Aller au contenu

Piranha balance thread - Lower DPS or RoF or Clip Size or increase Weight


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
1320 réponses à ce sujet

#401
Pride Demon

Pride Demon
  • Members
  • 1 342 messages

death_for_sale wrote...

Pride Demon wrote...

death_for_sale wrote...

To give a better idea, this is a pic about 25 Meters with Smart Choke, and a 15% accuracy boost from HM.

Image IPB

We need a Claymore pic for comparison though...


Claymore, SC, 15% HM, same distance.

Image IPB

Thanks for the comparison picture, OP... :)
Well, it does seem that the Claymore is more accurate, the shots are more concentrated in the middle...

I still wonder the reason for the different reticle on the Piranha though...

#402
brian_breed

brian_breed
  • Members
  • 799 messages
The weapon in the first screencap is a GPR. Look at its arc forward and snubbed edges.

#403
neteng101

neteng101
  • Members
  • 1 451 messages

usctrojanbulldog wrote...

My experience tells me this picture isn't right. Is he really using a Piranha? Could I mimic these results with say, a Talon and switch to my Piranha? I've just never experienced this type of spread cluster at this distance with this weapon.


The picture is accurate.  The key is that you must use a smart choke *PLUS* have an accuracy bonus of some sort ie. Hunter Mode, Devastor or Marksman.  Spread is crazy accurate with Marksman.  I did testing myself using a different distance, but you can see spread patterns and comparisons...

http://social.biowar.../index/13291015

The difference is that a Claymore only requires a Smart Choke.  For the Piranha to compete with the Claymore for accuracy, you can only do this with the N7 Destroyer, Geth Engineer, Geth Infiltrator or Turian Soldier.

On everything else, the Piranha is just a close range weapon even with the smart choke.  One very interesting thing, the Piranha is totally the most off centered shooting shotgun in the game (see other tests that people did in the topic I started that shows most shotguns spread pretty on center, the Piranha hits on the fringes).

Modifié par neteng101, 25 juillet 2012 - 09:03 .


#404
Guest_death_for_sale_*

Guest_death_for_sale_*
  • Guests

We Tigers wrote...

death_for_sale wrote...

To give a better idea, this is a pic about 25 Meters with Smart Choke, and a 15% accuracy boost from HM.

Image IPB


1) That's not close to 25 meters, so you fired it while standing still from pretty far away at the deadliest of targets, a non-moving wall
2) You know very well that this thing is meant to fire full auto and that a grouping won't look anything like that when you fire a whole clip, especially if you're moving or your target is
3) That's a tighter pellet spread than you'll get with anything other than a TSol using Marksman, and it still isn't obnoxious

Good job on getting us to give you 15 pages in 4 hours.  Now go find something else to incorrectly complain about.


It is definitely close to 25 meters and it is simply a spread test. Of course it will climb on full auto, use a stability mod or learn to compensate by moving your reticle down as you fire. That pellet spread is only boosted on the Gi by 15% over any other character. You do know that firing aimed shots from cover gives you an accuracy boost AND reduces recoil on any character, yes?

#405
Pride Demon

Pride Demon
  • Members
  • 1 342 messages

brian_breed wrote...

The weapon in the first screencap is a GPR. Look at its arc forward and snubbed edges.

That would actually be the wheelbarrel over the Piranha...
The GPS doesn't have pellets, and I don't think the Talon has that many, so...

#406
Guest_Air Quotes_*

Guest_Air Quotes_*
  • Guests
Weight increase would achieve exactly NOTHING. Like with Reegar. The gun is most effective on Destroyer, GI and Turian. they DON'T CARE about weight. Well maybe Turian, but not much. 

So weight increase would only make this gun not viable for Vanguards. That's it. And Bioware can't nerf damage, they only just increased it. They would look like complete incompetent douche-bags by doing it.

Modifié par Air Quotes, 25 juillet 2012 - 09:07 .


#407
Guest_death_for_sale_*

Guest_death_for_sale_*
  • Guests

GroverA125 wrote...

death_for_sale wrote...


Could you post the calculations you used to get to those numbers? I don't think they look right.


Lv. X Claymore Damage (with HCB) is 2060. DPS with RCs included is 1041.3. Against armor, that's 839. Could otherwise be modified with shredder, but that's another story.

I only have a Lv. III Pirahna (with HCB), doing the math I have (15.3 damage increase per level, 15.3 x 7 = 107.1, 107.1 + 561 = 668.1, 1059.1 / 561 x 668.1 = 1261. I was on by a rough shot, which was an estimate.)

Shotguns that have a lot of damage always have a more impressive DPS than their actual workings. Expect at least 1/4 of your shots to be off target, so drop the DPS by 25%, from 1261 to about 1000. Then you have to think that it will be worse than that at maximum RPM, where your boomshot is bouncing everywhere and so are your pellets. With an automatic shotgun or one with High-RoF, you don't get the time to line up your shots if you are going at max RoF. Looking at it that way, the claymore is superior, in that you are capable of putting accurate shots on target and achieving that RoF.


do the math without mods.

#408
Kick In The Door

Kick In The Door
  • Members
  • 1 029 messages

Rebel_Raven wrote...

Kick In The Door wrote...

Envious1 wrote...

Someone help me out here, why do people want to nerf weapons?

We are not competing with each other. It's a team effort and nerfing powerful weapons will only make it harder to win.

Where is the advantage in this?


Because of something called an inferiority complex. I'm a psych student. I'd have a f*cking field day with video game jocks like the OP.


It's coz Bioware decided it was a brilliant idea to put in a scoreboard that doesn't really tell you how well you contributed to the battle, just how much you killed more than anything else.

It's a blow to the mentalmind to see your score low, and feel like you didn't do jack to help the team.

It's even worse when someone tromps around the map racking up kill after kill after kill while you're struggling just to keep up.

It's just not fun when you feel less than viable. People want balance.

Way I see it though is if you feel less than viable, and then drag people down to your level, what the hell are you doing?!


Yeah.

But people like the OP have a st*ck up their ass. I'll bet anything his parents never really showed affection towards him. Anything that the OP did was never good enough in the parent's eyes. He most likely came from an Authoritarian household. Where "because I said so" was reason enough to warrant anything. Most likely developed an Avoidant attachment style(indifference to parents/guardians, treats them as strangers), which creates people with low self esteem and insecurity. And I'm willing to bet he wasn't the most poplular kid around, which I'm sure created "difficulties" for him, being the odd ball and all. It all comes from his language and demeanor. I can feel the insecurity just oozing out of his posts, the awkwardness, the betaness.

It's quite disgusting really.  



But that's just speculation, I'll examine him/it some more to see if we can find a way to get that stick out of his ass. 

#409
brian_breed

brian_breed
  • Members
  • 799 messages

Pride Demon wrote...

brian_breed wrote...

The weapon in the first screencap is a GPR. Look at its arc forward and snubbed edges.

That would actually be the wheelbarrel over the Piranha...
The GPS doesn't have pellets, and I don't think the Talon has that many, so...


I said GPR, not GPS. Look at them dumpy currrrves.

#410
Arcataye

Arcataye
  • Members
  • 1 055 messages
I love the Piranha and it's very fun to use.

BUT I DONT LIKE FUN Image IPB

Modifié par Arcataye, 25 juillet 2012 - 09:09 .


#411
Pride Demon

Pride Demon
  • Members
  • 1 342 messages

brian_breed wrote...

Pride Demon wrote...

brian_breed wrote...

The weapon in the first screencap is a GPR. Look at its arc forward and snubbed edges.

That would actually be the wheelbarrel over the Piranha...
The GPS doesn't have pellets, and I don't think the Talon has that many, so...


I said GPR, not GPS. Look at them dumpy currrrves.

My mistake... :P
It still looks like that round thing mounted over the Piranha to me though...

#412
Rebel_Raven

Rebel_Raven
  • Members
  • 2 326 messages
Pirahna is a mixed bag. Light enough for caster classes to do some decent damage vs a boss on their own in light of people with the typhoon, the harrier, and such. On the other hand they absolutely have to get close to make use of it.

#413
Pitznik

Pitznik
  • Members
  • 2 838 messages

Kick In The Door wrote...

Rebel_Raven wrote...

Kick In The Door wrote...

Envious1 wrote...

Someone help me out here, why do people want to nerf weapons?

We are not competing with each other. It's a team effort and nerfing powerful weapons will only make it harder to win.

Where is the advantage in this?


Because of something called an inferiority complex. I'm a psych student. I'd have a f*cking field day with video game jocks like the OP.


It's coz Bioware decided it was a brilliant idea to put in a scoreboard that doesn't really tell you how well you contributed to the battle, just how much you killed more than anything else.

It's a blow to the mentalmind to see your score low, and feel like you didn't do jack to help the team.

It's even worse when someone tromps around the map racking up kill after kill after kill while you're struggling just to keep up.

It's just not fun when you feel less than viable. People want balance.

Way I see it though is if you feel less than viable, and then drag people down to your level, what the hell are you doing?!


Yeah.

But people like the OP have a st*ck up their ass. I'll bet anything his parents never really showed affection towards him. Anything that the OP did was never good enough in the parent's eyes. He most likely came from an Authoritarian household. Where "because I said so" was reason enough to warrant anything. Most likely developed an Avoidant attachment style(indifference to parents/guardians, treats them as strangers), which creates people with low self esteem and insecurity. And I'm willing to bet he wasn't the most poplular kid around, which I'm sure created "difficulties" for him, being the odd ball and all. It all comes from his language and demeanor. I can feel the insecurity just oozing out of his posts, the awkwardness, the betaness.

It's quite disgusting really.  



But that's just speculation, I'll examine him/it some more to see if we can find a way to get that stick out of his ass. 

Reported.

#414
whateverman7

whateverman7
  • Members
  • 1 566 messages
lol at this thread...it is a prime example of the bsn as a whole: yall complain for good stuff, when yall get good stuff, yall then complain cause it's good...i swear this is the only gaming place that doesnt like for good things(weapons, builds, styles to make the game easier, etc.) to be in games....like i and others have been saying: it's gonna be the bsn that kills of me3 mp....

anyway, to respond to the OP: no, leave the piranha alone...it's fine the way it is...the gun is a high risk/high reward weapon...yea, you can do a lot of damage to things, but you gotta be extremely close, even with mods....

also, to comment on something else i saw: leave the talon alone, it's fine the way it is...it works like a pistol/shotgun hybrid should: more shots then a shotgun; more damage then a pistol, but less then a shotgun; more weight then a normal pistol; and great from mid to close range...if you think differently, you need to look at how you're using it, cause it's you, not the gun

#415
Guest_OSDAPro13_*

Guest_OSDAPro13_*
  • Guests
I just got done playing a gold match with my pirhanna wielding sentinel...

And to the OP... I say... In the tone of sentinel krogan... Stop Whining.

Leave the pirhanna as it is... U don't like it, dont use it. U don't like being out scores with it, go find another lobby.

We have already suffered too many casualties in ME MP to waste such opportunities when BW gives us good stuff to play with.

#416
Kick In The Door

Kick In The Door
  • Members
  • 1 029 messages

Pitznik wrote...

Kick In The Door wrote...

Rebel_Raven wrote...

Kick In The Door wrote...

Envious1 wrote...

Someone help me out here, why do people want to nerf weapons?

We are not competing with each other. It's a team effort and nerfing powerful weapons will only make it harder to win.

Where is the advantage in this?


Because of something called an inferiority complex. I'm a psych student. I'd have a f*cking field day with video game jocks like the OP.


It's coz Bioware decided it was a brilliant idea to put in a scoreboard that doesn't really tell you how well you contributed to the battle, just how much you killed more than anything else.

It's a blow to the mentalmind to see your score low, and feel like you didn't do jack to help the team.

It's even worse when someone tromps around the map racking up kill after kill after kill while you're struggling just to keep up.

It's just not fun when you feel less than viable. People want balance.

Way I see it though is if you feel less than viable, and then drag people down to your level, what the hell are you doing?!


Yeah.

But people like the OP have a st*ck up their ass. I'll bet anything his parents never really showed affection towards him. Anything that the OP did was never good enough in the parent's eyes. He most likely came from an Authoritarian household. Where "because I said so" was reason enough to warrant anything. Most likely developed an Avoidant attachment style(indifference to parents/guardians, treats them as strangers), which creates people with low self esteem and insecurity. And I'm willing to bet he wasn't the most poplular kid around, which I'm sure created "difficulties" for him, being the odd ball and all. It all comes from his language and demeanor. I can feel the insecurity just oozing out of his posts, the awkwardness, the betaness.

It's quite disgusting really.  



But that's just speculation, I'll examine him/it some more to see if we can find a way to get that stick out of his ass. 

Reported.


:lol: I am immortal.

#417
Machazareel

Machazareel
  • Members
  • 474 messages

Fortack wrote...

Machazareel wrote...

Gotta love armchair developers who feel the need to make posts on a forum to inform people how they feel something is unbalanced, then act shocked as people lash out at them for parading around and trying to ruin everyone else's fun.


So you're speaking for everyone? That's good to know.

If it needs to be rebalanced, it will be, after developers look at actual data, as opposed to numbers that are mathed out in a vacuum in some forum post which generally does not apply to actual gameplay.


Well, there are some people who actually think a little about which weapon would be best for their characters. I know, that might sound odd, but it happens. Can be incredibly difficult at times though, rocket sciences is peanuts compared to the decision to take a weapon that does insane damage, weights close to nothing, and mows down everything when you test it playing a match.


Trying a bit too hard there, champ.

#418
usctrojanbulldog

usctrojanbulldog
  • Members
  • 575 messages

We Tigers wrote...

usctrojanbulldog wrote...

We Tigers wrote...

death_for_sale wrote...

To give a better idea, this is a pic about 25 Meters with Smart Choke, and a 15% accuracy boost from HM.

Image IPB


1) That's not close to 25 meters, so you fired it while standing still from pretty far away at the deadliest of targets, a non-moving wall
2) You know very well that this thing is meant to fire full auto and that a grouping won't look anything like that when you fire a whole clip, especially if you're moving or your target is
3) That's a tighter pellet spread than you'll get with anything other than a TSol using Marksman, and it still isn't obnoxious

Good job on getting us to give you 15 pages in 4 hours.  Now go find something else to incorrectly complain about.


My experience tells me this picture isn't right. Is he really using a Piranha? Could I mimic these results with say, a Talon and switch to my Piranha? I've just never experienced this type of spread cluster at this distance with this weapon.

Probably because you play it like a normal person, moving around and not firing one shot at a time at an immobile target!  A Talon would only give 6 bullet holes, and I'm sure he's using a Piranha as he says.  The picture just doesn't really say much since it involves an accuracy bonus--which only 3 of 36 characters in the game can achieve--and since it isn't exactly relevant conditions.



HA!!!!!!!!! I just replicated this picture.

A) Yes, He's using the Piranha.

B) You have to be: 1)in cover and 2) have your accuracy bonuses MAXED "I'm talking both class passives and equipment." In other words - you won't be this effective during actual play.....EVER!!!!!!!!!!!

Nice test OP. Lets see you manipulate some more data to fit your erroneous point.:blink:

#419
Afromanb

Afromanb
  • Members
  • 138 messages

Fauxnormal wrote...

Afromanb wrote...

Please rate this a 1 star people. Sigh...


I'll rate it five. Just to annoy you.


Doesn't matter, I don't get annoyed by trival things such as this and You! Lolz:D

#420
E71

E71
  • Members
  • 709 messages

death_for_sale wrote...
...der diddly dum dee derp...


STHU and stop using it, problem solved.

#421
Bessy067

Bessy067
  • Members
  • 315 messages
Why is it that every time there's a weapon that's fun and powerful people scream that it be nerfed? Who cares that it's more powerful than your precious claymore, just let us enjoy it...

#422
FlamboyantRoy

FlamboyantRoy
  • Members
  • 798 messages

Pitznik wrote...

Reported.


Reported for reporting.

:innocent:

Modifié par FlamboyantRoy, 25 juillet 2012 - 09:24 .


#423
Guest_death_for_sale_*

Guest_death_for_sale_*
  • Guests
How many times do I have to repeat this? Aimed shots from cover give you a small bonus to accuracy and lower recoil no matter what class.

So yes, this is capable from other classes than the ones with abilities.

I had to move up about 5M to the box to take cover, but this is from an Asari Vanguard. If you know how to aim with this weapon, you are going to land 6 of those pellets most of the time. That is a ton of damage for something this light and is one of the reasons people are fighting so hard to keep it overpowered.

Image IPB

#424
CitizenThom

CitizenThom
  • Members
  • 2 429 messages

Gamemako wrote...

CitizenThom wrote...

Ok, buff the Claymore then.


I'm actually down with that, but the weight class of the Piranha and its DPS dominance over every other weapon in the game just doesn't make much sense to me. You'll have to buff every other weapon in the game to match (in which case the game will get comically easy) or you nerf the Piranha in some way.


You forget the accuracy issue. The weapon itself is balanced just fine. Some class abilities over-synergise with it perhaps, but that's the result of the class abilities, not the guns themselves.

#425
TehMerc

TehMerc
  • Members
  • 244 messages

E71 wrote...

death_for_sale wrote...
...der diddly dum dee derp...


STHU and stop using it, problem solved.


Intelligent discussion there bro. Doesn't make you look like a tool or anything.