means I'd make a movie with this plot. A guy trapped on the Citadel trying to survive this hell could be entertaining

I could make for an entertaining movie, add a few other survivors along the way that dies horribly like a Krogan that tells the protagonist to stop being a frightened Pyjak and start headbutting the reaper husks, then the Krogan dies horribly as the protagonist retreats and eventualy meets new people...
Might not seem heroic but it could be entertaining with all the fun and tragic character you can throw in  

[Kingthlayer]

shepdog77 wrote...

Oh just stop it. I'm sure the first time you saw this scene you thought it was moving. You're letting your feelings about the Catalyst get in the way.

Not really.  It's the stupid kids fault he died.  Plus I was still angry over the "Get out here" line from Shepard, I thought I'd yell at this idiot but instead of talks all gentle to him.  I was glad to see him dead, but then I had to see hime another 5 times throughout the game, and the dreams is easily the worst part of them game.

I really hope BioWare removes them from the game, they add nothing.

[SSPBOURNE]

MetioricTest wrote...

You spend the entire game dreaming about that one kid and then make that kid the image of the leader of the enemies

What about these poor guys? They died too



Honestly if I had nightmares about giant shadowy asses in the foreground with a hot girl in the background after sleeping with my girlfriend... I wouldn't be too bothered. But dreaming about little boys after ****ing Tali just seems wrong somehow. Especially considering I just risked her life by ****ing her.

Stupid kid, making my Shepard do weird things.

She becoems immune to your after the first time.
DUH.

[RavenEyry]

arial wrote...

well, to most mature people the death of a child is much more tragic then the death of an Adult.

I consider any undeserved death equally tragic.

shepdog77 wrote...

Oh just stop it. I'm sure the first
time you saw this scene you thought it was moving. You're letting your
feelings about the Catalyst get in the way.

I didn't. It was such an obvious attempt to tug the heartstrings that I was neutral throughout the whole thing.
Still wasn't as bad as the little girl in one of the trailers. I actually laughed out loud the first time because of the reaper deciding to personally go after that one kid alone in a field.

Modifié par RavenEyry, 31 juillet 2012 - 04:03 .

[Fawx9]

shepdog77 wrote...

Oh just stop it. I'm sure the first time you saw this scene you thought it was moving. You're letting your feelings about the Catalyst get in the way.

No i took it for what it was, Bioware saying "**** has hit the fan, look we even had a kid die"

And then I moved on. Oh but apparently my Shepard didn't. Instead of worrying about Thane or Mordin or Kadin or Reeger or Jenkins or coming back to life  or etc(you get the point), it's the kid in the vent, who should win a darwin award, that my Shepard has nightmares of.

And then to bring it full circle and to my great enjoyment its the vent brat again as the catalyst.

The concept was average at best and was executed horribly.

Modifié par Fawx9, 31 juillet 2012 - 04:13 .

[Simotech]

Shepard pls

[MetioricTest]

SSPBOURNE wrote...

MetioricTest wrote...

You spend the entire game dreaming about that one kid and then make that kid the image of the leader of the enemies

What about these poor guys? They died too



Honestly if I had nightmares about giant shadowy asses in the foreground with a hot girl in the background after sleeping with my girlfriend... I wouldn't be too bothered. But dreaming about little boys after ****ing Tali just seems wrong somehow. Especially considering I just risked her life by ****ing her.

Stupid kid, making my Shepard do weird things.

She becoems immune to your after the first time.
DUH.

"over time" meaning at least two times you risked killing her.

[Goneaviking]

MetioricTest wrote...

Honestly if I had nightmares about giant shadowy asses in the foreground with a hot girl in the background after sleeping with my girlfriend... I wouldn't be too bothered. But dreaming about little boys after ****ing Tali just seems wrong somehow. Especially considering I just risked her life by ****ing her.

Stupid kid, making my Shepard do weird things.

The child was the only one that Shepard had any interaction with. Makes it more personal than the billion other civilians whom have never had the privilege of talking to Shepard before dying in front of him.

Also, you never risked Tali's life by doing naked things to her. Quarians are as allergic to each other as they are everyone else, that's why sharing their air is such an intimate act.

[incinerator950]

The Angry One wrote...

MetioricTest wrote...

If I had the means I'd make a movie with this plot. A guy trapped on the Citadel trying to survive this hell could be entertaining

Wouldn't that just be Dead Space?

If it involves lots of swearing, gore, and a girl with a hot accent, yes.  It also involves a semi-original plot and a satisfying ending.

[Urdnot_Bucdawg]

Bolt-Action wrote...

A person's subconscious has a way of truly f*****g you over mentally, physically or emotionally once
A person has seen horrific events-the best part, no control of it when they close their eyes, just hold on for the ride.
A child is considered "innocent" and tends to be more difficult to cope with because people relate to their own.
While adults are dismissed as, wrong place wrong time, they chose to be there etc

I suppose the alternative would have been Shepard saves the kid , takes him with him \\ her and he becomes the ship mascot. Ten minutes of that and I'd toss him out the airlock:devil: