117 réponses à ce sujet

[RobertM525]

What are your picks?

EDIT: Here are some weapon stats, if anyone wants them. Seems pretty relevant.

Modifié par RobertM525, 27 juillet 2012 - 03:15 .

[IllusiveManJr]

In my opinions...
Best
1. Talon
2. Saber
3. Paladin
4. Harrier
5. Valiant

Worst
1. Incisor
2. Javelin
3. Krysae (Too awkward)
4. Crusader
5. Graal (I just don't like it)

I haven't used the Locust, Shuriken, or Raptor in multiplayer. So I figured I shouldn't include those on my list.

Modifié par theillusiveman11, 26 juillet 2012 - 10:40 .

[Titus Thongger]

Top 5: (of what I have, QQ)
Claymore
Reegar Carbine
Black Widow
Indra (or Hurricane, interchangeable imo depending on range)
Saber

Worst 5
Geth Pulse Rifle
Raptor
Incisor
Javelin
Kishok

[Grub Killer8016]

Best:
1) Typhoon
2) Graal Spike Thrower
3) Claymore
4) Paladin
5) Hurricane

Worst:
1) Indra
2) Shuriken
3) Striker ( had it's good time before nerfed)
4) Acolyt (new pistol, can't spell it for the life of me)
5) Kyrsae (would've been best if not nerfed to h**l)

[Chromatix]

1. Claymore. Stay classy.
2. Reegar'o. Be Awesome.
3. Carnifex. Just Elegant.
4. Harrier. Well Played.
5. Paladin. No comments.

Worst
1. Krysae. Please, go to hell.
2. Acolyte. What the i don't even.
3. Incisor. Nice try.
4. Locust. That's not even funny.
5. Geth Pulse Rifle. Sigh.

[upinya slayin]

Best 5
1) particle rifle
2) avenger
3) predator
4) eagle
5) harpoon gun

worst 5
1) harrier
2) typhoon
3) GPS
4) Claymore
5) pirhanna

[Blood shot47]

So hard to pick your "opinion best" weapons because it all depends on what class im playing BUT I can easily with worst

1.locust
2. Incisor
3.Avenger
4.Predator
5.Vindicator

[Sailears]

Hmm well I don't have a typhoon yet so can't comment on that. But anyway

Top
1. Talon (works on every class, every build)
2. Pirhana (until it gets nerfed)
3. Wraith
4. Paladin
5. Harrier

Worst
1. Shuriken
2. GPSMG
3. Incisor
4. Javelin
5. Locust

Modifié par Curunen, 26 juillet 2012 - 10:58 .

[xCreamyy]

Top 5 (in no particular order):
Paladin, Harrier, Valiant, Claymore, Hurricane

Bottom 5 (again, in no particular order):
Incisor, Geth Pulse Rifle, Locust.... Acolyte? I guess? And I can't think of a fifth.

[PsychoticBiotic]

Best 5:
1. Pirahna
2. Talon
3. Claymore
4. Hurricane
5. Typhoon / Harrier (love em both)

Worst 5? Probably the Locust, Incisor, Raptor, Geth SMG, Geth Pulse Rifle... I don't really care for any of those.

Modifié par PsychoticBiotic, 26 juillet 2012 - 10:38 .

[Landriss]

Best:
Reager
Harrier
Carniflex
Geth SG.
Phalanx (idc I still love pistol)

Worst:
At work so can't think of the names...

[RobertM525]

My 5 Favorite Weapons:
1. Cerberus Harrier (even at level 1, it's fantastic)
2. Carnifex (definitely use it on almost every character)
3. Tempest (nice light-weight pairing with the Carnifex for my Engineer)
4. Geth Plasma Shotgun (look, ma, no aiming! though it makes my fingers hurt using it too much)
5. Krysae Sniper Rifle (it's fun pretending to be a Geth Rocket Trooper; haven't tried it since the nerf, though)

Bear in mind, my manifest is rather pathetic. The Hurricane is kinda cool, but it weighs too much for me to use on the characters I play a lot, which are very power-focused (I try to keep them above +170% CD). Likewise, I'd use my Paladin more if I had Pistol Ultralight Materials. Or the Talon, for that matter.

The Revenant is a runner up for me. I loved it to death in ME2 and found it works okay as a close/mid-range Assault Rifle in ME3. But, again, it's just too heavy for me to bother using on most of my characters.

5 Worst Weapons (that I've used in Multiplayer)
1. Falcon (my first level 10 weapon and I found it very "meh")
2. Geth Pulse Rifle (only because I'd love to use it if its DPS wasn't so awful)
3. Acolyte (tried it yesterday and found it nigh useless)
4. Javelin (I feel like it could be good but I suck at using it)
5. Predator (I'm sorry, did I actually shoot something?)

Runner up is the Geth Plasma SMG, which I often carry (with ULM) on characters whose cooldowns it won't affect. And then wonder why I bother doing so, since it's so awful most of the time.

Modifié par RobertM525, 26 juillet 2012 - 10:51 .

[CrazyManimalR]

Top 5:
Black Widow
Paladin
Javelin- Good alternative to widow
Disciple- Nice damage with low weight
Mattock- Easy to use, accurate and nice damage

Bottom 5:
Hurricane- Almost unusable due to ridiculous recoil, don't understand why everyone likes it so much
Geth Pulse Rifle
Viper
Falcon- Don't understand why everyone likes it so much, its pathetic
Striker

[Kalas Magnus]

Best: GPS,claymore,piranha,harrier,hurricane
Worst:GPSMG,locust,shuriken,predator,crusader

[IndigoVitare]

12 replies and only one mention of the Eagle?

Finally people are learning it's not as bad as claimed.

[Necrotron]

-Top 5 (okay, 6)-
Reager
Claymore
Piranha
Black Widow
Geth Plamsa Shotgun
Typhoon

-Worst 5 (okay, 6)-
Locust
Incisor
Shuriken
Particle Rifle (needs more testing, but wasn't impressed)
Geth Plasma Rifle (a bit rough to use on gold because of armor damage reduction)
Javelin (too many downsides and killed by shield gate on gold)

-Honable Mentions/Underrated Guns-
Falcon (stagger, decent damage per shot, AoE, what more do you want?)
Krysae (yes, still, staggers, AoE, excellent gun still)
Carnifax Hand Cannon (best gun for casters and still 200% cooldown)
N7 Valiant (Black Widow lite anyone?)

Modifié par Bathaius, 26 juillet 2012 - 10:57 .

[ParaNeuman]

Best:
Typhoon
Harrier + Saber
Crusader
Hurricane
Paladin

Worst:
Javelin
GPR + GPSMG
Locust
Falcon
Incisor

[Chealec]

Depends too much on the class - the Phaeston is great on the Human Sentinel for instance and the Falcon is pretty damned solid on the Turian Sentinel, but overall (can't include the Tyhpoon or Particle Rifle in either list - I don't have them so I've no idea):

Best
1: Paladin (a great weapon on any power-based class)
2: Phalanx (a great secondary on any class which needs cooldowns, including soldiers)
3: Piranha (best secondary shotgun - excellent on Turian Soldier)
4: Hurricane (goes with almost anything)
5: Valiant (one of the few SRs that can be used by non-infiltrators)

Worst
1: Incisor (too much climb for a gun that relies on headshots)
2: Locust (better off with an Eagle, seriously)
3: Kishok (too heavy, too slow, needs charging to do serious damage)
4: Javelin (too heavy, too long to reload, completely defeated by shield gate)
5: Acolyte (for me - it's too situational and takes too long to charge)


I think it's basically those I think are best are the most versatile and those that are worst the most situational (or just a bit underwhelming) - probably comes from playing U/U/G mostly.

[RobertM525]

IndigoVitare wrote...

12 replies and only one mention of the Eagle?

Finally people are learning it's not as bad as claimed.

If it were an uncommon or a rare, I don't think people would dislike it. As it is, it feels like a very underwhelming "promotional." Or frustrating, even, since it's basically blocking people from getting a Valiant or Hurricane (which seem to be the only promotionals anyone wants).

[Chealec]

IndigoVitare wrote...

12 replies and only one mention of the Eagle?

Finally people are learning it's not as bad as claimed.

It's had a lot of buffs; I quite like it on biotic classes.

[RSA586]

Sorry I know this isn't a direct answer to the question but I really feel this is completely subjective to difficulty/class settings. For example, a gun like the Falcon or Scorpion is fantastic at crowd control and for applying and causing tech bursts with a character like the demolisher but I would almost never use them on an Adept. Not to steer the conversation away from its intent, but I think there's a major issue with the balancing if this many people have an ultra-rare N7 weapon (such as the Javelin) on the "worst" list. At least in my opinion, an ultra rare weapon that is MUCH more difficult to unlock and as a result requires more credits and playtime SHOULD outclass weapons in the common/uncommon and most in the rare categories, not necessarily be equal to them and definitely not be worse than them.

[Chromatix]

How dare people calling Falcon a worst choice? Unskilled scrubs are just making awesome gun look bad.

[RobertM525]

RSA586 wrote...

Not to steer the conversation away from its intent, but I think there's a major issue with the balancing if this many people have an ultra-rare N7 weapon (such as the Javelin) on the "worst" list. At least in my opinion, an ultra rare weapon that is MUCH more difficult to unlock and as a result requires more credits and playtime SHOULD outclass weapons in the common/uncommon and most in the rare categories, not necessarily be equal to them and definitely not be worse than them.

Yeah, I think if the community were to re-classify the weapons, there'd be a lot of shuffling around (e.g., Incisor dropped to Common, Javelin to Rare, pre-nerf Krysae up to Ultra Rare or Promotional).

[PostJazzCore]

Best: (no order)
Piranha, Carnifex, Cerberus Harrier, Geth Plasma Shotgun, n7 Hurricane

Worst: (again, no order)
Acolyte, n7 Eagle, Javelin, Particle Rifle, Paladin (Drop, damn you! DROPPPPPP!)

[Chealec]

RSA586 wrote...

Sorry I know this isn't a direct answer to the question but I really feel this is completely subjective to difficulty/class settings

....

Yes it's subjective, which is why I listed the 5 best guns being those that I use on multiple characters or classes and the worst are all weapons I use on ... well, nobody ... ever.

Bear in mind I normally play U/U/G - if I played silver a lot I'd probably not have the Javelin in the worst list since it's not completely defeated by shield gate in silver... this isn't meant to be a definitive list just what YOU think are best and worst ... yes?