paxxton wrote...
BleedingUranium wrote...
paxxton wrote...
KevShep wrote...
paxxton wrote...
When Anderson tells Shepard he was born in London Shepard asks "Really?" It could be just courtesy but it could also be a hint for the player that something's off with the old man.
In the book Mass Effect Revelation it does say that anderson is from london.
Yeah, but the whole way this scene plays out is weird. Anderson's face expression makes him untrustworthy.
I always saw that as Anderson being suspicious of Shepard. Shepard's the one who said "Really?" when he knew that he was born there. He could have said "Yeah..." with the same tone, or "It must be tough/hard to see" or something that showed he knew that, while still being nice about it.
The very next thing he does is the "Too bad it too the Reapers to bring us together" line, with an odd focus on "Reapers", while purposefully moving so everyone in the shuttle hears him. When your squadmate corrects him and says it was Shepard that did that, he says "That's exactly what I meant!". He doesn't say it like he's embarassed, he truely means that's what he meant.
It seems he thinks something's up with Shepard, or maybe just testing him.
Wow. That makes perfect sense. Anderson connects Shepard to the Reapers! He means, not saying it straight, that Shepard is (being) indoctrinated.
EDIT: 3 hours since the last post. 
The question with this is: When does the indoctrination attempt start?
Of course we have the dreams that take place earlier and the kid while leaving Earth. These are hints that the whole process starts at the beginning of ME3 or even earlier (Arrival for example).
The difficult part is to identify the point, where Shepard starts to be in a full hallucination. The common theories suggest that the full hallucination part starts after the beam hit or even later.
Since Anderson's line about the Reapers/Shepard collecting everyone on Earth is after trashing the AA-gun and going to FOB, we can assume it is not a hallucination. If Anderson is real and has concerns about Shepard's mental state, why wouldn't he confront Shepard directly? Note that a similar situation happened after Thessia (ie. Joker telling his classy joke about Asari's defensive capabilites), where Anderson was concerned about Shepard's emotional state. Though Anderson tried an inderect approach (through Joker) to calm Shepard, this is understandable, since Anderson is on Earth during that time and vid-com bandwith is too valuable for extended therapy sessions.
Another interpretation could be that Anderson may be under Reaper influence himself and cannot directly communicate his thoughts to Shepard (ie. Dr. Kenson's dialogue in Arrival was kind of ambiguous in that matter; this was discussed earlier in this thread). The folly about this interpretation would be that Anderson under Reaper influence would oppose Shepard (like Saren/TIM/Kenson). Unless the Reapers want everyone to charge to the beam, which in reality is a huge indoctrination booster (as hinted on one of the datapads).
A third interpretation would be that during that scene we already left the realm of reality and the battle of minds is foreshadowing.