117 réponses à ce sujet

[UnknownMercenary]

Best: Claymore, Black Widow, Saber, Paladin, Harrier
Worst: Particle Rifle, Locust, Incisor, Crusader, Javelin

[Edolix]

Best: Piranha, Cerberus Harrier, Claymore, Geth Plasma Shotgun, Carnifex (i'd put the Typhoon here, but I haven't unlocked it yet.)

Worst: Geth Pulse Rifle, Eagle, Krysae, Kishock Harpoon Gun, Locust.

[Ultenth]

It's always going to be pretty obvious lists.  The top's will mostly be N7 or UR weapons, the bottoms will be starter or Uncommon weapons mostly.  But it should be like that.  I'd be more interested in seeing a list of top 5 underperforming and top 5 overperforming weapons based on their class vs. their power level.  In that vein, this would be my list:

Top 5 Overperforming Weapons:
1. Eviscerator, Uncommon weapon that plays like a fairly high quality rare shotgun.
2. Piranha, Rare weapon that plays like an extremely good UR.
3. Tempest, Extremely fast firing Uncommon SMG that can actually be used as a main weapon on the right classes.
4. Geth Plasma Shotgun.  Fast firing, fairly fast reloading Rare multi-shot shotgun that has slugs that track, making it great from any range.
5. Harrier.  Even as an UR, this gun overperforms, as it was the first truely viable end-game AR, even with it's limited ammo, it's a complete monster.


Top 5 Underperforming Weapons: 
1. N7 Eagle, A fast firing N7 pistol that only excels vs. shields. Even moreso now with the Acolyte there really isn't a loadout that this weapon works with, especially for such a rare weapon.
2. Indra, an UR sniper rifle, that you're forced to stand out in withering Gold/Plat fire in order to use to full effect.  Why not just use a good AR and keep your field of vision intact?  Or use a real sniper rifle and allow yourself to spend more time behind cover and still deal the same damage but much safer?
3. Geth Plasma Rifle.  A Rare rifle that is probably the worst AR in the entire game, if not the worst weapon.  It's extreme accuracy and rate of fire do not in any way make up for it's complete and utter lack of damage.
4. Disciple, A light shotgun, only useful if you're using it for mods, it's great that it's light, but again, it's complete lack of damage (or the stagger effect it claims to have) make it pointless to ever really fire.
5. Locust, yes it's only an Uncommon weapon, but it's outperformed by even the Shuriken.  It should have been the lone UR SMG, and be 10x more powerful than it currently is.  What a complete waste of a formerly fantastic weapon (in ME2).

[leiruc]

Best for me

1.tempest X (cus with ma disrupter ammo and Edrain)
2.piranha X (kicks but)
3.Disciple X ( was the only gun i used with everyone cus its a life saver)
4.partical rifile (lazers!!1)
5.Typhoon (nuff said

Worst for me

1.Scorpion V ( cus i wanna keep useing it but it keeps letting me down.
2.saber V ( cus the recoils makes ma thumb hurt keeping the joystick down.
3. Typhoon I ( cus i wanna take it everywhere i go but cant lol.
4.Reeger X (kills to fast
5.Black widow II  (cus my wife gets mad at me and wont make me food cus she wants it and i dont use it ever)

Modifié par leiruc, 26 juillet 2012 - 11:19 .

[Elderwand38]

Best
5)Reeger Shotgun
4)Revenant
3)Scorpion
2)Phaesteon
1)Paladin

Worst
All Sniper Rifles(i hate them)

Sorry if i misspelled any of them.

[Tallgeese_VII]

Best: GPS, Claymore, Typhoon, Hurricane, Valiant
Worst: Incisor, GPR, Eagle, GPR, Eagle

[trunglefever]

Of my manifest:

Typhoon
Harrier
Claymore
Talon
Carnifax (Yes, I still like the Carnifax)

Worst:
Predator
Locust
Scimitar
Viper
Particle Rifle (I don't like it)

[RobertM525]

Ultenth wrote...

It's always going to be pretty obvious lists.  The top's will mostly be N7 or UR weapons, the bottoms will be starter or Uncommon weapons mostly.  But it should be like that.  I'd be more interested in seeing a list of top 5 underperforming and top 5 overperforming weapons based on their class vs. their power level.

I actually considered phrasing my question based on rarity (e.g., "what's your favorite and least-favorite uncommon/rare/ultra rare?"), but decided that might be too restrictive.

Ultenth wrote...

3. Tempest, Extremely fast firing Uncommon SMG that can actually be used as a main weapon on the right classes.

As I mentioned, I think the Carnifex and Tempest make a great, relatively light-weight pair. Slap a scope on the Carnifex and use it at range, and use the Tempest up close. (Even better if ULM worked. :happy: )

Ultenth wrote...

Indra, an UR sniper rifle, that you're forced to stand out in withering Gold/Plat fire in order to use to full effect.  Why not just use a good AR and keep your field of vision intact?  Or use a real sniper rifle and allow yourself to spend more time behind cover and still deal the same damage but much safer?

When I saw videos of this, I was very excited to get one. (I'm a rather terrible shot, what can I say?  )When I finally got it, I found it very underwhelming. And, yeah, rather a liability. If it delivered awesome DPS, that might make it worth using. At least it's not too heavy.

Ultenth wrote...

Geth Plasma Rifle.  A Rare rifle that is probably the worst AR in the entire game, if not the worst weapon.  It's extreme accuracy and rate of fire do not in any way make up for it's complete and utter lack of damage.

It seems completely on par with the Avenger and Phaeston. As such, it really ought to be an Uncommon. I love its speed and accuracy, but it's just such a pathetic pea-shooter. Even on my Geth Engineer. (On a related note, it'd be cool of the Geth classes made the GPSMG and Geth Pulse Rifle into good weapons.)

Ultenth wrote...

Locust, yes it's only an Uncommon weapon, but it's outperformed by even the Shuriken.  It should have been the lone UR SMG, and be 10x more powerful than it currently is.  What a complete waste of a formerly fantastic weapon (in ME2).

Yeah, I was shocked to find out that the Locust sucks so badly in ME3. I'm just happy the Revenant (my favorite AR from ME2) didn't get eviscerated as badly as this did.

[whalewhisker]

Best in no particular order:
1. Talon
2. Hurricane
3. Harrier
4. Geth Plasma Shotgun
5. Piranha

Worst:
1. Locust
2. Geth Pulse Rifle (i love it though)
3. Javelin
4. Disciple
5. Wraith (seriously outclassed by Piranha and Talon)

Modifié par whalewhisker, 26 juillet 2012 - 11:27 .

[Silbane_23]

I see many list the acolyte among the worst. I was in that camp on first impression. But it really does its job extremely well. The charge effect takes getting used to but ability to strip phantom shields almost entirely (with X on gold) is just amazing. It also staggers and can hit around cover due to the small bomb effect (similar to scorpion).

Its my preferred weapon on my fury and slayer. May try on some of my other classes as well.

[Sacramentum]

Best:
1. Harrier
2. Reeger
3. Hurricane
4. GPS
5. Claymore

Worst:
1. Incisor
2. Shruikren
3. GPR
4.GPSMG
5. Eagle

IMO

[superligerzero]

I can't really put down five of my best or worst. However some of the worst I see are some of my best.

[MBuot]

My personal favorites...
1) Typhoon
2) Reegar
3) Paladin
4) Phaeston
5) Vindicator

The ones I despise...
1) Kishock
2) Viper
3) Arc Pistol
4) Javelin
5) Graal

[mpompeo27]

In no particular order...

Best:
Talon
Valiant
Piranha
Claymore
Harrier

Worst:
Incisor
Predator
Eagle
Shuriken
Kishock

[ProfGast]

I'll rank 'em by type:
Bests:
AR- Harrier (overall balance, only weakpoint is ammo)
SR- Valiant
SMG- Hurricane
HP- Carnifex
SG- Piranha

Worsts:
AR - GPR
SR - Krysae
SMG - Locust (I miss the old Locust)
HP - Predator (once you get others, no real reason to use it)
SG - Scimitar (Piranha, only bad)

[Silbane_23]

Best:
Typhoon
Reegar
Piranha
Claymore
Talon / paladin (tie)

Worst:
Eagle
Striker
Krysae
Locust
Incisor


Honorable mentions:
Acolyte (reasons above)
Graal. Cuz every time I see someone shoot spikes into a mook's head i still say ooooh, pain

[ebls]

IMO, the Best:
1) Saber (it's just the best hybrid assault rifle - sniper: great damage, accuracy, etc.);
2) Harrier (it's the way how assault rifle should work);
3) Reegar (best weapon against shields and barrier);
4) Piranha (best shotgun now: light, you shoot fast and has an excellent damage);
5) Black Widow (despite the weight it's the best sniper rifle).

Honorable mentions: Paladin, Widow, GPS and Claymore. They are all fantastic weapons, but require training, better aim, etc.

Wrost: Incisor, Kishock, GPR, Shuriken and Predator.

Some weapons are not "that bad", but become useless when you unlock other. For instance, Eviscerator it's obsolete if you have Wraith. Other weapons, are good for some classes: Javelin and GPSMG for Geth Infiltrator and Engineer.

[MDK236]

 Best

Claymore (Best shotgun for the Infiltrator)
Deciple (wish I had it higher)
Carnifex (Go to pistol on any Biotic)
Vindicator (First weapon I unlocked out of Basic Equipment pack my go to AR and remember when it was perfect)
Mattock (Good trigger finger and I can drop a brute with a few clips and at under 10 seconds wish it was ME2 nice)

Worst

Crusader (Have it upgraded higher than most...dreaded each upgrade, wish they would lower the weight)
N7 Eagle (Meh)
Javelin (Too heavy and too few shots, too slow to shoot)
Graal (Don't care for charge up weapons)
Stiker (Love the idea but it needs to be buffed, fixed or something)

[FlowCytometry]

Guns I use too much
1. Claymore
2. Hurricane
3. GPS
4. Piranha
5. Carnifex/Paladin/Phalanx (for power classes, depending on amt of weight training)
(just got the Typhoon, perhaps I need a 6th slot.. we'll see)

Guns I wish I didn't see everywhere:
Piranha
Cheesar Carbine
(Krysae isn't on here anymore, ofc)

Guns that could sink into the abyss and I'd be like 'Those once existed? Oh well, no loss':
1. Shuriken
2. Locust
3. Incisor
4. Katana
5. GPSMG
(+ many many others :/ )

Modifié par FlowCytometry, 26 juillet 2012 - 11:54 .

[Ultenth]

ProfGast wrote...

I'll rank 'em by type:
Bests:
AR- Harrier (overall balance, only weakpoint is ammo)
SR- Valiant
SMG- Hurricane
HP- Carnifex
SG- Piranha

Worsts:
AR - GPR
SR - Krysae
SMG - Locust (I miss the old Locust)
HP - Predator (once you get others, no real reason to use it)
SG - Scimitar (Piranha, only bad)

The N7 Eagle is actually worse than the Predator, and are you seriously trying to say the Krysae is the worst SR?  Seriously?  It's worse than the Viper or Incisor?  Yeah, someone's overexaggerating to try to make a point...

[CaptainAchilles]

Clearly, you can tell who plays Platinum on a regular basis and who doesn't by the responses.

Best
1. Typhoon - dps output, natural armor penetration, and massive clip make this an easy choice
2. Hurricane - if you need to drop something quick, this gun is unstoppable at close to mid range.
3. Piranha - high risk, high reward...very deadly at close range. Has the clip size to adjust.
4. Valiant - easily could have been number one based on productivity, pre Krysae (pre nerf) and typhoon.
5. Harrier - high dps output with a good rate of fire. Only lacks in the clip size.

Worst
1. Krysae - Once was the best gun in the game via the Rebellion dlc, now buried by Bioware. RIP Krysae.
2. Incisor - poor damage output
3. Hornet - so much kick, the three round burst may only land one solid round per squeeze.
4. Vindicator - poor damage output.
5. Falcon - Once was a good weapon, but got nerfed to lameness. The Krysae of assault rifles.

[Robbbbb]

bioware troll acount to determine what's getting nerfed

[Seerezaro]

Best:
Claymore
Geth Plasma Rifle(really no idea why people don't like this gun)
Eviscerator
Mantis(something about the way the gun sounds when it fires)
Tempest

Worst:
Shuriken
Locust
Javelin
Eagle(no need for it now that you can get piercing on smg)
Crusader(great gun, but its not a shotgun in the sense that I'd use as a shotgun)

[Moress]

I can break down my favorites by catagory, but don't make me pick five of them...
AR: harrier/particle rifle/sabre (if the argus was in MP it'd beat all of them though)
sniper: kishock
SMG: hurricane
shotgun: graal/claymore
pistol: carnifex/scorpion

As for suckdom, that's easy
5: Shuriken
4:Disciple
3:Arc Pistol
2:Scimetar
1:Incisor